Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Village hit by insect plague

Climate change blamed after hundreds fall ill

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 December 2007
PANIC started to spread through the village of Castiglione di Cervia in Italy in August as one person after another fell ill with weeks of high fever, exhaustion and excruciating bone pain, just as most of the nation was enjoying Ferragosto, its most important summer holiday.
By the middle of the month, more than 100 people had come down with the same illness. Although the worst symptoms dissipated after a couple of weeks, doctors were unable to diagnose what was wrong.

Antonio Ciano, 62, recalled: "At one point, I si
mply couldn't stand up to get out of the car. I fell. I thought, OK, my time is up. I'm going to die. It was really that dramatic."

River pollution was blamed. People denounced the government. But most of all they blamed recent immigrants from tropical Africa for bringing the pestilence.

"Why immigrants?" asked Rina Ventura, who owns a shoe shop: "I kept thinking of these terrible diseases that you see on TV, like malaria. We were terrified. There was no name and no treatment."

The villagers were both right and wrong. After a month of investigation, Italian public health officials discovered that the people of the village, population 2,000, were, in fact, suffering from a tropical disease, chikungunya, a relative of dengue fever normally found in the Indian Ocean region. However, the immigrants spreading the disease were not humans, but insects: tiger mosquitoes, who can thrive in a warming Europe.

Aided by global warming and globalisation, Castiglione di Cervia has the dubious distinction of playing host to the first outbreak in modern Europe of a disease that had previously been seen only in the tropics.

From the start, doctors suspected that the disease was spread by insects, rather than people. While almost all homes had one person who was ill, family members seemed not to catch the disease from one another.

"By the time we got back the name and surname of the virus, our outbreak was over," said Dr Rafaella Angelini, director of the regional public health department in Ravenna. "When they told us it was chikungunya, it was not a problem for Ravenna any more. But I thought: this is a big problem for Europe."

The epidemic proved that tropical viruses are now able to spread in new areas, far north of their previous range. The tiger mosquito, which first arrived in Ravenna three years ago, is thriving across southern Europe and even in France and Switzerland.

Dr Angelini added that if chikungunya can spread to Castiglione, there is no reason why it cannot go to other Italian villages. There is no reason why dengue, an even more debilitating tropical disease, cannot as well.

Dr Roberto Bertollini, the director of the World Health Organisation's health and environment programme, said: "This is the first case of an epidemic of a tropical disease in a developed, European country. Climate change creates conditions that make it easier for this mosquito to survive and it opens the door to diseases that didn't exist here previously. This is a real issue. Now, today. It is not something a crazy environmentalist is warning about."

With climate change at hand, Dr Bertollini said, chikungunya will surely be back somewhere in Europe again.

BLOOD RELATIVE

CHIKUNGUNYA is spread when tiger mosquitoes drink blood from an infected person and, if conditions are right, pass the virus on when they bite again.

Tiger mosquitoes first came to southern Italy with shipments of tyres from Albania about a decade ago, and their habitat has expanded steadily north as temperatures have risen. But the doctors were baffled by how the virus made its way into mosquitoes in northern Italy since no-one in Castiglione di Cervia had been abroad. Eventually investigators discovered a link: one of the first men to fall ill in Castiglione di Cervia had been visited by a feverish relative in early July. That relative, an Italian, had previously travelled to Kerala, India.

Chikungunya came to Italy in his blood, but climatic conditions are now such that it can spread and find a home .



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 23 December 2007 11:33 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Kipling,

24/12/2007 12:22:05
"Tiger mosquitoes first came to southern Italy with shipments of tyres from Albania about a decade ago" & "one of the first men to fall ill in Castiglione di Cervia had been visited by a feverish relative in early July.. [who had] previously travelled to Kerala, India".

So too the spread of destructive algae to marine life via ships; so too the spread of diseases and parasites across Africa with migration, sexual diseases from Europe to South America, tobacco from the Americas to Europe; tuberculosis has risen in the UK, not unassociated with immigration from south Asia to the union & so on.

The assumption that it was due to movement of populations was not a 'racist' one, as somewhat implied at the beginning of the article, although other types of movement and carriage could be included in general health education. Australia has had a strict policy, I believe, of checking migrants for communicable diseases. And in the UK there are known cases of inexperienced doctors failing to recognise malaria in patients who had been abroad & this goes back a long way before 'global warming' was on the agenda.

Given all this is known to those in public health, why does the director of the World Health Organisation's health and environment programme attribute those who are simply trying to think ahead as "crazy environmentalists"? Doesn't his organisation value preventative medicine? Is WHO only a reactive agency?
2

Kobi.,

24/12/2007 13:53:10
"Aided by global warming"

Utter rubbish.

In reports today it was claimed that the deteriorating standard of journalism to be found at the Scotsman newspaper was due to global warming.
3

Kipling,

24/12/2007 20:12:41
#2. "global warming" just means average temperature rising world wide. The story doesn't attribute the phenomenon to carbon emissions, nor does it by omission deny that this might be followed by an ice age, nor does it deny that it was pretty hot in the Middle Ages, nor does it deny that the temperature in my home is now 3deg.C. And getting colder. But the other summer it was 30deg.F. and for several summers hotter than I've ever experienced. And of course there is the problem of less birds = more mustiques. Where the writer goes wrong is perhaps in not advising us of the size of the bird-killing cat population in north Italy so we can make up our own minds.
4

Kobi.,

25/12/2007 07:40:19
#3

"There is also nothing new about mosquito-borne disease in Europe. Until DDT, malaria was endemic and common in many regions as far north as Russia, with 13 million cases a year in the 1920s: at Archangel, on the edge of the Arctic Circle, 10,000 people died in one year. In Italy the highest incidence was in the Po valley, in exactly the same area now hit by chikungunya. Dengue, another so-called tropical virus infected 1,000,000 people in Greece in the 1920s.

"Despite all this, a WHO official has claimed that warming allowed this cold-weather mosquito to settle in Italy. Whether this is ignorance or deliberate mis-information, it diverts attention from the real cause: the increasing globalization of disease as a result of modern transportation."


Professor Paul Reiter, Director of the Insects and Infectious Diseases Unit of the Institut Pasteur, Paris

 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.