Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Scandal of Canada’s ‘stolen ones’

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 May 2008
AFTER decades of dragging its feet, Canada is about to take a close look at what one aboriginal leader calls “the single most disgraceful, harmful and racist act in our history”.
From the 1870s to the 1970s, some 150,000 native Indian children were forcibly removed from their parents and sent to distant residential schools. Many say they were abused mentally, physically and sexually.

Conditions in the schools – run by va
rious churches on behalf of the government – were sometimes dire. Contemporary accounts suggest up to half the children in some institutions died of tuberculosis.

One prominent academic calls what happened a genocide, yet for many years, few Canadians knew what had happened. Now, for the first time, the mainstream population is to learn a lot more about what was done in its name.

As part of a C$1.9 billion (£975 million) settlement between Ottawa and the 90,000 school survivors that ended years of law suits, a truth and reconciliation commission is to start work next week. It will travel across Canada to hold hearings on the abuses.

Chuck Strahl, Canada’s minister for Indian affairs, said: “You have to get the truth out…it seems impossible today, but it’s real, it happened.”

Native leaders hope the commission – to be headed by an aboriginal judge, Harry LaForme – will help improve ties between their largely marginalised community of 1.1 million and the rest of the 32 million population.

Mr LaForme said: “I don’t say this is going to be a magic wand and everybody is going to feel good when this is over. But we do know there is a healing component to that sort of process.”

In decades past, government officials said the residential schools were supposed to educate native children. The other aim was to assimilate aboriginal peoples and crush their cultures. Duncan Campbell Scott, a senior government bureaucrat dealing with aboriginal matters, declared in 1920: “I want to get rid of the Indian problem.” He went on: “Our objective is to continue until there is not a single Indian in Canada that has not been absorbed into the body politic.”

Children in the schools were called pigs and dogs. Teachers beat them if they used their own languages and told them they would go to hell unless they converted to Christianity. Many parents never saw their sons and daughters again. Survivors often took to drugs and alcohol to dim the pain.

Critics, noting the commission will not have subpoena powers, say it will not make much of a difference.

Roland Chrisjohn, of the University of St Thomas in New Brunswick, said Ottawa must first admit that taking children from their parents and giving them to outsiders constituted an act of genocide. “Residential schools were about destroying our political systems, our religious systems, our communities, our cultures, our livelihood. They largely succeeded,” he said.

The churches are suitably contrite. Fred Hiltz, primate of the Anglican Church of Canada, said the religious authorities had tried to “socialise and Christianise” aboriginal peoples. “We failed them, we failed ourselves, we failed God. We failed because of our racism and because of the belief that white ways were superior to aboriginal ways,” he said.

Ted Quewezance, director of the National Residential School Survivors’ Society, is confident the commission will help reconciliation efforts. He was abused physically and sexually during seven years at a school, and when asked how he coped with the memories, he replied: “You just live with it, that’s all.”

The scandal has strong parallels with what happened at the same time in Australia, where at least 100,000 aboriginal children were removed from their parents for a variety of reasons. Kevin Rudd, the prime minister, apologised to the “Stolen Generations” in February.

Canada’s prime minister, Stephen Harper, will meet a key aboriginal demand on 11 June, when he formally apologises too.

No-one knows whether Canadians will pay much attention to the hearings.

Tribal chief Robert Joseph said: “If they don’t listen, it will be a tragedy. I think once and for all we, as aboriginal people, will be certain Canadians simply dismiss us as nothing important…that would be the worst insult of all.”

First Nations peoples fight for dignity after years of oppression

THE aboriginal peoples of Canada are split broadly into three groups. People of First Nations descent number some 700,000, the Métis comprise about 400,000 and the Inuit about 50,000.

First Nations peoples live predominately in the provinces of Ontario and British Columbia, but communities live across most of the other provinces.

Their ancestors were prairie living and similar to the Native American tribes of the great plains in the United States.

The terminology used to describe them has been a frequent source of controversy and up until the 1980s, they were frequently known as “Indian bands”. There are more than 600 recognised First Nations governments or bands in Canada.

The Métis are descendants of marriages of Cree, Ojibway, Saulteaux, and Menominee aboriginals to French Canadians, Scots and English.

Inuit is a general term for a group of culturally similar peoples inhabiting the Arctic regions of Alaska, Greenland, and Canada. They were formerly known as Eskimos, but in Canada and Greenland the term is now considered pejorative.

Although Canada spends about C$10 billion (£5.09 billion) a year on the aboriginal population, many serious problems remain.

Native leaders say the destructive legacy of the schools helps explain the lamentable living conditions, poor health and high crime levels that many face today.

“I think Canadians will have a better appreciation of why we have become so stereotyped – that we’re lazy, or losers, or drunkards, or whatever. [This] resulted from a very destructive, oppressive colonisation of aboriginal people,” said Chief Robert Joseph.

www.wherearethechildren.ca



The full article contains 979 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 29 May 2008 11:27 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

,

30/05/2008 00:49:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

truthsleuth,

30/05/2008 01:16:02
Eskimo was the name for a people who through honest toil made good of their lives and their harsh environment. How can such a term be taken as other than 'in praise' of those so described.

Unless of course it is in aid of claiming compensation for 'historical events'.

These claims are ridiculous we shall soon hear that the descendants of Adam and Eve are suing the snakes.
3

truthsleuth,

30/05/2008 01:16:21
or should it be God.
4

Scullion,

Canada 30/05/2008 01:19:15
It is a complex problem that has its roots in a simple power and land grab by invaders. Only Australia can appreciate the struggle we have to keep aboriginal culture alive. It is an almost Darwinian battle as natives want to retain their heritage but the siren call of white society is often too strong and is often destructive to them.
The U.S. had a far more confrontational style with their aboriginals which led to problems such as Wounded Knee but has led to, it seems, some real success stories on some of their reserves (often through the establishing of gambling or other tax haven industries).
5

Biker,

Ayr 30/05/2008 08:10:32
As Scullion points out Australia can be accused of the same thing for many decades. I dissagree however that this was done to keep the native culture alive. In most cases it was a crude attempt at ethnic cleansing, nothing more. Cheap labour and a constant supply of workers. As the article above points out , many died from tuberculosis or indeed other aflictions.
This can also be appied to the UK who allowed Dr Bernardos to send children to Australia and other parts of the world, often without their relatives knowing about it.
What a world we live in!!!!!!
6

Montford's Jaicket,

Hanging around 30/05/2008 08:45:55
"In decades past, government officials said the residential schools were supposed to educate native children. The other aim was to assimilate aboriginal peoples and crush their cultures.

Teachers beat them if they used their own languages...

Many parents never saw their sons and daughters again."

Sounds not too dissimilar to the Highland Clearances.
7

donald,

glasgow 30/05/2008 09:02:06
Sounds like wot they did to our Gaelic speakers.
8

Pilrig.,

Livingston 30/05/2008 09:08:01
6 - some of are. You see in the grand British imperial scheme of things the aboriginal peoples didnae count for much. I'm not just talking aboot Canada and Aussieland. For instance the Great Famine in Ireland, what did a couple of million non-Church of Ireland members matter in the eyes of the imperialists.
And so to Scotland, we were told our history didn't amount to much (an attitude that still exists in some parts of the Labour Party). We are still told that Gaelic is a waste of time and money and that the Scots/Doric tongue is little more than slang. We should know oor own place in the grand scheme of things...and of course pay oor taxes on time !
9

Pilrig.,

Livingston 30/05/2008 09:11:53
10 should have read "8 - some of us are etc"
Never compose an e post before breakfast !
10

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 30/05/2008 09:39:23
Destroy their culture.

Create a state of dependence.

Steal all their natural resources

Lots of parrelels don't you think.
11

postmark54,

Chongqing, China, 30/05/2008 10:16:08
The reality is that in the end nothing will come from this, I lived in Canada for more than 47 years, and this subject was brought up many times, and swept under the rug everytime. The Canadian government and the guilty churches are waiting to see the last of the victims die, and then the payouts don't have to be so large, and they hope by then most everybody has forgotten what happened. The Anglican church was so bad, and really still is, for they have not settled anything with the natives, again, waiting and holding out for all to die off. It really is a sad story, but I can't see anything positive coming out of it anytime soon.
I have visited many reserves and talked to many victims and their families, and none hold out much hope. Most have very low self esteem and blame that on what happened at the hands of the church, and indirectly, the government.
12

MacLaren,

30/05/2008 13:09:23
The US, Canada, and Australia are fairly new countries and still have aboriginal culture. Most of the criticism directed toward these nations from us Europeans who destroyed our own and then set ships to destroy others are laughable. How dare we criticize anyone, we have the worst history of anyone.

Africa still has place that practice slavery and genocide, few places in the Middle East allow religious freedom, look at China, and people on this thread are critiquing Canada? Unreal.
13

postmark54,

Chongqing, China, 30/05/2008 13:30:25
#15 MacLaren,
Canada needs to clear this issue up now, and that will not happen. This is not what anybody else has done, it still doesn't change the fact what's at stake here now, and it needs to be resolved now. The damage can never be undone or reversed, but some type of compensation needs to be paid, if just to show that we can not and will not tolerate what the church and government is guilty of. What is 'unreal' here is that you fail to see what damage has been done to those people, and it is 'unreal' that you compare this to anything else, this is a tragedy to these people, comparisons are not necessary as to how bad they had it compared to other people who have suffered whatever they have suffered.
14

,

30/05/2008 14:15:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 30/05/2008 14:46:50
I, for one, WILL be listening to the findings of this "reconciliation commission".

Too often I have noticed on the streets of downtown Ottawa within sight of the ParliamentBuildings drunk Inuits of both sexes passed out on cheap rotgut sherry and/or drugs. This is a national disgrace and is not
confined to Ottawa.

We have failed the Inuit miserably.

truthsleuth @ 2

Your conception of the word "eskimo" may be erroneous.

It was employed as a pejorative term by those who settled Canada's north and is now replaced by the more correct word "Inuit".

The word "eskimo" has a disputed etymology and means "eaters of raw meat" and was employed by the "conquerers" of Canada's north from England and France to denigrate the Inuit for their supposedly unsophisticated and crude eating habits.

It was VERY hard for the Inuit to cook their whale and seal blubber and meat as wood was VERY scarce so they were forced by necessity to eat their meat raw in order to survive.

I hope this clarifies.


16

Helene,

Ontario Canada 30/05/2008 14:54:43
Good comments from Canadians and others. I have taught many native children and have seen how much "they" and "we" are at odds. There'so immediate answer. I wish I could say something more to enlighten.
17

Darren_Prefontaine ,

Saskatchewan, Canada 30/05/2008 15:11:08
A very good story and truly Canada's greatest shame. Remember, however, Canadians learned this genocidal behaviour from Mother Britain. Wherever, the Brits settled, these terrible things occurred: Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, India, America...
18

,

30/05/2008 15:52:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
19

postmark54,

Chongqing, China, 30/05/2008 16:16:05
#17 Whisky Smuggler,
Our current government in China is indeed a kind and caring government, one look at the job well done after that horrible earthquake should verify that.. I can't and won't comment on previous governments, that was before my time, and I have learned not to trust the western media when it comes to reporting about China, I've witnessed them telling many lies since I've resided here since September of 2005.
I do feel comfortable about stating my opinion as to what is happening to the natives there in Canada, since I've talked to many , at many reserves, mainly in British Columbia. Those people suffered a horrible ordeal, and squat has been done about that, and yet both the church and government have admitted to wrongdoings, so these are not just stories. If you find me to be pathetic because I side with the natives and feel that justice should be served, so be it, you're entitled to your opinion as much as I am to mine.
20

,

30/05/2008 16:50:33
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 30/05/2008 19:20:36
Where ever the European colonial powers went in the world: Africa, North America, South America, and Australasia, after carving up the land and resources they used Christianity in the name of civilisation as an excuse to ethnically cleanse the native peoples from their lands, and steal their children!

The controversial BBC television series about Empire proved to be too much for many Old Indian Diehards, as Great Britain was one of the worst offenders!

22

Pilrig.,

Livingston 30/05/2008 19:52:09
15 - wrongdoing is wrongdoing, whether it be Canada or Timbuktu
23

Pilrig.,

Livingston 30/05/2008 19:54:31
20 and that is why the flag is sometimes referred to as the Butcher's Apron.
24

Pilrig.,

Livingston 30/05/2008 19:56:06
22 ditto the Yanks
25

Dekester,

Canada's westcoast 30/05/2008 20:10:58
Postmark 54.

What tosh! I work with and around natives. Some of the wealthiest folks I know are natives. Google the Musqueam band. Or any of those on the North shore.

Free university education, free medical and dental. No income tax. Tax free cigarettes and liquor.Free on reserve housing. Nearly half of BC'S allocated fish harvest.

I know one native that owns, yes owns 3 condos in Hawaii.

I too know several residential school survivors, and yes their's was a sorry,sorry lot. The churches did the damage though.

All the best.

26

Hawks1,

Salida Ca 30/05/2008 21:54:43
To insensitive people like truthsleuth, who think nothing of adding insult to injury, I ask one question? "Where is your sense of Humanity?" or do you lack such characteristics due to lack of being properly raised, informed and read? History repeats itself in repetitive loops (Full Circle) when it`s lessons are not grasped, learned and owned. Which means Creations Laws apply to ALL OF US. No exceptions. All that is being required of the Perpetrators here is to take full responsibility for their actions and lack thereof in regard to atrocities exacted upon your fellow Human Beings, who did not ask for your impositions upon them. When will we as a Species on Mother Earth finally come to our senses and reason?
27

Kipling,

North of the Mounth (at least in Spirit) 30/05/2008 23:01:34
#9. Ah, the poor Gaels. So tell me, what happened to the Pictish language? Did the Gaels have no hand in its disappearance then?
28

Pilrig.,

Livingston 30/05/2008 23:18:17
31 it fell into disuse. Perhaps the Gaels did have a hand in it's disappearance. The sins of the fathers shouldn't be visited on their children. Anyway Gaelic and it's sister languages Lowland Scots and Doric, should be encouraged and promulgated. As I've asked before, what price Scottish culture ?
29

Truely English,

31/05/2008 22:50:32
I see the name of the person mentioned was Duncan Campbell Scott. So the Scots were never involved in assimilatation like the rest of the countries. Of course they were, but they blame the English for anything unfavourable.

Nothing changed there then.
30

,

01/06/2008 04:24:23
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.