Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 20th August 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Google is watching you!



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 July 2008
IT has been branded the latest phase of Big Brother culture, sparking controversy for its creator, Google.
Now the web giant's latest virtual mapping service – Google Street View – is set to launch in the UK amid claims from civil liberties campaigners it could lead to invasions of privacy.

Camera cars have been spotted on the streets of the Capital, photographing roads, landmarks and pedestrians.

Google has refused to deny its cars are in Edinburgh, but is remaining secretive over which cities will be included in the new UK service.

Street View offers virtual street-level city tours in an extension to the popular Google Maps service. Street View tours are currently only available for Manhattan (pictured below) and have already sparked complaints after people were photographed sunbathing and visiting sex shops.

A Google spokeswoman today refused to say if Edinburgh was next. She said: "Edinburgh may be one of the cities included when we launch Street View in Europe

"As with all new products and services here at Google, we spend a considerable amount of effort researching and testing any new initiative. Many times our tests don't directly result in the launch of a product or service, therefore we don't pre-announce them so as not to disappoint."

But the News has obtained an image of a black Astra matching the description of the camera cars outside the Canny Man's pub in Morningside last week.


Google refused to comment on the car, but conceded it is unaware of any other organisation using a similar camera rig in the UK.

The image was taken by Edinburgh-based internet marketing company Bigmouth Media.

Marketing director Iain Bruce said: "We're obviously keen to keep up with everything that they're up to, so we ran a competition in the office to see if anyone could spot one of these cars and we came up with a result very quickly."

UK human rights group Privacy International has complained to the UK Information Commissioner regarding the new programme's alleged potential to breach UK data protection laws after American citizens complained.

A recent Court of Appeal victory by JK Rowling banning photographs of her walking the streets of Edinburgh with her children further extended UK privacy laws regarding street photography, and could potentially be used to restrict Street View's movements.

Simon Davies, Privacy International Director, said: "Google has informed the media that it will institute 'face blurring' technology to ensure legal compliance." However he added there had been problems with the technology. Google has denied such problems exist, adding that it is already in effect in newer versions of Manhattan Street View.

An Information Commissioner spokesman confirmed it was taking the complaints "very seriously" and would be speaking to the parties concerned.

UK civil liberties group No2ID has said the site could also be co-opted by law enforcement agencies and contribute to what it calls "The Database State".

City Centre Councillor David Beckett cautiously welcomed the new website as a potential new tool for marketing the city.

But he added: "While Google have made a commitment to take action to ensure that people included in the photos would not be readily identifiable, I believe further discussions need to take place."

www.maps.google.com/streetview
www.bigmouthmedia.com


The full article contains 548 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 09 July 2008 1:46 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

allknowing,

09/07/2008 12:04:55
Excellent, so if i rush to the corner of princes st, i can imagine what it would have been like for the person in the photo 6months ago.

C'mon, hardly a threat to anyone, unless your caught doing a poo or a pee!!!
2

,

09/07/2008 12:07:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
3

,

09/07/2008 12:09:07
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Foo,

ejinbara 09/07/2008 12:13:29
There's always some group of people ready to complain about something they don't like.
5

EPS,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 12:16:24
This does not invade privacy. The photos are of public spaces only. I see nothing objectionable in that.
6

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 12:20:22
Erm

1) Flickr
2) Photobucket
3) Anyone can take pictures
4) Crock of sh*t
7

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 12:22:04
I think we have far more important things to worry about in this respect than Google Maps.
8

SDRAWKCAB,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 12:22:27
These civil rights groups need a slap in the face.
Do they think google are plotting some World conquering conspiracy? I think not.
Public places are exactly that.... PUBLIC.
If you're photo'd entering a sex shop, that's your fault.
9

SDRAWKCAB,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 12:25:01
In the photo above.... someone is entering GAP! quick, someone call the police!
10

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 12:32:52
7. I'm more concerned why I have adverts in Finnish in the top right hand corner.

maybe. i. must. go. there.
11

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

09/07/2008 12:42:12
They're a menace I tell you. I was out yesterday and was nearly run down by a search engine.
12

FrankGallagher,

09/07/2008 12:42:32
maybe its candid camera and they are hanging around for hilarious banana skins incidents?
13

Paddy McGuire,

09/07/2008 12:46:28
This simply can't happen! Gone will be the joyous laughter of a Saturday night running of 'You've been framed'. Google...stop and think...please!
14

I love to eat Sellotape,

09/07/2008 12:47:25
It is actually the unofficial van of the Scottish Labour party, looking for dirt to dig up in advance of the Glasgow East bi-election.

Incidentally, why is it called a bi-election? It sounds vaguely underground.
15

gorgeousgorgieboy,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 12:48:13
For "civil rights campaigners" read "opportunistic lawyers looking to make a buck".
16

Paddy McGuire,

09/07/2008 12:50:13
The car looks inconspicuous to me...how did they track it down?
17

Glasgow Jim,

Glasgow 09/07/2008 12:52:54
One of the cars was in Glasgow this morning http://www.hiddenglasgow.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=7542
18

Andrew Kent,

EDINBURGH 09/07/2008 12:54:28
Great.... Everyones going to want to come to Edinburgh when they see all the mess on the tram route.
19

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 13:11:52
Are you sure its not a tram ? Isnt that what trams look like ?


Maybe it's just a "funny" car.
20

Iggy Iguana,

09/07/2008 13:17:25
I saw on of these cars with the camera on it a couple of weeks ago.. cant remember if it was this black astra but the fact it had a blinking Google sticker on the side was a kinda giveaway dont you think?
21

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 13:38:37
Ist es gerade ein " funny" Volkswagen, Vielleicht.
22

Dragonlord,

09/07/2008 13:39:33
This is a great idea, three years from now, you can look back and see how nice the city was before the trams.
23

Gastric Antral Vascular Ectasia,

09/07/2008 14:04:17
Well, that's relaxed the nation.
24

I love to eat Sellotape,

09/07/2008 14:12:08
Mario, ich glaube dass es ein "Opel" ist, nicht ein VW. "Funny," vielleicht, aber mir ist es gar nicht lustig.
25

fresian,

Dubai 09/07/2008 14:24:28
Ich esse gern Sellotape, Sie sind ganz richtig, es ist ein Opel. Ist es moglich, die Arbeiter sind Auslander... Polisch spion vielleicht. Dann schenken sie den fotografen nach Polen zuruck um ihren Freunden "was eine Scheisse Stadt Edinburg ist" zu schauen??
26

NorT,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 14:28:40
The number is clearly visible in the picture. Perhaps somebody could check the registered keeper on DVLA.
27

I love to eat Sellotape,

09/07/2008 14:39:25
Vielliecht, Fresian. Aber ich war einmal in Gelsenkirchen.
28

Gastric Antral Vascular Ectasia,

09/07/2008 14:41:45
"Big Brother culture" is surely a contradiction in terms.
29

Foo,

ejinbara 09/07/2008 14:45:05
Kekkyoku, opel ga kawii desu ka?
30

different name,

09/07/2008 14:50:17
obviously its no surprise that the article is inaccurate, but the google street view is also available for San Francisco. I used it to get a sense of where we would be staying earlier this year and it was great. you couldnt make out people or licence plates as such...but you could look at landmarks and get your bearings.
31

I love to eat Sellotape,

09/07/2008 14:53:39
This is obviously making some Edinbrugh residents uncomfortable. But a vehicle is currently driving through the streets of Calgary with a giant cucumber attached to its roof.
32

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 14:56:14
Nicht ist es wundervoll, dass alle wir babelfish benutzen können?
33

I love to eat Sellotape,

09/07/2008 14:56:22
"Edinburgh". Sorry, citizens.
34

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 15:25:48
Theres a place called Edinbrugh in slotcand .
35

I love to eat Sellotape,

09/07/2008 15:28:48
Thanks, Maroi.
36

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 15:34:26
Im starting to question this behaviour. I'm a grown man ffs.
37

- McLovin,

hawaii 09/07/2008 15:35:28
This must be an old picture of the car as it was spotted in Mayfield last week, now the road tax, camera and wheel trims are missing.
38

,

09/07/2008 15:41:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
39

,

09/07/2008 15:56:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
40

Foo,

ejinbara 09/07/2008 16:12:09
#38 - I don't want to know. Stop commenting. I've reported you.
41

,

09/07/2008 16:32:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
42

Chris,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 16:50:02
There are 19 street views located in France as well, never mind all over the main States and Alaska.
43

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

09/07/2008 16:52:39
Dr Jekyll & Mr Hyde was an absolute classic. I've read it twice
44

Geez Geez,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 17:03:39
what s the point in doing this at the moment all they ll see is road works, i m sure i spotted one of these cars outside the racecourse in musselburgh today
45

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/07/2008 17:11:46
43 Freak.

Anyway, are we trying to turn Edinburgh into the equivalent of a Algerian airport ? why cant people take pictures ?
46

conundrumking,

edinburgh 09/07/2008 19:59:45
whats going on here then? a car in edinburgh on a yellow line & no ticket on the window.......forgot,the meanies are busy grassin up the jakies;)
47

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

09/07/2008 20:01:41
There was a street car named Desire
48

scaramela,

Edinburgh 09/07/2008 20:37:03
News has obtained an image of a black Astra matching the description of the camera cars outside the Canny Man's pub in Morningside last week.

I saw one of these cars last week. It has got Google graphics on the side of the car and a big contraption on the roof. Not hard to spot.
49

Ninian Reid,

Edinburgh 10/07/2008 07:24:33
As someone who frequently photographs anything that moves, I'd be a hypocrite to condemn the right of Google to indulge in similar activities albeit on a much grander scale. We who are transfixed by the lens must guard against infringements that could be on the horizon. Without resorting to "Google" at this bleary-eyed hour, I think I read recently that the civic authorities in NYC (?) were considering an outright ban on the taking of people-identifiable photographs where consent hadn't been given...Now that really would be an infringement.It's a bit like CCTV; if you've got nothing to hide, what's the hassle?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.