Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Campaigns alone 'not enough to end racism'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 January 2008
EDUCATION campaigns alone may not be enough to change attitudes towards minority groups, a leading academic told MSPs yesterday.
Professor John Curtice, a research consultant for the Scottish Centre for Social Research, said that, depending on events, discrimination could increase, despite the efforts of specific initiatives.

Last year, a study by Prof Curtice and others
found a change in attitudes towards Muslims, with 50 per cent of people questioned believing Scotland would lose its identity if more Muslims came to live here. He said this was in spite of the "One Scotland, Many Cultures" anti-racism campaign launched by the previous Scottish Executive.

Prof Curtice stressed the importance of events in shaping attitudes, adding: "Allegations have been made in connection with members of the Muslim community being involved in terrorist events. We've had unusually high levels of immigration over recent years. The potential for the revival of discriminatory attitudes is always there.

"An educational programme will find it difficult to succeed unless there is a wider social climate operating in its favour."

Prof Curtice was giving evidence to MSPs following the findings of a survey, published last month, which showed that 29 per cent of respondents believed there was sometimes a good reason to be prejudiced.



Page 1 of 1

 
1

EPS,

Edinburgh 30/01/2008 00:20:24
Racism is a deep-rooted problem. Nations have characteristics: if I do not like the characteristics of another nation, is that racism? A person may not be able to choose his or her feelings and beliefs about members of other ethnic groups, but it is important that these feelings and beliefs should not spill over into words and actions. And racial PREJUDICE is always wrong: taking an adverse stance against an individual from another ethnic group on the basis of one's feelings and beliefs about the group as a whole.

At times, all of this may be easier said than done.
2

,

30/01/2008 00:48:27
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
3

Guga II,

Rockall 30/01/2008 08:13:11
How do you define racism? If I dislike the Americans, or to be more exact, their war criminal led government, is that racism? If I detest that other war criminal, Tony Bliar, is that racism? If I consider those Spanish who encourage and enjoy killing bulls as disgusting, is that racism? If I detest the murdering thugs that call themselves Zionists, is that racist?

Every race on the face of the earth is racist, in one way or another. They all prefer their own race to others. This is a normal human condition, and it will never change.

In any event, why is it that white people are called racists for making comments about non-whites, but non-whites are never called racists for making comments about whites?

#3 Whilst I totally agree that a lot of the problems in this, and other countries, is caused by the promotion of this so-called multi-culturalism, rather than promoting integration, Dave is correct, Muslims are not a seperate race. The question of religious fanatics, be they Muslims, Christians or whatever, is a totally different matter.
4

Mercutio,

FALKIRK 30/01/2008 08:40:26
#More guano from the selective Xenophobic Guga.
5

GP,

30/01/2008 09:37:20
I think 1# sums the situation up very well.
The media psin of English hatred of the French is unproven when so many french live in London that is has become the 5th largest french city. Thousands of english have relocated to southern france and appear to have inegtrated well, so much for their racism.
Muslims are not a race but have been evidenced to apply terror campiagns in this country (Scotland). This would suggest that there are some who do not feel part of this nation. If so then they should leave and allow those who do feel part of this nation to get on with making things better for all. It is a shame that muslims feel they are being targetted with racism but then as stated several times they are not a race at all therefore cannot legally be harmed by racism. If the peoples of certain races feel that they are being stigmatised by the suspicion of people that they may be terrosits then I would suggest that they take control of those within their community who advance terror or lawbreaking and they will find no racism or at least a big reduction in race insults and so called crimes.
6

Logie Almond,

30/01/2008 10:09:01
"Allegations have been made in connection with members of the Muslim community being involved in terrorist events."
What a pussyfooting way of expressing the fact that in this day's paper alone there are two cases of Muslims planning and organising terrorist attacks. The situation we have today is as if in 1939 we had two million Germans in the UK, many of whom (particularly the young) were fanatical Nazis.
7

sweet76,

Coventry 30/01/2008 10:54:16
Very selective, these reports on racism. I've listened to the BBC this morning telling me that pregnant Eastern Europeans are a problem for the NHS. Not a challenge but a problem. Would they have made that statement if the 'problem' had been from the non white, non Christian community?
Chav. Is that not racist? Used to describe a socially and ecomonically deprived enthnic group. All very politically correct.
8

oder,

Scotland 30/01/2008 13:03:09
3 Dave from Barra ©,Western Isles

you said


Where is the country called Muslimabad?

three states of Existence in Islam

1.Dar El Arb
the land or war all and any land not Islamic

2Dar El Sulth

land of temporary truce, in Islamic tradition means normally 10 year peace and the war continues

3 Dar El Islam (land of peace) all lands and nations that are subjugated to Islam

your view and the Islamic view appears to be quite different!

Muslimabad? what do you think?


9

It's me!,

30/01/2008 13:24:54
I'll make a deal. I won't make Karachi look like Edinburgh if Edinburgh is not made to look like Karachi. Then the world will have true diversity. We will just have to travel further to see it. Let Oman look like Oman, Sumatra like Sumatra and Nigeria like Nigeria et al. We don't need to see all nationalities in the one street. I sometimes wonder if policies are not based on the lyrics of an old pop song that wanted 'coffee coloured people by the score'. Clones! Move over Dolly the Sheep!
10

Neil,

Glasgow 30/01/2008 13:40:53
"with 50 per cent of people questioned believing Scotland would lose its identity if more Muslims came to live here"

It is not racist to say this. It is simply a statement of fact. Nations aree not merely geographical entities - they are human beings & if a large proportion come from a different culture then culture is bound to change. If the PC brigade wish to have unlimited immigration they should say so publicly, rather than allowing it through the back door & let the electorate decide. That is democracy & is a part of our culture too.
11

Neanderthal75,

Rocky Mountains USA 30/01/2008 15:56:23
Hello All,

Firstly, I agree whole-heartedly with Dave: Islam is a religion and Muslims are adherents of that religion.

Muslims come from all races and so the nitwit politicians and the even dumber Scotsman reporters and editors, haven't the brains to understand that plain FACT.

I would also point out, that the article doesn't ask, nor do the idiot politicians ask, "Should not minority groups do all they can to INTEGRATE into our larger society?"

Why is the onus placed ONLY on one party in this equation?

It 'takes two to tango', but the politically correct politicians and the equally politically correct Scotsman, NEVER really point that FACT out! According to the reporters and editors of the Scotsman and the PC Politicians, it's the average Scot who MUST be REQUIRED to bend over backwards in accepting Muslims, their beliefs, their desires, their religious requirements, and their ever present goal of wanting to replace the Secular Rule of Law, with Islamic Sharia Law!!!!

Remind me again which Islamic nation has done the obverse?

You can't even take religious books of other religions into many Islamic countries, NOR are you allowed to have religious services other than Islamic services in those countries!!!

What happened to 'tolerance' in those cases?

I'm glad to see that more and more Scots are waking up to the dangers which Islam presents to Scotland and the UK as a whole; if only the PC Politicians would become that sensible.

No hope for the Scotsman I fear.

Cheers from the Rockies
12

Allan(handofgod137),

30/01/2008 16:29:59
Scottish Centre for Social Research

Another qango we could get rid of.
13

GP,

30/01/2008 18:44:20
The articel poses a question.
Is the answer direct action perhaps?
14

Hunky Dorey,

Glasgow 30/01/2008 19:24:22
# 2 Archie...... Well said! Sectarianism is an institutionalised thing here in Britain. Just read the anti- Catholic British act of settlement 1701. Or, when was the last time Britain had a Catholic prime minister? Answer.....never, not allowed . Why is the British prime minister allowed to appoint "Protestant only" bishops to the house of lords ? Yes you are absoluely correct .Britain has a sectarian problem, and it is state sponsored.
15

Hunky Dorey,

Glasgow 30/01/2008 19:25:49
#18 that should spell "absolutely" sorry! H.D.
16

The Fly Fifer,

Fife 30/01/2008 21:12:49
Being a member of the most oppressed "race in the world" is a badge I wear with honour .

I am a Protestant Christian white, hetrosexual, married, working, tax paying, drug free, no criminal record, parent who is debt free, and spends at least 2 hours a day with my bairns, eats with the family twice a day person.

17

Maurice,

Fife 30/01/2008 23:14:28
21 The Fly Fifer, I hate your race! I only get to spend 1 hour a day with my bairns and eat with the family once a day. Apart from being very similar to you in most respects (mentioned), I am oppressed into spending my time working off my debts. To the TAXMAN!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.