Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Heather gets put through the mill

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 November 2007
HEATHER Mills McCartney. Does she still use the McCartney name these days? I dunno. All I know is that's she been all over the papers - again. Now, before we go any further, I don't know her personally, have never met her and, as far as I know, I have never met anyone that has met her either. I, like you, probably only know what I know of her through what I've seen on TV and read in papers.
And, to be honest, I've never really formed much in the way of an opinion of her because so much has been written about her, and there is really no way to know what is true and what isn't.

So, at this point, I'll just stick to the facts. She lost
her leg in a horrific accident some years ago, successfully went on to campaign for other amputees, met Sir Paul McCartney not long after he lost his wife Linda, married him, had a baby and is now presently going through a divorce.

And now the bits we're unsure about. She made porn movies, hunted down Paul McCartney and married him for fame and his money, is presently trying to nail him for millions, went to court in crutches to get sympathy and, most recently, killed her neighbour's dog.

I say we're unsure about those bits because they are all stories which have come out about her in our tabloids.

And it would appear that this week, she's had enough. On Wednesday morning, she came out on GMTV and This Morning with all guns blazing, in a full-on attack on the British tabloid press.

She spoke of the distress and anxiety she has suffered through being constantly followed, tailed and photographed by photographers. She also spoke of the hurt that many of the "dreadful" and "untrue" stories that have appeared about her in the press in recent times have caused.

Now I'm not saying that everything that has been written about Heather Mills was a lie, but I can't believe that everything is true either, which makes the whole situation a bit cloudy.

One of her big concerns was for her daughter who will no doubt, in this technological age, find herself looking at these stories and, let's face it, they won't make pleasant reading. She says she is not "taking on the tabloids", but campaigning to the European Courts to make it law over here that these papers have to be answerable to the stories they write.

In being answerable, it means backing their stories up with evidence and it would include revealing the "sources" and "friends" we often read so much about. And if the stories are revealed to be false then the apologies that the papers have to issue have to be the same size as the coverage they gave to the original article.

In essence, she wants truth and honesty in our tabloid press. Fantastically admirable sentiments, but is that something we really think can happen in this celebrity-obsessed country?

Problem is we do live in a celebrity-obsessed society, so the tabloids will sell more if their papers cover more. There are of course only so many celebrities and so many papers, so the competition to get the biggest exclusive is huge.

But in all honesty, how much do we really need to know about this divorce case? Do we really care that a footballer's wife has just spent ten grand on a bag?

I couldn't for sure say that papers print stories they know are untrue, but in some cases if they feel the story is strong enough, I would go as far to say that very little is done to check the authenticity.

My family has experienced first-hand the full force of the press, so you can understand that what Heather has said this week strikes a huge chord with me.

She seems to have had a solid bank of friends and family around her to support her through these last 18 months, and one thing's for sure, her close family will no doubt feel it at times as well.

No doubt about it, the implications these stories have on an individual's family is something that will never be given a second thought when they are written. Having been there, I can assure you it is a horrific thing to have to go through and as much as we seem to be through it, the effect on certain members of my family will never go away.

Don't get me wrong; if someone in the public eye does something wrong, irresponsible or illegal then they absolutely deserve to have it reported by the press, no matter who they are. If it is in the public interest to know something about someone, then that's when the press should do what they do best.

We've long accepted that the tabloid press are very powerful and, in some cases, appear to be able to write what they want about who they want. But in some cases, like Heather's, it becomes almost like some sort of personal vendetta, so should there not be some sort of control?

Take some of yesterday's headlines; saying she was comparing herself to the McCanns. I saw the interviews and my interpretation is that although she mentioned the family she never once made any such comparison, yet that didn't stop the headlines appearing. Twisting the facts like that just isn't right.

As I said earlier, I have no personal knowledge or opinion of Heather Mills McCartney, but one thing I do know is that she has taken on a quite fascinating and momentous battle and we'll no doubt continue to read all about it, and her, as it progresses.



The full article contains 963 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Henpen,

desk 02/11/2007 12:43:36

Like Mr Stott, I have don't know her personally. The GMTV interview just made her come across as a total loonie! (How are her daughter's and class mates going to react to seeing that?!)

As was mentioned today - she should be in contempt of court for discussing her divorce in public & as for paying her off - no chance...

Someone please send her some vallium and shut her in a dark room for a few weeks. The woman is cracking up!

Good tv though...

2

Mr_H,

Embra 02/11/2007 13:02:32

Hey, I've got an idea!

If you don't want the media scrutinising your behaviour, don't marry one of the most famous people in the world.

Then divorce him.

After doing soft core prawn.

3

Henpen,

desk 02/11/2007 13:05:14

#2 totally agree - what was with that scrap book - is she maybe obsessing a little too?!

Has no-one told her about sticks & stones & all that?!

4

Duncan still in Edinburgh,

02/11/2007 13:14:56

5. Is that your idea of a joke? Because it's not very funny. In fact, it's rather sick. You disgust me.

5

Dorian,

02/11/2007 13:23:20

My mate has a prosthetic leg and he thought No.5's joke was hilarious.

6

Oh for the banter,

02/11/2007 13:28:19

I love these folk that will use the media to their advantage without a worry but start crying when it turns against them.

Live by the sword die by the sword

7

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 02/11/2007 13:39:42

She is also allegedly withholding "evidence" which allegedly could be damaging ........... is that not crininal in manyways, obstruction of justice on the one hand and threatening on the other?

8

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Ontario 02/11/2007 13:47:30

Heather Mills is a self-serving, greedy, loud-mouth, lying, fornicating former prostitute and gold-digger as well as being a murderer of dogs.

Should we have NAY sympathy for this piece of inferior human material? NO!!!!

What goes around comes around and she will get her comeuppance some day soon.

For God's sake Heather, SHUT THE EFF UP, YOU NUMPTIE!

9

AJ of Fife,

02/11/2007 13:57:25

TCW#10,

Stop sitting on the fence and say what you really think!

10

Jingsitsme,

Edinburgh 02/11/2007 14:08:21

I think Heather needs 'mind' help but it appears she has behaved like she does for many years. She grabbed Paul at his most vulnerable. Seh certainly plays the amputee when needed - can't walk etc but sprightly goes across the tarmac a few days later to the states.

A number of charities say they have had little/no contact with the woman so I question all this so called charity work - attention seeking more like.

Social Services should be looking at the ability of her to look after a child as Paul appears to be a more stable parent. She is just a lunatic and her presence on GMTV proved that. Even her PR agent has ceased working for her.

Paul at least is being dignified, living the quiet life, giving a wave to press. It takes two to make a marriage and to break one up but I suspect Paul has come to his senses and realised he made a big mistake in marrying her. Think back to all his family and friends comments when they got married.

So go away Heather, never to be seen again. You are unfit for the name McCartney and anyway you are Heather Mills.

I may be hard but I wont be taken in with all this gush from her and false tears.

11

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 02/11/2007 14:24:43

I think PM is doing a favour holding back, the money would destroy her and her child, if only she could have seen sense and stayed with the old man till he passed on ................. no reason for her not to fly about th eworld before then with occasional togetherness press shots ........... and it would have all been hers in the end

12

Jingsitsme,

Edinburgh 02/11/2007 14:34:09

and GRant STott we don't want to read about the trials and tribulations of Heather Mills.

Enough is enough...........

13

Gayle,

Big Smoke 02/11/2007 14:34:53

I feel sorry for the child that is involved here Heather should move on with her life, this doesn't have to be as messy as she insists it is... isn't she just making things worse by going to the press. If I was her and stood to gain the millions that she probably will, I would move to the Isle of Skye to live a quiet and dignified life.

Not go looking for sympathy where she obviously won't find it.

14

Jingsitsme,

Edinburgh 02/11/2007 14:53:53

# 15 but Heather is not you or I, she is off her trolley - deluded and attention seeking! She's like dracula needs it!!!

If everyone gave her short shift she would soon get bored......

15

Gayle,

Big Smokey T.O. 02/11/2007 16:02:50

# 16. I suppose you are right, yes she does seem to have some issues and the need for attention is probably one of them. Something missing in her childhood perhaps?

Any thoughts? If she is off the rails, what will happen to the wee un?

Lots of folks go through divorce an don't get the attention or the benefits she will acquire.

16

Paul Voltaire,

02/11/2007 17:29:59

John Leslie Stott has left the building.

17

Jingsitsme,

Edinburgh 02/11/2007 18:28:10

#18 - Think alot must be missing but Heather is a grown woman and has choices and made them! We can't all blame our childhood. We have to take responsibility for our behaviour.

My opinion is that Paul would be a better parent for their daughter to stay with. If Heather was so caring and concerned she would have kept out the limelight for the sake of her daughter and swanning around TV studios here and in US blaming everyone but herself........

Ive no experience of divorce but I would think she should be more concerned with sorting it out so she can move on rather than making it worse raning on TV. She got advice and refused to take it.

Here should end Heather Mills - the golddigger......RIP

18

it has always been allan,

02/11/2007 18:33:46

I want to know what Paul says in the morning when he looks at himself in the the morror in the morning.

Also youse would like to know what speciality she servers up in bed, which is worth millions

19

Gayle,

Big Smokey T.O. 02/11/2007 19:33:45

#18, Truer words couldna be spoke.

Enjoy the day!!

20

Gayle,

Big Smokey T.O. 02/11/2007 19:35:06

oops, I mean#20, LOL!!

time to hang up this discussion I think

21

Jingsitsme,

Edinburgh 02/11/2007 20:32:34

#23 - yes indeed - RIP Heather.

I'm going to have a greaaaaaaaat weekend hope you all do as well.

22

COLINTON.MAINS,

canada 02/11/2007 23:34:47

she.is.nothing.but.a.gold,digger

23

linny1000,

New York 03/11/2007 01:26:34

So Heather thinks that tabloids must name a source, and then goes does an interview yesterday, and says "one of Stella's friends" told me...so a source without a name is just fine for her to use, but the tabloids can't. There are many pro-Heather articles that were "a source close to Heather" that were damning to Paul, but not one interviewer called her on that when she is suggesting that Paul planted articles on her because they said "a source close to Paul". I wish one interviewer would have done their homework. The interviewers in the States had 24 hours, but didn't do a damn thing. If one interviewer or reporter would document the Heather lies, exaggerations, etc., the would be shocked. Her first husband would not marry her until she went to therapy for her lying problem. Enough said. Way to go, Heather. You made people go from not believing to HOPING Paul punched you out.

24

Ranger,

England 03/11/2007 11:18:12

A rational view from Mr. Stott and very welcome as Mrs. Mills-McCartney does not appear to inspire confidence herself, even though her campaign would lead to better reportage, I'm sure.

More clear thinking and reporting is required. Who cares what legal individual action is required if the outcome benefits us all.

25

Jingsitsme,

Edinburgh 03/11/2007 11:48:25

#26 - very good comments and I hope Heather Mills reads them!

#27 Any campaign Heather Mills is so called involved in is for her own need - attention. It's sad that the campaign itself is not the priority reason. My charities whom she mentions have had little contact with her and don't want to either.

26

Grandma,

USA 03/11/2007 19:05:28

With all the back biting and sniveling going on I'm not surprised Heather is put out. In fact, I've read this kind of mean spirited hog wash from the other side of the pond for too long now. I think this forum gives a select few who can't get along with people on a normal basis, a spot to vent and spew. The child needs to be thought of here. So put it away folks. You're merely adding to the situation she is complaining about. These things damage a growing child into adulthood and then they become people who like to hurt other people. We are what we create. Would you guys want your Mother to be the most reviled person on earth? And why hasn't big important super Paul defended his wee daughters enviornment? Just because you play a guitar doesnt make you a good parent folks. And the suggestion that Paul was so soft headed and limp is an insult to him inferring that he couldn't see Heather coming. These people are old enough to play by themselves. I say shelve it.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.