Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Second-hand smoke heightens dementia risk, say scientists

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 February 2009
BEING exposed to other people's smoke could increase the risks of developing dementia, researchers said yesterday.
The scientists said second-hand smoke could cause damage to the way the brain works, making dementia more likely.

The study, published in the British Medical Journal, found that those exposed to high levels of other people's smoke were 44 per cen
t more likely to suffer cognitive impairment, affecting their memory and ability to perform calculations.

Previous research has established that smoking can increase a smoker's risk of dementia, but the latest study, led by Cambridge University, is the first to look at the effect of smoking on other people.

Dr David Llewellyn and his colleagues analysed data for more than 4,800 non-smoking adults aged 50 and over. They included some people who had been smokers but had given up.

The adults were split into four groups based on the levels of cotinine – a marker of nicotine exposure – in their saliva. Neuro-psychological tests were carried out on the volunteers to assess brain function.

These included tests of verbal memory – recalling words – numerical calculations, time orientation and verbal fluency, such as naming as many animals as possible in one minute.

On the basis of these tests, those whose scores were in the bottom 10 per cent were identified as suffering from cognitive impairment.

The results showed that, compared with the lowest levels of cotinine, those in the next group up were 8 per cent more likely to suffer cognitive impairment.

People in the next highest group were 13 per cent more likely to suffer cognitive impairment. And those in the highest concentration group were 44 per cent more likely to suffer cognitive impairment compared with those in the lowest group. The results were similar for people who had never smoked and those who had been smokers once but had given up.

The researchers said one reason for the link could be that smoking was linked to an increased risk of heart disease and stroke.

Dr Llewellyn said: "

Our results suggest that inhaling other people's smoke may damage the brain, impair cognitive functions, such as memory, and make dementia more likely.

"Given that passive smoking is also linked to other serious health problems, such as heart disease and stroke, smokers should avoid lighting up near non-smokers."

Rebecca Wood, the chief executive of the Alzheimer's Research Trust, said: "Previous research shows that smoking increases our risk of developing dementia, and this new study reveals that this danger exists even when the smoke is second-hand."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 12 February 2009 9:53 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Tobacco
 
1

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 13/02/2009 01:34:05
There you go. First hand smoke is better for you.

And better for the Chancellor due to the , well, dues.
2

Dragonhead,

Dalian,China 13/02/2009 05:12:19
As usual no real comments from the smoking fraternity.Mind you it takes backbone to quit!They of course will come up with every excuse under the sun to refute this evidence.Like addicts in all fields, admitting you are addicted is the first step!
3

fife runner,

13/02/2009 07:28:26
it may be because smoking or passive smoking affects the oxygen supply to the brain over a period of time. Also, documents released by the companies showed they knew of the dangers of passive smoking back in 1974. They tried to cover it up by telling their scientists to say nothing.

It is not easy to give up.
4

fife runner,

13/02/2009 07:29:45
its like a drip drip effect. Slowly many are wakening up to the fact big tobacco conned them and smoking in any form is dangerous.
5

Tim C,

Southern England 13/02/2009 09:05:32
Now it is all starting to make sense why they did not ban tobacco smoking in the Palace of Westminster.
6

G,

dundy 13/02/2009 10:18:25
there you go #1 proof that some people won't get hte message not matter how simply it is spelled out.....
7

walter,

13/02/2009 10:33:30
The head line states
Second-hand smoke heightens dementia risk, say scientists.
the 1st paragraph states
BEING exposed to other people's smoke could increase the risks of developing dementia, researchers said yesterday.
the 2nd paragraph states
The scientists said second-hand smoke could cause damage to the way the brain works, making dementia more likely.
then Dr Llewellyn states
Our results suggest that inhaling other people's smoke may damage the brain, impair cognitive functions, such as memory, and make dementia more likely.

In the 1st paragraph researchers say it "could" in the 2nd paragraph the scientists say it "could" and then Dr Llewellyn says the research "suggest" it "may", none of them has stated that the research proves it does, Yet Rebecca Wood, the chief executive of the Alzheimer's Research Trust, states "Previous research shows that smoking increases our risk of developing dementia, and this new study reveals that this danger exists even when the smoke is second-hand."
But the study reveals no such thing, at no time have the scientist said it does reveal that second hand smoke does cause a heightened risk of dementia it only suggest it may or could.
8

english charlie,

13/02/2009 10:38:54
COULD. COULD. Where's the PROOF?
9

banhater,

13/02/2009 11:10:24
Anti-tobacco are getting desperate. One of a myriad of science by press release flying around at the moment.
This is junk science, infact its just junk, it has no scientific basis. It is with all SHS studies based on questionaires and guesswork. How can exposure be quantified? Its impossible to do. As with all SHS studies that 'suggest' and 'could' point to harm, the results are pre-determined and designed to promote the ridiculous naivety reflected by some of the previous comments made here. SHS is a bunch of chemicals that are prevalent everywhere in any indoor space in much greater quantities end of story. Look up toxicology and SHS, and see real science.
10

DaveA,

Forfarshire 13/02/2009 11:17:03
Don't worry the calvalry is at hand, the reasearchers themselves are not touting it as proven.

"Secondhand Smoke Bad for Brain?
Study Links Secondhand Smoke Exposure to Cognitive Impairment
By Miranda Hitti
WebMD Health News
Reviewed by Louise Chang, MD

The findings held despite other factors, including participants' age, sex, education, diabetes, high blood pressure, and heart disease. But the researchers -- who included David Llewellyn, PhD, of England's University of Cambridge -- note that the study also has some limits.

For instance, the researchers couldn't control for every possible factor that may have influenced the results. Also, participants weren't followed over time, so it's not clear which came first -- cognitive impairment or secondhand smoke exposure. And although cognitive impairment can take decades to develop, cotinine doesn't linger in the body very long, so it's not a marker of long-term exposure to secondhand smoke.
"This study raises the strong possibility that secondhand smoke causes cognitive decline, but further research is needed to establish a causal effect," Mark Eisner, MD, MPH, an associate professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, writes in an editorial published with the study."

11

im brian and so is my wife,

edinburgh 13/02/2009 11:22:40
well now joke mcconnel,why didnt you listen to the irish
i now have to inhale all that second smoke when walking past boozers,at dalry road you get gassed,its so smoky at times ,you could film hammer horror movies ,with that atmosphere
12

Zitori,

London 13/02/2009 11:36:32
Refute this evidence? What evidence? More anti-science from the very lucrative grant maintained Tobacco Control Dept. of Propaganda. The richest movement in the world is now struggling to keep the momentum going of the lies they have been telling for many years, and are now descending into even more fantasies than ever.

Recent independant studies showing the COMPLETE opposite results concerning Altzeimers disease, where considerably more non-smokers are afflicted, have been ignored by the media. What's new.

Einstein, who always referred to his pipe as a close friend and an aid to his genius, would have been beside hiself with laughter at this total trash.
13

Charles IIIX,

13/02/2009 14:12:09
Beware of new research – any that disputes the smoking religion is invariably suppressed! –Anti-tobacco has ALL the money and it is invariably denied to ethical scientists’;

"University of South Florida studied 70 young Tourette's syndrome patients and found significant increases in the control of muscle tics and verbal outbursts associated with the disease when using nicotine." Same with Alzheimers. Smoking slows the effect of alzheimers in patients who already have it, and smokers are way less likely to get it to begin with.

"A review of 61 studies suggests that smokers have a 60% lower risk of Parkinson's disease." Sixty percent! That is pretty damned significant, no? "Parkinsons is a nerve disease aggravated by dopamine shortages. Smokers have about 40% less of the enzyme that breaks down dopamine, so they have more dopamine."

http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/296834/what_they_wont_tell_you_smoking_has_pg3.html?cat=70


SMOKERS HAVE REDUCED RISKS OF ALZHEIMER'S AND PARKINSON'S DISEASE; Patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) have a considerably decreased life expectancy, with the entire course of the disease taking an average of about eight years. AD is defined by a specific combination of neuropathologic features that include neuronal loss in particular regions of the brain and a high density of senile plaques and neurofibrillary tangles. It is hard to distinguish during life because of other damage and dementias. As many as 80% of the cases may be unrecognized by general practitioners.

Of 19 studies, carried out between 1982 to 1993, 15 found a reduce risk in smokers, and none found an increased risk. And smoking is clearly associated with a reduced risk of Parkinson's disease, another disease in which nicotine receptors are reduced. The fact that acute administration of nicotine improves attention and information processing in AD patients adds further plausibility to the hypothesis
e.g.
Soininen H, et al. Clinical and etiological a
14

Charles IIIX,

13/02/2009 14:12:48

Soininen H, et al. Clinical and etiological aspects of senile dementia. Eur Neurol 1982.
Korten AE, et al. Control informant agr. in case control studies of Alz. Int. J Epidie. 1992.
Breteler MMB, et al. Epidemiology of Alz disease. Epidemiol Review 1992


"The risk of Alzheimer's disease decreased with increasing daily number of cigarettes smoked before onset of disease. In six families in which the disease was apparently inherited, the mean age of onset was 4-17 years later in smoking patients than in non- smoking from the same family."
(Conelia M. van Duljn MSC Albert Hoffman Md., Erasmus Univ. Md. School)

All sorts of benefits;
http://www.forces.org/evidence/didyou/benefits.htm

15

soapy1,

rainworth 13/02/2009 15:14:24
Scientic opinion is like traffic lights, constantly changing, what will it be next week smoking causes ingrowing toenails perhaps or maybe bunions?

there are two scientific facts :

You are born, and you will die, everything in between is opinion and where science is concerned most of it wrong or it would not keep changing!
16

DesertRat,

Somewhere in the desert 13/02/2009 17:12:55
Below are a few names of pipe smokers, arguably subject to a lot of second hand smoke and noticeably, with a lower dimentia rate than non smokers. Statistically, pipe smokers live 1.3% longer than non smokers, (Govt. Stat) which may explain why some insurance companies give them preferred non-smoker rates. A long but incomplete list can be found here: http://fujipub.com/ooops/famous.html

Adams, John (President of U.S., Statesman)
Armstrong, Neil (Astronaut)
Bach, Johann S. (Composer)
Bacon, Sir Francis (Intellectual, Scholar)
Baldwin, Stanley (English Prime Minister, Statesman)
Barrie, Sir James M. (Writer)
Benn, Tony (English Political Leader)
Benhard, Prince of the Netherlands
Bildt, Carl (Swedish Prime Minister)
Bohr, Neils (Physicist)
Bruce, Nigel (Actor)
Byrd, Richard E. (Explorer)
Byron (George Gordon, Lord Byron; Poet)
Casals, Pablo (cellist, conductor)
Chapman, Graham (English entertainer, member of Monty Python)
Clemens, Samuel (Mark Twain; writer)
Cosby, William "Bill", Jr. (Entertainer)
Crocket, Davy (U.S. Congressman, frontiersman)
Cronkite, Walter (TV Journalist)
Cronyn, Hume (Actor)
Crosby, Bing (Singer, Actor)
Cushing, Peter (Actor)
Darwin, Charles (Biologist)
Davis, Angela (Political activist, academic)
Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan (Writer)
Dulles, Allen (Diplomat, Head of CIA)
Dupine, A.A.L. (George Sand; writer)
Earp, Wyatt (U.S. Frontier figure)
Edward VII, King of England (Prince Albert of Wales)
Einstein, Albert (Physicist, Mathematician)
Eisenhower, Dwight (Military leader, President of U.S.)
Ellison, Harlan (Writer)
Emerson, Ralph Waldo (Poet)
17

mandyv,

14/02/2009 01:36:57
Have these scientist got dementia or what? How about spending some money on real research, how much more money is going to be spent on blinkered ideas?
http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/80beats/2008/07/14/a-nicotine-pill-could-help-dementia-patients/
A Nicotine Pill Could Help Dementia Patients

British researchers have found that giving nicotine to lab rats boosts their concentration and memory, and say that the findings could point the way towards pharmaceuticals that could treat the symptoms of Alzheimer’s and dementia. This benefit may be linked to the effect nicotine has on addicted smokers: The “boost” in concentration that smokers experience from cigarettes could help sufferers fight the mental decline associated with dementia, studies suggest

So, as long as Big Pharma have the control, it is good then, hmmm
"The results showed that, compared with the lowest levels of cotinine, those in the next group up were 8 per cent more likely to suffer cognitive impairment".
Tomatoes contain continine as do many other vegatables/fruit of the nightshade family, same family as tobacco I believe.
freedom2choose.info for smokers and non smokers alike, fighting for choice and TRUTH
18

Unimpressed one,

14/02/2009 09:25:01
More junk science from the same stable as the second hand smoke kills bammys.
19

Mrs. Pelican,

Canada 16/02/2009 22:50:38
Wow. I love studies like this. The whole article devoted to "could", "may", and "suggests" somehow concludes with "this danger exists". That's not the scientific method I learned in school. Must be the new improved version. Lovely unbiased reporting.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.