Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


One year on from quake, people are still grieving – and still angry

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 12 May 2009
A YEAR after the massive earthquake that ravaged Sichuan province, China has announced improved measures to ensure its impoverished regions are better prepared for the next natural disaster.
But many villagers still struggling to rebuild say they have little faith in the government's ability to restore their homes and livelihoods, or to fully explain why so many of their children were crushed to death in poorly constructed schools.

"Whatever they rebuild, they cannot return my daughter," said Xiong Yonghao, whose 11-year-old died in her school one year ago today.

He spoke after another failed attempt to petition officials in Beijing for further investigation into the schools' collapse. "We have been talking about it for a year. What does it take? I just came back four days ago from Beijing. No results. It's no use," he said. "You can say that I have totally given up. There won't be a result, ever."

The 7.9 magnitude earthquake, epicentred in the Sichuan county of Wenchuan, claimed a staggering toll: 68,712 dead, 17,921 missing, 374,000 injured and 15 million displaced, according to official statistics.

Included in that number are 5,335 dead and missing students, an official tally released only last week after months of begging from parents. Shoddy construction blamed on corrupt officials and contractors meant the floors of thousands of classrooms simply collapsed on to each other, killing their students, while office buildings and homes nearby remained standing.

Yesterday, Chinese officials admitted at a press conference in Beijing there had been problems in their response to the quake. They said they had improved the country's disaster management system and ordered local governments to draw up contingency plans. All schools across the country are to be reinforced within three years.

The government has also invested billions in developing an early warning system for quake-prone regions, in the hope of giving residents a few seconds, or even minutes, to take cover. Scientists are to drill four deep observation wells on the fault line in Sichuan province to try to add to their research.

"There is still a long way to go before it can be put into practice," said Du Wei, deputy director in the country's earthquake disaster prevention department. "Though the (warning] time can be extremely limited, we believe it's vital for minimising casualties and economic losses."

Meantime, rebuilding is under way; Sichuan's provincial government says one million homes in rural areas and 33,000 city flats have been rebuilt, with hundreds of thousands more units still under construction.

But people say they are not being built fast enough.

"I have not much confidence in the government on rebuilding so far," said Liu Mengying, 35. Her second son was born 54 days ago, after her first child, a boy of 11, was crushed to death in his classroom on 12 May last year.

Ms Liu, her husband and her in-laws have rebuilt their collapsed house, but say the 16,000 yuan (£1,500) they received in government assistance was only a little more than one-tenth of the cost, forcing her family to drain their savings and borrow a further 60,000 yuan.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 11 May 2009 9:53 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 01:04:08
Will the whining never cease? The problem with these people, or the western media, is the focus on the children, always the children. It seems no one cares about the other 75,000 others who died. And I will tell you why. Many of those were elderly folk. Now as you know we Chinese take great care of our elderly folk, we keep them in the home as far as possible and we visit them if we cannot keep them in the home. Yet the western media slants this on THE CHILDREN.
It takes time to rebuild 5 million homes. It has also taken time to design them to withstand further quakes. But the work is ongoing as fast as possible.
Maybe we could focus on that huh?... oh no.. of course not. This is the whining western media.
2

Arminius,

Teutoburger Wald 12/05/2009 03:07:55
#1 Mashimaro - "Will the whining never cease?" - Apparently not, since you are still here whining about the western media and acting as an apologist for the regime that plagues your country.
3

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 03:37:35
It might interest you to know that the government will be spending 1 trillion yuan to rebuild this area. That's around US$147 billion. There is a huge amount of work that still needs to be done in some pretty inaccessable areas through mountains where roads have been truncated. I guess your readers would never have seen the pictures of the PLA guys carrying people out of those areas on their backs.
It's extremely easy to criticise but you need to bear in mind that this was a poor area to start off with. Five million people were left homeless. The scale of destruction and lives lost make it one of china's worst earth quakes and there have been some pretty bad ones. Much as your press would like to tell you, the "communist goverment" has no power over earthquakes. It is doing the best it can to ensure that the houses being built are able to withstand any further quakes. However in future when people build their own, and they will, there is no way to guarantee that those buildings will be up to this kind of exacting standard. Families who are penniless will get homes for free, around 325sq feet. Those who can afford to add their own money will be able to get bigger homes.
4

,

12/05/2009 03:43:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

,

12/05/2009 05:18:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

,

12/05/2009 05:28:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 06:52:06
Hey Posters! Good to see you still have the fighting spirit.
8

Jim A,

12/05/2009 06:55:52
#1 Mashimaro, I listen to a BBC report earlier in which the reporter was touring the rebuilding sites and he was really impressed, within a year nearly half the 5 million houses are rebuilt and the said they will have it completed within a year. Well I must admit I'm impressed as well, unfortunately as with everything else in life there is a down side to this. Again I admit, I thought the Government was paying for this rerbuild and they could well be, I don't know how your system works but this isn't free housing, is it? These folks have to pay for it, they spoke to one Chinese gentlemen who was starting again but the only problem was he couldn't get a mortgage. Even though he is working he can't get the funds to buy a house/flat. The gentlemen said that people over 50 years old were finding it near to impossible to get a mortgage yet people under that age were having no problems. What's the deal with that?
9

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 08:16:47
Hey Jim... some folks will get their homes completely for free, others get low interest government loans. It is all done by a means test, you know... from those according to their ability, to those according to their needs. To be honest I don't understand how the heck it works. I know my grandparents will get theirs for free but some other relatives have to pay a portion. I know the target date for the rebuild to end was 2010 but yes, they are ahead of schedule. I think they've done really well. You cannot believe what the town looked like this time last year.
10

2dogs in D.C.,

12/05/2009 08:25:22
Hey,All.Good job Postit.Truth be told you guys are doing an impressive job w/the rebuild.And,Mashimaro,I did see pictures of the soldiers helping.
11

Jim A,

12/05/2009 08:32:36
#9 Mashimaro, yep a heck of a job. I was just wondering why the over 50's seem to be singled out. Still on reflection later I got to thinking about some of the other factors that may be involved such as what's the average worklife and lifespan in that part of China. Still, Mortgages? That' capitalism isn't it? Which is the opposite of communism. You folks are feeling the lure of madam money. Or sack a few politicians,hell that will pay for free housing for everyone.
12

2dogs in D.C.,

12/05/2009 08:45:20
Leave it to you,Jim,to hit with the tough questions.
13

Arminius,

Teutoburger Wald 12/05/2009 09:07:05
#4 & #5 Mashimaro - Sounds suspiciously like whinging to me with some childish name calling to boot. Also your offensive little sock puppet is pulled out of his drawer.
Simply shows that you have abandoned the pretence of a reasoned argument in favour of posting propaganda and t-shirt slogans. I expect no less from a marrionette in the service of a totalitarian regime.
14

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 09:10:23
Jim, in our society, old folks are looked after by their children. So there should be no need for the wrinklies to have their own homes. Of course some of them at 50 think they will be around forever and be able to work for that time. Industrialisation has indeed changed the face of the area where children are left for grandparents to raise (if they are lucky) while parents head off to work in towns. There are some cases where kids as young as nine have to look after their siblings.
So the reasoning behind this mortgage cut off would be, yes, the person is not going to be able to pay it back and secondly, the family should look after them.
Money is rearing its ugly head in our society, much as it saddens me. It is no longer a case of big brother providing the iron rice bowl. The government now has to account for its money and please the taxpayers instead of pleasing the masses.
You'd think sacking a few politicians would pay for a couple of houses but sadly that is not the case. Our politicians are paid little compared to those in the private sector. I think if you know what Hu Jintao earned you'd laugh.
15

Arminius,

Detmolder Raum 12/05/2009 09:21:44
Not all Chines are happy to console themselves with the thoughts of derring do by the PLA and some want real answers as to why so many died.
"The Sichuan earthquake has now taken a prominent place in this national story. The government's response was portrayed as quick and compassionate. The Premier, Wen Jiabao, was cast as the noble hero - the leader who cried with the bereaved and who promised that fallen towns would one day rise again.
This is the official legend of the earthquake. It's what ordinary Chinese people are told - and it's probably what most of them genuinely believe as well.
On a hilltop overlooking the ruins of the town of Beichuan, hundreds of Chinese tourists now queue up to buy pieces of this legend. Vendors sell picture books and DVDs of the disaster, incense and candles to be placed on memorials.
"This national tragedy has made us build a much stronger nation," says one tourist. "The government is deeply concerned, ordinary people work hard - all obstacles are overcome."
But these tourists know almost nothing of the parents' story. Since early June 2008, the Communist Party has banned the Chinese media from covering the parents' campaign.
Over the last year, local officials have harassed, sometimes even attacked the parents in an effort to keep them quiet".
With the dictatorship of the proletariat, some habits die hard.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/jamesreynolds/
16

,

12/05/2009 09:31:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

,

12/05/2009 09:38:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
18

,

12/05/2009 09:57:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
19

,

12/05/2009 10:01:36
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
20

,

12/05/2009 10:46:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 11:08:51
#15 You're telling ME what's going on in Beichuan... that's rich
22

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 11:28:27
#15 I love your attempts to bring down our glorious country. Basically you're saying that China is dealing with the problem and the majority of its people think the government did an amazing job aside from a few malcontents who want "answers". The fact is that they only want the "answers" they want to hear. And what would those be? That corners were cut when building those schools? We know that. The government has admitted to it. Was it outright fraud? That's harder to prove and the government is still investigating.
Why did the schools fall down? IT WAS A MAGNITUDE 7.9 QUAKE YA EEJIT!
In 1976 there was a mag 7.6 in Tangshan, you might have heard about it. 242000 people died in that one. The dam mountains crashed together in Sichuan.
That is your "answer". I still do not get why everyone is focusing on a handful of students. Almost 80 THOUSAND people died. And yet they are grinding on and on and on and on about a few kids? Gimme a break!
23

,

12/05/2009 12:01:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

Mashimaro,

China 12/05/2009 12:50:11
Hi Posters. No I've not interviewed Fan Run Run. But I know he was hired by a college in Beijing, something of a promotion.
25

,

12/05/2009 12:57:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

,

12/05/2009 13:16:07
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
27

,

12/05/2009 13:32:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
28

Stefan,

NYC 12/05/2009 14:53:24
Looks to me like the PRC and PA are doing a great job. I hope they finish up early so they can rebuild New Orleans, should it get hit again.
29

Stefan,

NYC 12/05/2009 14:59:22
Who's the main building contractor in China that is getting these contracts? Do 'independant' or 'semi-independant' construction companies get contracts and therefore revenue or is it truly government? Just curious.
30

Jim A,

12/05/2009 16:32:25
#19 Posty, and with all due respect, why shouldn't I ask questions? I'm just trying to understand how things work over there. C'mon give the hostility BS a break.
31

Arminius,

In der Gaststätte 12/05/2009 17:41:03
My, the site hasen't seen this level of trolling from the vile Chinese Commies and their useful idiot puppets since the Olympics.
Must have hit a raw nerve - hope there are plenty of tissues to wipe up the rabid slavers.......
A final quote from James Reynolds of the BBC in China:

"In the official legend of the Sichuan earthquake, there is no room for the parents who want to know why their children were killed".
32

Arminius,

Noch in der Gaststätte 12/05/2009 19:54:53
#21 & #22 Mashimaro - Dear me, are all Chinese as humpty as you? The quote is from James Reynolds, the BBC's man in the PRC. He is a journalist and is in your country yet he has a very different view of events to you.
I think this is around about where you denounce him as a western imperialist lackey or some such stock phrase.
33

Arminius is both James donald and vehm Gericht,

China, 12/05/2009 23:34:33
#30 Jim A,
To tell you the truth Jim, we're doing the best we can over here, and neither need or appreciate prying eyes that are here to criticize us, like I said, your WHOLE stinking elected officials, and let me stress 'ELECTED', have all been caught feeding at the trough yet you don't see us questioning you as to why that is.
Also, people died here as a result of a natural disaster, not an illegal invasion that both your government and forces as well as the American government and forces are 100% guilty of which has turned into a far greater disaster than what we have here, so may I kindly suggest that you do something useful with your collective votes and vote all those criminals out of power, and when you've accomplished that, feel free to come knocking on our doors and tell us how to run our country.
Strange how an unelected government here in China is doing far greater things than an elected government is doing for you over there in Scotland eh !

POSTMARK 55
34

,

12/05/2009 23:40:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
35

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 02:09:23
HI Posters, my bad... Fan Run Run didn't get the job in Beijing so he had to take a lesser one in Chengdu.
36

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 03:05:28
#32 I would say it is patently obvious that he has an agenda. Anyone who knows journalism knows you write in the tone of the publication. The publication in this instance is anti-china. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that he's dripping acid.
At some point these parents are just going to have to accept that it was a 7.8 quake. Buildings fell down, as buildings do. This western culture of "blame" is being stirred up by the western press. Of course it is. It doesn't fit in with the west's idea that the poor folks in China are suffering at the hands of the commie baskets. China's culture is acceptance and endurance. But your man is obviously focusing on, if not directly stirring, the small discontented minority... s'prise! Not
37

Arminius,

Teutoburger Wald 13/05/2009 04:42:30
#36 Mashimaro - What is patently obvious is your agenda and that of your sock puppets/useful idiots.
How convenient to dismiss any news report from the West as anti-China bias when it does not show the glorious PRC in a flattering light.
38

,

13/05/2009 04:56:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
39

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 09:52:57
#38 You know, Posters, let's not be too harsh on the man for allowing the basic survival instinct to take over. He had his own daughter to think about.
#29 It's a mix of private and government and even foreign enterprises.
40

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 11:31:00
#37 Ah Jimmy Dee, we both know that we've been through the same old same old same old before.
I don't mind "some" criticism of China, when it's due. I even do it myself from time to time. But constant muck-raking is best left to the tabloids and British MPs, neh?
Why do your journalists think that good news is no news, hmmm? What a miserable bunch of folks you must be, constantly whining and whinging about how you're not being looked after. No wonder so many westerners are on prozac and similar "medication". The constant sense of "someone did me wrong" must be awful to have to live with day in and day out. No wonder Oprah is the most powerful woman in the world. She understood what people like these journos can't figure out.
41

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 11:36:25
Let me tell you some stories about the quake. Let me tell you about the thousands of ordinary people who dropped their lives and left their families and made the journey to the devastated area to help those in need. I'm not talking about rescue workers. I'm talking about postmen and students and grandmothers.
Let me tell you about the millions more who streamed into blood donation centres right across the country
How about the grannies that got together to produce hundreds of quilts for survivors, or the Muslim folk from the neighbouring province who churned out thousands of loaves of flat bread to be given as food.
Maybe your reporters could have talked to the children that came to the area just to keep other children company in hospital, or the nurses who could do nothing more than hold a trapped person's hand until help arrived or the old grandfather who found his niche filling buckets of water, one after the other
42

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 11:42:43
Why don't your journos write about the policewoman who left her baby at home and fed babies with her own milk while they waited for help to come.
How about the husband who, getting free himself, went back for his wife and child. They both died in an aftershock, using their bodies to protect their baby who survived.
How about the man who walked more than 100k over trembling ground to reach his wife and then walked 100k over trembling ground to find his parents
How about the young girl who dreamed of being a ballet dancer and the doctors who had to amputate her leg while she lay trapped and their own lives were in danger of falling debris.
How about how the trapped children kept each others' spirits up by singing and how we wept when that singing stopped.
Then there's the Russians and the Dutch coming in to help. That air aid just pouring in from a generous world united for a brief few days by the common purpose of saving lives.
43

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 11:54:59
Maybe they'd like to write about the phenomenal fortitude of the old man who lay trapped for more than 200 hours - 100 hours more than western standards of search and rescue.
How about the way the PLA humped in the explosives to blow the quake lake? How they shared their rations with kids, brought them clean water and supplies. All of this while the ground was still shaking, Jimmy Dee, when at any moment they could have died.
I will bet you haven't even been able to conceive of the scale of devastation. You sit there in your lovely safe little world and scritch scratch at other people's misery. You use it as coinage to score debating points, you and your lowlife western media.
44

Arminius,

Jetzt in der Heide 13/05/2009 12:30:21
#40 Mashimaro, (sock)puppetmaster - Yes, I can see that you are no stranger to an anti-Western rant so it is not difficult for me to believe what I was told about Han Chinese being very racist. So many westerners are on prozac? What's the matter, can't you get this in China?
45

,

13/05/2009 12:35:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
46

Arminius,

Jetzt in der Heide 13/05/2009 12:41:55
#41, #42 & #43 Mashimaro - Of course, as a party loyalist you will want to focus on the happy, shiny, uplifting stories of any disaster. Typical tactics of a totalitarian regime and very reminicant of the Wochenschau nonsense from the time of the 3. Reich (just substitute "heros of the Technische Nothilfe" for "heros if the PLA). Makes a good distraction for the masses too. Your verbosity and anti-western bile do not make it any the less unconvincing.
47

,

13/05/2009 14:09:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
48

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 14:21:29
#46 only you would think children dying or getting their legs amputated or parents dying to save their child is a happy shiny story you sicko
49

Mashimaro,

China 13/05/2009 14:29:06
#44 take it from your own media
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2008/feb/08/uk.liberaldemocrats

Some highlight from this article for the lazy folks
Clegg will highlight figures showing one in four Britons suffering from mental health problems at some point in their lives, with one in six at any one time. The cost of mental ill-health is estimated at £77bn a year.

He will also point to an "explosion" in antidepressant use, with 31m prescriptions issued in 2006, including 631,000 for children.

"Britain has become the true Prozac nation. I believe this trend has gone too far," Clegg will say.

****
http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/health/la-he-themd11-2009may11,0,3918306.story

Antidepressants are the most commonly prescribed drugs in America... ooops...


50

Arminius,

In der Heide 13/05/2009 15:12:08
#48 Mashimaro - Just like a journalist. Deliberate misinterpretation followed by an insult.
51

Arminius,

Teutoburger Wald 13/05/2009 15:14:36
#49 Mashimaro - And your point would be? So the Chinese are such stolid folk that they don't get depressed. They are all high on love of the motherland I presume.
52

Arminius,

Uelzen 13/05/2009 15:37:54
#49 Mashimaro - Since you are a big fan of the Guardian, I thought you might enjoy this article also:

"Tiananmen Square leader arrested, family saysAlmost 20 years after violent crackdown, US-based Zhou Yongjun is detained in China while visiting father"

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/may/13/tiananmen-zhou-yongjun-arrest-china

Show trial for an enemy of the people in the offing?
53

Mashimaro,

China 14/05/2009 01:05:59
#52 Trial? Probably not.
54

Arminius is both James donald and vehm Gericht,

China, 14/05/2009 05:24:37
#52 Arminius aks James Donald aka Vehm Gericht aka Jimmy Dee,
Speaking of trials, where were the trials for these innocent victims, victimized by your troops who LIBERATED Iraq.
http://www.kirkbytimes.co.uk/antiwaritems/uk_torture_iraq.html

POSTMARK 55
55

Mashimaro,

14/05/2009 05:37:01
#51 No, Jimmy Dee, my point would be that your media continually feeds you a steady diet of doom, gloom, shock, horror. You people are miserable. They never seem to think that any "good" news is worth news. The minute they see something "good" they have to "find the angle" to attack it. I've worked in western newsrooms, I know how it goes. While there are plenty of good things to report about the quake, they have to seek out or even stir up the bad stuff.
Journalism - western journalism at least - seems to thrive on "controversy" and where there isn't any, they don't mind making it. I'm not saying parents are not upset, of course they are. Many people are upset. But you don't have to highlight it. You don't have to invest in it. Just report it and move on.
56

Arminius,

In der Heide 14/05/2009 07:35:19
#55 Mashimaro - So if it is "good" (human interest) stories that you are after, the BBC (part of the lying western media don't you know) does these too:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/8046004.stm

Some journalists like to follow stories up, be they good or bad, rather than "just report it and move on".
57

Mashimaro,

China 15/05/2009 07:18:00
#56 By law of averages even they should get it right once in a while.
58

Arminius,

Bei Uelzen 15/05/2009 07:52:28
#57 Mashimaro - Rather a negative response but then you believe the western media feeds a "steady diet of doom, gloom, shock, horror".
If you like reading when you are not busy propagandising for the PRC here are some details of a book you might be interested in:
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/asia/article6284837.ece

"Secret Tiananmen Square memoirs of Zhao Ziyang to be published

Now, on the 20th anniversary of the bloody suppression of the protesters, Zhao’s memoirs — painstakingly reconstructed from hours of tape recordings smuggled out by supporters — provide a unique glimpse of the deep divisions within the Chinese leadership. The first memoirs made public by such a highly placed party official will enrage today’s leaders because of his assertion that Western-style democracy is essential if China is to avoid future bloodbaths".

Note that it might not be available in the PRC.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.