Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Police officer filmed hitting protester is suspended by MET

View Video
Download Video

Video

Mobile phone footage of a police sergeant striking a G20 protester
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 April 2009
A POLICE sergeant filmed hitting out at a woman during the G20 protests was suspended amid fresh allegations of police brutality during the summit.
The officer was seen swiping at the female with his hand before apparently hitting her across the legs with a baton in footage on YouTube.

Scotland Yard said the matter raised "immediate concerns" and announced the Independent Police Complaints Commission, already probing the death of Ian Tomlinson, would launch an inquiry.

"The officer has been identified and suspended pending further investigation. The officer works as a sergeant in the territorial support group," a Yard spokesman said.

Labour MP David Winnick condemned what he said was "outright police brutality" while Shami Chakrabarti, of Liberty added: "It is very difficult to understand what justifies a gargantuan police officer assaulting a smaller woman for having the audacity to complain.

"It is no doubt a pressure cooker environment, however highly-trained professionals are supposed to be better at defusing the situation."
David Howarth, Liberal Democrat justice spokesman, called for a "full-scale inquiry".

He said: "The fact that this video shows another example of an officer with his number obscured assaulting a member of the public indicates that there is a systematic problem here, not just a series of individual acts of misconduct.

"The question is on my mind whether the police are using a some kind of 'designated hitter' system."

According to the Guardian, footage of the confrontation was taken at the Bank of England the day after Mr Tomlinson's death.

The IPCC previously said it remained hopeful that fresh CCTV footage would help piece together Mr Tomlinson's final moments.

Investigators are trying to trace the 47-year-old newspaper seller's movements around the fringes of angry demonstrations outside the Bank of England.

Mr Tomlinson collapsed and died from a heart attack after clashing with police officers at least once as he walked home across the City.

A Metropolitan Police constable caught on camera hitting Mr Tomlinson with a baton and pushing him to the ground has also been suspended from duty.

A spokeswoman for the IPCC said there were a number of public and private CCTV cameras in the streets around where Mr Tomlinson died.

She said an earlier statement by the watchdog's chairman Nick Hardwick that "there is no CCTV footage" may not be accurate as investigators continued to trawl through hours of evidence.

The spokesman said: "From the outset it has been a main line of our inquiry to recover all CCTV from the Corporation of London and from all private premises in the area.

"This work is ongoing and involves many hours of viewing and detailed analysis."

Mr Tomlinson died as more than 5,000 protesters converged on the City of London on April 1 to mark the G20 summit in Docklands.

Amateur video footage captured by a New York fund manager emerged several days later of him being pushed to the ground by a policeman.

Other photographs have also come to light of Mr Tomlinson apparently remonstrating with officers in a riot van in Lombard Street up to an hour earlier.

Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson said the images of Mr Tomlinson being struck "raised obvious concerns" as questions arose over the police tactic of "kettling" demonstrators – penning them in – to prevent them moving freely.

Page 1 of 1

 
1

C.,

15/04/2009 10:24:33
after watching numerous clips of this, i think that the police office has acted correctly for his own safety. one of the clips i watched seems to show the woman provoking the police officer, you can hear shouting to get back get back, but the woman ignores this and seems to keep provoking. the clip isn't the best, but it looks as though she pushes the police officer who turns round and slaps her face. they are then told to get back but she moves forward. i think she is lucky she only got a slap in the face and baton to the legs. she should be arrested for public offences, and the police offer reinstate to full duty.
2

Horrible Cankers @Cyber Shebeen,

15/04/2009 10:30:40
1...Nonsense...no police officer is trained to slap a woman across the face...that is dangerous behaviour in a crowd situation like that...it is potentially provoking the crowd to react..and this idiot...being a sergeant should know this...his then batonning her was unnecessary and abuse of police power...

"Reinstate to full duty"...you are having a laugh mate...he could have caused a riot and should have his stripes taken and sent back to training....
3

go boil ur heid,

15/04/2009 11:51:46
#1- Nice to see a real man answering questions here today. I Mean how dare a woman antagonise a man even if he's trained for these situations
4

,

15/04/2009 12:16:10
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

Paesano,

15/04/2009 12:44:10
How sensational....so what if it's a woman! If she wants to get into these situations then why not expect exactly the same treatment a male protester would get. She will be delighted her irresponsible and antagonistic goading resulted in such footage. The family claim she was traumatised - aye right, she looks like the she was just in the wrong place at the wrong time rather than entirely in her element!

Do the police need to divide the crowds into men and women in future so they at least know where to focus their attention. If it's totally ok for women to act in exactly the same manner but with no opposition or control to be allowed from the police, then the least we can ask is they stop muddying the waters by mingling! I fully expect an explosion of cross dressing to occur at future street fights.
6

joppie joppie,

Everywhere 15/04/2009 13:15:05
Slap in the face? He backhanded her off as she was trying to grab him. The truncheon to the legs was standard police tactics. And she came back for more!! The way it was potrayed on the news I thought it was really violent. I've seen kids playfighting with more violence. A news story???? Ha!
7

Paesano,

15/04/2009 14:19:59
And while on the subject of singling out women not to be hit...

We are repeatedly told (mainly by women) that women have a higher pain threshold than men, surely this would indicate that if anything it's ok to hit women but not men! Failing agreement on that we should settle that it's ok to hit both men and women, but women should be hit slightly harder in order to equalise the pain threshold differential and allow the same punishment administration.

I'm pro equality but I like my equality straight down the line!
8

Bejjy,

Europe 15/04/2009 14:31:38
5 Rab The Ranter™,

They attacked innocent Scots down in Manchester, beat them up,

Total and utter rubbish, hundreds of drunken and violent Scottish "football supporters" attacked the police but don't let your prejudice get in the way of facts. The criminal thugs who attacked the police in Manchester deserve the severist of sentences that the Criminal Justice System can hand down for such mob violence. The thugs went to Manchester to create trouble and deserve all that they get.
9

Distalgesic,

15/04/2009 14:34:34
From the video it looks like the Policeman is being harangued by someone in front of him and then the daft wee lassie comes in at hiom from the side. I don't think he meant to backhand her as his attention does seem focused on the threat directly in front of him, it looks more like a "gettaefek" motion and he smacks her coupon as it looks like he's not even looking at her.

She then leaps in front of him and as already mentioned he uses standard tactics, draws a baton and smacks her leg.

Perhaps we should be equally focused on the great unwashed dole scroungers who were attacking the Police at the G20.
10

Jack Macarup,

Alba 15/04/2009 14:36:06
Protest at your peril under labour.
No one is safe from these thugs.
11

greenhill,

15/04/2009 15:35:21
I am all in favour of the Police going in hard on troublemaking demonstrators but this one is clear.

She is a petite woman and he is a big guy with a baton.She was out of order with her behaviour but what he did was wrong.Very wrong.She did not pose a threat to him.
12

uno.who,

Livingston 15/04/2009 15:50:02
I don't usually have any sympathy for the "great unwashed", who don't represent the majority of us, being herded about by the police, but this sergeant is clearly a moron.

If he's a panicker or can't control his temper he's in the wrong job, and promoted beyond his abilities.

He's at least twice the size of the wee nyaff who was goading him - did he really need to hit her wi yon big baton as well? Any chance of claiming the original back-handed "slap" was a mistake have just been flushed doon the lavvy!
13

Jack Macarup,

Alba 15/04/2009 16:16:47
This very same police thug had removed the ID number from his uniform,the only reason I can see for this illegal behaviour would be to make sure no one assaulted by him could report him as they would need this number to identify him.
Thankfully he was too thick to realise his thuggish actions were being recorded.
I believe he is guilty of assaulting the tiny female demonstrator not once but twice.
14

,

15/04/2009 17:00:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

Jack Macarup,

Alba 15/04/2009 17:16:44
18 Ribbonman,Glasgow
Rangers unionist fans hardly represent the Scottish nation.
Brought shame to Glasgow Rangers mibee.
The Scottish nation ,get real.

16

Jack Macarup,

Alba 15/04/2009 17:21:58
17 invictager,Kent
I suggest you watch the video, the wee lassie was pointing with her right arm out streched, away from the thug who whacked her on the legs with the baton.
She was looking him in the eye and did not have a chance of avoiding the blow,he did not even give her a warning.
17

Paesano,

15/04/2009 17:37:31
Look at the video - she goes right up to him makes contact with him, he then uses his arm instinctively to push away. I think he would have done this whether she was a he, or if the person was the same size or bigger than him. It's not a slap in the face, it's brushing off an arm....no doubt not too dissimilar to how you or I would react if some just came up to you and start touching / grabbing you.

Size doesn't feature in this debate. If she was that wee and f'ckin defenceless what is she doing right at the front of the crowd, purposely seeking out police to goad and physically harrass! Common sense is lost here. You have the image of a policeman along with his colleagues actively trying to control, antogonised by the crowd - Question: You're right in amongst that situation and see the blatant tension of it, do you A) Do as you are told, or B) Decide now would be an ideal time to grab one of the officers, safe in the knowledge that no matter what, due to being female and being much smaller than the officer, that no response could possible result!!

And back to size, anyone really think that there is a rule that states that police can only use force against those bigger than them? Maybe when faced with similar situations in future someone can just press pause while the policeman and protestor can have a wee weigh-in, and quick series of strength metrics to see if the rule is met to take action.

Theoretically by sounds of it packs of small aggressive women are order of the day for these events, they can do what they want without pesky police interference.
18

greenhill,

15/04/2009 17:37:33
It was terrible.He is a coward.
19

Jack Macarup,

Alba 15/04/2009 17:53:35
22 Paesano,15
"Size doesn't feature in this debate".
If the police thug was a WPC ,four foot nowt, would she have whacked a guy the size of a mountain, I dont think so.
Its the right of the public to protest without fear the police dont seem to agree.
BTW the police thug backhanded the girl with force.
Not an unintentional slap but a directed and willfull
assault.

20

uno.who,

Livingston 15/04/2009 17:57:04
#19 .. Ribbonman is spot on with his comments. Mad Rab is the one who needs to get real, claiming that "innocent Scots" were attacked in Manchester. It was the innocent people of Manchester I felt for when these vermin were blackening the name of Scotland.

PS in case you get to thinking I'm anti-Rangers, let it be clear that I don't have any football affiliations (just as well .... coming frae Livi!)

#23 greenhill .... Don't go overboard. He wiz an @rse but I doubt she was seriously injured, else her wee "innocent" bruised coupon would have been all over the ragtops.
21

Alba Abú,

15/04/2009 17:59:17
19 Brought shame to the orange order,the masonic lodges,the black preceptories and all other organisations which spawned them.
22

uno.who,

Livingston 15/04/2009 18:28:25
#27 well said invictager.

These @rseholes tried to do exactly the same during G8 in Edinburgh .... I experienced it at first hand as someone trying to go about my business.

The important issue is that people have a right to live in their own city without having to put up with worthless moron anarcho-tourists whose sole purpose is to cause damage, use up the local resources, and threaten anyone who doesn't agree with their viewpoint.

23

Paesano,

15/04/2009 18:36:19
24 - as 27 points out, think you are maybe naive about some of the motives for attending such events as clearly this specific incident involves protesters antogonising the police. As I said, this woman's actions and manner do not display her as a shrinking violet interested only in airing her views on the finer points of the economic issues our world is facing. And just can not see this forceful backhander you are talking about anyway.

Your comment re the theoretical actions of a WPC are suitably sexist given your stance on how this woman protester was treated and why her sex matters to her treatment. I believe you will find examples of WPCs performing their duties alongside their male colleagues and being required to use force even where the individual was larger than them.

It's a joke to assume purely because the PC was male and larger makes this a slam dunk. But hey if you just want a world where male PCs police similar sized males and vice versa for WPCs then I can only imagine crime stats will suitably match that absurdity.
24

Jack Macarup,

Alba 15/04/2009 19:42:16
29 Paesano,15

Hahhahaha.
You sure post some pi$h.
Are you a Labour advisor by any chance?
25

Paesano,

15/04/2009 19:57:45
30 - No need to huff just cause your post was shown to be worthless. Where's a decent 4 footer WPC to issue a bch-slapping when one's needed!
26

Jack Macarup,

Alba 15/04/2009 20:59:28
I rest my case.
27

Stan Butler,

15/04/2009 21:10:20

The police horses are more disciplined than the police.
28

Stan Butler,

15/04/2009 21:20:09

Why has the policeman covered up his number?

They seem to be operating a 'designated hitter' system.
29

Jason,

Japan 16/04/2009 13:25:50
Looks like the police are at the receiving end of the surveillance society. They can claim the street cameras malfunctioned and/or remove the tape, but can’t prevent members of the public taking a photographic record on their mobile cameras. Good, huh? The biter bit, or would that be hoisted with their own petard.
Either way, they don't like it up um.

30

Cute Beuaty,

Eastbourne 20/04/2009 18:21:24
I cannot believe that some people actually feel that this type of police behaviour is acceptable.

Would it be acceptable if it happened to you?

The police are given adequate powers of arrest, and restraint, and other aids to subdue those causing a nuisance. Police officers who act like thugs should be dismissed from active service immediately.

The police do a good job and they do not need the minority of these thug officers to bring the service into disrepute.

When I studied law, I was taught that only reasonable force should be used , what I have seen is excessive and those responsible must be charged in the same way as other person would who inflicts excessive injury.

If this behaviour continues without discouragement, then how long will we have to wait until the next police victim?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Web Links:

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.