Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Campbell has new spin on Susan Boyle phenomenon

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 April 2009
ALASTAIR Campbell has announced that politicians can learn a valuable lesson from Susan Boyle, the middle-aged Scottish spinster whose unruly appearance but sensational singing on Britain's Got Talent has attracted global media attention.
While Tony Blair's former spokesman did not go so far as to suggest politicians serenade the electorate with a rendition of I Dreamed A Dream, from Les Miserables, as Ms Boyle has done to the delight of millions of viewers on television and via YouTube, he did advise them to recognise her "authenticity".

In a post on his blog, Mr Campbell said: "If politicians tend to read the Sunday papers with a mix of horror and trepidation, one person who must read them week after week with a sense of his own skills in shaping the popular culture agenda is Simon Cowell.

"The overnight sensation that is Susan Boyle and her 25 million YouTube hits is the latest chapter in Cowell's story.

"If there is a lesson from her success for politicians, it is authenticity. It is the only communication that works."

As of last night her performance had been viewed more than 50 million times on YouTube.

And yesterday Ms Boyle's singing teacher revealed that she was a serial talent show failure who had previously auditioned without success in the late 1990s for My Kind of People and abandoned the auditions for The X Factor when she realised people were being chosen for their looks. Fred O'Neil said that Ms Boyle's audition for Britain's Got Talent was her final throw of the dice.

He said: "I remember a phone call late last year when she said she was too old and that it was a young person's game."

Mr O'Neil urged her to reconsider and attend the auditions in Glasgow.

This weekend Elaine Paige sent a message of support to Britain's latest and possibly most unlikely singing sensation.

Ms Boyle, 47, told the talent show she had dreamt of becoming as successful as Paige, who starred as the original Evita in London in 1978.

The veteran singer said there had been a huge reaction to Ms Boyle's performance from listeners to her Radio 2 show.

In a message posted on her website, she wrote: "Ever since Susan's appearance on Britain's Got Talent my Radio 2 inbox has been flooded with e-mails. It seems her performance has really captured the hearts of everyone who saw it, me included ... it looks like I have competition. Perhaps we should record a duet?"

Paige is not the only celebrity backing the unemployed church volunteer from Blackburn in West Lothian. Hollywood actress Demi Moore last week said she was reduced to tears by the performance.

Ms Boyle, complete with her distinctive curly locks, won over a sceptical audience to become a global phenomenon following her appearance on Britain's Got Talent. Her performance was also watched by millions online.

She has been catapulted into the limelight in America, where her story has been featured on US morning television shows and news programmes.

She was interviewed by satellite from Scotland for the talk show Larry King Live. The show which will be broadcast on CNN International today.

Alex Salmond, the First Minister, has also sent a letter of support to the singer, who hails from the same area of West Lothian as the SNP leader.

The First Minister's letter offered his "warmest congratulations" for what he describes as a "stunning performance".

The full article contains 578 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 20 April 2009 12:45 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Susan Boyle
 
1

Dark Lochnagar,

http://darklochnagar.blogspot.com 20/04/2009 00:09:18
Elaine Page is a has been who hopes to ride the Susan Boyle wave.
2

FerryPort,

20/04/2009 00:23:27
Dark dark Lochnagar
3

Unelectedbythepeople,

Edinburgh 20/04/2009 01:23:40
So what happened to the sexed up dossier Alistair 45 minutes and all that.........? You think people forget
4

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 20/04/2009 01:27:37


"The First Minister's letter offered his "warmest congratulations" for what he describes as a "stunning performance".

Question is!, did he actually watch the show, me thinks,...

...'I don't think so!'


5

drunken proffet,

Tassy 20/04/2009 01:31:07
Well Elaine Page is, and will continue to be a great singer, whereas you will never be the Dark Lochnagar. A wee *illock is about the best you could achieve. Keep on getting a * when I try and type an h. Right.
6

donald,

glasgow 20/04/2009 04:37:18
Will Godzilla Broon get in on the act by demanding a duet?
7

Finlang,

witzerland 20/04/2009 04:42:53
Politicians and their camp-followers are never slow to jump on the latest popularly-accepted bandwagon. Campbell is a skilled spinner of renown, and his latching onto this latest nugget of potentially propagandist claptrap displays only the depths to which he and his stinking Labour Party ilk will sink.
8

,

20/04/2009 04:46:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

Thrawn,

UK 20/04/2009 06:46:57
According to Alistair Campbell: ""If there is a lesson from her success for politicians, it is authenticity. It is the only communication that works."

Unlike Damian McBride's e-mails, I suppose?

A message for Stephen McGinty, who wrote the above piece: I cannot imagine that 47-year-old Susan Boyle would be called anything else but "Miss Boyle".
10

Voice of reason,

EDINBURGH 20/04/2009 08:47:43
How typical of this desperate Govt to try and capitalise on this to make Brown " a man of the people " . Anything to divert attention from their criminal activities .
11

ExpatNL,

glasgow 20/04/2009 09:33:18




I don't get what all the hype is about, she's got a no bad voice and she's no uglier than any other big fat ugly opera singer I've ever laid eyes on.

I reckon that she had a make-under before her appearance on that excuse for entertainment show called "ITV's Got a Brass Neck".

I mean check the nick of her hair, it takes hours to create that nonchalant "jist oot ma bed" look.

A wee bit of a critical take on what we are being fed by the reality TV industry wouldn't go amiss people.

Bring back the "Clap-o-meter".

Here that's an idea for the next election, nevermind postal ballots, the clap-o-meter is much easier to fiddle.



12

Banana Heid,

Ayrshire 20/04/2009 09:40:17
So what he's saying in reality is all policians are a bunch of fakers who should have a reality check to get them back on track with the electorate. Well Mr Campbell for your information the electorate have known this for a long time so your suggestions are too little too late. Being honest and genuine is a natural ability not something you can switch off and on at will you moron...
13

,

20/04/2009 10:05:33
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
14

The west awake,

Argyll 20/04/2009 10:11:39
Doesn't Campbells remarks reek of New Labour?
Eager to adopt the latest "ism" regardless of whether you actually believe in it. I wonder if Campbell sees the irony in advocating a new "ism" of authenticity.

Campbell should try to understand you can't "adopt" character, you either have it or you don't.
He clearly doesn't, but at least he's in the right party.
15

Mikko,

20/04/2009 10:25:47
The best take on it must be Jay Leno

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVI__AqXnio
16

Louisa,

Perth 20/04/2009 10:36:51
Mikko -10:25
Thanks - that cheered me up on a Monday!
17

bluehead,

edinburgh 20/04/2009 10:49:11
jings!!I thought we had got rid of that guy!!!!
18

AJ Fife,

20/04/2009 11:42:50
Isn't she a deadringer for the old fitba ace Jim Baxter?
19

frostwyrm,

Ontario, Canada 20/04/2009 14:50:36
I hope that everyone making derogatory remarks about this person have had a good look in their mirrors, at themselves, to make sure they are perfect enough to make said comments. If they are that perfect then I, for one, would like to see them to see what it is I have to do to reach their model of superiority.
20

edimck,

Edinburgh 20/04/2009 15:13:04
"If there is a lesson from her success for politicians, it is authenticity. It is the only communication that works."

Maybe true but it only works when there is genuine talent - which Susan Boyle clearly has but sadly many politicians lack. Hence they resort to smoke and mirrors to see how long they can get away with it.
21

Raymond Thomas Brooke,

Leven England 20/04/2009 15:39:06
Article by Alistair Campbell.......more sh..e
22

Xian Shu Fen,

Hong Kong, China 20/04/2009 16:43:29
True, true, true, we all love the suddenly (famous) Susan and many are desperately seeking Susan for interviews, record contracts.... Ten days has gone by and the craze, heat, cheer are still going on and on around her. Hello there, give a minute: grab an icepack on your forehead, it's time we cooled our head down a little and THINK now.

Who engineered the entire Susan Boyle Phenomenon?

YES, engineered, of course.

Susan's dulcet voice is true, no doubt. We may believe that the responses of the judges may/might be true as long as no one pre-told them that "such" a contestant was let loose along the air-tight screening process. And the audience's snickers, smirks, jeers, boos and the later contradictory cheers were absolutely 100% very, very, very true.

Yet, for sure there was at least one mastermind behind. Before stepping on the stage to be insulted or commended, all candidates have to go through interviews after interviews, trials after trials. By normal TV rule, unattractive people in general are dumped in the first or second round. How come she could get onto the stage to be in front of the three notoriously acidic-tongued judges?

Some smart brains in the production team had a well-woven plan to shock the TV audience deliberately from the very beginning of the series. It did. It succeeded. It helped the rating. People are impatiently waiting for the end of May to come. Internet viewers are now crazy. Musical stars and films stars joined the rally. It gives hope to the less beautiful. It educates people that we should not judge a book by its cover. It stirred up talks around the globe.

Susan can sing, definitely, and so many other hard-working musical actors. So, does her voice grasp our attention or the explosive, instant, dramatic, powerful effect created by the combination of her background, look, age, gender and voice, which are so against the general norm/expectation of a "talent".

Remember the success of "Full Monty
23

Xian Shu Fen,

Hong Kong, China 20/04/2009 16:48:30
(cont'd) Remember the success of "Full Monty"? How very true, at difficult time, our dormant intelligence and guts wake up wide. I long to know, I desire to know that super clever mind who called the shot to manufacture this frenzy. Well, they deserve their caviar even at the time of economy meltdown. Shakespeare is from Britain, TV is for drama. Britain's Got Talent not only on the stage but also behind the scene.
24

Observer,,

Glasgow 20/04/2009 17:34:45
''authenticity is the only communication that works'' says Alistair Campbell.

Quite right Al. Made up dodgy dossiers and imaginary WMD only work in the short term, in the long term you will be found out
25

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

20/04/2009 17:55:59
He's having a laugh isn't he? Labour wouldn't know authenticity if they found it in their soup.
26

andy2804,

canada 20/04/2009 22:21:59
In a press statement, Les Misérables' producer sir Cameron Mackintosh has echoed the comments of judges Simon Cowell, Piers Morgan and Amanda Holden, saying, "Just like the judges and audience I was gob-smacked by the emotional powerhouse performance of Susan Boyle's show stopping rendition of 'I Dreamed a Dream.' Vocally it is one of the best versions of the song I've ever heard. Touching, thrilling and uplifting. I do hope she gets to sing it for the Queen. Now call me a fool , hmmm do i believe him, and elaine page and others who say she is oustanding or the collection on here who think she is rubbish and who are straight out of the movie ,'deliverance. well it's a no brainer. the deliverence crew lose every time
27

PinkSwan,

California, USA 21/04/2009 06:03:07
I had not seen Susan Boyle before this night, and was amazed by her. I find it interesting that many of the comments here are difficult for me to interpret. I'm not sure if being a Californian qualifies me as a /Yank/, but in a /Yank's/ opinion, she rivals the best we have to offer on American Idol! (With apologies to Adam. I guess you guys don't get that show!) Love to UK and Scotland from the US of A.
28

PinkSwan,

California, USA 21/04/2009 06:04:16
P.S. I love that phrase, "Report Unsuitable". We have "Report Abuse" which is so victim-y.
29

Prudence,

Moray 22/04/2009 10:39:17
"If there is a lesson from her success for politicians, it is authenticity. It is the only communication that works."
Thats an interesting comment , especially emanating from Alistair Campbell. I wonder who he's referring to in particular . I don't think its Alex Salmond , nor Jim Murphy or Nick Clegg. I wonder could it possibly be Gordon Brown, or even Tony Blair , both of whose messianic tendencies have failed to deliver .

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.