Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


T in the Park

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

MPs claim cuts to disabled services are a breach of human rights



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 18 March 2008
A SCOTTISH city council is facing the threat of legal action over controversial plans to axe services to vulnerable and disabled people as part of a £27 million package of budget cuts.
Frank Doran, the Labour MP for Aberdeen North, yesterday claimed that Aberdeen City Council had breached disability legislation following its decision to withdraw £650,000 in funding to Glencraft, a local factory which employs blind and disabled work
ers.

The management of the Glencraft factory have warned they have been left with no choice but to close the plant with the loss of 56 jobs following the council's "cruel" decision.

A local charity, the Choices More group, also claims it could be forced to close a day centre for the disabled in Westburn Road as a result of the cuts.

Mr Doran said: "Under disability legislation, public authorities have a number of legal responsibilities when making decisions which affect disabled people. These include a duty to consult particularly service users, to prepare and consider an impact assessment on any decisions which may affect disabled people, and to apply its own statutory disability equality scheme.

"None of these things were done by Aberdeen City Council and consequently, the decisions made at the council meetings are unlawful."

Mr Doran claimed: "The council has failed to meet its legal obligations to disabled people in Aberdeen. I have been asked by my constituents to write to Aberdeen City Council and point out the breaches in the law which have occurred, and to advise the council that legal proceedings will be commenced against the council for judicial review and possible interdict to prevent the cuts being implemented.

"I have also been asked to contact the Equality and Human Rights Commission and report the failings of Aberdeen City Council."

He added: "There is a great deal of anger at the way in which the council has acted and many of the disabled people affected by the council's decisions are deeply upset and distressed at the way they have been treated.

"This is a very vulnerable group and many depend on the services from the council to give them a reasonable quality of life. But there is also a real sense that disabled people need to fight back against a council which seems to have no respect for them and has ridden roughshod over their rights."

Anne Begg, the Labour MP for Aberdeen South, backed the claims and said: "Under the Disability Discrimination Act 2005, Aberdeen City Council has a duty to consider the effects of their policies on disabled people and to involve disabled people in decisions which affect their lives.

"The council has done none of these things. It is a dereliction of their duty and is causing a huge amount of distress.

Responding to the claims, Douglas Paterson, the chief executive of the city council, said: "At this point we believe that we have followed due process and, more importantly, that we are making every effort to ensure the wellbeing of our citizens as we work to bring budgets closer to our grant allocation and to spending patterns in other local authorities."





The full article contains 531 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 March 2008 11:13 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Furchrissake,

18/03/2008 00:44:37
Two dead beat, soon-to-be-ex labour mps jumping on the bandwagon for a last gasp at seeing their name in the papers.

Lets see your expenses claims Frank and Anne
2

truthsleuth,

18/03/2008 01:36:36
There are many if not most disabled who struggle against their disability and quietly achieve the respect and admiration of us 'able' bodied lot.
The problem now is that the disabled taleban who with one hand say they should be treated the same as everyone else then in the next breath have lifts built in stations costing hundreds of thousands of pounds and as a result put the construction of many new rail stations out of the question and so all have to suffer for the diabled. This 'equality' is NOT equality its the rule of the masses by a selfish louud mouthed terrorist minority out to make sure if they have to suffer so should everybody else.

PS I think Aberdeen is jusifying the description applied to Aberdonians in this particular example.
3

Furchrissake,

18/03/2008 01:52:06
I would agree with your last comment if it wasn't for the fact that they're happy to spend lots of taxpayers money on super-duper arts complex.
4

Grahamski,

Falkirk 18/03/2008 05:48:57
Oh dear oh dear, the disabled are terrorists now are they? Still, these posts give us a glimpse of our future if we're stupid enough to support the SNP....
5

Pilrig.,

Livingston 18/03/2008 06:23:32
"Disabled Taleban" ? and I thought I'd heard everything !

Perhaps those born as less than perfect specimens should be left oot on hillsides afterbirth, I mean we wouldn't want them to be a burden on the taxpayer !
6

A Better Way,

Edinburgh 18/03/2008 08:04:57
The Libdems and Tories are certainly showing their true colours on this one if it is true. We all know the Hootsman and the BBC delete anything that could hurt a British Party. Like the latest polls on how the Big Man Alex is plus 57% in popularity and trust by the Scottish People while the Criminal Wendy is languishing down at 22%. She and Brown are deadlabour walking. If Brown is relected at the next Election then 20% more Scots will vote for Independance. If Cameron wins then 25% more Scots will vote for Independance.

I reckon we should be allowed to vote for both of them. Then we are sure to be on our way. By the Way Cameron has said or done nothing and now leads Brown by 13%. Brown has done nothing of any substance since he got the PM's Job by default. Lets face it he was never elected by the People for that Job. He certainly knows how to bankrupt a country, actually he is one of the best we have seen.
7

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 18/03/2008 09:10:43
Well this is NEW Labour in a nutshell eh?
They want to introduce an armed forces day in order to fool us in to believing they want to honour our soldiers and then they want to bring in policy which will adversely affect the seriously wounded from Iraq and Afganistan the ones you never see in the news the blinded and those with missing limbs.
Makes you proud to be British.
8

CLX,

Way Up North 18/03/2008 09:30:19
Does it not make sense to merge two half full schools into one full one to save money on heating etc?
And as far as I know the pool due for closing, beautifull as it is, doesn't get used by enough people to make it viable. The people of Aberdeen, of which I am one, have themselves to blame for a lot of this by deciding to drive to the likes of Dundee to use their facilities.
The same goes for Glencraft. This work place will only succeed like any other business if they make a profit. Why support a loss making business?
Don't get me wrong, I think Glencraft is a superb idea but who actually keeps an eye on the financial side of things and could it be run better?

As far as Doran is concerned, I cannot come up with one positive idea that he brought to the table in his time representing Aberdeen.
9

,

18/03/2008 09:49:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

,

18/03/2008 09:52:12
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Jeeemy,

St Andrews 18/03/2008 09:56:16
CLX, Way Up North#
Have you checked up on Doran, he is a product of the Dundee Labour party just like “Gorgeous George”? Like all they are very busy trying to get into the press and on the box; pontificating on this and that, could it be that there may be an election in the offing?
Or is it just that I have become a cynic in watching the antic’s of the labour party over the past 60 years.
In the 50’s they lied and did much double dealing, to-day they lie and break the law at every opportunity with gay abandon (Wendy). When the law does not show them in a good light they then return to the courts to have the coroners gagged (Browne); ineptitude at best corrupt at worst.
12

joppa jock,

Huntingdon 18/03/2008 10:11:48
#2 Your comments are unbelievable! You display all the characteristics of the sort of person who will spitefully park in the disabled slot in your local supermarket while using your Granny's badge. Remember that all disablement is physical, you appear to be suffering from a mental disorder and would advise you to seek help as soon as you can to prevent you from making a complete and utter fool of yourself again.
13

joppa jock,

Huntingdon 18/03/2008 10:13:13
Stupid mistake on my part....it should have read all disablement is NOT physical.
14

CLX,

Way Up North 18/03/2008 10:32:46
#13, Jeeemy
Couldn't have put it better myself.
Inept, double dealing, self promoting, totally useless, all words to describe George and Rank.
I also like how Begg has brought in the disbled slant to the plight of the Labour party in Aberdeen rather than the affected.
15

Jimmy the Pie,

18/03/2008 12:05:40
Dorran and Begg know their days are numbered. I just hope it is soon.
16

Number 6,

Germany 18/03/2008 12:13:55
Keep it up Labour. Shout shout , protest protest yes yes, under you things would be much better eh ? On your bikes you wasters.
17

Derick fae Yell,

the fluhoose 18/03/2008 13:27:50
And thus we'd rant and gull the crowd
And spout the people's woe
In the days when we were radicals
A short time ago

fae memory = original is in 'Radical Renfrew'


Labour - gies me da dry boak

18

YooHoo!!!!,

18/03/2008 13:45:49
And there we have it - labour mps stooping to using the disabled to get their faces on telly and names in the paper. Who'd have thought it.
19

Huntly loon,

Aberdeenshire 18/03/2008 15:59:19
The city of Aberdeen has one of the highest Council Tax and lowest central Government grant of any local authority. The current problems must have been building up for years so for Labour to point the finger of blame at the present Libdem/SNP administration is hypocritical. The SNP should have stayed out of power in Aberdeen as it is looking like a poison chalice. I think the election of the two far too young SNP siblings was unfortunate. Youth is not an asset over experience of life when it comes to the dirty war of local politics. Hard choices need to be made by those with a long view and years of decision making. Not for those still in job-training. All it has done is given the Unionist parties a stick to hit the SNP with.
20

OscarMacApfel,

Dumfries 18/03/2008 17:47:19
This is appalling they could like get a fine and shitt.
21

John Blackley,

Florida 18/03/2008 19:36:43
The quality(?) of political opinion on this site is stunning (in the meanest sense of the word).

Two Labour Party MP's make what seems to be a reasoned argument on behalf of Aberdeen's disabled and they get insulted for doing so?

Classy.
22

OscarMacApfel,

Dumfries 18/03/2008 19:45:41
Mr B, given that the charity and the two Labour MPs are given an extraordinary amount of space to express their views in the article, it takes on the appearance of a churnalistic press release.
23

poststalker,

18/03/2008 21:20:39
During the years that Labour ran Aberdeen City Council, neither of these dead beat mps complained once - that's NOT ONCE.
24

Matt there,

somewhere 18/03/2008 22:45:34
And of course, Mr Doran is equally outraged about Gordon Brown's decision to close down all the Remploy factories.

What's that? Mr Doran has said nothing about this? He isn't insisting that Mr Brown might be breaking the Disability Discrimination Act?

Hypocrite! Nose in trough! Morals in gutter. Ladies and gentlemen, I give you the perfect Labour MP.
25

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands, Scotland 18/03/2008 22:47:54
In an ideal world we would have facilities for all forms of disablement but the world is not ideal and the pockets of the councils are not endless.

As a society we are at least trying but the though of thousands of pounds being wasted in legal wrangles about closing a factory for the disabled is just stupid.

I also agree that the waste supporting AFC on consultation in a total joke.

Was it wrong to laugh about the disabled taleban as I also felt this was a valid point if slightly harsh.
26

Pilrig.,

Livingston 18/03/2008 23:16:34
27 - valid point my backside. The guy is an idiot.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.