Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Liberal Democrat leader Scott calls on Nationalists to cut 2p from income tax

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 September 2008
ALL Scots should receive an immediate 2p income tax cut, according to the new leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats, Tavish Scott.
Speaking at his party's conference, Scott will call on the SNP Government to use the existing powers of the Scottish Parliament, which allows MSPs to vary the tax rate by 3p in the pound.

The 2p cut would represent an annual saving of £330 to the
average Scottish taxpayer; money which, Scott says, families need as the credit crunch begins to bite this winter.

He is now calling on the other parties in the parliament to back his plan, insisting funds can be found through cutbacks and savings within the Scottish Government's budget.

Scott's call is the first time since devolution that a leader of one of the major parties has supported using the tax-varying powers. The SNP backed an increase in the rate prior to the 1999 election – the so-called penny for Scotland – but none of the parties has ever proposed a tax cut.

A spokesman for Scott said: "Families across Scotland are having to make savings to help their family budgets because of the economic situation. If that is what families have to do then the Government should do the same."

As to how the plan would be funded, the spokesman said: "The challenge to other parties is to work with Tavish in order to find savings so that they can make a 2p cut using the Scottish Parliament's current powers."

Scott was elected leader of the Lib Dems in Scotland two weeks ago. His radical call for an income tax cut comes amid warnings that the Lib Dems have been crowded out in Scottish politics, after they decided to reject a coalition with the SNP last year.

The Lib Dems estimate that a 2p income tax cut would cost in the region of £400m a year. The Scottish Government's budget is £30bn a year.

But the SNP Government gave a cool response to Scott's proposal. A source close Alex Salmond said: "It's only a couple of years since the Liberal Democrats were calling for an increase in income tax when the standard rate was higher. Now they are calling for an income tax cut.

"The biggest items of Scottish Government expenditure are health and education and the hard question for Tavish Scott is to answer is where the cuts will be. The Scottish Government has already frozen the council tax and cut business rates."

Meanwhile, the UK party leader, Nick Clegg, said yesterday that the Liberal Democrats are the only alternative to a Labour Government in its "death throes" and Conservative "cowboys".

Clegg kicked off his first annual conference as leader with a stinging assault on the major parties.

He faces a fight in Bournemouth this week to win the support of left-leaning activists for a pledge to slash public spending by £20bn and for 'big' tax cuts.

But he will tell them his "blueprint for a freer, fairer Britain" is the only way to show the Lib Dems understand voters' concerns during the present economic slowdown.

Talking to reporters as another Labour MP called for Prime Minister Gordon Brown to face a challenge, Clegg said: "We are watching the death throes of the Labour Party."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 September 2008 11:24 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Senga Jean,

14/09/2008 09:18:51
Sad that Tavish Scott and the Lib/Dems are so confused about the economy. The SNP Government are still suffering from the lib/dem decision to waste much needed money on trams. All the claptrap about "Bwoken pwomises" ignores the fact the SNP do not have an overall majority and therefore petty schemes from other parties drain their core policies of funds.
2

suchaparcelofrogues,

Scotland 14/09/2008 09:19:57
Strange to see a British national party pushing for independent Scottish political policy.
Do they have an overall "British" agenda and if not are the "Scottish Lib Dems" no longer a part of the "British Lib Dems"?
3

Calum10,

14/09/2008 09:25:15
No one will buy into this nonsense when the same Tavish Scott argued just two weeks a go that the Scottish government should be providing more funds to improve public services.

Lets not forget too that for the 8 years when the LibDems were in power they argued specifically against using tax varying powers.

This is all about shoring up the LibDems vote in marginal areas where they have to compete with the Tories. The Tories have called for a cut in Council Tax, now the LibDems are calling for a cut in Income Tax.

Marginal politics by marginal politicians.
4

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 14/09/2008 09:25:28
The normally anonymous Lib-Dems have made a mischievous proposal!
5

GM,

14/09/2008 09:28:06
@8

and I'd love to see there faces if Alex announced tomorrow -

"great idea and with your support it shouldn't be an issue. What date do you want the cut from"?


6

suchaparcelofrogues,

Scotland 14/09/2008 09:30:39
What the Lib Dums are suggesting is in fact Thatchers poll tax policy in reverse.
When Thatcher introduced the poll tax into Scotland a year before introducing it into England.
They are in fact illuminating just another gigantic flaw in devolution.
Unless the rest of the UK can vary their tax rates by 3p in the pound its daft to allow a part of the UK to do so on its own if youre a unionist that is.
Suits me but then I am a Scot Nat.
They aint called the Lib dums for nothing then.
7

suchaparcelofrogues,

Scotland 14/09/2008 09:34:01
6

Right enough we have the Tories calling for tax cuts.
This is the same tories who gave us the Poll Tax, VAT, PFI etc in fact 22 brand new taxes under Thatcher alone.
8

suchaparcelofrogues,

Scotland 14/09/2008 09:40:06
5

Youre the one picking pointless fights how can you argue on one hand that LIT will cause a tax hole and then argue it isnt a local tax cut?
Your not a Lib Dum as well by any chance?
The SNP LIT proposal is to add 3p to income tax and abolish the council tax. The suggestion is now to then take off 2p on income tax as well so in effect only have an LIT of 1p in the pound.
I reckon we should put for unionism see stupidy in the dictionary.
9

donald,

glasgow 14/09/2008 09:51:36
That can only be done under Independence and our own Treasury.
10

Ugly George,

edinburgh 14/09/2008 10:59:46
whether you are a nationalist, an agnostic or a unionist there is a real problem connected to this which has to be addressed. Scotland has very high levels of public spending. Can this be maintained? The Barnett formula appears to be doomed and North Sea oil/gas production is forecast to fall by 10% per annum in future years. Both of the crutches that do or could sustain this expenditure have limited futures. What is going to be the postion in 5-10 years time whether or not Scotland is still part of the UK?
11

Tynietiger,

14/09/2008 11:05:49
SNP is effectively cutting Income Tax by 2% by introducing LIT at 3%.

Suggest Fib Dems just support that....
12

Ugly George,

Edinburgh 14/09/2008 11:10:54
15 Tynietiger
The polcy of LIT is one of replacing one tax with another. It is not a cut in the overall tax burden. It therefore does not deal with the point I raised in post 14.
13

Itchy,

14/09/2008 11:11:29
A tax cut would be nice.

I won't bet my house on it happening but it would be welcome.
14

subrosa,

14/09/2008 11:17:55
I see Lavish Tavish wanted in the headlines so he thought up another silly idea.
15

Coileach an taobh Tuath,

14/09/2008 15:30:14


Is Tavish now saying that the 3p rate for LIT is infact the right amount.?



16

suchaparcelofrogues,

Scotland 14/09/2008 15:42:19
14 16

Ugly George I am getting the impression youre either clueless or just predudice. Who says Scotland has high levels of public spending and relative to who?
this statement is only made by those with a political axe to grind and has never ever been substanciated by any reliably untained sourse.
To say LIT is not a tax cut shows a level of complete ignorance on the subject strangely prevelant on these blogs. By keeping all other tax levels the same and changing from council tax to LIT then there is a most definate tax cut unless your living in a garden shed and earning in excess of 50K a year especially when you consider a continuation of council tax will mean a tax level reveiw to reflect the present cost of housing. You are already 4% better off than you would have been had any other party won the elections.
Now either learn some facts or learn objectivity before you post again.
17

suchaparcelofrogues,

Scotland 14/09/2008 15:45:10
14

Who is forcasting the fall in NS oil revenue? the same sourse which failed to forcast the huge oil price increaces I wonder?
18

Alan B,

15/09/2008 10:24:02
#Ugly George

LIT is a tax cut over all.

However I agree with you overall point. Scotland must address the economic failures and underperformance which have burdened us under union rule.

19

Doh,

15/09/2008 20:46:38


That last time Tavish spoke, he called for help for the building industry and homebuyers.

So I do wonder if this tax cut is actually just common chatter at Holyrood - i.e. it being at least thought baout by the SNP - after all - according to the right,
if you cut taxes you get more growth.

Not convinced by that argument myself.

But I do support a switch in our taxation, from council tax to LIT and if possible reducing income tax and increasing green taxes. All good ideas but I hope taxation doesnt become a dirty word. Something you do by stealth, like Labour. That would be a shame.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.