Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Squirrels say nuts to birth control

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
04 June 2007
TRAPPING is cruel, shooting is tricky and poison is dangerous. If only there was a way to stop the grey squirrels advancing through Britain from breeding in the first place.
That was the thinking behind a government project aimed at protecting red squirrels from their foreign cousins by giving the grey invaders contraception.

But the £1 million project is set to end in failure and disappointment because the pesky creatures just won't take the pills.

Grey squirrels, originally imported to Britain from North America, are spreading through the country, out-breeding the native red squirrels and spreading a pox deadly to the smaller animals.

Campaigners fear that the greys will soon bring the disease across the Border into Scotland.

But trials of "immuno-contraceptive agents" on grey squirrels failed to devise a safe, reliable method of dispensing the drugs.

Scientists conducting the trials have been experimenting with special food hoppers accessible only by greys, to avoid the powerful drugs being consumed by other species.

However, devising a dispenser that reliably persuades the greys to take the contraceptive drug has so far eluded the researchers.

Progress has also been limited by a shortage of the contraceptive.

The three-year project is part of a study funded by the Department of Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) and the Forestry Commission. Separate trials have focused on giving contraceptives to wild boars and parakeets.

Although animal rights groups have backed the use of contraceptives, the squirrel trials, using captive greys, are taking place at a secret location due to fears of attack from animal-rights extremists.

The project is due to wind up next year, and the Forestry Commission said there are no plans to develop it in the wild.

"No decision has yet been taken on funding ongoing research beyond March 2008," said a spokesman for the commission, which is paying £40,000 towards the work. DEFRA

said: "It is too early to predict if or when the technique will be ready for use on wild populations." This is not the first squirrel contraception project to run into difficulties.

In 2002 the Forestry Commission and the Joint Nature Conservation Committee abandoned a study after researchers found it was impossible to replicate the successful laboratory trials under field conditions.

Earlier this year, authorities in Santa Monica, California, announced a contraception experiment, but they have not reported any significant success.

The Scottish Executive is understood to be funding a three-year squirrel-pox project, looking at how the virus is transmitted, to begin this month at a total cost of £300,000.

Scotland is the last UK haven for the red squirrel, as the species has been largely driven out of other parts of mainland Britain. More than 121,000 out of a total red squirrel population of 161,000 live north of the Border.

There are believed to be three million grey squirrels in the UK, but only 250,000 in Scotland.

There are still strong red squirrel populations in Dumfries and Galloway and the Borders but most are found north of the Highland line.

The full article contains 517 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 04 June 2007 12:05 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Squirrels
 
1

Scullion,

Canada 04/06/2007 01:43:07

Squirrels should be the new symbol of the Catholic church (note that I have not mentioned the word "nuts".)

2

Guga II,

Rockall 04/06/2007 02:34:57

Trapping isn't cruel, and shooting isn't tricky. But I do agree that poisoning is dangerous.

The easy way to get rid of them is put a bounty on them. £20 a tail should do the trick.

3

Jim A,

04/06/2007 03:05:59

Shooting them isn't so hard and they taste delicious.

4

The Wizard,

OZ 04/06/2007 03:30:02

Weeshooie

How's it going over in the wild East?

Wiz

5

Aoda,

Pennsylvania Wilds 04/06/2007 04:24:45

Shooting them is easy, just takes patience. Why build a feeder. Just put a cob of corn for them or better yet have everyone put potts with begonia seeds. That attracts them and they make a racket.

Jim A, I ate squirrel and don't like them but I have hunted them for a neighbor that did like them. Ever skin one, that isn't easy.

6

Jim A,

04/06/2007 04:32:42

#6 Aoda, Hi mate, yep skinned plenty of them, made a real mess of a few in the beginning but got the hang of it now. I found it was easier to cut off the legs first.

7

Grim Reaper,

04/06/2007 05:14:17

Why don't they genetically modify the brown squirrels to make them bigger, smarter, more aggressive and give them AK-47s.

8

The Wizard,

OZ 04/06/2007 05:30:52

Cut all trees down in a 50 mile swathe from Hadrians wall south. Set up army posts with snipers and knock the little buggers off as they head noth.

9

Jeeemy,

04/06/2007 06:32:57

This article really does sum up the knowledge and mentality of the employees of this paper.
You would believe that there are no tree rats (grey Squirrels) in Scotland, this is of course well wide of the mark the tree rat is rampant in Scotland. To cure this invasion culling with a price per tail of £10.00 would sort out the problem.
P.S it is Monday and a no news day.

10

Cadgers,

Perth 04/06/2007 06:56:10

#9 Tempting Wizard tempting, but would we stop at the squirrels? ;-)

11

Conan,

Here 04/06/2007 07:21:33

If the local red species of squirrel can't hack it, screw them. The yank grey squirrels are here and staying, with their huge and inexhausable wedding tackle that the local 'reds' can't get enough of ..... kind of like with yank men and our local skanks.

12

sam the god,

04/06/2007 09:28:59

All and any means should be used to eradicate the tree rats. They cause vasts amounts of damage to property and kill the indigionous reds.
£20.00 per tree rat seems a fair price for the vermin. As the daleks say exterminate exterminate

13

Yane,

Quince Jelly 04/06/2007 09:40:23

Mibbee the answer is in their nuts....

14

Neil,

9% Growth 04/06/2007 09:55:28

Back in November the Scotsman carried a similar story about Holyrood starting a similar programme.

http://thescotsman.scotsman.com/scitech.cfm?id=1662122006

What I said then needs no update:

Recently Murdo Fraser introduced a Bill to produce a bounty of about £5 per grey squirrel payable at police stations. This would have worked. It would have given the reds their ecological niche back. It would have been simple & cheap to operate.

Other MSPs & the "squirrel caring professions" held up their hands in horror & denouinced it for involving the public.

This, on the other hand is only designed as a holding operation until a "vaccine for the deadly squirrelpox is developed", something which may not happen & anyway involves visions of public employees then having to hunt down & inject all the red squirrels.

Still it has a good side - lots more jobs & more chance for SNH to empire build.

15

Iain's,

LONDON 04/06/2007 10:00:06

In the good old days, this was not a problem.
They paid 10d for a squirrel's tail and all kids had access to an air gun.

Before my time or I would be rich today!................if

16

Suzi B,

04/06/2007 10:17:48

#16.
The thought of kids with airguns going squirrel hunting gives me the horrors.
I don't think it is a good idea to encourage children to be inhumane towards any animal. Leave the job to the professionals, who hopefully dispatch pests in a more humane way.

17

The Wizard,

OZ 04/06/2007 10:26:20

11Cadgers

I could not possibly comment!!!!!

18

Yane,

Quince Jelly 04/06/2007 10:28:34

#17 There was a problem with miner birds here in Aust. (don't know if they still wanna kill em) & people suggested gassing them, poisoning them & so on & on but my favourite suggestion came from someone inteviewed by chance on the street -- he said -- "pull their heads off I guess..."

19

sam the god,

04/06/2007 11:17:10

#17 suzi b

we use all methods on the farm to control the tree rats one of them is using airguns (used in buildings and close to buildings) this is an ideal tool for the job but when taught properly it gives the youngsters a respect for not only quarry but the use of guns in general. If you will notice the main problems relating to airguns are in built up areas where they have never been given any formal training in using them and buy them on a whim and not for a specific purpose. Please leave the management of the countryside to people who know what they are doing and we will not comment about the multitude of problems in the built up areas (drugs murders prostitution etc).

20

Nell,

Far from the Struan 04/06/2007 12:39:39

Why not make them get married. After a while they wont want to have sex anyway.

21

Culandun,

USA 04/06/2007 12:49:13

I used to live in Batsford Park in England and as a teenager one of my jobs was to reduce the Grey Squirrel population. I recall putting four .410 cartridge shots into one of the little buggers before it dropped. Weight of lead I thought, but no, autopsy revealed only one pellet had penetrated the skin, the rest left bruising. All in all, they're tough little sods! Now my main concern is keeping them out of the bird feeder. However, They are a foreign species in Scotland and whatever methods are taken to control their numbers are worth it in the end. Live trapping and then culling is probably the best as it ensures that only the target species is destroyed.

22

Allan(handofgod137),

04/06/2007 13:44:26

#17 The thought of someone like you breeding gives me the horrors

23

Lanna,

04/06/2007 14:31:57

£1 million spent in squirrel contraception...are they nuts?!

him inside and my bro-in-law, as young teens, would earn extra money shooting squirrels for the local farmers

24

Sam,

Edinburgh 04/06/2007 15:11:00

What can be done with grey squirrels?
They're prolific and annoying at best,
They out breed and drive out the red ones,
And put all our schemes to the test,
But consider that there is an answer,
If we dare not to ask how or why,
For there are some few folk among us---
Who see squirrels and think stir-fry.

25

Lanna,

wild west 04/06/2007 15:25:02

#26 Sam, good one!!

26

Angus,

Balloch 04/06/2007 15:47:44

ALL SQUIRRELS ARE NATIVE

In recent months we have seen a build up of orchestrated hate being directed at grey squirrels by a number of NGOs and conservation organisations in order to gain public support for an agenda of killing these friendly, amusing and relatively harmless animals. This is now a reality as Aberdeen City Council has embarked on a ruthless program of killing.

However, before falling for the smooth-talking well paid advocates of death, perhaps we should consider a number of issues.

·The word “species” is no more than a scientific term within an anthropocentrically concocted classification system and the idea we should have adjectives such as “native”, “non-native” and “alien” describing an inanimate term is really quite ridiculous. It amounts to the grand theft of these words for spurious and emotive reasons.

When a grey squirrel is trapped and bludgeoned to death, it is not an alien or non-native species that is on the receiving end of the club but an individual animal born and bred in this country from around forty five generations and as native as I am.

All individual squirrels in Scotland are native by birth, irrespective of their ancestral heritage or the colour of their fur. The Greys’ ancestors were brought here from America, just as the present population of non-indigenous Reds were brought here from Europe. Indeed, there is no evidence to show that the so-called past “indigenous” population was not introduced here as well. Archaeological evidence of their existence in England after the last ice age is both sketchy and inconclusive.

The idea that genetically different animals within the wide-ranging flux of a species can be “re-introduced” because they look similar is not only the product of sloppy science but on or over the verge of dishonesty. It’s a bit like passing off a reproduction for an antique.

The indigenous Red population, if there ever was such a thing, was shot to extinction (confi

27

Angus,

Balloch 04/06/2007 15:49:52

> Continued

The squirrel-pox virus can be passed from Red to Red as well as Grey to Red, and Red squirrel populations are now showing signs of antibodies similar to that which provides the Greys with immunity. This natural process will eventually protect the Reds. In reality, very few Greys are carriers of this disease and it is as unfair as it is obscene to slaughter them indiscriminately on the premise of a possibility.

The political and grant grabbing fad of planting native broadleaf trees favours the expansion of Grey squirrels. This is well known to conservationists, yet in only a very few places are they willing to deviate from this path because of the money and politics involved.

Scottish Natural Heritage is the leading protagonist in this drive against Grey squirrels. They are in the unique position of being advisors to government who in turn provides them with the necessary funding to carry out whatever they manage to convince the government is necessary. This is an unhealthy and unbroken ring that requires a continuous flow of environmental crisises to fund their existence and regrettably this results in persecution of wildlife unheard of in the past. Sadly, they are adopting the same principle of ethnic cleansing against wildlife as numerous brutal regimes have done against human populations. It is a proven fact that those who have little regard for animal life are the most likely to have little regard for humans. This intolerance should have no part in a civilised society.

Squirrels are not “ours”, no matter what colour they are. We don’t own them. They are independent and parallel mammalian populations to our own and we should afford them the same respect and freedom we expect for ourselves.

Angus Macmillan
www.grey-squirrel.org.uk

28

sam the god,

04/06/2007 22:00:12

#29 angus

the bottom line is they are vermin that cause a lot of damage thus they have to be controlled

29

Angus,

Balloch 04/06/2007 22:08:58

30. sam the god

The bottom line is that we humans cause a lot more damage than any squirrel population.

Squirrels of whatever colour will not destroy the planet as we know it. It is more than likely we shall.

Have you considered that perhaps we're the "vermin" in the greater scale of things?

30

Darrell,

04/06/2007 23:37:12

Angus, so what you are saying is that we should kill of all the humans in the UK who can't prove that they have at least 45 generations of ancestry on the island. I think thats a great idea, more real estate for the rest of us.

31

Angus,

Balloch 05/06/2007 07:38:24

32. Darrell

No. What I'm saying is that we should consider the damage we do to the planet before we call other species "vermin" and call for their destruction.

After all, what is "vermin" other than wildlife some consider as pests?

But we are probably the biggest pest in terms of damage to the natural environment that ever existed.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.