Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Axe hangs over Mary, Queen of Scots again

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 December 2007
AFTER 10 years of toil, the top Hollywood actress is ready, the breathtaking Scottish locations are organised and the money – perhaps as much as £30m – is firmly in place. Trouble is, the words aren't finished.
The Hollywood writers' strike, after first bringing the American movie industry to a halt, has now claimed Mary, Queen of Scots as its first major victim this side of the Atlantic.

Shooting of the movie is scheduled for this spring but the movie i
s almost certain to be delayed and may even be scrapped altogether because no one can be found to complete the all-important script.

The huge commercial and critical success of Mel Gibson's Braveheart convinced Hollywood that movie-goers had a big appetite for historical Scottish blockbusters. At various stages, Sean Connery was involved as producer and Bryce Dallas Howard was cast as Mary, before the project evolved into a low-budget TV two-parter, which was shot in Romania in 2003.

The original screenplay was left gathering dust on Warner Brothers' shelves until it was spotted by Scarlett Johansson, who has developed a passion for historical roles. The revived project was announced at the Cannes Film Festival in May. A new producer and director were recruited, Scottish castles and other locations were visited, the budget was in place and the film was quietly moving towards production in April next year.

But producer Iain Smith said the film will probably now have to be postponed. "It's likely," he said. And he admits there is a danger of it collapsing completely. "The film has been trying to get off the ground for a while but this time I thought we had got a fairly clear run at it. It may be the last chance in the sense that you only get so many lives in this industry."

However, writers' strikes in 1988 and 1960 both lasted five months and commentators do not see much prospect of an early resolution to the current six-week-old dispute, which is largely about payments for "new media".

It would take the movie weeks to get back on track and it is not simply a question of preparation and juggling other commitments further down the line. "Scarlett is okay with it," said Smith. "The problem is not so much her, as the impending SAG (Screen Actors' Guild) strike, which would kick in at the end of June."

The film is based on the original screenplay by Cracker writer Jimmy McGovern. But it was being reworked by Ron Harwood, the Oscar-winning writer of the 2002 Holocaust drama The Pianist, when the Hollywood writers' strike began. "We can't get the next iteration of the script until the thing is resolved," said Smith.

McGovern's script focused on the relationship between Mary and the Earl of Bothwell and was described as an "epic love story" and a "psychological romance". The project looked dead and buried before it was taken up earlier this year by Johansson.

John Curran, director of the Somerset Maugham adaptation The Painted Veil, was recruited as director. Smith's team visited numerous locations, including Eilean Donan Castle, and had a definite idea of the ones they wanted to use, though no deals could be made while uncertainty hung over the project. Smith said the film was technically a British production and it might be possible to recruit a British writer.

Anne Hogben, deputy general secretary of the Writers' Guild of Great Britain, was sceptical, pointing out that there was American money in the film.

"It would taint the whole project," she said. "It's quite a small world, the film industry."

Belle Doyle, head of the locations section at Scottish Screen, the public film agency, said: "It would have meant a significant spend and a good boost to the economy. And from a cultural point of view it's an important film for Scotland."



The full article contains 652 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 December 2007 7:55 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Scottish film
 
1

Kipling,

16/12/2007 03:11:52
This isn't the version of Mary's life where , in typical American re-writing of history, she miraculously escapes execution (a look-alike having been persuaded to take her part at the last moment), jumps on her horse, and with the help of Philip V of Spain in return for co-planning the Armada with him, retires on the Costa del Sol until her death in her late 80s?
2

Guga II,

Rockall 16/12/2007 03:35:08
If it turns out anything like the film Braveheart, it will be the usual Hollywood garbage which bears no resemblance to reality, or history.
3

Gaius,

Paisley 16/12/2007 05:36:05
So now the ignorant Scots cannie write?

We need a Yank to write the story of Scotia's brave Queen Mary Stuart.

Do we need another fantasy history episode like Braveheart? (I walked out of Gibson's ham performance.)

Americans use History and disinformation like a strange mental drug to confuse people about their own history. The Scots are confused enough: they are even thinking about divorcing England!

Viva UK! Remember we became strong when we decidd to put all our tribal squabbles behind us and go out and trade and influence the world. We were very sucessful in this strategy. Now when a thing's not broken, as the Aussies say, dont fix it!

Wake up Scots! There must be someone who can write Mary's lines who is not a foreigner!

GAIUS
4

donald,

glasgow 16/12/2007 08:11:13
I'll do it.
5

donald,

glasgow 16/12/2007 08:31:51
Mary Gives the axeman a Glesca kiss. Jumps oan the wagon, drives furiously back to Scotland, closes the Border, gives birth to Jamie the Saxth, tells him "yer no'gauin' tae London ya wee Jessie" and that's that". Jamesie in shell suit and Burberry bunnet rebuilds Hadrian's Wa' merries Annabelle Goldie and Lib Dum Jessies get deported to London. John Reid Merries Queen Liz and declares his undying love and fealty, becomes Director of the New All British English League Celtic Loyalist club. Brian Wilson becomes Director of English Nuclear bases and Windmills and Chelsea. Billy Connolly goes back to Windsor to become Court Jester with Lord Fooks.

Alex Salmond declares stealin' English coos perfectly legal and honourable.

Charlie Gordon becomes Meenister of London one way railway line. Alistair Darling tells Prince Cearlie, "At least oor Price was Bonnie but I'm still your Darling.".

London Bridge fa's dooon and Godzilla smashes up London again. Happy ending and tears all round for Tartan Army as Scots Italians put a hoarse's heid in the bed of the new England manager and donkey's tail on Gordon Broon as he loses the Republic of Fife.
6

Boy Wonder,

16/12/2007 10:11:02
#5. A plot that's not as implausible as it looks at the first readthrough. I like this. I like this a lot, Donald. Can I do the lyrics for the theme tune? :)
7

donald,

glasgow 16/12/2007 10:37:04
Yes Boy Wonder, for a small glass of Glenmorangie and providing you use your dad's computer.

You can have the sequel lyrics to the Xmas panto, Where Jack McConnell vanishes up the beanstock trying to plant a Union Jack and Wendy of the ugly Alexander sisters eats him up after turning into a giant caterpillar. She falls of and lands on all her feet with a property developer in a Barliniie striped jersey.
8

donald,

glasgow 16/12/2007 10:55:28
Good Team Wendy last looked out
On the Feast of Stephen
She turned her Party inside out
Tae keep her butt from Freezin'

Brightly shone the moon at night
Tho' the frost was cruel
Cherlie Gordon took the rap
All for London Roo - oo - el.
9

Mcsnagpile,

16/12/2007 12:04:35
It would be interesting to see what reaction there would be to a proper historical account of the life of Marie Q.S. Perhaps told be a French historian. I am sure John Knox would agree, the Scottish and English have no rights on telling the story.

Leave it to poetic Hollywood to give a more cosy, romantic account.
10

rgeg,

16/12/2007 12:17:53
Donald, brilliant, your talents are wasted here.
11

Gina Gibson,

Wales 16/12/2007 12:37:58
Donald....absolutely hilarious!

I can see the cast of Still Game in the primary roles!!
12

Reider McReid,

paisley 16/12/2007 13:39:33
re #3
gaius (or is it gallus?), some very bizarre double-think typical of 'confused' unionist thinking. you seem to think that we are only worth something if we stay 'married' to england, yet you call for 'scots' to stand up so that a 'foreigner' doesn't have to our jobs for us.
do you not see the contradictions in your posting? why do unionist see an opportunity to have an anti-independence rant in just about every article? please feel free to try and answer these questions in as coherent a manner as you can summon. i'm in the mood for another laugh after reading donald's superb postings. nice one donald.
ps. since i got my divorce and became 'independent' again i've never been so happy, content or carefree. better a divorce than an unhappy marriage, especially with the english tories looking like they are going to be our new (senior) 'partner'. want to be in their pockets like the days of maggie and major again, do you?
13

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 16/12/2007 15:21:58
Donald's take on the story certainly is original - IF I could comprehend all of the in-references to Scots and the English who are not part of my daily "reading the latest British news" experience.

But if BW approves, I will abide by his opinion. He has not gone off course but for a very, very few times - in MY opinion.

Too bad that a workable script could not be done by a knowledgeable script that would reflect the Scots version of events rather than the biased palaver that comes from the USA and England.
14

Hunky Dorey,

16/12/2007 16:22:59
Most of the Braveheart film was filmed in Co. Kildare Ireland.
15

Hunky Dorey,

16/12/2007 16:29:10
Will someone please tell the Americans that Scotland is currently under the rule of a German queen and her Greek husband and that being easily led most Scots are happy with this farcical situation. So! it is unlikely that we would want to be reminded of the fact that we were once a nation.
16

RedSwanie,

16/12/2007 16:30:59
#5 donald: Brilliant. Totally brilliant. Great script outline and with BW writing the tunes, it's a hit. "Ya wee Jessie." LOL!
17

Hunky Dorey,

16/12/2007 16:39:06
Nice one #5....... Celtic are at this time a loyalist club i.e. top loyalist John Reid being top man at Celtic So! whats new?
18

Caora Dubh,

Croit sheasgair 16/12/2007 16:46:03
Oh come on, Alba, come on! The AmerUSAns throw huge amounts of cash at projects and churn out sentimental, melodramatic kitsch, full of clichés and hackneyed, knock-kneed, wooden-legged dialogue, like that awful sugary, schmaltzy, sickening "ET" of old Steve what's-his-face. How AmerUSAns fail to understand just how bad this stuff is, is quite beyond me - the average AmerUSAn audience is obviously worse than the average AmerUSAn director. The French make incomparably better, tighter films on incomparably smaller budgets, with generally superb acting and fantastic dialogue. There is a gritty, grainy reality to much of French cinema that is foreign to Tinseltown. And Scotland can do it too! We don't need massive budgets, we don't need incredible sound effects, we don't need Scarlett Johansson or Mel Gibson. All we need is a good Scottish script writer who knows his/her history, and a good troupe of Scottish actors & actresses. If Mary isn't Scots, I refuse to go and see the film.

AmerUSAns stop hijacking other countries' history and culture! You've got more than enough of your own! What about films based on the Spanish War in Cuba, or the original AmerUSAn takeover of the Phillipines? In the former case you could bring in the fight against yellow fever, which is of extreme medical significance.
19

Guga II,

Rockall 16/12/2007 17:54:14
#8 Donald. Excellent stuff. I agree with #10 your talents are definitely wasted. Maybe the Hootsmon should be offering you a job, they could badly do with some decent writers.

#15 Phil the Greek is really only a wee bit Greek. He's mainly German. His real name is Philippos Schleswig-Holstein Soenderburg-Glucksburg.
20

Kipling,

@Doom Ray 16/12/2007 21:25:31
#5. Donald, excellent. Who gets to play Mary's wig?
21

John Blackley,

Austin, TX 17/12/2007 00:00:08
"The AmerUSAns throw huge amounts of cash at projects and churn out sentimental, melodramatic kitsch, full of clichés and hackneyed, knock-kneed, wooden-legged dialogue, like that awful sugary, schmaltzy, sickening "ET" of old Steve what's-his-face" etc., etc., etc. (continuing through unremarkable, anti-US rant.)

Yep, all true - and Scots flock to see those movies in numbers Scottish film makers can only imagine while well into their eighth pint.
22

donald,

glasgow 17/12/2007 07:13:57
#5. Donald, excellent. Who gets to play Mary's wig?
Lilly Savage.

#8 Donald. Excellent stuff. I agree with #10 your talents are definitely wasted. Maybe the Hootsmon should be offering you a job, they could badly do with some decent writers.

I'm cheap as well.
23

Frank1,

Who cares 17/12/2007 16:36:40
Lots of openminded people here...movies are movies and are rarely historically correct...if you want history got to waterstones. Hollywood isn't responsible for education.
And...Ron Harwood...the guy who took over the writing of this movie...was born in South Africa and has spent a large part of his life in London...just to correct the US bashers here.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.