Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Migrants find new life in Scotland is just the job

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 December 2007
WHEN Magdalena Szpilczynska came to live in Edinburgh three years ago, she had a part-time job in a restaurant.
Now she is running her own chain of delicatessens stocked with traditional food and drink from her native Poland.

The 34-year-old had struggled to even find work at home before deciding to move to Scotland. But she managed to set up her business f
rom scratch in only three months after spotting a gap in the market in the city.

She is not alone. Her Polski Smak chain has since been joined by a growing number of Polish businesses to have opened in Scotland.

And a new report has revealed she is a classic example of the kind of immigrant to have settled in Scotland in recent years.

The accession countries that joined the European Union in May 2004 – dubbed the EU8 – included the Czech Republic, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland and Slovenia.

A new study on the influx of immigrant workers into Edinburgh since then has given an intriguing insight into what kind of people are flocking here from overseas.

According to research carried out on behalf of the Scottish Government, they are mostly aged 18 to 34, have left their home country for economic reasons and have almost certainly found employment of some kind. Almost half were employed in the hospitality or catering sectors.

More than half of those surveyed said they specifically came to live in Edinburgh, with one in three being inspired by having either friends or family living in the city.

About a quarter of migrants who took part in the research said they wanted to settle permanently. Two-thirds said they had managed to secure accommodation in Edinburgh in advance, and almost all were living in private rented accommodation.

It is thought up to 10,000 people have arrived in Edinburgh from EU8 countries in the past three years.

The report found 85 per cent of EU8 migrants in Edinburgh were Polish, with those from the Czech Republic making up the next highest proportion, at 3.8 per cent.

The report states: "The vast majority of EU8 migrants in Edinburgh have been successful in finding work and in securing their own accommodation. The city council has been quick to welcome new citizens as their economic and cultural contribution benefits the whole community."

Ms Szpilczynska, a mathematics graduate, said: "There's no doubt it was work which brought me here. It was difficult to find a job in Poland, but I had also been to Edinburgh before and knew what a beautiful city it was. I was very keen to come back.

"At the time I came here, it was relatively easy to find accommodation as well, although I know it is a lot more difficult now. I was working in an Italian restaurant when I had the idea for the shop and it was actually pretty easy to start it up."

A spokeswoman for the city council said: "All the evidence gathered so far suggests many EU8 migrants are single, young, healthy, well-educated, economically active and rely relatively less on public services than indigenous communities.

"The vast majority of migrants are in employment and are successful in finding accommodation in the city through the private sector. Only a very small minority have experienced homelessness and evidence indicates that they are no more likely to become homeless than Edinburgh's existing population."

Tom Buchanan, the council's economic development leader, said: "Edinburgh welcomes all its new citizens, wherever they come from, since their economic and cultural contribution benefits the whole community.

"In economic terms, the net contribution of migrant workers to the city is overwhelmingly positive.

"Migrant workers are generally low users of public services. As well as contributing to Edinburgh's continuing economic growth through filling key labour and skills shortages, they also pay council tax, national insurance and income tax."

The influx of Eastern European people into Scotland is said to have helped boost direct air links to cities such as Warsaw and Gdansk, while Catholic churches have witnessed a surge in visitors.

After English, Polish is now the main language spoken in almost a third of Scotland's council areas.



The full article contains 704 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 20 December 2007 10:21 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Immigration and refugees
 
1

Scythia,

Glasgow 21/12/2007 02:03:41
The migrant is in direct competition with our young people for a finite number of jobs.

Studies have shown that the young and those seeking entry level jobs are being displaced by the ultra-motivated migrant ( who is being paid 5 times the Polish minimum wage).

In Scotland we have an increasingly serious problem with NEETs, estimated at 20,000. There isn't a level playing field here. If you offered the NEET the opportunity to work in a foreign land at 25 pound/hour they would probably jump at it with zeal.

As a taxpayer,and for society as a whole , it would be better if the playing field was levelled to allow NEETs a fair crack. That means employers must become more responsible and politicians need to shape employment law accordingly.

At the end of the day, it is the taxpayer that is picking up the financial and social tab for the NEETs through social security, social disorder etc.

The economy would benefit more too, as the wages earned stay in the Scottish economy and not send abroad as is currently the case.

In 2011 , Germany and France must allow free access to their labour markets. By then most of the Poles will be heading there.

Lets take the long term solution and start putting our own house in order now, before inviting here today, gone tomorrow migrants.

2

Incandescent,

21/12/2007 02:42:48
For those who don't know, "NEET" stands for: Not in Education, Employment or Training.
3

John Blackley,

Austin, TX 21/12/2007 03:31:24
A certain type of economic migrant will always succeed in their adopted country (in my experience because I am one). They are motivated, generally intelligent and generally add to the quality of life in their adopted (however temporarily) countries.

As for those who claim that the immigrant population is squeezing the indigenous population out of jobs, I would ask: Were these jobs not available before the immigrants came and, if they were, why were they not filled with, for example NEETS?
4

Scythia,

Glasgow 21/12/2007 04:47:09
Research comes from Ernst & Young ITEM club.

"Since 2004, the number of unemployed British 18 to 24 year olds has increased by 100,000, according to the study. "There is some evidence that the growth of immigrant employment seen in the last few years may have come at the expense of the domestic workforce," the report concludes"

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/global/main.jhtml?xml=/global/2007/12/18/noindex/nmigrants118.xml
5

Yokel,

21/12/2007 05:19:06
Well done Magda! We need all the truely motivated folk we can get. For those that don't know NEET is mistranslation of NEAP
6

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 21/12/2007 08:40:48
Scottish inborn 'Apathy' is this our problem?
7

scunnin,

Ex-pat overseas 21/12/2007 08:55:30
Its very interesting how we say such things about people who come to scotland and are successful. Lets swap this around for a minute, where I live there are 60,000 Japanese which is the largest colony outside Japan. They have their own area of the city etc, we Scots also have quite a few in the country I live in. If we have a gap in our economy, wheres the problem in someone filling it who is not from Scotland?

I am thankful the country I am living in has accepted me and allowed me to work here, not that I couldnt live back in Scotland. If you come to different European Countries, you will see Irish Pubs all over, you will see shops selling British things too ... we Ex-pats regard those things as a part of home and are glad for them. So lets look to these people from other European countries as a benefit to our community rather than a hindrance.
8

Mike S,

21/12/2007 09:14:41
#1 Who else is going to contribute to subsidise the indigenous NEETs' benefits but the incoming tax paying workers?
9

Boy Wonder,

21/12/2007 09:19:55
#7 RbnR ... why should the Poles change the spelling of their names? It's the pronunciation that matters! Your comment of how the names look, smacks of racism to me.

Here are 50 of the most common Polish surnames; NOWAK / KOWALSKI / WISNIEWSKI / DABROWSKI / PAWLAK / KAMINSKI / WALCZAK / KOWALCZYK / GORSKI / ZIELINSKI / RUTKOWSKI / SYMANSKI / OSTROWSKI / WOZNIAK / DUDA / KOZLOWSKI / TOMASZEWSKI / WOJCIECHOWSKI / JASINSKI / KWIATKOWSKI / ZAWADZKI / KACZMAREK / CHMIELEWSKI / PIOTROWSKI / BORKOWSKI / GRABOWSKI / CZARNECKI / NOWAKOWSKI / SAWICKI / PAWLOWSKI / SOKOLOWSKI / MICHALSKI / MACIEJEWSKI / NOWICKI / SZCZEPANSKI / ADAMCZYK / KUCHARSKI / DUDEK / KALINOWSKI / ZAJAC / WYSOCKI / WIECZOREK / ADAMSKI / JABLONSKI / SOBCZAK /
KRÓL / CZERWINSKI / MAJEWSKI / OLSZEWSKI / JAWORSKI

Where's the difficulty in them? I grew up with several first generation Poles in the 70s. One of my best mates has more end of the alphabet letters involved in his name than our middle of the alphabet ones. But so what? They were born in Scotland, and they are Scots, regardless of where their parents came from. Their names are easy to pronounce as yours or mine.

I suggest the problem is yours, rather than anyone else's.

Read the article and you'll find they're not the spongers you and people like you think thay are!

10

Paul Voltaire,

21/12/2007 09:22:01
Scottish folk can be awfully lazy and there are many who play the welfare system to never work.
Well done these folk from Poland.
They are grafters.
I had two Polish builders do some work for me. They charged half what the Scottish builders had quoted and never wasted a minute and did a quality job.
More power to them.
11

gus1940,

Edinburgh 21/12/2007 09:36:02
Well done Magdalena
12

Robb,

21/12/2007 10:11:19
The main reason there are so many NEETS is that they are too lazy, unmotivated, and in many cases uneducated. The fact that they lack motivation to get up off their a*ses and do a days work is not the fault of the motivated Eastern Europeans who come here to work. I suspect that if the benefit culture existed in other countries, perhaps their native population would be less motivated to work, however, as the UK Government seems to be the only one to spoon feed those who are too lazy to work, they have created an apathetic, benefit scrounging element of the population who will spend a large part of their lives (if not all of it) living on benefits, happy in the knowledge that the taxpayers will pick up the tab. They could learn a lot from Magdelena and those like her.
13

Partan,

Fife 21/12/2007 10:12:55
#11 BW
Have exactly the same experience as your good self.
A fair number of the men who worked in the pits here had other trades and skills but were prepared to take the work that was available at the time. Some of their sons are my friends and are as Scottish as I am.
14

Partan,

waking up 21/12/2007 10:14:55
Oops, I meant the Polish men, of course.
15

W Smith,

Middle East 21/12/2007 10:24:54
Well done Magdalena.

While some Scottish men embrace victimhood and the whisky bottle, this Polish lassie kicks ass!

Give it another 15 to 20 years and half the millionaires in Scotland might have Polish or other Eastern European surnames.
16

McMicrogal,

21/12/2007 10:42:17
To all you moaning whingers, where do you think our lovely Valvonna and Crolla came from? Hard working Italian immigrants that's where!

Good on you Magda, may you carry on to be Poland's answer to V&C, our city can only be the richer for it.
17

Why can't I use my usual name?,

Glasgow 21/12/2007 10:44:01
#1, you are right that there has been a marginal impact on NEETs (et al) but I think that most studies also conclude that the benefits have outweighed the costs. You seem only to be looking at one side of the argument.

Your questions about our own NEETs are relevant but this once the influx of Poles, etc. slackens off (as it will, if not has), we will have a larger economy with more oppoprtunities for NEETs and everyone else. As the article notes, Poles generally come here to take existing jobs but they also create new ones through increased demand, new businesses, etc.
18

Why can't I use my usual name?,

Glasgow 21/12/2007 11:16:09
With regard to our own NEETs, trying to force employers to thole them (instead of recruiting Poles, etc.) is not a very satisfactory solution.

What's needed is "tough love", I would suggest. State support without return shouldn't be an option: (almost) everyone can contribute something, and there's plenty to be done. More supported employment schemes ("intermeidiate labour markets") could be tried - doing something useful is important for individuals mental health and self-confidence, as well as their long-term career propspects. It also helps stop them getting up to mischief. And there's plenty environmental and social projects that could be done without displacing 'real jobs'.

Paying people not to work might seem soft but it's allowing too many to rot away - after a couple of years on the sick you're actually more likely to die (usually early) than find another job. That's not very compassionate!
19

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 21/12/2007 11:42:01
I agree with Boy Wonder that there will always be an undercurrent of racism and xenophobia in newsitems of this sort but then it may only be an indicator of a segment of the Scots population that is of a certain age group, educational level, or social background.

And those Polish surnames are certainly NOT hard to pronounce even if you have to take a second or TWo to phonetically sort them out.

It would seem that some Scots are ignorant, stubborn, and insular to a fault.
20

Silence of the Yams,

21/12/2007 11:51:16
When I cam out my office two nights ago (Baillie Gifford building next to the Omni centre) I came upon a huddled group of Polish Jakeys downing the fortified wine. I know I must be 'ignorant, stubborn, and insular to a fault' not approve of these people, but who is paying for these types? One of them started shouting in that peculiar dialect. Bring back the iron curtain!
21

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 21/12/2007 14:23:40
#2 And when you have been a NEET for a very long time they promote you to a NED.
22

Boy Wonder,

21/12/2007 14:36:39
#29. And just how do you draw THAT conclusion about Polish Humour from my comment? I can't see it! And I'll have you know the Poles I know are WAY funnier than you'll ever be! You're just a plonker, aren't you?
23

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 21/12/2007 14:42:36
The incomers are not the problem for the NEETS. It is their own laziness thats the problem. An overly generous welfare state has allowed a culture of intergenerational idleness to take hold. So of these NEETS are third generation benefits scroungers. What happens when time are tough and jobs are difficult to find the ones with some gumption go where the work is. While spineless just just moan their way between benefit payments.
24

\seasider,

Saltcoats 21/12/2007 15:01:02
#31 & others.
Better I think with 5 hard working Poles than 100 local junkies. What about a exchange scheme with Poland, 5 of our junkies for one polish grafter. much better deal for the economy. Again a enforced working holiday in Poland for our miscreants might be better and cheaper than the current community service orders.
25

The Daleks,

21/12/2007 17:55:07
Some totally deluded posings from the usual clueless turkeys voting for an early Xmas.

Are you really so blind, not to see what mass unchecked immigration really means for our small country?

The Bruce and the Wallace must be birlin so fast in their graves that we could shut down the nuclear power stations and tap into them instead.
26

Martyk,

sussex 21/12/2007 18:12:54
Seems to me these Poles will likely be paying the benefits of the lazy creatures who your heart bleeds for. Why couldnt your useless neets do these jobs then?
27

Martin 2,

Edinburgh 21/12/2007 22:10:53
Look around and see who is serving you in most city centre bars and hotels over Xmas - hard working people who have come to Edinburgh to work. I am sorry for those "NEETS" who are not working but you( in most cases) have had far more opportunities in life being born in Scotland and you have not taken them.

Some of the comments about Polish people drinking are just stupid - are we Scots temperance society folks??

How many British older ex-pats receive great health treatment in Spain - thats what the EU is all about - free access and travel for all EU citizens in al countries. People should be thankful that Scotland is seen as an attractive option.
28

weeshooie1,

Australia 22/12/2007 21:37:19
BW #31,

G'day Bdub, Must agree with the sense of humour, I mean, look at 'Pole' dancin', thats quirky :o)
29

weeshooie1,

Australia 22/12/2007 21:40:06
Ooh! Nearly forgot, on behalf of all those who pass comments on these pages "Merry Christmas to all our readers" :o)

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.