Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


'Act now or 290m people will go hungry'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 June 2008
URGENT action must be taken to tackle the soaring cost of food that is plunging poor nations into crisis, according to a new Oxfam report.
As world leaders prepared to meet in Rome for an emergency United Nations food summit, Oxfam called on governments to draw up a global action plan to tackle the disaster.

With world food prices up 83 per cent on three years ago, Oxfam estimates 2
90 million people are struggling to afford to eat.

The charity said the crisis dwarfed the number of people affected by even the largest natural disaster, such as the 2004 Asian tsunami.

According to the charity's report entitled The Time is Now, an extra £7.33 billion is needed in immediate assistance.

But as well as short-term help, Oxfam wants a longer-term plan of action to be drawn up that supports agriculture in developing countries, puts a stop to biofuels targets, and helps poor countries get a fair deal from trade.

It blames soaring food bills on high oil prices, rising demand for cereals linked with the growth in biofuels, and increased consumption in countries such as India and China.

Climate change is also expected to lead to more weather-related disasters, adding to food instability.

The charity said its aid workers were seeing millions of people forced to eat less food, as well as cut back on healthcare, education and other necessities. Women's and children's nutritional levels are particularly vulnerable, as women often put men's consumption before their own.

Oxfam Great Britain's chief executive, Barbara Stocking, said: "In countries where Oxfam works, we are seeing the negative impact of higher food prices on poor people, who already spend more than half their income on food.

"This is a huge challenge to the leadership and legitimacy of the world's multilateral institutions, but also a genuine opportunity for long-overdue reforms."

She said the amount of money is small compared to more than one trillion dollars which the US Federal Reserve and European Central Bank have injected into the financial system in the past six months to try to avert economic crisis.

She said: "An unprecedented level of co-ordination is required across agencies, governments and the private sector to address this crisis.

"The vast amount of money spent on averting the financial crisis shows what is possible when there is political will. The cost of failure will not just be measured in lost lives and human suffering, but also in lost credibility."

ActionAid analyst Magdalena Kropiwnicka agreed there needed to be a focus on providing more help to agriculture in developing countries.

"It is an outrage that poor people are paying for decades of policy mistakes such as the lack of investment in agriculture and the dismantling of support for smallholder farmers," she said.

The World Food Security conference begins in Rome today.

STOP PUSHING BIOFUELS

Using food crops to produce biofuels is a hugely inefficient use of agriculture, according to Oxfam.

The amount of grain required to produce enough ethanol to fill the tank of an SUV is enough to feed a person for an entire year.

As well as diverting food crops into fuel production, biofuels also compete with food production for agricultural land.

The International Food Policy Research Institute has estimated that the push for biofuels explains 30 per cent of recent food price inflation. Oxfam said governments should dismantle current subsidies and tax exemptions for biofuels.

IMMEDIATE AID

An estimated 290 million people need immediate help in the form of food and cash and Oxfam believes that an extra £7.33 billion is needed to tackle the immediate problem.

The charity argues that cash is better than food aid.

Dumping food in communities can lead to dependency, undermining local production but giving cash can help support them.

As well as providing money, Oxfam recommends scaling up social protection schemes such as minimum income guarantees and setting up food reserves, such as national or regional grain banks.

SUPPORT AGRICULTURE

The food price crisis is caused in part by decades of neglect of farming in poor countries, according to Oxfam.

A lack of investment in agriculture has left rural households with nothing to fall back on when prices rise beyond their means. Three-quarters of the world's poor people still live in rural areas, most on small farms. But international aid to agriculture almost halved between 1980 and 2005. Oxfam said the aid budget for agriculture, about £2billion, is dwarfed by the support by rich countries for their own agricultural sectors, which in 2006 stood at an estimated £63billion a year.

Mugabe's presence 'an affront to the hungry'

THE presence of Zimbabwe's president, Robert Mugabe, below, among the heads of state at this week's food summit has been criticised as "obscene" by Britain.

Mr Mugabe is making his first official trip abroad since elections condemned by Western and opposition leaders as fraudulent.

Douglas Alexander, the International Development Secretary, who is representing the UK at the summit, said: "I think it is obscene and I'm outraged by his attendance. We don't see Robert Mugabe as gaining any legitimacy or credibility from attending this meeting when four million of his own people are now relying on food aid as a direct consequence of his profound misrule of the country."

He vowed to have nothing to do with Mr Mugabe at the summit. "I'll neither shake hands with Robert Mugabe nor meet Robert Mugabe," he said.

The MP for Paisley and Renfrewshire South claimed Mr Mugabe's attendance in Rome was "an affront to all Zimbabweans who are suffering hunger, destitution and poverty as a direct result of his rule". The EU has a long-standing travel ban on Mr Mugabe, but the Rome food summit is taking place under the umbrella of the United Nations.

Call for faster action on climate change

POOR countries appealed to a conference yesterday to move faster on an agreement to tackle climate change.

The call, by delegates from nations that said they were already suffering from floods and cyclones brought on by rising temperatures, came at the opening of a two-week meeting in Bonn.

During the conference 2,000 delegates will start tackling the details of a new climate change agreement to take effect after 2012, succeeding the first phase of the 1997 Kyoto Protocol.

"We are concerned over the slow progress of the last two years," said Amjad Abdulla of the Maldives, speaking for a group known as the Least Developed Countries. Climate change "for us is not a distant reality, but a present reality", and the recent cyclones that have battered Burma and Bangladesh "should be a wake-up call to all of us", he added.

The Bonn meeting builds on a landmark accord reached last December in Bali. For the first time, the US, China and India had indicated they would join a co-ordinated effort to control the carbon emissions blamed for climate change.

Scientists say the world's carbon emissions must peak in the next ten to 15 years and then fall by half by mid-century to avoid potentially catastrophic changes in weather patterns, a rise in sea levels that would threaten coastal cities and the mass extinction of plants and animals.














Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 June 2008 10:17 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

truthsleuth,

03/06/2008 00:42:29
How many of these 'poor countries' are subsidising their petrol and diesel
how many are already receiving aid.

The real problem is most of them require to cut their birthrate
now that would be something worth investing in.
2

Dougie, Edinburgh,

03/06/2008 01:36:06
What Oxfam doesn't tell us is that if these countries are already overpopulated to the extent that 290m are starving, by next generation they'll be overpopulated by 800m if we're somehow able to feed them.

Look at which countries have the highest birth-rates: Afghanistan, Sudan, Ethiopia, Niger etc.
http://www.xist.org/earth/pop_growth.aspx
3

Carolyn 1,

03/06/2008 01:40:25
The inhumanity of world hunger can not be solved without first addressing the dictatorships and corruption that causes the hunger.
4

Maisie from Morningside,

03/06/2008 03:57:28
High prices for oil and food are caused by the manipulation of the markets by cartels and speculators respectively.
Break the cartels, ruin the speculators.
Problem solved.
5

Itchy,

03/06/2008 06:44:32
#4 wrong. Less government is what is needed, not more.

Have you missed the news about Zimbabwe?
6

Unimpressed one,

03/06/2008 07:49:24
Maybe if Oxfam hadn't jumped on the PC bandwagon of decrying GM crops, much of the developing world would be in a better position to feed itself now. Of course they believe that 'climate change' is also a big problem...
7

sam the god,

03/06/2008 08:14:13
#2 dougie,

well said these countries keep on expanding (population) and expect the west to look after them just remember that they wanted their freedom from the empire so let them look after themselves that is what they said they wanted. Also the way inflation is going in this country we will be a poor nation very shortly.

8

Farmernot,

03/06/2008 09:31:43
GMO is the answer
9

Miss Pixie,

03/06/2008 11:24:13
The USA should be included in this head count. The cost of food over here has caused an unpresidented increase in people seeking free food assistance from our food banks. The food banks are now running very low and will soon be empty.

There is a growing amount of "third world" type issues taking root over here!
10

JayJay,

Right here 03/06/2008 11:26:54
Oxfam ignore the elephant in the room. That creatures such as Mugabe can cut a swathe through Rome with his brutish minders is a finger in the eye to just about every decent human being on planet earth. This one man natural disaster has created famine through policy and he should be told by every nation present that his very presence is an affront to the aims of the conference. The man should be arrested whilst in Rome for crimes against humanity.
He, like many of his ilk in Africa, will doubtless have a giant bank account somewhere safe and, when he is safely boxed and buried we will all be asked to pay for his theft and haphazard views of economics.
So, Oxfam, focus on Governments, because, if the people running countries are corrupt, brutal, inept or a combination of all three, then people will continue to starve.
11

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 03/06/2008 11:37:00
The major issue is overpopulation trying to extract ever more from limited and finite resources. Western aid has paradoxically reduced developing nations' ability to think out solutions for themselves and line dictators' pockets. Seems we have to be guilty of being colonialists and provide even bigger cheques to show it. Excepting disasters maybe this should now cease and a bit of responsibility be demanded from national leaders.

Throw into the equation the nonsense that is Anthropogenic Global Warming and the guilt trip is complete giving unprecendented tax opportunities to shiftless politicians whose main goal is to extract and waste money on madcap schemes while the rest of us vainly try to make a living and an increasingly sparse one at that. It really time to get tough when our own pensioners and the ill get second class treatment while 3rd world spongers waltz in and demand red-carpet treatment.

Little wonder there is a food shortage with this kind of muddled thinking going on on domestic affairs never mind foreign.
12

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 03/06/2008 12:11:09
The cost of producing food has risen with the cost of oil because agriculture uses a lot of energy.

A calorie of wheat requires the expenditure of 12 calories of energy to produce. A calorie of beef requires 96 calories of energy to produce.
13

PJ,

Edinburgh 03/06/2008 12:31:48
A “bio-fuels” frenzy and other misguided policies have led to the global food crisis in which prices have soared and rice consumption has outpaced production, threatening a billion people with malnutrition.

Billions of people, particularly in Africa, Asia, and Central and South America, are victims of a gradual and unsustainable rise in the prices of all farm products – wheat, soybean, rice, maize, milk, and meat. Riots are breaking out daily, and at least three dozen countries urgently need wheat and rice shipments.

At the end of the day Bio-fuels don’t feed starving people, it's imperative that policies are changed as soon as possible, because the remedies that have been adopted so far are worse than the sickness they were designed to cure. Bio-fuel policy is rushing ahead without understanding the implications, they look good in climate change terms from a Western perspective, but globally they actually lead to higher carbon emissions.
14

Fairfax,

03/06/2008 13:14:05
Maisie (4): "High prices for oil and food are caused by the manipulation of the markets by cartels and speculators respectively."

To some extent that's true, but they are not the fundamental cause of these high prices. The industrialization of India and China, together with political unrest in several oil-producing nations, imply high oil prices for this finite resource. High food price are fundamentally due to massive population growth in countries unable to feed themselves -- essentially cheap food surplus elsewhere has made their growth possible: we now have a world population of 6 billion, compared to some 3 billion in the early 1970s.
15

Allan(handofgod137),

03/06/2008 14:33:30
Oxfam won't advocate birth control, and the developing world or indeed ourselves applying any form of population control for the same reason that the ratcatcher won't kill all the rats.
16

doublescotch,

U.S.A. 03/06/2008 15:03:58
#10 And did you read in the Washington Post about the people in their SUV's driving to the food banks in Leesburg, Loudon County, VA? They were by no means "third world". This is happening in most cities here. The real poor are missing out. Even at Christmas when the Toys for Tots charity hands out beautiful toys, it is women in fur coats and pearls picking them up.
17

ebbi,

spain 03/06/2008 15:08:54
i wonder there would be any of politicians or their members of their family amongst them!!!!!
of course not,they'll be having caviar and champagne at the taxpayers expenses and the rest of us starve to death.
18

celtic4,

USA 03/06/2008 16:02:27
#10 right on! I went to market yesterday and got quite a shock! The food prices had risen astronomically! I couldn't believe it.
And as for those in fur coats picking up food, did anyone ask how OLD those coats were by chance? They might really need food now, but did not when they had the coat new. And the thought likely never occured to sell the coat. Anyway, hunger is real. And my food budget will not now go as far. And I do not waste things and am quite frugal.
19

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands 03/06/2008 16:30:15
A combination of Nature and bad Government has created massive food shortages for a overpopulated Africa. There is no shortage of bullets but a shortage of rice. It seems priorities are not clear.

When a population becomes too big to be sustained people will die until they reach a sustainable balance. Unless we keep pumping food aid into the corrupt governments for the elite to squander and steal.

The problem with Africa is its leaders and its family size. Too many people. Not enough Food. Why is anyone surprised this causes mass death. This is the inevitable result of bad policy.

In Scotland in the 1700’s we just died until we worked out how to farm efficiently. Sometime disaster brings with it a change. People need to learn. In Africa at the moment no lessons are being learned good or bad because the West continues to send aid to failed regimes, failed systems of government and unsustainable populations. People must see a link between action and result or else they cannot develop.
20

Itchy,

03/06/2008 19:13:09
#6 "Free trade and open markets in world food is the wrong way to go."

Exactly wrong. Hyperprotectionism, interventionism and socialism are what makes people starve. The Ukraine is fertile enough to feed the entire world. You are an ignoramus.

21

John Blackley,

Florida 03/06/2008 20:04:02
Some very cogent arguments in this comments column (along with the usual sniping and downright rudeness). I don't have any answers to 'world hunger' but I do have a question.

What possible benefit to the starving poor can be found in flying hundreds and thousands, from all over the world, to Rome for a three-day jolly at various taxpayers' expense?

I do so look forward to hearing what solutions to global hunger and poverty spring from the fertile minds of Robert Mugabe and his ilk.
22

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands 03/06/2008 20:10:19
#24 John Blakeley

If I may.

I suggest that it will be of no benefit to the people of Africa nor the starving to know the elite are eating a 5 course mean discussing how they can help.

It will make the various commercial charities and do gooders feel better about themselves and that unfortunately seems to matter more that real results.
23

John Blackley,

Florida 03/06/2008 21:42:41
Just so we know: Hundreds of the great and the good (/sarcasm off) will be eating, tonight:

vol au vent stuffed with sweetcorn and mozzarella, followed by a pasta dish with a sauce of pumpkin and shrimps, and then veal meatballs and cherry tomatoes, with a fruit salad and vanilla ice-cream for dessert. The wine is a "straightforward but very acceptable Orvieto Classico".

Tomorrow the lunch menu features cheese mousse, pasta, green beans and pineapple with ice-cream, all washed down with a Nero d'Avola Cabernet from Sicily.

On Thursday, the last day of the summit, delegates will be offered courgette tart, parmesan risotto, ragout of veal with sautee potatoes, and lemon mousse for dessert with a strawberry sauce, with Pino Grigio from Trentino as the wine.

I do hope the hunger pangs don't keep them from thinking brilliant thoughts about.......... er, hunger.

24

Green booger,

04/06/2008 14:21:30
Common Purpose (CP)

- a hidden menace in our government and schools



Common Purpose is the glue than enables fraud to be committed across government departments to reward pro European politicians. Corrupt deals are enabled that put property or cash into their pockets by embezzling public assets.



Although it has 80,000 trainees in 36 cities, 18,000 "graduate" members and enormous power, Common Purpose is largely unknown to the general public.



It recruits and trains "leaders" to be loyal to the directives of Common Purpose and the EU, instead of to their own departments, which they then undermine or subvert, the NHS being an example.



Common Purpose is identifying leaders in all levels of our government to assume power when our nation is replaced by the European Union. Unlike current leaders, CP leaders are taught to rule without democracy, and will bring the EU police state home to every one of us.



It has members in the NHS, BBC, the police, the legal profession, many of Britains 7,000 quangos, local councils, the Civil Service, government ministries, Parliament, and it controls many RDA's (Regional Development Agencies).

25

sigholm,

ayr 04/06/2008 15:09:09
Is there any significance that the summit is held in ROME?
Dont suppose that the real cause of hunger and poverty will be tackled,too many mouths!
Wouldn't look good raising the obvious question of contraception in that neck of the woods.
Never mind Gordon,we've room for another few million....with a squeeze.
26

57Nomad,

california 09/06/2008 13:10:11
The notion that there isn't enough food to go around is nonsense. It's not the amount of food available, it is the food distribution system that has collapsed in various places. In America a significant fraction of the 'poor' (poor is a relative term, only meaningful in comparison to other Americans) are obese. They may not have enough money to put a swimming pool in their back yard but they have plenty to eat. It is government meddling that is the cause of hunger not the planets ability to provide enough food.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.