Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Half Price Tapas with Scotland on Sunday

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Auschwitz falling into ruin, say Poles in cash plea



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 August 2008
POLISH authorities responsible for maintaining the Auschwitz extermination camp as a memorial to the million-plus people murdered there warn it is slipping into ruin.

An appeal has gone out to the international community for funds to keep the site of the Birkenau extermination centre – separate from the rest of the camp complex – open as a place of homage and remembrance.

Jaroslaw Mensfelt, spokesman for the
museum on the site, said: "Without outside help, Poland could have trouble retaining Auschwitz as a memorial site."

According to the director of the memorial, Piotr Cywinski, some 62.5 million euros (£50 million) is needed for repairs. The budget the museum gets annually from the Polish government is less than £2 million a year while another £2 million is earned from the sales of books, fees for tours and parking.

Mr Cywinski said that the international community, particularly the EU, should "share the burden" of keeping up the memorial.

Germany gave £5 million in the Nineties to upgrade barracks and install heating in some rooms.

But time has taken its toll on what was the prime killing centre for the Nazis in the Second World War.

Between 1.2 and 1.5 million European, Balkan and Russian Jews were murdered in the gas chambers of the Birkenau complex.

After the war, a monument and museum was built on the site of the camps. Interest in the monuments has grown in recent years, with a record 1.2 million people visiting last year.

Auschwitz, near Krakow, was also a slave labour centre, with inmates not "selected" for death put to work in factories producing goods for the German war effort.

When the Russians liberated it in January 1945 they discovered mountains of valuables, hair, gold teeth, spectacles and thousands and thousands of childrens' dolls – all taken from those who were murdered there.

Since the fall of communism it has become a place of pilgrimage for people from all lands, but particularly Jews from Israel.





The full article contains 339 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 05 August 2008 9:56 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Lobeydoser,

06/08/2008 01:16:15
This report is in The Herald, word for word, without accrediting it to Allan Hall. Whose stealing from who?
2

James Donald,

Newbridge 06/08/2008 08:06:52
Let it fall into ruin, there is no need to preserve the site "in aspic" in its entirity. If the Poles cannot afford £50 million to preserve the site then they should look at what is worth preserving before going cap in hand to the "International community".
Since it has become a place of pilgrimage particularly for Jews from Israel, perhaps the Israelis could chip it a few million.
Another possible source of funding would be the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, which currently holds $1.7 Billion in it's accounts, although it only finances welfare assistance for 9,000 holocaust survivors. Surely the money would be better sent on preserving parts of Auschwitz rather than being squandered on huge salaries for fat cats such as these:
Gideon Taylor , executive vice- president $437,811
Rabbi Marvin Hier, president and CEO, $461,418 (plus a further $614,951 to close family members)
Rabbi Israel Singer, policy council chairman, $356,492
Steve Schwager, executive vice-president $401,066
(Source: Organisations’ US filings for tax exemption, Guidestar.org)
http://www.thejc.com/home.aspx?AId=43985&ATypeId=1&search=true2&srchstr=%22Gideon%20Taylor%22&srchtxt=1&srchhead=1&srchauthor=1&srchsandp=1&scsrch=0
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/1,7340,L-3338282,00.html

3

david watts,

06/08/2008 09:26:56
perhaps the polish government could put out an appeal to all the polish brickies,labourers etc currently living in Britain to give up a days wages. That should just about cover it.
4

james 1st,

hamilton nz 06/08/2008 10:39:17
hopefully the uk will keep its hands deep in its pockets. its a memorial for jews let them and the axis nations pay up, the uk has its own good causes that need money. im tired of reading about the holocaust its history
5

Number 6,

Germany 06/08/2008 14:30:21
The Swiss could pay for it's up-keep just with the interest they have accumilated from Jewish gold, held in perpetuity in their banks
6

Gere,

Scotland 06/08/2008 14:34:26

Memorial or revenue generating tourist trap ?????????

How much of the structure is rebuilt alter to communist propaganda???

Remember the Katyn Forrest where it was pronunced that the Nazis murdered 40,000 Polish Military Officers and intellectuals?????

When communism collapsed and the KGB files in Moscow were opened it was revealed that the murders were a KGB operation carefully carried in such a manner to make the Nazis appear to be the perpetrators.

No person is allowed to carry out a critical and analytical examination of Auschwitz or other such alleged site on pain of imprisonment. In fact there is a prison term awaiting anyone who even demands the intellectual freedom to critically examine this area of the past!

Believe or be convicted of thought crimes!!!

What truth needs a law with a prison sentence as a penalty for daring to question a forced belief ????

The spirit of Thomas De Torqamada lives on and places like Auschwitz are monuments to that resurected inquisitorial spirit to ensure unquestioned belief!!!
7

Gere,

Scotland 06/08/2008 14:37:55
Post #10

Apologies, second line of post should read:

How much of the structure has been rebuilt and altered after Soviet occupation to conform to communist propaganda????
8

Neil,

Glasgow 06/08/2008 14:42:39
#1 ,y guess would be & that it was distributed by AP or Reuters. That Mr Hall pulled it off the net & put it out under his byline - possibly changing a few words. I'm afraid this is how the media work. The traditional picture of hard bitten reporters hunting down leads is long gone, if it ever existed. Rewriting press releases & getting unatributable briefings from politicos is what the job consists of.

For example if you ever see a review of the hedalines on Newsnight etc you will see that if a newspaper has a lead story diferent from all the others the attitude is that the standout has chosen the wrong press release/story not that they have found something unique.
9

Lobeydoser,

06/08/2008 16:15:46
#13 Neil:
Jings! Heevins! Help ma Boab! My head is bowed to your superior knowledge of the media. And here's me thinking that the Scotsman got all its knowledge direct from the Western Isles or Newbridge.
10

Ben More,

Edinburgh 06/08/2008 17:04:33
11--Gere

Got to be more careful with your cut and paste, mate!
11

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 06/08/2008 17:45:47
15 Looks like cut and paste from some BNP holocaust denial rag.
12

Joseph Gibson,

Ayrshire 06/08/2008 19:34:30

Haha, while our own buildings here in the UK are suffering, like such "Buckingham Palace" I wonder if the British government puts some money into this "As we are jewish supporters" While our own Monarch had to ask for more money to do repairs now before its costs alot more, and many people were out-raged, WHAT A BLOODY LAUGH.
13

American,

06/08/2008 20:13:49
#9-number 6-or the germans could pay for it since they were the ones who actually took the gold, diamonds, painting, money, and lives from the millions of jews.

#2-My, my james!!! I see nazi-ism is still alive and well in your house.
14

Bend Over,

06/08/2008 20:37:22
The Communists built the Gas Chambers in 1948, to cover up their own atrocities which were far worse than the Nazi's.
15

James Donald,

Newbridge 06/08/2008 22:52:26
#18 American - The Germans have paid millions to the Claims Conference, the Israeli State, Holocaust survivors and many other various Jewish organisations. If you had taken the time to read the article, you would have learned that Germany already paid £5 million in the 1990s for repairs. Germany is not a bottomless pit of money to be "milked" generation after generation and have enough problems of their own which require attention and funds.
"I see nazi-ism is still alive and well in your house" - only an idiot would see that, thus it comes as no surprise that this is what you see.
There aren't too many Nazis that quote from the Jewish Chronicle or Jewish World. I'll just put your outburst down to embarassment at the naked greed of your fellow countrymen.
16

Let's have the truth,

Here 06/08/2008 23:16:02
Some of my forebears were treated very badly during the French invasion of England in 1066 and I want the French government to finance a monument in their honour.
17

james 1st,

hamilton nz 07/08/2008 10:54:11
#6 you must be very childish indeed,i believe that a memorial should be paid for by the state of israel as it is a memorial to the jewishc victims. very few people alive today were responsible for this atrocity and should not feel obliged to pay money for a memorial.
there have been many atrocities since eg a million butchered in cambodia, where is their memorial
so why dont you go and read your own copy of the beano
18

Allan(handofgod137),

07/08/2008 14:38:47
So where's the monument to the Palestinians who's country has been stolen by the Jews then?
19

Gere,

Scotland 07/08/2008 15:21:49
Post 23# Allan(handofgod137)

Good Post, you have identified the cause of 9/11 and all similar subsequent actions!

Posts #15 & #16

A perfunctionary perusal of your posts both here and elsewhere seem to indicate that you are both facing a challange in the intellectual department to contribute any remotely meaningful comment on articles that could stimulate and promote discussion.

I sincerely suggest you read more widely on the subject before you post any comment.
20

Gere,

Scotland 07/08/2008 15:23:52
Post #19 Bend Over

Congratulations, you have diligently been doing your homework!
21

Ben More,

07/08/2008 17:15:11
"A perfunctionary perusal of your posts both here and elsewhere seem to indicate that you are both facing a challange in the intellectual department to contribute any remotely meaningful comment on articles that could stimulate and promote discussion."

ha!

A perfunctory (note correct spelling) of YOUR post(s) reveals severe spelling and grammatical issues. The question is: are the mistakes truly yours, or are the BNP rags from which you lift your quotes to blame?

I find it laughable that one who consistently makes such elementary mistakes should talk about homework, much less politics and the vaunted Truth. Sort out your own house first. Education begins at home. A true British Nationalist would show his language due respect by using it correctly.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: get Nick Griffin to proofread your work, son.
22

jan ptak,

warsaw 08/08/2008 04:38:57
REading some of post here I am getting a feeling people dont know about history at all. Aushwitz was the place where not only jews was murdered. Maybe for some of You its a symbol of jewish propaganda but not all small groups wanted to use it in their cause. This is a place of much significane - german slouthered people from all nations and religions. 70 years ago one people betrayed other people and start to kill them on a mass scale. in the heart of europe. You should see it for Yourself.
There are voices that poles should do something with money earned in scotland. Poles dont have to do anything. If some of you wanted to live a life of unedutaced sheep - its your call. But dont feel sorry when a guy nexd door ,with a big helmet come to you and kill your family. Impossible? how you can tell - in the past so many times people didnt believe its possible.
Best ,
23

Gere,

Scotland 08/08/2008 13:58:59
Post #26 Ben More

Oh small minded petty person!

Facts, not spelling is of consequence!

You seem to have some sort of fixation with the BNP!

Before you malign the BNP remember the man you mentioned Nick Griffin predicted the fact that the Muslims will target Britain with a suicide bombing campgain. For this insightful prediction he faced criminal charges!

Whilst he was on trial the first bombing was carried out in London!!!!

You are a Pedant attempting to present yourself as a knowledgeable person.

Incidently, your hatred of the white skin is plainly evident. No doubt, you look forward with anticipation to reading about the next successful suicide bombing by a Muslim as filled with as much hatred for the white skin as you are and equally as dedicated as youare to the destruction of Western civilization.

24

American,

08/08/2008 18:49:58
#20-james-LOL! Stop being a closet-nazi already. The germans might have paid millions, but does it cover the millions it stole?

25

Bend Over,

09/08/2008 01:26:38
@29

They pay 1 billion Euros a year to Israel. 60 years after, just embezzlement really.
26

Bend Over,

09/08/2008 01:45:51
10 million Ukranians were deliberately starved to death by the Communists in 1932/3, the man in charge was a Genrikh Yagoda, Commander of the NKVD, a Russian Jew, wonder why we dont have a Holdomor museum ?

Don't believe me; read about it here in an Israeli neswpaper, ironically they have more press freedom than we do here in Europe.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3342999,00.html

27

James Donald,

Newbridge 11/08/2008 10:36:29
#29 American - Seems you easily amused if you find this funny. Try actually reading the article from the Jewish Chronicle before spouting this guff (or perhaps you think the JC editor is a closet-nazi).
Germany may have stolen millions during the war but the Nazi state did not survive to "enjoy" these millions most of it ending up in Allied hands.
Somehow I think you have missed the point of my posts - holocaust survivors are in need and yet millions continue to be paid out by the Germans. The "fat cats" of the Claims Conference live a life of luxury paying themselves huge salaries. Think hard and ask yourself who is at fault. If you still think the claims conference "Bonzen" are doing a good job, are value for money and are serving the interests of holocaust survivors well, you are no better than them.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.