Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Tuesday, 7th October 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Tartan enforcers target BBC bias



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 July 2008
THE BBC will unveil plans this week to 'Tartan-proof' its flagship news programmes in a bid to ensure Scottish viewers no longer get enraged by being fed stories which are only of interest to the English.

A special 'enforcer' is to be hired in its London studios to ensure that inaccuracies or English bias about Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are no longer allowed to go on air.

It comes after a damning report into the corporation by Professo
r Anthony King concluded that the BBC was "London-centric" in the way it viewed the rest of the country, and had failed properly to come to terms with the reality of the post-devolution era.

Research by Cardiff University for the report found that Westminster stories outnumber those about the devolved parliaments by a factor of 17 to one.

Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland generally only made the news on issues of sport or crime. The research also found that reporters held "an assumption that England can safely stand in for Britain or the UK".

BBC director-general Mark Thompson is to reveal a new management plan this week which will seek to counter the findings of the report, which was commissioned by the BBC Trust, the independent body that oversees the corporation.

It follows Scottish MPs' demanding that BBC Scotland be handed far more production time than it is currently given. Some are suggesting that BBC Scotland should, for example, set up a new Scottish breakfast programme which cuts into the main UK edition.

Thompson's report is expected to order BBC journalists in London to be far more accurate about which parts of the UK certain stories relate to, following evidence which found that many items about health and education were often billed as a "British story" but in fact only applied to England.

Meanwhile, a new troop of BBC journalists will be ordered out into the nations and regions to reflect how different policies are impacting on people in different parts of the country. Editors based in London who have not lived or worked outside the capital will be ordered to work in regional offices.

Meanwhile, the 'enforcer' will be back at the BBC newsroom to ensure "accurate reporting of devolved issues".

BBC bosses will say the moves herald a new type of programme which better reflects the diversity of the United Kingdom.

Thompson last week acknowledged the BBC's failure to report properly on Scottish issues, but he said that the Government also had to take some of the blame.

"This is seen as only a BBC problem but they (BBC journalists] have had to deal constantly with ministers speaking as if devolution has not taken place, offering messages as if they apply to everyone."

Labour MP Rosemary McKenna, who sits on Westminster's Culture, Media and Sport Committee, welcomed the new measures but said the BBC was still "complacent" about Scotland. "They are always going on about how they have built Pacific Quay, but when you look at what is going on in there, only 3% of the BBC's production comes out of there."

McKenna said that an opt-out Scottish Breakfast programme – much like the current Newsnight Scotland section – should be introduced.

A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: "The Scottish Government believes in a strong, representative media.

"That is why the First Minister established the Scottish Broadcasting Commission last year to investigate the current state of broadcasting and define a strategic way forward."

She added: "The King Report shows that the BBC needs to make more efforts to better serve its viewers. The BBC Trust made a commitment to address this issue and we hope the action plan meets the expectations of viewers in Scotland."

The joint Broadcasting Commission & Scottish Government Public Attitudes to Television research report found that people in Scotland are not clear about whether UK news reports apply to Scotland.





The full article contains 650 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 12 July 2008 11:36 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: The BBC
 
1

Americanbob,

Edinburgh 13/07/2008 10:36:46
Oh my God! Does this mean another overpaid senior BBC official, (this time with a CU Jimmy hat and a tartan beach towel) sitting in London and pontificating about what is relevant to Scotland.
2

Douglas,

Bathgate 13/07/2008 10:55:47
They can pay for the post by re-assigning their "Scotland correspondent" and using a tame local for the occasional report.
Even the most strident Saff Lahndaner could surely understand Louise Bachelor or Brian Wilson.
3

Jaimeson,

13/07/2008 10:57:05
Americanbob,
You're not american. Your a scaredy cat Inger in disguise.
4

Capital Boy,

13/07/2008 11:09:51
i'd rather have london centric news anytime rather than the same old boring repetitive news stories a la old firm like the way we do at present
5

Joe,

West Granton View 13/07/2008 11:24:41
More like Weegie-proofing? Time the BBC dropped it's almost 100% 'reporting Glasgow' fare and gave us universal coverage to Scotland.
#4.. How many folk think the same but are afraid of being cited anti-Scottish?
6

willyam7,

lanarkshire. 13/07/2008 12:13:25
re;- bbc
the corperation are principaly the westminster propaganda machine and always will be its westminster that allows them to increase the license fees year on year so they have to toe the line that the resident government agrees with the tax payers subsidise this cartel on behalf of the control freaks in the most undemocratic of countries in the western hemisphere.
7

The Spook in Leith,

13/07/2008 12:32:25
BBC Scotland is on the up
8

A Better Way,

Republic of Scotland 13/07/2008 12:41:33
Congratulations to Willyam, Lanarkshire and Joe, West Granton View on your posts.

Thats exactly the point that these numpties dont get. Its not just the fact that we have to listen to the London View, its also the fact that we dont get fair and comprehensive coverage by the English Broadcasters. Scotland isnt just about one or two cities, its about a Nation of Scots who want a full coverege service that includes both local and Scottish National News. Where is the coverage of the Scottish Parliament daily events, we have surely had a gutfull of the English Parliament. The Scottish Nations News is what most Scots want.
9

Neil,

Glasgow 13/07/2008 12:42:59
Privatise the BBC. The BBc is inherently baised in favour of big government in all its forms & is bound to be as long as it is funded & appointed by government.
10

Booster,

13/07/2008 13:59:27
We need to cut ourselves free of the TV Tax that is the BBC.
It is a huge monstrosity that has it's fingers in so many pies you have to think it is only a self-serving play toy and cash cow for its managers.

Hopefully come independence we can leave the BBC to England.
11

Isonomia,

Lenzie 13/07/2008 14:28:06
'''This is seen as only a BBC problem but they (BBC journalists] have had to deal constantly with ministers speaking as if devolution has not taken place, offering messages as if they apply to everyone.'''

What an excuse. Because we normally just act as the mouthpiece of the government telling the people of this nation precisely the rubbish that the politicians tell us to ...
12

FrancesP,

13/07/2008 14:56:13
Do my eyes deceive me? Rosemary 'Union Jack' McKenna calling for a Scottish opt-out from Breakfast? What's the betting this is a cunning gambit to head off Labour's nightmare of a Scottish Six?
13

Guga II,

Rockall 13/07/2008 15:30:42
It's long past time that they scrapped the iniquitous television tax, and forced the EBC to compete on the open market.

If anyone wants to keep the EBC in its present form, then it should be changed to an encrypted subscription service.

I doubt whether we will get any support from Westmiddenster for this though, as that lot of scumbags claim their television tax, along with their Sky television subscriptions, and everything else, on their lying, dodgy expenses claims.

Apart from that, it is also time that the Scottish Parliament had control over broadcasting in Scotland. Going by the EBC, and other English television companies, Scotland does not exist.

The EBC even sends reporters up from England to report on the odd Scottish story; this is despite the fact that the story is also reported on their Scottish news, using a Scottish reporter. We can only assume from that that the EBC does not think the English can understand Scottish accents, though the Scots are supposed to be able to understand all the weird English accents.

14

Dumb Eye @,

Azerbaijan at the moment 13/07/2008 17:31:12
Maybe something similar could be done wrt SKY news, which is even worse, but is unfortunately the only UK based news channel available in my present location.
15

,

13/07/2008 18:32:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 13/07/2008 19:28:28
Privatising the beeb won't do much good either. Think Murdoch.

The private monopoly is on a par with the state monopoly.
17

Andrew BOD,

Aberdeen/shire 13/07/2008 22:52:20
"Meanwhile, the 'enforcer' will be back at the BBC newsroom to ensure accurate reporting of devolved issues".

A part-time job then. 'Cos when does national BBC report on 'devolved' issues?

"the NHS in England... schools in England... the police in England and Wales... the law in England..." blah, blah, blah...

All very interesting, but not relevant to Scotland. We are merely a 'region' to the BBC, treated like East Anglia and the West Country.

It will take more than an 'enforcer' to ensure effective reporting and parity across all nations of the UK.
18

John PM,

Edinburgh, Scotland 14/07/2008 01:23:33
Move broadcasting powers to Scotland as demanded by both Labour and the Lib Dems in the Scottish Constitutional Convention which set up the plans for devolution.

Of course that was before BritGov and more specifically Tony Blair got their sticky fingers on it.
19

Dougie Douglas,

Brisbane 14/07/2008 01:32:47
What is an 'enforcer' going to enforce that allegedly educated journalists are not going to be aware of already?

Surely a journalist on 50K PA should be able to tell if a story pertains to England or Scotland?

What are the editors up to at this point too?

Of course if every single BBC journalist and editor is seemingly and equally unable to make these distinctions it points to a wider institutional bias.

Scottish produced news for Scotland is the only way.



20

Mike S,

14/07/2008 09:14:18
Perhaps the BBC can start by pronouncing Scottish place names properly. The BBC seem to make every effort to pronounce foreign place names correctly but cannot even pronounce the simple word loch.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.