Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


No more grey areas as cull is agreed

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 June 2009
THOUSANDS of grey squirrels in Scotland will be trapped and killed under new plans drawn up by Scottish Natural Heritage.
The agency revealed details yesterday of a scheme aimed at protecting native red squirrels from the spread of their American grey cousins.

Under the plans, which will cost more than £1 million, trappers will target the animals in specific location
s around Aberdeen, in the Borders and along a line from Angus to Argyll.

Scotland is home to 75 per cent of the UK's remaining red squirrels, which are at risk of extinction because of an influx of greys.

Grey squirrels, introduced to the UK from America in the 19th century, carry a disease that is deadly to the reds but leaves the greys unharmed. They are also larger, meaning they out-compete for food and replace the reds within 15 years even if they do not carry the disease.

The SNH plans, launched in a public consultation, were criticised by animal rights group Advocates for Animals.

However, SNH bosses say the tactics, which would see the animals either shot or clubbed to death, could offer the last hope of saving the reds.

Ron Macdonald, head of policy and advice at SNH, said: "The spread of grey squirrels in Scotland must be halted if we are to save the native red squirrel from extinction.

"While complete eradication of greys is clearly not feasible at this stage, this strategy seeks to target grey squirrel control at areas where it would most benefit red squirrels."

Squirrelpox has as yet only been found in the south of Scotland, and Mr Macdonald said it was crucial to prevent the disease spreading further north.

The plans have been drawn up by Saving Scotland's Red Squirrels, a partnership of Scottish Wildlife Trust, SNH, Forestry Commission Scotland and the landowners' group Scottish Rural Property and Business Association.

In North-east Scotland, efforts will focus on the rivers Dee and Don, to push the greys back towards Aberdeen and prevent them spreading into the as-yet grey-free north-west. Trapping will also take place in Aberdeen.

There will also be grey squirrel control along a line from Angus to Argyll, which – apart from an area around Aberdeen – currently forms the northern limit of the species.

And in south Scotland every effort will be made to kill greys to stop their deadly pox spreading further into the country.

The project is due to be fully in place by March next year, and will be evaluated in April 2012.

If it does not work, Mr Macdonald said red squirrels could only be saved by isolating them on islands off Scotland, or by creating a method of sterilising the greys.

He said he had "every sympathy" with the views of people who were against killing grey squirrels.

"We have got to respect other people's value judgements," he said. "But I believe we cannot afford to wait for a chemical contraceptive because by then we might not have any red squirrels left."

Ross Minett, campaigns director for Advocates for Animals, said it was "totally wrong" to attempt to save red squirrels by "slaughtering thousands of grey squirrels".

"What we want is a real and achievable long-term solution to saving red squirrels, through effective habitat management and development of a squirrelpox vaccine," he said.

The consultation will close on 1 September.





The full article contains 567 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 June 2009 9:39 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Squirrels
 
1

nabodican,

Rural Scotland 03/06/2009 00:13:15
Should make some nice coats
2

Florajo,

in the orchard 03/06/2009 01:35:49
A dilemma certainly for all animal advocates.

In my relatively short lived experience here on earth, I would go for nature everytime. Intervention is not the best policy.
3

Kate,

Zurich 03/06/2009 07:15:38
There are the replacement sporran hides!
4

Unimpressed one,

03/06/2009 08:05:27
Another futile exercise and waste of public funds to control the uncontrollable. Greys are better adapted to survive and to cull them is only interfering in a natural selection process, regardless of the fact that they are not native animals. Imagine using this argument to control the human population of past immigrants to the UK. Where's the difference?
5

sam the god,

03/06/2009 08:06:49
well i am doing my bit i trap or shoot them
6

Kate,

Zurich 03/06/2009 08:48:48
Squirrel meat is high in protein and low in cholesterol and fats, similar to venison, squirrel hides could be used for sporrans instead of seal fur and the reds would be better protected.

I agree it's horrible to have to cull the greys but they are not native to the UK and are endangering our native species. This is therefore a necessary evil...
7

Am Fidhleir Lomartach,

03/06/2009 09:56:45
The difference, No. 4, would be obvious if you had even the slightest understanding of ecological and wildlife issues. You have as little understanding of these as you have of most of the topics on which you feel compelled to expound your lack of wisdom.
8

RSG,

Edinburgh 03/06/2009 10:10:34
I've yet to read the report - but we should all get behind this plan - Scottish public money being spent on Scotland and it's unique aspects instead of moats in middle England!
9

Unimpressed one,

03/06/2009 11:46:10
#7, I've forgotton more on wildlife facts than you'll ever accrue. As for your idiotic statements re the sightings of big cats in the UK, you presumably are one of these idiots who only believes what they can see with their own eyes, such is their lack of intellectual abilities.
10

digiRobbo,

03/06/2009 12:08:20
#7 Aye, back spouting c**p again
Must be marvelous knowing everything the way you do
11

Am Fidhleir Lomartach,

03/06/2009 16:48:02
So, no.9, you've forgotton [sic] more on wildlife facts than I'll ever accrue. You've 'forgotton' one hell of a lot then, and that perhaps explains why you write such nonsense on the subject.
12

Pilrig,

Livingston 03/06/2009 18:53:32
Why not cull SNH, an Embra quango as aboot much use as a chocolate fireguard ?
13

Am Fidhleir Lomartach,

03/06/2009 20:59:13
That would be Embra the suburb of Inverness, I suppose, no.12.
14

Angus,

Alexandria 03/06/2009 23:28:11
“Squirrel culling is not a new phenomenon. Some 60 years ago the Ministry of Agriculture started to encourage people to kill squirrels, offering—I remember it only too clearly—a shilling a tail. I became a very wealthy young man at that time, as we had a lot of grey squirrels in the area and I did not need a lot of encouragement to do something about them. When the government at that time had paid out some £250,000, they decided that that was enough. There was no perceivable difference to the squirrel population.” Lord Plumb, March 2006

In Merseyside, a buffer zone has been in place for a number of years where grey squirrels are killed. However, increased human exploitation of red squirrels for tourism and the frequent intrusion by conservationists for monitoring population levels was always likely to lead to stress and loss of condition of the red squirrel resulting in an increased susceptibility to disease. The recent announcement that the red squirrel population has declined by 90% in the past two years is hardly surprising.

In short, fewer grey squirrels with more conservation and tourist intrusion have resulted in a massive decline in the red squirrel population – definitely not the predicted outcome.
15

Am Fidhleir Lomartach,

04/06/2009 08:00:48
No. 14. Your first paragraph demonstrates why a bounty will not work, and is not being considered.

The rest of your post (whether your conclusion is correct or not - I am not familiar with the situation in Merseyside) does not apply to the areas in this this scheme, which is to prevent spread of Greys and their pox on a much larger scale.
16

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 04/06/2009 09:32:20
#15 Am Fidhleir Lomartach

Angus is referring to the situation at Formby, where a population of red squirrels exist on an area of pinewoods on sand dunes near the coast. They have managed to survive there because, unlike all surrounding areas where red squirrels have already been destroyed, the area forms something of an island where the encroachment of greys can be resisted.

Unfortunately that resistance is not absolute and an outbreak of squirrel pox virus there since the autumn of 2006 has reduced the population from around 1000 to less than 100, according to reports by the National Trust who own and manage the site. The squirrel pox virus is reported to produce "similar symptoms to myxomatosis in rabbits with swelling around the eyes, skin ulcers, lesions and scabs. When the sores spread to the mouth the squirrel is unable to eat. Often they are found shivering and lethargic as the disease takes hold." The disease takes about 15 days to kill them.

There is no doubt that i) the virus is spread from grey squirrels, and ii) reds have little if any resistance to it. Despite this, Angus ascribes the appalling result of the spread of this infection to "increased human exploitation of red squirrels for tourism and the frequent intrusion by conservationists for monitoring population levels", which is not only ludicrous but shows a callous disregard for the suffering of the reds.

These recent events at Formby underline the truth that, without the eradication of grey squirrels, red squirrels will likely become extinct in the UK, since it only takes one infected grey squirrel to come into contact with a red squirrel population for that population to be wiped out.
17

Am Fidhleir Lomartach,

04/06/2009 18:40:34
Thanks, Slioch No. 15. I knew his conclusion was rubbish.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.