Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Tablet links Judaism and Christianity

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 July 2008
AN ANCIENT Hebrew tablet to be highlighted at an Israeli conference of biblical scholars today could link Christianity far more intimately with Judaism than previously recognised.
According to Israel Knohl, a professor of Bible studies at the Hebrew University, the 87-line tablet, dating from the years before the birth of Jesus, shows the idea that the messiah would be resurrected after three days is not original to Christia
nity.

"We can see much more clearly the common roots of Judaism and Christianity," Prof Knohl said. "The finding places Jesus in the context of the messianism of this period."

The stone tablet had been in the hands of a Swiss-Israeli collector for about a decade after he bought it from a Jordanian antiquities dealer. It is believed to have been found on the Jordanian side of the Dead Sea.

Prof Knohl, an expert on the language of the Bible and Talmud, who has long argued that the idea of a suffering messiah existed before Jesus, turned his attention to the tablet after reading an analysis of its contents last year that dated it to the late first century BC.

The tablet's text concerns an apocalyptic vision transmitted by the archangel Gabriel and draws on Old Testament prophets Daniel, Hagai and Zachariah. Prof Knohl says he has filled in a crucial missing word, hayeh, meaning live, making a line of the text say: "In three days you shall live, I Gabriel command you."

According to the tablet, the command is addressed to "The Prince of Princes". Ada Yardeni, one of the scholars who wrote the original analysis of the tablet, says Prof Knoll's deciphering of the word hayeh was "100 per cent" accurate.

Prof Knohl is convinced that "Jesus acted according to the concepts in the tablet: that the messiah must die to bring redemption".



The full article contains 309 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 July 2008 10:04 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Lobeydoser,

08/07/2008 00:20:16
I hope that they didn't miss the label "Holy Land Souvenirs Inc"!
2

2dogs in D.C.,

08/07/2008 00:49:23
#1-You beat me to it! :)
3

Guga II,

Rockall 08/07/2008 01:45:24
#1. Or the small print in the corner saying "Made in Taiwan".
4

yockel,

08/07/2008 06:40:20
Interesting that Gabriel, who ever he is meant to be, is in a position to command the messiah. Slight readjustment of Christianity required?

Suppose the prior existence of the myth explains why the hingers on had to claim a resurrection.
5

follow the evidence,

Atlanta 08/07/2008 10:55:51
Trying to spin this discovery, if it turns out to be genuine, as a problem for Christianity or the belief that Jesus is the Jewish Messiah is illogical and contradictory. The opposite is actually the case. Messianic believers already point to dozens of passages from the Jewish Prophets that predate Jesus that predict a Suffering Messiah that is killed and returns to life. (See the dead sea scrolls, Great Isaiah Scroll, Isaiah 53) . If this tablet turns out to be authentic, then it is just another Jewish text, like the scrolls of the prophets that points to a suffering and resurrected Messiah. An additional text like this one adds support rather than detracts from the Christian message.

The idea that this could explain away the origin of the resurrection reports is equally foolish. There were several Messiah wannabes in the first and 2nd century. Why didn't they all have a resurrection story associated with them? The disciples must have had actual experiences for the event to be reported.

Finally, if this tablet does prove to be authentic it should finally put to death all that outdated skeptical nonsense that claims the resurrection story has a pagan, non-Jewish origin. What this tablet actually represents is a blow to all those half-baked Atheistic sites on the web, that want to claim the reports can be explained away as pagan myths. The suffering and rising Messiah is entirely a Jewish expectation from within Jewish tradition. For such Orthodox Jews only an actual bodily and tangible resurrection would be convincing. They would literally have to touch the Messiah who had been returned from the dead to be convinced.


Some Hassidic Jews today believe that Rabbi Schneerson is the Messiah although he died in the 90s. These Orthodox believers believe that Rabbi Schneerson will rise from the dead. At the moment he is still very much dead, and no reports of his resurrection have been circulated. The reason no "He's alive" cult has developed is
6

Newman!,

08/07/2008 11:31:01
#5 Cobblers.

I'm the messiah, and so is my wife.
7

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

08/07/2008 11:48:17
5...And thats another thing...how come Orthodox Jewish wumman hiv tae hid there hair whin they git married,cover it wae a wig and only their husbands kin see it thereafter..?..I mean is that no jist a big piece o' bliddy nonsense or whit?

Wumman hidin thir hair??..2008..!!......
8

AJ Fife,

08/07/2008 12:58:03
Canky,

It could be worse, the Jewish Unorthodox Church insist the wumin get married whilst riding aboot on a unicycle, juggling three terry chocolate oranges and blawin' intae a mouthie, aw at the same time!
9

Alan Abbey,

Jerusalem, Israel 08/07/2008 13:20:46
Read Israel Knohl's full argument only on the Shalom Hartman Institute website. Knohl is a Senior Fellow at the Institute in Jerusalem, Israel: http://hartman.org.il/
10

hertscot,

08/07/2008 13:34:21
Sorry, but, is there any rational person out there who believes that that the 3 Abrahamic religions are NOT intrinsicly linked?
11

Mcsnagpile,

08/07/2008 14:17:24
Wait a minute, Jesus rose on the second day. He died on bad Friday and rose on Easter Sunday- two days?? So now you are saying he rose like everybody else on a Monday
12

Gere,

Scotland 08/07/2008 14:19:27
This European adoption of the worrship of an Asian God on a cross almost completly destroyed the tolerant Pagan European Civilization.

The dark ages fell circa 415 AD with the murder of Hypatia, the last librarian of Alexandria by the Christian folowers oc Bisop Cyril of Alexandria, later St Cyril. Democracy itself was a gift from Pagan Europe, a man called Pericles circa 400 BC in Athens thought this up.

Learning was considered Pagan by the early church, subject to strict control by the clergy. Allowing freedom of thought was anathema to a intolerant Asian religion. Unfortunately, tolerant Pagan Europe even tolerated the early christians, until Rome woke up to the fact that intolerant Christians would not abide other faiths. Alas, their awakening came too late, for all we know, Nero might have been right about the fire. Christian fanatics could have had something to do with it.

Europe was to suffer Christian oppression and the accompanying clamp on knowledge for nearly two thousand years before slowly re-asserting the treasured European concept of free thought and enquiry.

Let us return to our tolerant Pagan spiritual roots!
13

The Batboy,

08/07/2008 14:29:59
He's NOT the Messiah! He's a very naughty boy!!!
14

57Nomad,

california 08/07/2008 19:27:38
#12 gere

gere said:

"Let us return to our tolerant Pagan spiritual roots!"

If you live in Great Britain then your spiritual roots are by way of the Druids. The Druids practiced human sacrifice. Tolerant?
15

Pilrig.,

Livingston 08/07/2008 21:05:02
5 - David Shayler is the Messiah. He said so. His miraculous powers got Middlebrough to the 2006 UEFA Cup final.
Ok they didn't win the final that's cos Dave was p*ssed at the game, and you can't work miracles when you're bevvied !
16

Pilrig.,

Livingston 08/07/2008 21:07:07
14 - true, but oor friendly Christian ancestors used to burn witches at the stake.
"He that is withoot sin, cast the first stane"
17

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

08/07/2008 21:42:55
8....aye and cookin up a Kosher banquet fir the guests it the same time AJ!

14...Think thit ye'll find the modern 'tolerant' pagan/druid type disnae go in fir a bit o' human sacrafice these days...they've pit aw that behind thim...jist like the Christian lot hiv wae the burnin o' the witches....I think...
18

The Daleks,

Longmen 09/07/2008 11:15:03
#12 Gere

Sounds a lot like what's happening with the spread of Islam into Europe from Asia, these days.
19

57Nomad,

california 10/07/2008 02:55:36
#16 Pilrig

Pilrig said:

""He that is withoot sin, cast the first stane""

Thats a good point and exactly the one I was making in my post. Thank you for your support.
20

57Nomad,

california 10/07/2008 03:09:10
#17 HC

HC said:

"Think thit ye'll find the modern 'tolerant' pagan/druid type disnae go in fir a bit o' human sacrafice these days...they've pit aw that behind thim..."

You are no doubt correct. I would take exception with the idea of "modern" Druids. If any of the "play druids" of today got transported back about 3000 years and bumped into some real Druids they'd be in trouble.

Here's the equation, no human sacrifice, no druid. Hey, these guys weren't cupcakes, you know. You didn't get to be the Druid Priest without smacking a bunch of Druid Priest contenders. You can't have a whole flock of Priests as that dilutes the exclusivity factor so sought after by our neolithic predecessors. No weenies allowed, and especially no 'accountants by day, druid by night' poseurs sashaying around in silk robes and pointy hats. Modern Druids, indeed!



 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.