Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

The hunt is On.
Sponsored by
Can you track down Scotland's wildest beastie?
 
 
Friday, 5th December 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Cigars, champagne and caviar – the gifts our leaders love (oh, then there's the toy rat and 24 tins of curried mackerel)



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 October 2008
POWER brings many perks, but a stuffed toy rat, curried mackerel and a papier mâché model of Alex Salmond were perhaps not what ministers would have put at the top of their wishlists.
The gifts were among a treasure trove received by SNP ministers since the party came to power in May 2007.

Mr Salmond, the First Minister, received signed football shirts, tea from India, cufflinks, a scarf, a collection of CDs, food and fish hampers from the House of Beauly and chocolates, all of which he gladly accepted.

But other gifts – including the papier mâché puppet, from the Cantilena Children's Art Festival on Islay, and the toy rat, from the Oriental studies academic Lady Mirrlees, he has decided not to take home.

He did, however, put a translation of the National Conversation white paper from the vice-president of Catalonia on his bookshelf.

The list of the hundreds of items received by ministers since Mr Salmond and his party took power up to 28 January this year was obtained under a freedom of information request, which took the Scottish Government more than eight months to answer.

Some eyebrows have been raised that eight out of the nine ministers offered alcohol accepted the gifts for themselves, despite planning an offensive on Scotland's booze culture.

Mr Salmond is the only one to have refused alcohol, but John Swinney, the finance secretary, pocketed three bottles of whiskey and a bottle of vodka, while Nicola Sturgeon, the health secretary, accepted champagne and caviar from the Russian consulate general.

Richard Baker, Labour's justice spokesman, said this was "highly hypocritical", considering the SNP wanted to stop under-21s buying alcohol from off-licences.

"They really have an unbelievable gall to tell young people they can't buy alcohol and then happily take free booze themselves," he said. "It seriously undermines what they have been saying about tackling the problems of alcohol."

Ms Sturgeon has also had to defend having received a cooler bag full of drinks from Coca-Cola, at a time when the Scottish Government was trying to stop fizzy drinks being sold in schools and on government property. Her spokesman said the drinks were fruit juice and water.

But little equals the haul that came from rural affairs secretary Richard Lochhead's trip to Brussels on 19 December last year, where he picked up a great deal more than new freedoms for Scottish trawlermen.

The minister managed to walk off with a bottle of sparkling wine and apples from the UK fisheries minister, Jonathan Shaw, 24 cans of beer and lager from the Danes, a bottle of Bushmills whiskey from the Irish and some salami and cheese from the Dutch. All of which found its way to his fridge and drinks cabinet at home.

Mr Lochhead is no stranger to taking home free delicacies, which at various points have included curried mackerel, fudge, cheeses and a tin of Greek sweets.

His junior minister, Mike Russell, has also done well from gifts, and the list has revealed his penchant for Cuban cigars – he received a box of them from the Parliamentarians for Cuba.

Adam Ingram, the children's minister, received an iPod from Young Scotland, while his colleague Bruce Crawford, the SNP business manager, was given an MP3 player by Manchester City Council.

Rules and regulations regarding official presents

SCOTTISH Government rules mean ministers can accept gifts on two conditions: first, that it is valued at less than £140 and second, that it does not appear as a conflict of interest in an important decision a minister is due to make.

Several of the more desirable items have been put on public display or use in government offices. The most high-profile is a painting of Linlithgow Palace by John Lowrie Morrison, given to Alex Salmond, the First Minister, and used on his Christmas card last year. Even if gifts are not accepted by the minister for personal use, they need to be declared and a record of what has happened of them needs to be kept.

Among the alcohol offered to Mr Salmond were eight bottles of whisky, which he put aside to be used for entertaining guests at official functions.

Ministers also have to declare gifts in kind. One gift to John Swinney, the finance secretary, was a lift on a helicopter while he was in the United States.

The problem many opposition politicians have with the register of gifts is that it is dependent on the Ministerial Code. This is self-regulatory and the final arbiter on what can be accepted or whether the code has been broken is the First Minister. Mr Salmond has bowed to pressure to have some independent scrutiny of these decisions by setting up a board of former presiding officers to offer advice when he requests it.

The weird and the not so wonderful – who got what

SALMOND:

Signed Barcelona, Hearts and Homeless Scotland World Cup football shirts – kept by First Minister

Papier mâché puppet of the First Minister from Cantilena Children's Art Festival – on display

Choosing Scotland's Future, A National Conversation – Translated Spanish version from vice-president of the government of Catalonia – retained for use by minister

Stuffed toy rat from Lady Mirrlees (academic) for Chinese New Year (year of the rat) – kept in ministerial office

STURGEON:

Champagne and caviar from consulate general of Russia, kept by deputy First Minister/ health secretary

Cool bag with samples of Coca-Cola products (drinks) from Coca Cola, kept by Nicola Sturgeon

SWINNEY:

Three bottles of whisky (from chambers of commerce) and a bottle of vodka (from Russian consulate general), kept

ADAM INGRAM:

IPod from Young Scotland, kept

RICHARD LOCHHEAD:

24 tins of curried mackerel from International Fish Canners, kept

On 19 December, 2007 – 12 cans of lager and 12 of beer from Danish minister; apples and sparkling wine from UK fisheries minister Jonathan Shaw; bottle of Bushmills from Irish minister; salami and cheese from Dutch minister – all kept for personal use

MIKE RUSSELL:

Box of cigars from parliamentarians from Cuba, kept

£100 of book tokens from Edinburgh University, kept

The full article contains 1032 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 October 2008 12:40 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Scottish National Party
 
1

Conan the Librarian™,

14/10/2008 00:14:50
In the interest of impartiality Mr Maddox, could you now report upon the gifts given to the last Scottish Government?
2

Conan the Librarian™,

14/10/2008 00:15:38
Sorry, Executive.
3

subrosa,

14/10/2008 00:23:02
Who is wasting government time by asking for such information using FOI Act? Took 8 months to answer? Perhaps they shouldn't have bothered answering at all then the enquirer could make a further fuss to the higher powers. Whoever it was they'd be a laughing stock.
4

Conan the Librarian™,

14/10/2008 00:51:22
3
Let's guess subrosa.

First name George pehaps?

5

Conan the Librarian™,

14/10/2008 00:51:58
Or, indeed perhaps.
6

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 14/10/2008 00:52:42


Alex Salmond as usual Laughing for the Picture, and Laugh he may, as he consumes His,....

.."Cigars, champagne and caviar"

While denying our 'ADULT' 21year olds the Same!

Shame on the Man!, it is of 'NO-WONDER' the SNP are becoming less Popular by the minute!
7

subrosa,

14/10/2008 00:54:28
#4

You're not far from my thinking Conan. I'm surprised David Maddox didn't give the name. Could be himself of course...
8

SNP hypocrisy,

14/10/2008 04:11:41
1. Since when did the SNP stand for election to be the Scottish 'government'? I don't remember casting my vote for any Scottish 'government', since NO PARTY stood on that ticket - and no wonder since it never existed.

Considering that the SNP have only 47 MSP's out of 129, I dispute the legitimacy of their calling themselves 'the government'. If they want to call themselves that then let's run the election again and this time it will be for election to that level of local government. And this time around let's try and count the 180,000+ votes that were somehow ignored last time around. The way things are going, I think the SNP might find themselves in a weak opposition. Salmond's egotistical pretentions and claims to be being 'the government' know no bounds. They must be high on the free booze or something...
9

donald,

glasgow 14/10/2008 04:41:02
Why is Alex holding up a Labour MSP in his photie?
10

Kyle N Carrick,

14/10/2008 06:43:32
"Papier mâché puppet of a First Minister " - I thought he had gone to Malawi?
11

Kyle N Carrick,

14/10/2008 06:51:06
What, nothing useful like 19 gifts of £950 in brown envelopes?
12

bully wee alba,

Edinburgh 14/10/2008 07:27:43
How about Mr Maddox showing us a list of all the gifts given away by the previous Lab-Lib coalition?
He could start with various PFI hospitals and schools, the Skye Bridge.......................
Rather puts the acceptance of a few bottles of wine or spirits, some apples fudge and sweeties into perspective.
13

,

14/10/2008 08:04:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
14

Rev. S. Campbell,

Bath 14/10/2008 08:06:07
"Richard Baker, Labour's justice spokesman, said this was "highly hypocritical", considering the SNP wanted to stop under-21s buying alcohol from off-licences."

Why? Are any of the ministers under 21?
15

Rev. S. Campbell,

Bath 14/10/2008 08:08:22
#6 Charles, I've been reading your posts for six months now and I have to ask - what's wrong with you? Are you of foreign extraction and struggling with the finer points of the language? Or was your English teacher at school just permanently on LSD? Your completely random use of punctuation, paragraphs, inverted commas and capital letters is exhausting to read and makes you sound like a mental patient.
16

Rev. S. Campbell,

Bath 14/10/2008 08:15:34
#6 Let me help you constructively by reposting your message in English that wouldn't get you held back in the remedial class for five years:

"Alex Salmond, as usual, laughing for the picture - and laugh he may, as he consumes his cigars, champagne and caviar, while denying our "adult" 21-year olds the same!

Shame on the man! It is no wonder the SNP are becoming less popular by the minute!"

In just those two short sentences you made no fewer than TWENTY-TWO basic grammatical errors. (I'll identify them all individually for you if you like.) I assume you're a grown man who wants us to consider you as someone of intelligence, and if so then that's absolutely embarrassing. Sort yourself out - you're lowering the intellectual tone of these comment threads, and that's no mean feat.
17

Boy Wonder,

14/10/2008 08:22:27
Let them keep the gifts ... but they should be forced to pay the cost of such, into the Scottish exchequer. It's not a lot ... but every little help as they say, doesn't it?

#15. Rev S ... Charles Linskaill, despite his protestations, is a 95 year-old man with senile dementia. We understand that on this forum ... and the majority of posters don't mind at all. He might be abit hard to take, but he's OUR Chuckles ... and the forum would be poorer without him ... and his rants! :D
18

Rev. S. Campbell,

Bath 14/10/2008 08:30:36
#17 What a surprise that you have nothing of worth to add. It's a genuine question - writing such drivel undermines any point Charles might be making, and since he's on your side rather than mine I'd have thought you'd want his arguments to be less badly presented. Of course, that's crediting you with an ability to grasp logic and reason that I've yet to see you ever display.
19

John S,

14/10/2008 09:02:06
1999-2004:Scottish ministers have been showered with 785 gifts incl box of fish, a baseball cap and two loaves of gingerbread since devolution a Sunday Herald (3 Oct 2004) investigation has revealed.
The Labour First Minister, Jack McConnell, and his Liberal Democrat deputy, Jim Wallace, have received far more than anyone else. Amongst their 219 gifts, were 31 free tickets for sporting and cultural events, 23 bottles of whisky and an avalanche of glassware, ties and cufflinks. McConnell recorded 120 gifts and Wallace 99.
The most popular presents were books (161), followed by glassware (85), whisky (59), tickets (33), pens (32), ties (28), flowers (27) and quaichs (25).
Note:The Executive offered to provide the list-but only for a charge of £1001.62. This charge was dropped after the Sunday Herald threatened to refer the matter to Scottish Information Commissioner.
http://www.robedwards.com/2004/10/first_minister_.html
2005-Jack McConnell, the First Minister, received more than 100 gifts in 2005 - incl an elephant statue and four cases of Tennents Lager.

Ministerial Gifts 1999-2004(pdf);incl Iain Gray-28 gifts:Andy Kerr-45 gifts.
http://tinyurl.com/3lyomu
Ministerial Gifts 2006(May)-2007(March(pdf);incl Andy Kerr-26 gifts
http://tinyurl.com/54ot25
Ministerial Gifts 2007-2008(pdf)
http://tinyurl.com/4l2hst
20

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 14/10/2008 09:07:00
No doubt, the multitude of gifts received each year by members of the UK Government and the Royal Family would make the Nationalists look like beggars!
21

subrosa,

14/10/2008 09:32:06
# 18 'Let them keep the gifts ... but they should be forced to pay the cost of such, into the Scottish exchequer. It's not a lot ... but every little help as they say, doesn't it?'

Why didn't you suggest we all put any birthday or Christmas presents in a public auction with profits going to public funds?

Yer daft.

22

,

14/10/2008 10:03:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
23

,

14/10/2008 10:11:54
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 14/10/2008 12:08:24
16 Reverend S. Campbell from Bath

Why don't you just SHUT UP and tend to your flock.

We like the linguistic eccentricities of Charles Linskaill and don't need the pedantic intrusions of fumbling clerics such as yourself.
25

Dragonhead,

Dalian,China 14/10/2008 12:16:51
Tinned Mackerel.Aren't they the new 'illegal tender' in prisons? So it would be interesting to know who in the slammer sent them? Joking of course,but am I?
26

dude,

wishaw 14/10/2008 13:59:05
The Scottish Government recieving small gifts from people is nice i think, at least they were honest about it not like the last shower of bampots, if you look at some of their admisions to the register most of them never saw a think ie. it was all given thru stuffed brown envelopes
27

Finnzz,

14/10/2008 19:34:00
It appears that unlike his previous Labour counterparts, the First Minister has yet to receive and keep anything illegal. But I'm sure that should that day come, the Scotsman will provide ample coverage of the momentous event.

Or perhaps various posters on here like their politicians to be bought.
28

Conan the Librarian™,

14/10/2008 20:26:23
28
All just under a thousand pounds dude?

29
"An honest politician is one who, when he is bought, will stay bought."

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.