Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


The road ahead – without potholes

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 November 2009
IT will be the ultimate highway to heaven – a road that doesn't have potholes, never has to close for repairs and reduces the need for time-consuming roadworks.
Engineers are working on a "forever open" design involving a new generation of road surfaces that clean and repair themselves.

Construction materials that bond together when cracks appear – already in use in some paints – are being developed to minimise the time when roads have to be shut down for costly maintenance.

New, smoother surfaces that retain anti-skid properties will allow water and detritus to drain away naturally.

The new road's green credentials are high, with a surface which collects the power of the sun's rays to re-use as solar energy. Underground heat exchangers will use the power to keep the road at a constant temperature, preventing cracks caused by water freezing and expanding. It could also supply street lights and signs with cheap energy.

Additional features include communications equipment buried below the surface for next-generation satnav, and traffic information for drivers.

Backers say the project to create what is being called "fifth generation" highways will "transform the way roads are built, designed, maintained and operated".

The new roads could cut costly damage to cars from potholes while improving drivers tempers.

The Forever Open Road project is being headed by the UK's Transport Research Laboratory and its counterparts in Europe. Development of the concept is expected to be completed by the end of next year, with detailed work continuing until 2013.

Bob Collis, director of TRL's infrastructure division, said: "The idea of self-repairing roads is based upon developing construction materials that easily bond together, such that surface cracking is minimised and the need for maintenance reduced.

"This project will bring together much of what we know already, as well as develop new research to fill in the gaps."

Engineers and scientists across Europe would be brought in to collaborate on the project. "These are early days but it is important to start thinking about future roads now, rather than wait until the demand for change is upon us."

In today's terms, the project is as revolutionary as the four previous generations of roads – tracks, Roman roads, smooth-surfaced roads and motorways. It could be adapted to different terrain and climates across the world and could be used for everything from minor roads to arterial routes.

The new roads will bring relief for motorists frustrated by gaping potholes and constant roadworks. An Automobile Association poll last week showed roadworks were the "most annoying road feature" for drivers after speed humps. The motoring group said there were some three million sets of roadworks across the UK every year, with the disruption caused costing the economy £2 billion.

Month-long major roadworks on the M8 in Glasgow are due to finish this weekend, but Scottish motorists now face the prospect of more hold-ups ahead because large sections of the country's 35-year-old motorway network are wearing out.

By contrast, the A74(M) cross-Border route, which was completed in 1995, is the closest Scotland has to the "forever open" concept.

It was privately built under the Conservatives to a higher design standard than other motorways, with the firm responsible for construction and maintenance being paid to minimise lane closures.

Motoring organisations said the Forever Open Road research programme was a step in the right direction.

Neil Greig, research and development director of the Institute of Advanced Motorists, said: "Roadworks are extremely unpopular and drivers will welcome this concept with open arms. As long as safety issues, such as skid resistance, are not compromised, the IAM can see no problem with the concept. There is no doubt that scientists may be able to solve the problem."

Philip Gomm, for the Royal Automobile Club Foundation, said: "For motorists used to potholes and roadworks, this scheme sounds great. Road engineering and design are key areas of transport policy that deserve particular attention and can deliver huge benefits in terms of keeping drivers moving, and also safety. A 'future-proof' road network is indeed an enticing prospect.

"The reality check comes in the form of the dire state of the nation's finances. Even if the expertise and technology can be developed, replacing the existing highways will take many years."

Paul Watters, head of roads policy for the Automobile Association, said: "We can probably fix the 'cables and pipes under the road problem' by putting them somewhere else, we can probably solve the road durability problems with the new, maintenance-free, and weatherproof technologies.

"However, the biggest headache will be traffic capacity and unexpected incidents."


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 November 2009 8:01 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 15/11/2009 00:34:15

The "ultimate highway to heaven" will be when the People of Edinburgh, can do their daily traveling, on our new promised tram system!, we have had enough the fear of, what road is closed next, what pothole, will granny Smith fall down next, and the rehousing of vermin in our food outlets.





2

Brianwci,

15/11/2009 00:42:50
Good to hear some good news.
3

bobbi o,

prestwick 15/11/2009 00:58:22
Dalton-your article is a lot of fabricated nonsense and the reality of the project bears no resemblance to the drivel you have written in search of a catchy headline to fill some space.

"the road without potholes" is merely a concept,which considering the government still avoids maintaining the road network we already have,will of course never be more than pie in the sky.
4

woodchopper,

Pennsylvania, USA 15/11/2009 01:05:18
We will never see it in the states. There is too much graft, political payoff and shoddy work. We spend billions every year fixing(?) the roads so that in 20 yrs we need lots of stimulas money to repair them.

5

BraveLungs,

15/11/2009 01:33:41
Will these roads also dig themselves up and install telephone cables underneath?
6

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 15/11/2009 03:04:59
Black Ops engineers are working on project Moledroid to lay cables and paranoid surveillance gadjetry, BL.

When roads are well made as they generally do in France, they last decades and decades with modest maintenance. How unbritish!

The Maggon and his Tonniness had this London "vision" of an LA by the sea without the sunshine. Literate people would call this a dystopia. Or dispepsia?
7

truthsleuth,

15/11/2009 03:26:44
Most of the damage caused to road surfaces is caused by heavy goods vehicles. The amount of wear(damage) to a road surface is proportional to the fourth power of the axle load of the vehicle as a minimum.

Taking the weight of a car as 2 ton produces an axle load of 1t.

The axle load of a large goods vehicle is typically

7t+7t+9t+ 7t+7t+7t = 44t

But road wear is the Fourth power of axle load

So compared with the car the first axle of the lorry does (7) to the fourth power more than the car. ie 7x7x7x7 times more = 2400 times more but that is just one axle of the lorry. Total damage by each axle is

2,400*5 + 6600 = 18000 times more than the car.

But thats not all

Your average motorist does 10,000 miles per year the average long distance lorry 100,000 ie ten times more than the car.
Damage by the Heavy lorry is therefore ten times the previous figure ie 10x18000= 180,000 times morec than the car.

But thats not all

Have you ever noticed how certain sections of road where heavy lorries accelerate or break suffer from 'rutting' (if you have not have a look at bus stops) this is aggregation of the extra tearing and compression forces exerted on the flexible surface that a road is.

This damage will increase even further total damage done to the road by the heavy brigade.

Now these figures assume fully loaded vehicles but of course we all know overloading and uneven loading is rife on UK roads so to be more than fair we can assume the heavy lorry does 100,000 times more damage than your average car. No wonder the Forth Bridge is in need of repair.

Now take a look at how much your tax disc costs and compare that to the heavy lorry.
8

Abel Magwitch,

15/11/2009 04:26:54
Fascinating possibility.

That past master of the future, H.G.Wells, predicted something like this over 100 years ago, in "The Sleeper Awakes". The road material of the future was known as eadhamite after its inventor, but Wells did not give us the recipe.

Presumably the aggregate will be bonded by some sort of polymer which would need to be better than asphalt, though not necessarily cheaper.
9

Mallory,

Edinburgh 15/11/2009 05:29:42
Just wait till the Holyrood mob get salivating about the tax raising prospects. This from an AFP report:

The Dutch government said Friday it wants to introduce a "green" road tax by the kilometre from 2012 aimed at cutting carbon dioxide emissions by 10 percent and halving congestion.

"Each vehicle will be equipped with a GPS device that tracks how many kilometres are driven and when and where. This data will be then be sent to a collection agency that will send out the bill," the transport ministry said in a statement.

Ownership and sales taxes, about a quarter of the cost of a new car, will be scrapped and replaced by the "price per kilometre" system aimed at cutting the Netherlands' carbon dioxide emissions by 10 percent.

"Traffic jams will be halved and it helps the environment," the ministry said.

Dutch motorists driving a standard family saloon will be charged 3 euro cents per kilometre (seven US cents per mile) in 2012. That would increase to 6.7 cents (16 US cents per mile) in 2018, according to the proposed law.

Don't understand why they need a GPS record apart from surveillance. What's wrong with an accurate odometer?
10

Hmm ...,

15/11/2009 07:12:58
... good point there, Mallory. But in fairness to the Dutch, the EU is determined to introduce GPS-based road charging - to help justify the EU's Galileo sagtellite system that it just had to have to compete with the USA's satellite system and now needs a use for, a use which will help pay the operating costs of the system (and the development of which the UK has paid hand over fist).

The EU has been running experiments to see what approach will make road charging most electorally palatable - Edinburgh's road charging system received funding under this project!

Of course, the Trots now embedded as officials in Edinburgh's town hall were only too happy to promote any impediment to car travel, regardless of the significantly heavier damage dome to roads and the environment by buses and trucks, just as Labour's refusal to maintain the roads we have has increased demand for this "heaven-sent" road surfacing.

And we used to talk of poor surfaces as being Belgian pave - now European car manufacturers use the UK to develop car suspension systems!
11

UserNameTaken,

Edinburgh 15/11/2009 07:29:23
>>Bob Collis, director of TRL's infrastructure division, said: "The idea of self-repairing roads is based upon developing construction materials that easily bond together, such that surface cracking is minimised and the need for maintenance reduced.

"This project will bring together much of what we know already, as well as develop new research to fill in the gaps."

Snigger
12

eric,

lothian 15/11/2009 08:14:02
Wish we had a Subway system like Glasgow,we will never see that.
13

Iron Soul,

bemused 15/11/2009 08:14:50
Strange drivel this - musy have been a good nightat the Club for someone....
so PRIVATELY FINANCED ROADS are more durable than publicly funded? Could this be because motorways tend not to have utilities and services beneath them? Or does someone have an Agenda?
Perhaps a 'possession' scheme whereby the diggers must work to a pre-approved timetable, and pay compensation for violations of these permits, would work. Network Rail has such a system, available now.
14

dieselted,

Picton 15/11/2009 08:21:58
Those who know have been speaking about turning old tyres into road surfacing for a lot of years, now that might be good if it come to pass, is it the oil company's thats stuffing up that as well.
15

Awoingt,

15/11/2009 08:25:09
"the ultimate highway to heaven"

It already exists and its called Copland Road :o)

Follow! Follow!
16

Rob Royston,

Africa 15/11/2009 08:25:23
The best roads are made from iron or from water. Britain used to be a world leader when it had good railroads and coastal shipping services.

The heavy goods truck has its uses, but is used for tasks that could be much cheaper, for the tax-payer that is, not the clients, if more use was made of the rail and coastal routes.

An independent Scotland would do well to develop its shipping routes, centered on the proposed Scapa Flow container transhipment terminal in Orkney, and on it's internal rail routes
17

Alice Cooper,

15/11/2009 08:53:42
scotland under brown---- Highway to hell
scotland free of bigots and loonies----- highway to heaven
you votes for your choice
funny how the smell of sulpher is prefered to fresh air
18

It's life but not as we know it,

The Oort Clouds 15/11/2009 09:36:46
If we get rid of road works what will become of the poor Irish?
19

Expat in Amsterdam,

15/11/2009 10:05:23
"There is no doubt that scientists may be able to solve the problem"

"No doubt" and "may" is a strange combination. There is no doubt I may win the lottery, but how likely is that?

This "Road Tax per mile", as measured by GPS is expensive and unnecessary. What is wrong with the simple concept of putting road tax on the price of fuel? The more you drive, or the heavier your vehicle, the more road tax you pay.

The pay-per-mile concept is Big Brother at it again!
20

Alice Cooper,

15/11/2009 10:09:37
18 yes what will become of those poor people
wont someone think of the irish
21

Pa broon,

Edinburgh 15/11/2009 10:56:19
I don't think this will ever come to be. If it does it will be double the price that's initially indicated. A bit like the Edinburgh tram Scheme.
22

scully,

Colchester Essex 15/11/2009 10:58:57
That is Brilliant. BUT? will the Government allow it. that will save money, But it will also put all road repair gangs out of work, then what about the transport minister, will he be out of work. Anything that saves money or spoils peoples enjoyment the Government ban, except their expenses.
23

Radical Mac,

The Kingdom 15/11/2009 11:14:42
Self repairing roads a great idea. No potholes but I assume the stupid road humps to replace the potholes will remain. Installed to keep councillors in post and look as though they are doing something. Edinburgh however wont need these roads as their aim is to stop anyone driving in Edinburgh and trade to cease for the shops. The first tram set has been completed in Spain but will be tested in Croydon due to the snail like progress in Edinburgh. Glad I dont live there anymore.
24

Abesaidwhat,

Minnesota 15/11/2009 11:32:04
Skewed, biased, wilfully ignorant and just a little disappointing.
25

Expat in Amsterdam,

15/11/2009 12:43:38
We should learn from Isaac Asimov. Build moving roads, so we can all travel, by foot, at speed.
No cars, no crashes, nobody run over. GPS / mileage based road tax per person would be a breeze, then.

OK, it's a zany idea.

Make vehicles greener, and put road tax in the fuel price.
26

Mallory,

Edinburgh 15/11/2009 13:33:20
Think you mean Robert Heinlein Expat - The Roads Must Roll.

Better idea than the trams....
27

Griffe,

15/11/2009 14:02:26
When its ready for launching we won't be able to afford it. This is like pharmaceutical firms constantly bringing out new and improved drugs that the NHS cannot afford to prescribe. Why does anyone bother?
28

Expat in Amsterdam,

15/11/2009 15:22:30
26 Mallory.

I stand corrected (blush!). (I KNEW that, dammit!)

Actually, on reflection, it's not a bad idea.
Thanks
29

letmeout,

15/11/2009 15:34:15
Just stop the heavy goods lorries coming in to town. Stop at an out of town area and spew out their load int smaller vans for distribution. These huge trucks are a nightmare in the UK. We do not have roads for them. The one size suits all containers are ruining our roads. They also go at 60 mph everywhere. I have never seen a lorry being stopped for speeding. They are the scourge of the country.
Rant over ;-)
30

mr broon,

Edinburgh 15/11/2009 16:43:36
"The A74(M) cross-Border route, which was completed in 1995 is the closest to the "forever open" concept in Scotland"?

"Forty years after it was first planned, the final length of the A74(M) was completed in 1999(and not 1995 as stated) and at present there is relatively very little structural maintenance required compared to other Scottish motorways. However, only 10 years after finally being completed, programmed structural maintenance of the A74(M) carriageway is already beginning to take place and will inevitably increase each year causing more and more delays."

(Source: Construction News)
31

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 15/11/2009 19:40:01
The EU is by no means the faceless org demonised. It is an association of nation-states, and most large scale projects are completed to time, budget and standard. Unlike here you can meet your local mayor or councillor personally and get some sense out of him/her wherether by formal means or in a pub, or sports club or professional society.

NATO is the can of worms now run by vicious war criminals who choose to meet in Edinburgh rather than face the more hostile popular reception they'd get in mainland Europe. Edinburgh flat on her back as per usual.
32

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 15/11/2009 20:57:10
The "smooth road" technology has already been used for several years although not, I believe, on trunk roads which suffer the most from heavy goods vehicles. Although it is generally effective in letting water run off quickly, there is a very serious problem when the temperature of the road surface drops below freezing point. Any rain will freeze instantly and the resultant black ice is just about the most slippery surface known to mankind.

As the worst damage to roads occurs after a heavy freeze, surely these boffins should be looking at ways of mitigating frost damage?
33

weeshooie1,

Wollongong 15/11/2009 23:07:04
How about a wee bit of humour:

Laughter is to life what shock
absorbers are to automobiles.
It won't take the potholes out of
the road, but it sure makes the
ride smoother
34

Mad Jock,

Offshore Denamrk 16/11/2009 07:49:01
25 Expat in Amsterdam, you were correct the first time, Isaac Asimov wrote of moving walkways, "the strips" in his Science Fiction detective novel, "The Caves of Steel".
I am probably more embarassed for knowing that. I read it in 1973.....
35

Iain MS,

Newcastle 16/11/2009 11:59:06
I still can't get over the fact that speed bumps were voted the most irritating thing to motorists. Was Jeremy Clarkson not included in the list?
36

jazzmann,

leicester 16/11/2009 13:25:53
WOW !!!! I wonder who in this paper has been digging in the archives ? or is 10+ year old technology just reaching the boondocks of Edinburgh ?
Now here`s a scoop for them if thats the case .
Caterpiller the makers of earthmovers etc are using a paint that you can hit with a hammer or chisel and it binds itself by molicules so no corrosion occurs.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.