Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Fears of 16-month delay as tram firm says it warned of hold-ups

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 February 2009
EDINBURGH'S £512 million tram scheme was facing further problems last night after it emerged completion of the project could be pushed back until November 2012 – 16 months later than expected.
The German construction firm at the centre of the row told The Scotsman it had repeatedly warned officials since last year that delays to earlier parts of the project would set back its schedule.

Sources close to the project claim that Bilfinge
r Berger, the firm heading up the consortium building the tram line infrastructure, has demanded an extra 70 weeks to finish its contract.

The company said it had warned Tie, the city council tram firm, "many times" of major delays to a separate contract to move underground pipes and cables. This utilities diversion work, being carried out by a separate company, is required before construction can start.

Bilfinger Berger has been under fire from politicians, business leaders and retailers over claims it is looking for £80 million more, on top of the consortium's £240 million fixed contract agreed last May.

However, the firm denied the £80 million figure or that it had asked for an extra 70 weeks for the contract.

A spokesman said: "For months and months, we've been urging the client to speed things up because we saw the delay coming. We have to work strictly to the agreed conditions in the contract. Conditions are not as they are in the contract.

"Preparation (utility diversion] work was not finished. Many times we told them there was a delay. Tie was aware we would not start until all the contractual agreements had been reached."

A spokesman for Tie said: "We are currently engaged in ongoing discussions over the terms of the contract signed by the consortium."

The new revelations raised the stakes in the row triggered on Friday when Tie and the council announced the eleventh-hour call-off of work on Princes Street because of "unacceptable" demands for extra money from the consortium.

Graham Birse, deputy chief executive of Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce, said the council had taken the "right stance" over the contract row, but said a quick decision was needed over whether to keep the Princes Street measures in place.

There was relief yesterday that the introduction of a host of diversions to accommodate the closure of Princes Street from Saturday had gone smoothly.

However, the capital's main business organisation gave the local authority a ten-day ultimatum to resolve the wrangle.

Nationalist MSPs have demanded the roadworks, which involve traffic being diverted on to George Street and Queen Street, be lifted from today to prevent further disruption to retailers. But the council is insisting arrangements remain in place until the middle of next month.

More than 4,000 people were yesterday said to have visited a mock-up tram which has arrived on Princes Street.

The council also released figures which it said showed "footfall" figures for key parts of the city centre had increased over the weekend compared to the average over the last four weeks.





Page 1 of 1

 
1

Andrew,

24/02/2009 00:21:25
I wonder why the expression 'Jerry-built' instantly springs to mind?
2

Son of Gramsci,

Edina 24/02/2009 00:33:27
If they are saying November 2012 now, then it could end up being 2013 or even 2014.

"The council also released figures which it said showed "footfall" figures for key parts of the city centre had increased over the weekend compared to the average over the last four weeks."

Great, lets do something random and unwise every weekend, and bring visitors flocking in. New moto for Edinburgh tourism "come to Edinburgh, where random acts of public autorities are a weekly event."

3

Navvy,

24/02/2009 01:48:49
Total utter incomtetence at both the City Council and Holyrood. Somewhere there has been a dereliction of duty tantamount to criminality. Were it anywhere other than Scotland i would expect to see heads rolling AND prosecution AND a complete change of both local and central government. Gut alas, I expect simply an increase in tax and the cost of living in Edinburgh combined with congestion dirt and pollution.

Elsewhere in the world contracts are tight and such delays and cost increases do not happen. Look to Asia and HongKong and Singapore in particular. Much of their rapid transport was designed, supervised and built by Brits including many Scotsso why can we not do the same at home.

Welcome to third world Scotland
4

Letters From Muscat,

edinburgh 24/02/2009 02:09:27
Sorry, don't want the TRAMS don't want to pay more council tax for the 'TRAMS' WANT TO SEE THA ACTUAL CONTRACT. iN NICE SIMPLE ENGISH and if it was not so late I might be able to type proper!
Forget the trams don't buy anymore trams, How much bribery and corruption is going on behind the flaming scenes? That would make quite an interesting story Hootsmon! TIE ? tie up the city in knots you mean...... Give the trams idea the elbow. Tell me where is the money going to come from? Thin Air? And don't get me started on the Banking fiasco.....
5

Hmm ...,

24/02/2009 02:40:20
... this sorry saga just gets longer and dearer. And the Gogar utility diversion work is now running eight months late!

A further delay fo 16 months will have a dramatic effect on the stores' ability to continue in business during this recession and the additional inflation will increase the eventual price again.

Yet Jenny Dawes is encouraged that "by the end of today, around 4,000 people will have visited the mock-up of the tram outside Jenners."

Sure you aren't missing the point, Jenny?

I should think that this German construction company simply can't believe the ineptness they are seeing in tie/Edinburgh City Council.

Its time this abortive project was simply cancelled if only to face up to te reality that tie and the City Council have been wasting our money on this unnecessary and ill-planned project for coming up for five years now!
6

Hmm ...,

24/02/2009 02:44:19
... news so good they had to tell it twice! Well, it will certainly help fill the pages!
7

fife runner,

24/02/2009 06:53:30
dalays caused by utilities companies? surely not.

It only took Scottish water 5 years to find my mains water pipe outside my house and put a new valve in. Perhaps instead of castigating the tram company read the article.
8

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 24/02/2009 07:44:18
It "tramatic" times in Edinburgh.

SNP blamed for allowing Labour to give trams go ahead.

Salmond at fault for Labours folly.

Sturgeon Blamed for German Contractors.

Ach, why not?.....
9

sam the god,

24/02/2009 08:19:50
ha ha ha just what you would have expected #1 jerry built usually mean good workmanship
10

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 24/02/2009 09:09:16
The people of Edinburgh should get used to less traffic on Princes Street?

In the not too distant future, with the exception of buses, taxis and trams, the Council hopes to make Princes Street a Continental-style pedestrian zone.
11

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 24/02/2009 09:33:37
#1 - I believe the phrase 'Jerry Built' derives from Biblical references to 'Jericho', where the walls came tumbling down. German construction and engineering is, by contrast, world-renowned. I, with many others on these posts, warned TIE & the Council of the complexity of Utilities in Leith Walk and Princes Street, in particular, as far back as mid-2007. I even discused the issue with Andrew Picken of the EEN who was being stonewalled with happy-clappy press releases by the Suits and PR Bimbo's in TIE. They just laughed these concerns off but I bet they're not laughing this morning.
12

Leila,

Edinburgh 24/02/2009 09:36:25
I was adding to the footfall in Princes Street on Saturday, really just to see what was going on. And how depressing it was. Pedestrians are being penned in by high metal barriers and if that's bad enough now, wait until it gets to summer and see how unpleasant a combination of high barriers, major roadworks and summer heat will be. I certainly won't be going there - I'll be going to the Gyle or Fort Kinnaird instead.
13

Sarah B,

Edinburgh 24/02/2009 10:11:22
(10) - That'll be interesting. Pedestrians will be pinned against the wall by the new 6-lane transport superhighway!
14

GrahamH,

Edinburgh 24/02/2009 10:40:12
Who can forget "Comical Ali" in Iraq, the information minister who was high on propaganda, saying all was in control and Iraq would win, whilst could see USA tanks just behind him.

Do you think Jenny Dawes took some training from him?
15

Gdgy,

24/02/2009 14:44:07
Why can't they get anything right in Edinburgh...
the delay and inconvienence when visiting Edinburgh may be troublesome BUT all the whinging and whining by the locals is utterly unbearable.....BUt it what they do best....
16

Breezy,

Argyll 24/02/2009 15:41:45
#9
"Jerry-built", which the OED defines as ''Built unsubstantially of bad materials,'' and is said to have arisen in Liverpool. It has been fancifully derived from the Biblical city of Jericho, whose walls came tumbling down.
"Jerry" as British slang for "a German, especially a German soldier" is not attested until 1898 and is unconnected with "jerry-built".
Never the less, it defines your brain perfectly.
17

AJ Fife,

24/02/2009 15:48:13
The Jerry contractor should be reminded of the fact that the first 'kill' of the Second World War took place in the skies over the Firth of Forth, when a Luftwaffe bomber 'copped' it.

That might just get the message over loud and clear!!




 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.