Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 6th July 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

German outsmarts Colossus in decryption challenge



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 17 November 2007
A COMPUTER developed during the Second World War to decrypt Nazi coded transmissions yesterday lost to modern technology in a race to decipher a new message sent from the continent.
An amateur cryptographer from Germany who built his own computer programme for the challenge beat the rebuilt Colossus machine to unravel the message, which was sent via Second World War technology.

The exercise was to mark the launch of the Nati
onal Museum of Computing at Bletchley Park in Buckinghamshire, where Colossus was created in the 1940s.

Colossus, the world's first programmable digital computer, was pitched against more up-to-date rivals to see who could decipher the message, transmitted from Germany on Thursday.

At the same time as the machine, which is the size of a small lorry, was cranking up, amateur code breakers using modern computer equipment also started trying to crack the encrypted text.

Joachim Schuth, a Bonn-based software engineer, cracked the code late on Thursday night.

Colossus eventually completed the challenge at 1:15pm yesterday afternoon, after taking a respectable three hours and 35 minutes, overcoming transmission problems and a blown valve.

Andy Clark, a spokesman for the Bletchley Park museum, said: "We are absolutely delighted with the performance of the Colossus."

The machines were broken up after the end of the war to preserve their secret. Over the past 14 years, experts have painstakingly rebuilt a Colossus Mark II, gleaning information from those involved in the creation of the original.

The 10 Mark II Colossus machines enabled code-breakers at Bletchley to decipher Nazi communications, leading to the war being shortened by many months and saving thousands of lives.



The full article contains 280 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 16 November 2007 9:50 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: World War II
 
1

Guga II,

Rockall 17/11/2007 03:11:38

The machines were broken up after the war on the orders of that fat old drunk Churchill, in another of his many memorable disasterous decisions.

2

Jim A,

17/11/2007 03:42:13

#1 Guga II, you wrote, "The machines were broken up after the war on the orders of that fat old drunk Churchill, in another of his many memorable disasterous decisions"

If you can get out to your local library see if they have a book called
The Turn of the Tide; a history of the war years based on the diaries of Field-Marshal Lord Alanbrooke, chief of the Imperial General Staff.

Fat? Yes he was, a drunk? Maybe, but he was no fool and despite what you think mate he saved a lot of Allied lives. Give the book a read and you will see what I mean, Alanbrooke was somestimes driven to distraction by Churchill but read what he says about him. It may just change your opion of the man.

3

Guga II,

Rockall 17/11/2007 04:12:43

#2 Jim A. Why don't you have a wee read about the history of the man, and his role in the Dardanelles; in Tonypandy in 1910 where he brought in troops against the miners; in Clydeside in 1919 where he brought in 10,000 English troops, and tanks, against the Scottish people, whilst keeping Scottish troops confined to barracks.

This was the same fat drunk that lived off the fat of the land, and drunk champagne and whisky like it was going out of fashion while ordinary people were struggling to get enough to eat from their miserable rations; and who was deep in a bunker while the London people had to literally force their way into the Underground to get some shelter from the bombing.

That fat, self-publicising drunk was responsible over the years for the deaths on many thousands of people, particularly in the Dardanelles campaign, all because of his fixation with the Balkans.

Don't be fooled into thinking that he was the only person capable of leading us through the Second World War, it is only his self-publicity that has led people to that conclusion.

4

Scullion,

Canada 17/11/2007 04:20:59

#2
I have to agree with Guga, to a point. Churchill was saved by WWII. Before it he was booed and spat at by his Dundee constituents, changed parties several times, sent the Black and Tans into Ireland among many other gaffes and if anything he shows that the upper crust in Britain can ruin everything they touch and still run the country. When the war was all but won, the nation knew that he wasn't the man to lead them in peacetime.
However, I believe he was a brave man and his own willingness to die for Britain and his penchant for turning marvelous phrases bouyed up a nation that was in desperate need of a strong personality to lean on.

5

Jim A,

17/11/2007 04:54:28

#2 Guga , you said "2 Jim A. Why don't you have a wee read about the history of the man, and his role in the Dardanelles; in Tonypandy in 1910 where he brought in troops against the miners; in Clydeside in 1919 where he brought in 10,000 English troops, and tanks, against the Scottish people, whilst keeping Scottish troops confined to barracks".

I've read it mate and I'm aware of Churchills history, all the same go get a hold of the book I mentioned above and see what his top General and the Chiefs of staff say about him. I agree he's all the things you say and he did all the things you say but during WWII mate he was more often right than wrong. Just check out the book if you have time to, it's very interesting reading.

6

Cywiro,

Caerphilly 17/11/2007 06:40:53

I agree with everybody’s comments here - Churchill was all those things!
It’s true that he had the Colossus machines broken up (“into pieces no bigger than a man’s hand”) and the blueprints destroyed, but this was in order to prevent the technology falling into the hands of the Soviet Union. Although our “allies” at the time, Churchill correctly warned against the ambitions of the Soviets – as he had done with the Nazis in the 1930’s. If Stalin’s scientists had had the use of an electronic digital computer they might have won the race to develop the H-bomb before the US (1951). They did, in fact, come close to doing this in 1949 before they had even detonated an A-bomb. The fact that The Scotsman is still printed in English not Russian vindicates Churchill’s actions.
Btw, two Colossus machines were reputedly spared for use by GCHQ and remained in service until 1959/60 (some say a few years longer).

7

Navvy,

17/11/2007 07:18:19

A bit of a spat here. As for his Dundee constituents, obviously there were plenty who voted for him or he would not have been elected. He was not the last person to change parties and clearly the Liberals failed to convert him to more 'liberal" views.

It is always a moot point when seeking to judge actions of the past by the standards of the present and he was a member of a freely elected government albeit one in a nation with a much narrower franchise than today.

We have all changed since those days.

Many great men are flawed. We should remember that he succeeded where Chamberlain failed and that he led an all party national government. His oratory was pure brilliance and his management of an unwilling and even hostile America greatly helped our lonesome and desperate fight for SURVIVAL. Remember it all.

8

Pete39,

Tassy 17/11/2007 07:56:26

Aye that fat old geezer once gave a speech to the masses. An aide mentioned that it was impressive that there was well over 20,000 folk gathered to listen to him. Churchill replied that if he was being hung there would be ten times that amount. There have been one or two politicians with same drive and integrity as Churchill. You could count them on one hand. None of them were Labour politicians.

9

JJJJ,

UK 17/11/2007 11:01:19

Why don't you all just take this story for what it is - the story of an engineering marvel that saved lives. Yes as always there is a lot of politics behind this, but you should set that aside and simply admire this machine and it's achivement in its own right.

So stop whinging! Why not praise the guys that have rebuilt this piece of history. I for one think it's amazing that a WW2 machine can crack these codes in a similar amount of time to a modern computer (yes I know the reasons why).

I am british but of polish decendents, and I feel very proud of the british nation and it's achivements. Rebuilding this machine means that I can have a chance to see an amazing piece of history with my own eyes.

10

Wolfrace,

Sussex 17/11/2007 11:40:10

This is directed to all posts above - I don't know if any of you lived through the second world war, but I did, and I firmly believe that without Churchill, Alan Turing and others at Bletchley you would not be alive today. Churchill drank heavily, smoked a lot, used bad language, but his leadership saved us from slavery and/or death at the hands of the Nazis and also the Russians. Turing was gay and lost his life because of narrow minded people like some, but without his brain to help us we would not have won the war... There were many others who played their part, of course, but these people and others like them were our salvation. I doubt the same might have been said of certain posters in similar straights.

11

zeno,

17/11/2007 11:40:54

JJJJ Hear, hear. It is a marvel of engineering and a testament to the dedication of those who re-built it.

12

Theo,

Virginia 17/11/2007 21:54:57

I guess most of you feel Chamberlain (we have an agreement) would have been better if he had lived?

13

Gordon Angus,

Sydney, Not the Australian one 18/11/2007 08:09:33

In view of the misinformation above, the fate of the Colossi (plural of Colossus) is very well documented in a number of easily available books. As the First Sea Lord of The Admiralty, Churchill was a driving force behind the setting up of the intercept organisation in 1939. And on becoming Prime Minister in May 1940 (nearly 66 years of age), and in the midst of the evacuation of the troops from France, made the setting up of BLetchly Park a major priority.
He was defeated in the JULY 1945 elections, and according to Tommy FLowers the General Post Office engineer who designed, built and maintained the Colossi, he destroyed all of the relevent paperwork and those machines remaining in Bletchly Park in JUNE 1946 upon the direct instructions of the Clement ATTALEE Labour Government.
And again according to Flowers the last Colossus held by GCHQ was written off in 1960.
Yours,
G/.

14

49th State,

following the path of the sand man 18/11/2007 08:33:18

I think Churchill was a great man. He was a sneeky old fart, talking us into getting involved in the war and all.

15

Dafydd,

18/11/2007 13:13:12

http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/colossus?view=uk

Plural of Colossus can be Colossi OR Colossuses


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Is the government right to continue with its policy of cutting down quangos?
No, I think their independence means we get a better job
Yes, they are unaccountable and expensive
Only if their work is duplicated or plainly redundant

Web Links:

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.