Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Labour urges SNP to 'see sense' on knives

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 18 May 2009
LABOUR yesterday demanded that justice secretary Kenny MacAskill "sees sense" and holds a national knife amnesty.
Richard Baker, Labour's justice spokesman, said a Scotland-wide amnesty in 2006 had collected almost 13,000 blades in just over a month. He contrasted that to the situation under the SNP, with First Minister Alex Salmond saying there had been 2,
000 knives taken off the streets since May 2007.

Mr Baker said he had written to the justice secretary last month calling for a national amnesty, but that the request had been turned down.

He said: "Why won't the justice minister see sense? This smacks of political dogma getting in the way of tough action."

However, Mr MacAskill insisted that the Scottish Government was taking action to tackle the "scourge" of knife crime.

And he said it was a matter for the police and the Crown to determine whether there should be a national amnesty.

Meanwhile, SNP MSP Angela Constance accused senior QC Paul McBride of undermining his new political party's hard-line policy on knife crime.

Mr McBride, who recently defected from Labour to the Conservatives, yesterday said there should be a "presumption" of jail for committing knife crime.

Ms Constance suggested this was at odds with the party previously presenting its policy as being for mandatory sentences.





Page 1 of 1

 
1

Mykel Mzoritz,

18/05/2009 00:37:22
Maybe Labour could see senses on expenses as well.

Fatty Salmond should pay back the food money tae - right now - cheeky barsteward.
2

Davy,

18/05/2009 00:49:15
What a load of bull knife amnesty.
You wonder what our politicians are all about.
Sorry I cannae stab yoo the noo, I have handed in my jib. When this amnesty is over, your getting the malky.
3

Alan B,

18/05/2009 00:52:23
labour are ridiculous here.

The snp have lead the way here. The tories have come in with a worth contribution.

What have labour done? Nothing. What did they do in power for 10yrs? Nothing. Police numbers were falling while the snp have reversed that trend. When the snp wanted to free up police time by getting police out of traffic labour thwarted this as transport is a reserved westminster matter. Grey has tried to jump on the band wagon and again just looks stupid.

With the snp you can agree or not with certain issues round the criminal justice system but they are dynamic and are trying to make a difference. This is a complete reversal of labour time in office where mcconnell did not want to do anything so not to make an ar5se of it.
4

Edward,

18/05/2009 01:13:18
Labour now clutching at any strawsblowing in the wind
Gray an the rest of the Labour muppets now look very very stupid.Obviously there having to think for them selves as the orders fom London have died to a trickle as London Labour are otherwise occupied in trying to save their skins!
5

,

18/05/2009 01:41:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

smokey joe 1,

18/05/2009 06:22:45
Is this the best labour can come up with,another knife amnesty, what about a troughing amnesty,no thought not.
7

English Voice,

18/05/2009 07:02:48
I just scanned the article. Have the SNP not been claiming enough for knives on expenses?
8

TWC,

exLabour 18/05/2009 08:28:39
Where's Murphy???
9

For Scotlands Future,

Vote for the SNP 18/05/2009 08:46:05
SNP urges Labour to use sense over Airguns.
10

gus1940,

Edinburgh 18/05/2009 08:49:57
Surprise surprise - no mention in today's paper of the little matter of Elmer Fudd's expenses claim re his Labour-owned constituency office.

Even more surprising no more sensationalised and exaggerated reports re Tobleronegate and Corkscrewgate.
11

Number 6,

Germany 18/05/2009 09:15:04
Oh shut your wretched mouths Labour. You went decades ignoring Scotland's social problems, and now here you all are, in Tasmanian Devil Mode, having the Gall to tell the SNP to see sense.!!!

Still blissfully unaware it seems of the Nation wide disgust and anger felt towards them.

Roll on the election, please.
12

carrottop,

Dumfries 18/05/2009 09:30:59

Pure political attempt at points scoring but Labour get a negative score, as many posters point out knifes are so plentiful that an amnesty is meaningless. Its catching them in possession in a public place that counts and like it or not stop and search is the only worthwhile deterrent that will have any effect, if they dont find many during the stop and search then just maybe its the threat of the search itself thats made them leave them at home.
13

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 18/05/2009 09:57:59
MacAskill's idea of addressing knife crime is to ban the sale of Stanley knives from DIY stores. As usual, he is only interested in crazy schemes that will hit the innocent majority hardest.

A sensible idea like a knife amnesty wouldn't enter his head. Such amnesties have been very successful in the past by removing a large number of pretty nasty weapons from the streets. They have also made people think. Maybe that's what MacAskill is afraid of.

It's about time MacAskill was sacked. He is an embarrassment to Scotland.
14

Miss H,

18/05/2009 09:59:54
2 Politicians don't decide when there will be a knife amnesty - the police take the lead in that. That fact is actually contained in the story but not the headline - as usual with the Scotsman.
15

alanh,

ek 18/05/2009 10:31:17
are the nu liebore sleaze and spin, north brittian dept,party saying that their knife amnesty didnt work then?
Or was it their attempt at law and order and past bills on knife crime that didnt work? Or , as usual are they simply USING a serious problem to try to point score. They had the opportunity to make prison sentence automatic whilst in power and have that power nationally. But for some obscure reason, probably the lack of room in prisons, they dont want that whilst in power only when they are in opposition and dont have to find the room or cash for it
16

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 18/05/2009 14:33:58
You really have to laugh at Richard Baker mimicking outrage.

The inconvenient truth is that they failed to "see sense" during their 10 years in power. This amounts to empty rhetoric.
17

Alan B,

18/05/2009 15:01:40
#Alternative

From the interview i saw MacAskill said he was not against an amnesty if the police wanted it.

labour are playing silly games. MacAskill is introducing sentencing guidelines. The tories come up with specific sentences for knifes. And labour are now trying to get headlines as they have trailed the other parties in taking a pro active approach.

politics with labour is just a game of power and not about real people and their lives.
18

The Creature from the Back Lagoon,

18/05/2009 18:44:07
Ma drawer is full o knifes.
How am a gonna slice ma pizza if they take em awae?
19

IainGlasgow,

19/05/2009 12:01:51
What good is a knife amnesty going to do? Most people who hand knives in are unlikely to intend to do harm with them and those who do will just acquire more knifes so we'll ned another amnesty again in a few months.

Besides a kitchen knife could do alot of damage in the wrong hands - would they suggest getting rid of all them as well?

Knife (and gun) amnesties are nothing more than PR exercises for politicians who want to look tough on knife crime but they have no effect whatsoever on violent crime statistics.

Knives don't stab people. People stab people and that is what needs to be addressed.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.