Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


T in the Park

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Happy birthday, Nessie – the legend lives on



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 November 2008
SWATHED in mist, the grainy image depicts the brooding water of Loch Ness and captures the exact moment the Nessie legend was born.
It is 75 years since the mysterious shape was first photographed and more than 1,000 people have been spurred on by the iconic picture, claiming to have caught a glimpse of the world's most elusive monster.

References to a creature in Loch Ness date back to St Columba's biography in 565, but the myth only took hold in the modern era after reports of a strange object and then a series of inexplicable photographs appeared in the press during the 1930s.

It was this picture, snapped by Hugh Gray on 12 November, 1933, that is credited as being the first photographic evidence of the Loch Ness monster.

Adrian Shine, designer of the Loch Ness Exhibition, has led many scientific studies to the depths of the loch but has not found evidence of a monster.

"In terms of starting the trail of classic photos from the 1930s to the late 1950s, it was the first," he said. "But it is very difficult to interpret. Some have speculated that it was a double exposure of a Labrador with a stick."

Over the years, local rumours reinforced ancient Scottish myths about water creatures called "kelpies" and the "each uisge", or water horse.

In the 1930s, talk of the monster reached fever pitch and Nessie-hunting took hold after a string of sightings. It was reported that circus impresario Bertram Mills offered £20,000 to anyone who could capture the monster for his circus, sparking international interest.

In 1933, a newspaper hired a big-game hunter, Marmaduke Wetherell, to track down the monster and he claimed to have uncovered its enormous footprints by the banks of the loch. However, researchers from London's Natural History Museum declared the tracks fakes.

Nessie was in the news again after a smudgy photograph was apparently taken by a London surgeon, Colonel Robert Wilson, purporting to show a slender head and neck rising out of the water. Published in 1934, the "surgeon's photo" became an international sensation and was for decades the best evidence of the presence of a sea monster.

But in 1994, the truth finally emerged when Christian Spurling, 90, Mr Wetherell's stepson, confessed to his part in a plot involving both Col Wilson and Mr Wetherell to fake the "surgeon's photo" using a toy submarine fitted with a sea-serpent's head.

After the advent of colour photography, Nessie photographs stopped appearing.

A ten-year project to analyse the surface of the loch in the 1960s turned up no evidence of a monster. But sonar expeditions and the hi-tech 1987 Operation Deepscan reported several unidentified moving objects.

The appeal of Nessie is as strong as ever, with tourists heading to the loch as part of a multimillion-pound industry.

A spokeswoman for VisitScotland said those early pictures of Nessie had captured the imagination of thousands of visitors and contributed to the enduring phenomenon.

"Nessie still has a lot of appeal," she said. "The first picture had a kind of snowball effect in terms of the myth.

"These photographs put a solid image in people's minds."

Loch bids for World Heritage status

A CAMPAIGN to secure World Heritage status for Loch Ness was launched yesterday.

While Nessie, the world-famous monster, may be its top draw, it is the loch's other attractions – particularly the outstanding natural beauty of its landscape – that are being used to spearhead the campaign.

The independent tourism group Destination Loch Ness (DLN) wants Britain's largest area of fresh water designated a World Heritage Site by Unesco.

If approved, Loch Ness would join 162 sites across the world that are on the World Heritage Committee's list because of their outstanding universal value. These include the Great Barrier Reef, the Rocky Mountains, the Grand Canyon, the Galapagos Islands and St Kilda.

Yesterday, at a special briefing on the shores of the loch, it was revealed that DLN had recruited Professor Terry Stevens, who has managed three World Heritage Sites, and View Marketing, a leading consultant, to provide strategic advice to the campaign and secure support, funding and sponsorship.

Independent research, commissioned by DLN earlier this year, found that, if successful, the bid for World Heritage status would result in an estimated economic boost for the area of £25 million over the first three years, and create up to 300 full-time jobs.

Have you seen Nessie? Send your stories to enquiries@thescotsman.com

The full article contains 759 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 November 2008 12:00 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Loch Ness Monster
 
1

S. A. C.,

Edinburgh 13/11/2008 01:22:32
Sadly, there have been too many hoaxes that have damaged Nessie. It is not too hard to believe there may be 'monsters' in the Loch, yes, I said 'MONSTERS'.
It is highly likely to have been a Plesiosaur, as the waters in that area are what they liked, I say this because in New Zealand, you cant move for Plesiosaur bones, which can and have and still are being found around the area, but what is more interesting is a carcus that was caught by a japanese fishing vessel, the Zuiyo Maru in April of 1977, goto www.Gennet.org for the pictures, and see what you think, after all the coelacanth fish was thought to have been extinct for around 400 million years, and yet is very much alive and kicking, untouched by evolution.
So the fact's are, Nessie, may very well be alive and kicking to, after all if the coelacanth can all of a sudden prove everybody was wrong then why not a Plesiosaur, it's not too far fetched.
2

Warden An' All, Reborn,

13/11/2008 03:41:58
I thought this was a link to "Salmond dives in with underwater power link to Europe" my mistake, and yet I think a picture of Eck above the fire would keep the kids away.
3

Guga II,

Rockall 13/11/2008 05:53:26
#2.

You have as much sense as those people that believe in monsters.
4

Limey,

USA 13/11/2008 06:24:00
What about all those people that believe in God and as far as I know no one has ever photographed him or her.No one ever questions their sanity, but once we concern ourselves with the existence of possible monsters which may have been photographed then we are accused of being senseless....It's a strange world all right and I think Nessie is wise to keep his down and stay out of site whenever possible !
5

Steve Evans,

Malta 13/11/2008 06:38:28
Nothing like a good Scottish mystery, but if there is a monster or not, the area is still an outstanding streach of beauty with plenty of myths and legends to keep one interested and a good reason to spend a couple of hours at the great Dores Inn.
6

donald,

glasgow 13/11/2008 06:49:38
Nessie lives. The Jelly Bean does not exist. It is an English myth.
7

voltaire's janny,

13/11/2008 09:03:30
That picture is me in the bath.....
8

voltaire's janny,

13/11/2008 09:10:35
#4 you are wrong; I question the sanity of religious believers. There is no god, yet the vast majority of the population conduct at least part of their lives as if there were. I cannot ascribe "insanity" to so many people, not least because there is no credible definition of that term, but I am in no doubt that the more avid practitioners throughout the ages, and today in many places are indeed raving loonies.

In the UK and much of the West (but not the US) religious delusion has morphed like a benign infection to a general fellowship of concern, jumble sales and singing songs - harmless and occasionally beneficial. However anyone who believes the literal teachings of any of the poisonous God-of-Abraham cults is as mentally unstable as any wearer of straight-jackets.
9

Lianachan,

Highlands 13/11/2008 09:20:52
Adamnan's Life of St Columba's description of the encounter with the monster was written a long time after it was supposed to have happened, and by somebody who wasn't there. It is just one of many occassions when Columba is described as banishing a monster. There is no "myth" - there is no historical validity to that notion at all. Outside of the original reference, there's no mention of a monster until the 1930's. That's 1,500 years with nothing, during which time any actual myth would have been well attested in song, oral tradition or writing.
10

Boy Wonder,

13/11/2008 09:21:09
Nessie is alive and well and when not making public appearances, is living with Charles Linskaill!
11

Lianachan,

Highlands 13/11/2008 09:26:21
Most "Celtic" religions greatly venerated water, and water spirits, and there's no reason to suppose the Picts were any different. What Adamnan was doing when he wrote about Columba banishing a strange aquatic creature (in the river, by the way, not the loch) is pretty simple. He was trying to say that his christ is more powerful than the native, traditional gods, that christianity is stronger than the then existing religion of the Picts in the area. "Look, your gods do what my god tells them" kind of thing.
12

Dr. James Wilkie,

Vienna 13/11/2008 09:36:51
When I am asked by foreigners about the monster, I reply tht Nessie's existence is certain, because she appears every year punctually at the start of the tourist season.

As for Loch Ness as a world heritage site, what does it have apart from Urquhart Castle and Nessie? All that the visitor sees from the road is a featureless wooded hillside on the other bank and equally monotonous open water. Loch Lomond, Loch Maree and Loch Morar have far more attractive features, to say nothing of numerous Scottish fjords. I am as patriotic as any true Scot, but I have seen a bit of the world, and I am all for keeping things in perspective.

13

Lianachan,

Highlands 13/11/2008 09:45:14
#1 The plesiosaur theory doesn't work, for several reasons. The wikipedia article about Nessie briefly explains a few of them.
14

Lianachan,

Highlands 13/11/2008 09:50:49
#13 Loch Ness also has Fort Augustus, with the old fort, the abbey, the caledonian canal, etc.. The loch is the largest body of fresh water in the UK, noteworthy in itself, and is of outstanding beauty - especially if you take its banks into consideration, with the Falls of Foyers and suchlike.
15

AJ Fife,

13/11/2008 09:56:52
Angus Von Vooterman-Crawford, the famous Nessie hunter, seems to be convinced of the famous monster's existence. From his converted WW2 U-boat, he claims to have had several 'close encounters' with Nessie.

Why do people think the whole Nessie thing is made up?
16

Warden An' All, Reborn,

13/11/2008 10:03:09
3-Guga II- Would that be the sense of touch, sight, smell, taste, or sound?
17

Lianachan,

Highlands 13/11/2008 10:12:49
#16 Why do people think the whole Nessie thing is made up?

Well, the original reported sighting (which was in the river, not the loch) is easily explained - I scratched the surface of it in #10 and #12. After that sighting, there is nothing at all until the 1930's. Nothing. Hee-haw. This is in a country and culture with a rich folklore, and a veritable menagerie of weird beasties. If there really had been something there in the (near enough) 1,500 years between the first two reported sightings, we'd have some sort of tradition associated with it.
18

AJ Fife,

13/11/2008 10:25:24
#18,

Well, Mr Von Vooterman-Crawford reckons his periscope was bitten off by a giant swimming dragon in 1963! He even has a three foot dinosaur tooth, which had penetrated the upper conning tower, as proof!

Surely that can't be made up?
19

Lianachan,

Highlands 13/11/2008 10:34:37
#19 Well, I've never heard of Von Vooterman-Crawford (and a google search finds no matches) so I can't comment specifically about it, and it would be unfair to immediately dismiss it out of hand. However, some general things spring to mind. Has this tooth been analysed, is probably the first and most important question. If so, who analysed it, what did they find, etc.. Also, he can't be that famous a Nessie hunter if I've never heard of him, and can't find him on the internet.
20

Lochiel,

West o'Glasgow 13/11/2008 10:40:40
Am I missing something?

This story has nothing to do with Obama at all.
21

AJ Fife,

13/11/2008 10:56:01
Lianachan,

Is your computer working properly? Never heard of Von Vooterman-Crawford?

Jings and crivens man, where have you been?

Vooterman-Crawford is not only famous for the 'Nessie bites periscope' incident, but he's also a character plucked out of my imagination. :)

Sorry you wasted time looking for Angus Vooterman-Crawford on the internet! :)



22

daveserviceman,

edinburgh 13/11/2008 10:57:57
It realy is alec Salmond swimming on his back, the monster myth is a story put out by the SNP to frighten unionists
23

Lianachan,

Highlands 13/11/2008 11:04:24
#22 Good stuff. I didn't waste much time - it was immediately clear that if the guy existed, which didn't seem likely, he was an obvious charlatan.

:-)
24

AJ Fife,

13/11/2008 11:12:56
#24,

He's on the internet now!! :)
25

Rabhairt,

Cannons Creek Downunder 13/11/2008 11:28:01
#2 why do you waste your time, you should be reading Donald Duck comics, as far as Nessie goes if it does exist or did at some time then it would be in a deep loch, also everal times a year fishermen at sea bring up some strange large fish never seen before so on that basis anything is possible, one big problem with mankind is that we think we know everything.
26

DirtyDeeds,

13/11/2008 12:11:14
Boleskine House, now there's a nice place to visit in Inverness.

"Sanine*, or the Master Therion"

27

Travis,

Chciago 13/11/2008 13:14:44
No. 27

Kilts are a load of nonsense.

Are you kidding? Ya just gone to far now! I would venture to say a kilt does more for a women's heart then a tight pair of Levi's. A what the hell does that have to do with the Loch Ness monster?
28

westview,

going north 13/11/2008 13:27:04
If this kind of story offsets Browns banking disaster ,by increasing tourist jobs then it is no bad thing.
29

john z,

edinburgh 13/11/2008 14:20:49
My advice to anyone in doubt, come to Scotland in 2009, for the homecoming, and you can visit Loch Ness and see for yourself. Maybe visit a few distilleries too.

Who knows, you might be the first person to get a good picture in recent years.....

For those abroad who don't know, Loch Ness is huge, with more fresh water than all the lakes of England and Wales combined.

As far as a monster or creature is concerned, I like to keep my options open. There is after all, no definitive proof that it doesn't exist, and Loch Ness really is very, very deep. Maybe some kind of creature, not necessarily a 'monster with humps', previously existed but has now died out??
30

Joanna,

13/11/2008 14:50:01
Is there a monster in Loch Ness?

Maybe yes, maybe no.
31

Uilleam,

Alexandria 13/11/2008 14:50:31
Llanachan - There actually is an oral tradition in Gaelic related to "Nessie" - just not necessarily as a prehistoric "monster", and not limited to Loch Ness (or the river). Ronald Black wrote a lengthy article on this some time ago (I think in the West Highland Free Press, not The Scotsman).

This time, you may be able to find it on the Internet. :)

And as you suggest in No. 12, Black suggests the "monsters" of so many Highland lochs and rivers originally were river spirits or river/water deities, appearing in times of danger or as an ill-omen of disaster to come. They weren't something anyone actually wanted to see ...

The whole "Loch Ness monster" craze with its dinosaur theories (as amusing as it may be) is an example of what happens when one culture picks a thread from another without keeping or knowing the original contejavascript:__doPostBack('wctlAddComment1$ctl00$btnPost','')xt ...
32

Uilleam,

Alexandria 13/11/2008 14:53:36

Ronald Black's article on Niseag was published in 1999 in the The Quern-Dust Calendar feature of the West Highland Free Press ... anyone interested in the subject should read it - if they can get a hold of a copy.
33

Dadya Davey,

Simferopol 13/11/2008 16:10:01
I have a perfectly logical explanation about why Nessie is so infrequently photographed. This is a very sensitive and somewhat shy dragon, particularly shy when there are skeptics about. This may be an appropriate time to publish my photo...probably the latest evidence that Nessie really exists. http://thumb14.webshots.net/t/26/27/7/26/79/370872679SuLyRQ_th.jpg Hope you like it :-)
34

Dadya Davey,

Simferopol 13/11/2008 16:16:21
Sorry I sent the stupid thumbnail Lets try this photo again...HAPPY BIRTHDAY NESSIE! [URL=http://entertainment.webshots.com/photo/1370872679048703034SuLyRQ][IMG]http://inlinethumb04.webshots.com/44419/1370872679048703034S600x600Q85.jpg[/IMG][/URL]
35

Dadya Davey,

Simferopol 13/11/2008 16:28:01
Sorreeeee! This will get you the FULL sized photo. Say "Cheese" Nessie! http://entertainment.webshots.com/photo/1370872679048703034SuLyRQ
36

MattyMat,

Cali 13/11/2008 17:50:38
Has any scientist or institution ever studied what this creature could possibly survive on?? It stands to reason this Nessie would have to eat tons of "fish-seals-birds-whatever?" and would eventually show itself in some fashion. Is this Loch repeatedly being stocked with giant sea bass, or large fresh water tuna in order to satisfy Nessie's huge appetite-- and we're just not being told about it by the authorities???

I'm skeptical at best.... but like Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny and Jesus--- it's good for the kids.
37

Madbagpypr,

STEORNABHAGH,LEODHAS,NA h-EILEAN SIAR 13/11/2008 18:04:18
Took my wife to the Loch once on the way to Ft William. I saw a stick....Mind you, it was a really BIG stick.
38

Haggis MacBagpipes,

Central Canada - ex Perth & Glesca' 13/11/2008 19:42:51
#11 - Boy Wonder.

You might well be right but I can't see 'Nessie' putting up with all the drivel that "Chuckles" comes out with and like me 'Nessie' probably believes that 'Chuckles' is a 'few bricks short of a load' or 'a few sandwiches short of a picnic' and 'his lift (elevator) doesn't go all the way to the top.'

As I haven't yet seen 'Chuckles' post today, perhaps he has gone to Loch Ness to chat with his friend!
Better to live in hope than die in despair!
Cheers,
Haggis MacBagpipes™©
39

Ileach,

13/11/2008 19:49:41
Diana Gabaldon, in her first book "Outlander", I believe, describes Nessie as a "time-traveller". The heroine of the book has herself come from modern times to before the '45, and meets Nessie on her way back home. The natives all immediately think she is a witch. If there is a time-portal below the Loch somewhere, who knows where Nessie is keeping herself these days! Seriously, though, I saw the movie "The Waterhorse" and am, of course, convinced that Nessie exists.
40

weeshooie1,

Wollongong 13/11/2008 20:19:20
H.M.B. #43,

:0) x 10
41

Lanna,

14/11/2008 05:31:14
Hey Weeshooie,
..don't you go encouraging the natives, now... ;)

42

LammermuirCollectables,

Scotland 14/11/2008 11:06:56
Yes, it's a pity about the 1934 "surgeon's photo" being a fake, because, like "Area 51" in the US, there's certainly something going on, the problem is just getting good photographs of it!

Visitors to Loch Ness are on the increase and certainly our wee Nessies are going strong. Of course Loch Ness should be a World Heritage Site !

For those not fortunate to be able to visit Loch Ness there is a live webcam which I always like to refer to readers from overseas. So ... after waiting a while, you can look for the LOch Ness monster at this site: http://www.lochness.co.uk/livecam/

Remember, it's UK time, so you won't see anything during the dark ! :smiles:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.