Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Half Price Tapas with Scotland on Sunday

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Resign or we will impeach you, call-girl scandal governor is told



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 12 March 2008
THE governor of New York, Eliot Spitzer, could be impeached if he does not quit over a sex scandal.
The threat, by state Republicans, added to the pressure on Mr Spitzer, a Democrat, to step down after a report that he hired a high-priced prostitute.

The Wall Street Journal quoted a person close to Mr Spitzer, who is 48 and married, as saying he
would resign but he wanted to deal with his family crisis first.

"If he does not resign within the next 24 to 48 hours, we will prepare articles of impeachment to remove him," said James Tedisco, the Republican minority leader in the state assembly.

"We need a leader in place that has the support of people on both sides of the aisle."

It was revealed on Monday that Mr Spitzer, a former state chief prosecutor who made his name fighting white-collar crime on Wall Street, hired a $1,000-an-hour prostitute and was caught on a phone wiretap at least six times on 12 and 13 February, arranging to meet her at a Washington hotel.

Mr Spitzer, who also investigated prostitution as chief prosecutor, apologised for what he described as a "private matter" but said nothing about resigning. He spent Monday night holed up at his Manhattan home, besieged by media.

Crime chiefs said yesterday that the investigation began last year during an Internal Revenue Service review of suspicious financial transactions reported to it by banks. "The payments were made over a period of several months in a way that investigators believe was intended to conceal their purpose and source, which could amount to a crime called structuring (punishable by up to five years in prison]," one source said.

Mr Spitzer, viewed as a rising star in the Democratic Party, was elected governor with nearly 70 per cent of the vote in late 2006, following a stint as state attorney general.

At the heart of this scandal is a criminal complaint unveiled last week that charges four people with running a prostitution ring dubbed the Emperors Club. Prosecutors rarely bring charges against clients of prostitutes in such cases.

Mr Spitzer was identified only as "Client 9" in the court papers. According to these, Client 9 arranged to meet with "Kristen", a prostitute who charged $1,000 an hour, on 13 February.

"Client 9" wanted Kristen to go to Washington on a 5:39pm train from Manhattan on that date. The door to the hotel room would be left ajar. Train tickets, cab fare, room service, and the minibar were all on him.

"Yup, same as in the past. No question about it," the caller is said to have told Kristen's boss, when asked if he would make his payment to the same business as usual, a federal affidavit said.

The client paid $4,300 to Kristen, touted by the escort service as a "petite, pretty brunette", according to the court papers.

They went on say that an Emperors Club agent was told by the prostitute that her evening with Client 9 had gone well. The agent said she had been told that the client "would ask you to do things that … you might not think were safe … very basic things," according to the papers, but Kristen responded by saying: "I have a way of dealing with that … I'd be, like, listen dude, you really want the sex?"

Among the charges brought against the four defendants last week was transporting women across state lines for prostitution purposes.

It was not clear last night if a similar charge might be brought against Mr Spitzer if it were proven he arranged for Kristen to travel from New York to Washington to have sex with him.

NEW YORK MEDIA ROUNDS ON SPITZER

ELIOT Spitzer, then attorney general, had this advice in 2006 for people who break the law: Never talk when you can nod, and never nod when you can wink, and never write an e-mail because it's death. You're giving prosecutors all the evidence we need."

His own strident manner has backfired on him now. The New York Times said in an editorial yesterday that his insistence on Monday that it was a "private matter" displayed arrogance. "He did not just betray his family in a private matter," it said.

The Wall Street Journal said he had shown his lack of restraint in overly aggressive tactics as attorney general, making "extraordinary threats" to those who criticised his pursuit of high-profile Wall Street figures.

The New York Daily News, New York Post and Newsday all demanded he quit. "Hit the road, John…and make it quick!" said the Daily News, while the Post called him "NY's naked emperor".



The full article contains 795 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 11 March 2008 11:46 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Carolyn 1,

12/03/2008 00:32:39
another politician hypocrite with a zipper malfunction.
-It's not the sex, it was his attempt to beat the bank by structuring the money transfers that is reprehensible-

Should we blame Harvard for educating these elitists, who have everything, but throw it all away because they think they are above the law?
2

1234567CalScot,

California 12/03/2008 00:34:10
Spitzer has been targeted by big money, especially Wall Sreet, due to his success in ridding us of financial crooks like Grasso. Of course, that doesn't excuse his behavior, but it may explain misleading headlines that say he is involved with a sex ring. He is a client only. So what? How many politicians, what percentage, have used a prostitute? 80%-90% ? They're a bunch of hypocrites, especially the Republican evangelical right. They've been caught with their pants down many a time. This is so typical of the Puritan heritage in the US.

Should he resign? Why should he? If he can be impeached for something trivial like paying for sex, what about Bush being impeached for lies, and spying on Americans and voting to keep torture such as waterboarding?
3

1234567CalScot,

CA 12/03/2008 00:43:08
carolyn. You must have been listening to Fox News. He was not "structuring" money transfers in the way some Republican media would like to depict. He was transfering relatively small sums of money, about 2,000 British Pounds, from his bank account to his wife's. guess what? That is not illegal. He was trying to keep discreet that fact that he was paying money to a prostitute. I have more than one bank account and move funds from one to the other on an as needed basis--usually to pay bills.

By your reckoning, any male who uses a prostitute should be accused of thinking himself above the law.
4

bill2,

12/03/2008 00:47:49
My body is going thu odd changes.
5

bill2,

12/03/2008 00:49:07
What if he was with another man? Whould he still have to resign?
6

Furchrissake,

12/03/2008 01:12:12
4 bill2 - You need a number 2
7

Carolyn 1,

12/03/2008 01:16:22
@ 3 1234567CalScot, CA

No he was structuring- (I have no idea what Fox reported) .

"structuring" is when a person uses a series of withdrawals or transfers, that together add up to the statutory limit, regardless of why a person does it; structuring isn't a crime. So what you said is partly true.
If you transfer money to buy a car, then another few thousand for a vacation- that's structuring but it is not a crime.

It becomes a crime when a person willfully and with intent structure the transactions to avoid suspicion, or cover a crime.
He's going to be indicted under 12CFR21.11

Quoting from 12CFR21

" Whenever the national bank detects any known or suspected Federal criminal violation, or pattern of criminal violations, committed or attempted against the bank or involving a transaction or transactions conducted through the bank and involving or aggregating $25,000 or more in funds or other assets where the bank believes that it was either an actual or potential victim of a criminal violation, or series of criminal violations, or that the bank was used to facilitate a criminal transaction, even though there is no substantial basis for identifying a possible suspect or group of suspects."


No, the jerk was not targeted because he's a democrat or he went after white collar crime, or whatever excuse you come up with; and I could care less who he sleeps with when where why or how or how much the fool paid for it. It's about the law. As a New Yorker I'm glad these DAs are going after the terrorists and corporate theives.

He was targeted because by law, the bank had to report his account to IRS. That's not targeting. That's law.

Using the fork test- this guy's done.
And by the way, there is no evangelical right in New York. It's a very liberal state.
8

bill2,

12/03/2008 02:25:47
6 Furchrissake

I do not understand but I just took a sleeping pill.
9

Guga II,

Rockall 12/03/2008 02:59:26
A politician is a politician, regardless of which country they are in. They are all liars and hypocrites. The only difference is that some are more crooked than others.
10

Mallory,

Edinburgh 12/03/2008 04:37:48
Democrats just cannot keep it under control. Remember Bill Clinton's Bimbo eruptions and cigars. Why is anyone surprised that the governor has been using call-girls?

Of course this would never happen in puritan Scotland where whips and group sex have been, allegedly, in greater demand.

Must be something to do with the climate.
11

GalacticCannibal,

Murrieta 12/03/2008 05:28:32

The client paid $4,300 to Kristen, touted by the escort service as a "petite, pretty brunette", according to the court papers.
-------------------------------------------

WOW at $4,300 for one night . That Babe better be the best there is.

GC
12

Urban Guerrilla,

Edinburgh 12/03/2008 07:57:09
He had sex with a call-girl? So what?

I don't see the relevance to his job. Why on earth should he resign?
13

Boy Wonder,

12/03/2008 08:16:11
What is wrong with people? You want our leaders to be SAINTS?? Newsflash ... they don't exist!!!
14

TheNim1,

12/03/2008 09:11:26
What's the matter with you guys over there? So what if he went with a hooker. That's a matter for him and him alone ( well maybe his family too ). If he did anything illegal such as getting his pleasures paid for on expenses then go ahead and take legal action. And sure - if he campaigned on a righteousness ticket then show him up for the hypocrite he is and go for a vote of no confidence.

Here in France it is normal and almost expected that male politicians have mistresses etc so when something like this comes to light nobody bats an eyelid. Better to measure somebody on what they deliver - just like any other job.
15

Gothic Rose,

12/03/2008 10:06:51
Double Standards? Of course not.Just aquiring the neccessary status symbols that inadequate individuals require,to prop up thier low self esteem.
16

WKKB,

12/03/2008 11:07:35
All this and yet people still vote for Hilary Clinton who turned a blind eye to her husbands infidilities just so she didn't have to move house. I wonder how many more blind eyes she has turned to climb the political power pole. Is it a democrat thing? We never seem to hear about the big bad republicans falling prey to street girls.
17

,

12/03/2008 11:08:36
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
18

WKKB,

12/03/2008 11:10:07
#14 it's normal here in the UK for politicians, princes and who knows who else to be a little less than faithful to their wives and families. I suppose it's that way world wide.
19

,

12/03/2008 11:18:40
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
20

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 12/03/2008 11:36:31
19...Hello mah wee scabbie dug...howsyirboz fir flea bites the morn?...my, Queen troll is still cruisin the forum...somebody really got to you darlin eh?...I would say however, that your reaction is more than slightly extreme, and that you are still in need of psychotherapeutic intervention....mmmmmh yes....quite psychotic...or is that sociopathic?....
21

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 12/03/2008 12:55:11
D'ye reckon Clarry?.....I think he might be giein it "I have shamed my country, colleagues, family and wife" (in that order) and now will jump before I am pushed...."It all happened in a terrible few moments of weakness and I shall now be seeking guidance from my local religieous hoodo man"....then he'l sneak off and resurface as a mayor somewhere.....having foon 'God' again...the benefits of a ham shank and a whole new set of brightly polished values...
22

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 12/03/2008 12:56:28
Doreen and Gothic Rose

Good morning, mesdames.

Boy Wonder

Good morning to you too,sir.

I agree with all three of you and ache for his wife because a close friend is reported as saying she has aged 10 years in 3 days. Why is it that the wives have to suffer the embarrassment and insult from their wayward husbands.

Boy Wonder is correct in that politicians and others in position of power will exercise it in the meeting rooms and bedrooms of the nation. It is all about control and domination.

The late-night talk hosts in the US of A have had a field day with this one. Do you blame them?

Here is a sampling:

1. It's just mind-blowing [sic] that he spent $4,300 on a hooker. It just shows howhigh the cost of living is in New York. That same hooker would cost $50 in Newark.

2. Spitzer's admission that he was involved in a prostitution ring means that Hillary Clinton is now only the second-angriest wife in the state of New York.

3. I sat next to the guy three times and I didn't pick up on any of this and I usually have excellent "wh*re-dar".

4. You've got to say one thing about this. He's been caught soliciting a hooker, but thank God, on the bright side, it did not involve an airport's men's room.

5. I thought Bill Clinton legalised this years ago.

With thanks and acknowledgements to Jay Leno, Conan O'Brien, Stephen Colbert, David Letterman, and Lisa Landry (in no particular order).
23

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 12/03/2008 13:19:57
24....Timothy Charles...that was funny, he'll be squirming in his troosers if he heard any of that!...

It gives me the boke though...what was that comment someone said about the French accepting it?...talking through another orifice...its hugely scandalous and that is a romantic notion that we have of the French....it is bad enough when you are Joe Bloggs on the street to find out that your partner has been paying to have sex with a stranger...but how about your partner is famous and you are thrown (along with your children) completely into the spotlight.... and everyone knows your personal problems?....horrendous...I think you are quite correct, power seems to go directly to the gonads of many a man... the newspapers keep exposing them after all... interesting... Testosterone has a lot to answer for!....in fact is there not a major investigation ongoing into a prostitution online story...that will have many a famous name quaking in their boots?
24

,

12/03/2008 13:24:18
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
25

Urban Guerrilla,

Edinburgh 12/03/2008 13:48:44
A service is offered. Willing buyer, willing seller. What's the problem?
26

GalacticCannibal,

Murrieta, CA....captured from Mexico 1845 12/03/2008 15:45:39
Marriage is a totally unnatural state to live in.
The planet is lop sided with Too many males.

Cull the males from approx 3 billion to 1/2 billion and then maintain that ration of six females to one male.

Prostitution would disappear more or less.

The world is filled with sexually frustrated men, caused by this unnatural marriage union requirement.
One man one woman union is a man made disaster called marriage.

GC



27

The Fly Fifer,

fife 12/03/2008 17:35:09
# 27 because it is against the law, and indeed a law he enforced and prosecuted other people for relentlesly.

If a man has to pay off a woman with money for sex or after an affair or relationship then he is not much of a man, and has little respect for women.
28

,

12/03/2008 17:39:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
29

Laurette,

Carlsbad, California 12/03/2008 19:11:56
What if he was with another man? Whould he still have to resign?

Let's see! We have Larry Craig of the wide stance - still in Congress and Vitter of the Dirty Diaper - still in Congress and applauded by his GOP cohorts when he returned to Washington after taking some time off to make amends to his wife.
30

American,

12/03/2008 19:53:57
#2-1-7calscot-"Spitzer has been targeted by big money, especially Wall Sreet"--Seems you got your facts a little backwards. It has been spitzer targetting big money (or anyone for that matter)."what about Bush being impeached for lies, and spying on Americans"-FYI-I do recall clinton saying the same about saddaam & iraq, and he (clinton) also had wiretappings (written about in 1996). Where do you get your news from--cnn, air america (are they still around??) or al jazeera??

http://www.fff.org/comment/ed0796b.asp

BTW-spitzer wasnt a likeable kind of guy! Bigtime ego.
31

Carolyn 1,

12/03/2008 19:57:10
Another zipper malfunction:
Reza Zarei, the Tehran Police Chief, was caught in bed with SIX prostitutes. Zarei is the guy in charge of the program for the 'moralization of the city'. In the past year 5,700 people have been sent to guidance classes on how to behave in society.
????
I guess it doesn't matter what country, the men do what they want, they get caught sooner or later, the john goes free and the women ends up in jail for the oldest profession, (except in Sharialand where the women end up being stoned while tied to a pole in the ground).


32

American,

12/03/2008 20:01:30
#31-laurette-craig resigned already. And democrat jerry studds (from ma)was applauded by his fellow dems after having a gay affair with a 17 year old male page. My point is both dems and repubs have scum.
33

American,

12/03/2008 20:03:09
#28-GC-"The world is filled with sexually frustrated men"--You cant blame women for that as long as males like you are around.
34

American,

12/03/2008 20:10:59
#12-UG-Prostitution is against the law in most states (it is not in nevada). He is also under investigation for misuse of campaign contribution funds, which may have gone to his pleasure (call girls) instead of his donators intent. Id be pretty p@ssed if I donated to someones campaign and found out it went to his personal call girls instead. And this is one of the politicians who claim to hold a higher standard!!
35

Zyskandar A Jaimot,

orlando, fl usa 12/03/2008 20:17:33
Shame about E-L-I-O-T SPITZER and all being 'caught' using high-priced 'PROSTITUTEES' - but why not a 'PEEP' from US SENATOR CHARLES SCHUMER of NY??? Geez you would think CHUCK'the-schmuck' had something to hide??? Just because he gave/offered the numbers/contact info for the 'EMPERORS CLUB' to E-L-I-O-T - why would that cause CHUCK'the-schmuck' to hunker-down??? Is 'SPITZ' rhymes with 'T^TS' the only POLITICO HACK who likes 'T&A'??? DON'T THINK SO???!!!
36

GalacticCannibal,

Murrieta, CA...bye Bush -Cheney..u. evil leaders. 12/03/2008 20:35:26
35
American,
12/03/2008 20:03:09
#28-GC-"The world is filled with sexually frustrated men"--You cant blame women for that as long as males like you are around.
-------------------------------------
U missed my point Dude.
First I have a girl friend and when we split I will get a new one.

All women are fantastic up to age 30, then their natural motherly instincts take over. Its baby time and all that stuff.

At this point the men who are naturally wired to fertilized the females, need new females to comply with nature.

But instead they are locked into domestic drudgery called marriage.

Its totally unnatural.

A world population in the ratio 6-to-1 (6 females to 1 male) would solve most of the world's problems including wars .

As men would be far too sexually satisfied to start killing .

Ok Dude

GC
37

bill2,

12/03/2008 22:24:34
#26 Finnking

I think you're right
38

Frank Brady,

California 13/03/2008 00:10:05
The $4,300 was for a 2.5 hour tryst (that works out at $1,700 an hour, and Kristen wasn't even the highest paid of these denizens of the night)in the same hotel where JFK did his sexual thing, and Roosevelt came up with the immortal line "we have nothing to fear but fear itself." It would appear as if Spitzer was up to this high-priced hanky-panky when, as Attorney-General, he was using these bank reporting requirements, which caught him, as a means to catch money launderers, which is probably what he will be charged with; although if the feds go after him using the Mann Act he could get 10 years for taking someone across state lines for the purposes of getting involved in an act of prostitution, and a further 10 for enticement (I guess that's where the expense money he paid her comes in).

Amazing the hubris of the man, believing that the
bank(s) wouldn't report him. Again, was he deliberately unaware that the Mob controls a lot of high-priced prostitution?; and that his trysts would have provided it with a potent blackmail weapon?

One question which remains to be answered is who are Clients 1-8, and 10 through X? I hear mention of the Duke of Westminster as one--isn't he the richest guy in the UK? And what evidence is there that Schumer gave Spitzer his Emperor's Club contact information?

Pity the three teenage daughters having this "man" as their role model when they seek a husband.
39

Urban Guerrilla,

Edinburgh 13/03/2008 07:59:20
#29 > #27 because it is against the law <

It's a silly law. If both parties are willing, why shouldn't it just be a straightforward retail transaction like any other?
40

Carolyn 1,

13/03/2008 21:11:56
Client #6 is Gerald Cavendish Grosvenor, the Duke of Westminster???


41

American,

14/03/2008 01:21:21
#38-GC-"I have a girl friend and when we split I will get a new one" - How much is she charging you?
42

American,

14/03/2008 01:28:04
#43-UG-I understand that it is mutual between a call girl and her client, but in this case--he's married, with children, and claims to be one who will uphold the law. Also, he may be subjecting his wife to std's, and he probably didnt ask her if she minded being a sloppy second.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.