Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 5th September 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Inquiry into hospital workers 'abusing cheap parking passes'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 26 January 2008
A PROBE has been launched amid concerns that health workers are using discounted permits to treat Marchmont as a "car park".
Both the city council and NHS Lothian are investigating any potential misuse of the permits, which are designed to make it easier for essential health workers who are based at the Sick Kids and need to park in residential areas.

The pass, which c
osts just £10 a year, is open to NHS Lothian staff and registered GPs, and allows them to park on single or double yellow lines.

Scores of permits were issued following the extension of parking restrictions in Marchmont in 2006, but residents claim some holders abuse the system.

It is alleged that workers still leave their cars in the area but actually travel on a free NHS shuttle bus to other parts of the city.

Local Tory councillor Cameron Rose has raised the issue with council officials.

He said: "This (potential misuse] has been suggested to me by a few locals. It looks as if it needs a review to check the permits are not being inappropriately used.

"Following comments from some local residents around the Sick Kids hospital, I asked the acting head of transport in the council to look at the issue.

"I noted on some days in Melville Terrace there were as many as 23 cars sporting 'essential user' permits on yellow lines."

NHS Lothian runs shuttle buses between the Sick Kids and various parts of the city, including the ERI and the Western General.

Parking problems arose after the city's controlled parking zone was expanded to cover Marchmont and the Grange.

The Sick Kids on Sciennes Road was inside the old controlled parking boundary, but many staff previously parked in surrounding streets where it was unrestricted. Now, most of those spaces are either for residents only or have pay-and-display meters, mainly with a four-hour limit.

An extra 80 permits were subsequently handed to NHS Lothian by the council for the use of essential staff at the Sick Kids.

The permits were supposed to ensure that staff who have to go out and visit patients could still park close to their workplace.

Councillor Phil Wheeler, the city's transport leader, said: "We are undertaking a review of essential users permits.

"The Sick Children's Hospital (has] 230 permits for frontline staff and we would expect a number of vehicles with permits to be in situ at any time.

"However if these permits are being abused by workers going to other facilities then that would be a matter of concern for us."

John Jack, director of facilities at NHS Lothian, said: "Where we find permits are held inappropriately, (they] will be withdrawn and reallocated.

BADGE CHEATS CAUGHT IN THE ACT

THE latest crackdown on blue badge fraud in the city has resulted in 18 warnings and one person being referred to the procurator fiscal.

The two-week crackdown in December also saw seven parking tickets issued for drivers failing to show a pay-and-display voucher.

Councillor Phil Wheeler, the city's transport leader, said: "The aim of this campaign was to educate drivers about the proper way in which blue badges should be used, rather than to catch people out.

"It was disappointing that so many were found to be misusing these badges. It takes valuable spaces away from genuine badge holders who have to rely on their cars. It also means that some people are enjoying free parking which they are not entitled to."



The full article contains 590 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Dave from Barra ©,

Western Isles 26/01/2008 12:55:45
So they park thier cars up then take a bus. So they are doing what the government want us to do, use thier cars less, reduce congstion and reduce CO2 output. Yet they are being critcised.

What an odd place the Lothinas are.
2

Dave from Barra ©,

Western Isles 26/01/2008 12:56:00
Sorry, Lothians....
3

alex paterson,

embra 26/01/2008 14:23:14
Does this mean residents go without a parking space,shame.
4

The Sheriff,

26/01/2008 15:09:29
So the powers that be have finally realised that these permits are being misused and abused,about time.

The essential user permit that I suspect this article refers to is a piece of white a4 lamenated paper with a black strip across the middle and the words "essential User Permit" emblazened on it,on the revers there are instructions on the correct use of the permit.

It was introduced to enable exactly what it says on "the tin",for health workers on essentail duties to administer health care to those in the community that require their services.

Over the years like any system introduced to allow people to carry out essential work it has been abused.........and so to "police signs"...."disabled Badges".....etc,etc,etc...........

5

earnabob,

26/01/2008 15:20:52
You know there are abusers of these badges all over the city.
I bet most areas can tell you about cars with these on nowhere near any nhs buildings that park continuously in the same spot all week then sometimes move at the weekends (when they need their car to go elsewhere I presume).
Since we are living in a controlled parking zone there should be zero tolerance for offenders, and since it takes ages to gather evidence for these offenders the fine should be worth at least a penalty notice for each day they were investigated (assuming they are guilty), would make them think about doing this sort of thing.
6

,

26/01/2008 15:23:40
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

,

26/01/2008 15:25:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

brettgallacher,

edinburgh 26/01/2008 15:31:26
the minute money could be made the take a back hander council started parking restrictions every where can you blame anyone who owns a car trying to save money have they forgotten car owners own the roads through their road tax the problem is not enough car parks plus the ones that are here charge a fortune
9

earnabob,

26/01/2008 16:10:20
Road tax allows you the use of the road in a proprely roadworthy vehicle, it does not mean you own it.
10

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 26/01/2008 17:32:42
The easy and obvious way round this is to revert the Marchmont parking regulations to what they used to before the idiots got their stupid schemes implimented.
11

Paul Voltaire,

26/01/2008 18:30:26
If Marchmont is a car park, it is not a very good one.
12

Gorgie_Tony,

Edinburgh 26/01/2008 19:27:45
This doesn't surprise me at all. When I first heard of this scheme I knew straight away that the nurses would abuse it. The council should now withdraw these permits and force them to pay their parking fees like any other member of the public - or get the bus!
13

NorT,

Edinburgh 26/01/2008 20:35:20
I complained to City Development about one of these passes (I included the veh reg no) being used to allow somebody to park on a yellow line outside there flat to save them having to get a residents parking permit. I am still awaiting a reply despite a reminder and further information as to the person's address.
14

NorT,

Edinburgh 26/01/2008 20:37:31
According the Council there are 1532 essential user permits in circulation. 1084 were issued to NHS Lothian, 10 to pharmacies and the rest to doctors surgeries or medical practices. They don't know how many are actually in use not how many the Council employees themselves have.
15

James (1),

28/01/2008 08:09:39
Of course this scheme would be abused. Its like people stealing pens etc from their workplace. Its a god given right or so I am told.
If its you doing the stealing you can justify it because the day has a "Y" in it.
16

Bring Back Poll Tax,

28/01/2008 12:04:51
#8 - car owners don't "own" the road - Vehicle Excise duty isn't hypothecated and just piles into the same black hole as any other tax.

Mind you, motorists do also shell out on Fuel duty plus the VAT that's charged on top of fuel duty, VAT on the purchase of their vehicle, VAT on servicing and repairs, Insurance Tax etc. etc. etc. Never mind whatever Income and Council taxes they pay, in return for which they can drive on less and less of the urban roadscape as it gets swallowed up for the infrequent passage of the odd bus and now tram. Where's my discount?
17

MandZ,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 19:29:11
As an NHS Worker myself. These permits where provided to us for use during home visits for patients. The comment earlier re these being used no where near nhs premises is daft as we have to use them on home visit where all these parking restrictions are in place.

You dont see These Kilted men handing out Pound coins to nhs staff for parking now do you so we have to have some thing to provide care to customers in the community.

I now do not have a permit as i work in the IT Section of the NHS as they have just taken them away from us saying because we dont provide patient care we dont need them. This is not right at all as if it was not for the people in the IT Section of the NHS going out on site and fixing their pc problems the NHS Would grind to a hault.
18

tumshie heid,

23/07/2008 13:14:21
#14
I,m glad your not my neighbour, you curtain twitching busybody!

Of course these passes will be used like this. Why can't the hospitals provide parking for their staff in the first place? These workers are quite often on shifts which don't suit public transport.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.