Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Beekeepers on alert as deadly disease found in Scots hives

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 July 2009
BELEAGUERED beekeepers are witnessing an outbreak of a devastating disease that is spreading through Scotland.
European foulbrood – a bacterium that infests bee larvae – has taken hold in Perthshire and Angus, and experts fear Fife and Aberdeenshire are also at risk.

Already about 100 hives have been burned due to infection by the deadly bacteria, which ca
n be spotted by its distinctive rotten-fish smell.

It is the latest problem to beset beekeepers in Scotland, who have already struggled to cope with a series of wet summers, and infestations of varroa mite.

Gavin Ramsay, bee diseases convener for the Scottish Beekeeping Association, said the European foulbrood outbreak was "potentially devastating".

He added that it was the "biggest bee health issue to affect beekeeping in Scotland in recent years".

"It looked like this was going to be a better year, but this has turned that on its head," he said.

The loss of the hives could have a serious impact on the livelihoods of commercial beekeepers, and also on the availability of Scottish honey.

The bacteria, which kill bee larvae by colonising their guts, was first spotted by a commercial beekeeper in Alyth, near Perth, earlier this month. As a result 85 bee hives were burned.

However, Mr Ramsay thinks the disease has probably been present for years and has previously gone undetected.

"The hope was it was an isolated case. In Scotland it's something that appears from time to time every few years," he said. "However, what seems to have happened here is that it has got a grip, at least in the operation of these commercial beekeepers, and they haven't realised it has become widespread."

Inspectors will now check about 5,000 colonies near the infected area in the hope of destroying the bacteria.

In all severe cases the bees are killed and the hive burned. In milder cases the problem can be treated with antibiotics.

Due to the scale of the problem, inspectors will be unable to check all hives before the end of the season.

"It's not going to be possible for the current team of inspectors to get on top of it before the season ends," said Mr Ramsay. "So it's certainly going to be here next year."

Experts are warning beekeepers not to bring their hives into infected areas. They fear it will have spread to commercial hives that have been moved close to heather for the summer in particular.

Heather is also used by amateur beekeepers, meaning their bees could be put at risk.

The disease is spread via contaminated equipment, or by bees that steal honey from hives with colonies weakened by the bacteria.

It can be difficult to spot in early stages, when adults bees are still plentiful enough to clean away the dead larvae.

However, as more larvae die and the colony weakens, the hive becomes littered with dead specimens and the sour, rotting smell is produced.

Nigel Hurst, editor of Scottish Beekeeper magazine, said: "On top of all the other problems this has the potential to be very, very serious.

"It has already affected commercial beekeepers and if the infection is too bad the hives have to be destroyed."

It is not known how European foulbrood first arrived in Scotland. There have been occasional cases since the 1960s.

However, beekeepers are worried that the increased use of bees from overseas could be increasing the susceptibility of disease.

Interest in keeping bees has rocketed in the UK in recent years. As a result, keeping up with the demand for bees has posed difficulties for suppliers, leading to the use of insects from overseas.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 24 July 2009 12:12 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 24/07/2009 08:57:22
Two points are correctly made in this article about how infections such as European foul brood are spread from from colony to colony.

One is by importing bees from distant lands, the second is by moving colonies to the heather.

Both are done with the aim of increasing the profit of bee-keepers, both imperil the biosecurity of the bees.

The terrible scourge of the varroa mite was spread around the world by the same practises of bee-keepers.

Yet still it goes on. There is no legislation to prevent or regulate the importation of bees into the UK or the movement of bees within the UK.

These diseases are the equivalent of foot and mouth in cattle or swine fever in pigs. Yet nothing is done to control their spread and bee-keepers will be bringing their foul-brood infected bees into uninfected heather country in a few weeks time, in the hope of making more money in the process. Curse them!

Migratory and importing bee-keepers are the worst enemies of the honey bee.
2

Dave Scott,

Broughty Ferry 24/07/2009 09:12:45
Slioch - I'm with you on this one.

Fancy trying to mobilise a bit and get a petition to present to the Scottish government for better bee care in Scotland?
3

Fi,

24/07/2009 15:21:42
Right with both 1 and 2.

If we had the kind of controls New Zealand has for importing anything alive, our ecosystem would be in far better shape. The Japanese knotweed is a case in point, another imported species, and the suggested answer is to import another species to kill it.
4

cazm,

Inverness 24/07/2009 16:29:26
I think you'll find a lot of beekeepers in agreement with you on this one. We need to concentrate our effort on looking after local bees and breeding healthy bees, not just shipping them in from anywhere. If the govenment recognised their importance and spent some decent money on the bee inspectors we could sort this. After the money they threw at FMD and now at Avian Influenza, its time they spent money on honey bees. They class them as livestock so treat them as such and get some import/export constraints in place!
5

Dave Scott,

Broughty Ferry 24/07/2009 21:57:09
Right, now there are four of us - what are we going to do about it?

Anyone know how to do one of these e-mail petition things that sends back to the originator after every 100 or so 'signings'?
6

sniffmykipper,

Stirling 25/07/2009 01:13:44
LOL. Gee you guys need a dose of facts. Bee imports ARE heavily regulated, and if you don't believe me then just try to get yourself permission to do so.
I also have it on good authority that this story has no connection to imports, and is in NATIVE stock.
But hey guys, who wants facts to get in the way of a hobby horse on the charge!
7

Dave Scott,

Broughty Ferry 25/07/2009 01:38:09
Kipper - don't get all 'ironic' or patronising on us but thanks for the wake-up call.
Hardly a 'charge' since the wording hasn't been decided yet but are you saying that a petition to Holyrood would be a bad idea? Don't see DEFRA doing much other than blowing a few million on a fudge paper.
Even if it is a native problem better bee care is best for us all - got it, there's the slogan 'bee careful or buzz off'.
8

anti kipper,

Glasgow 25/07/2009 12:05:43
Kipper
Who's side are you on? The quesstion is not whether imports are regulated - the question is whether imports should be allowed at all!
Regarding your defence of the import situation and by default your alignment with the selfish shortsighted actions of folk who are importing and have done for many years, you obviously have some vested interest in trying to fudge the underlying root of this EFB outbreak. EFB in Scotland had been extremely rare. The fact that the condition has been located in areas where commercial beekeepers operate is extremely significant. These lazy, greedy commercial men who rather than breed their own stock from our native gene pool took the easy, cheap way out and are responsible for the large numbers of perhaps regulated imported bees, but bees which could not be assessed for disease without due quarantine, have done and have been doing Scottish Beekeepers at grass roots level a great disservice, which has now come high profile and could sound the death knell of the craft in Scotland. An immediate Standstill on the movement of bees is necessary. And a total ban on the importation of foreign bees has to be put in place before next Spring!
9

asl,

aberdeenshire 25/07/2009 14:46:09
I find it astonishing that while this is a matter of concern for all Scottish Beekeepers, commercial or not. A recent stakeholders meeting on the issue consisted only of SGRPID, SBA, and the commercial bee farmers organisation, and was not open to all. Surely in cases like this information from all beekeepers is important and as such, all should have an opportunity to contribute.
10

Phil Chandler,

Devon 26/07/2009 18:48:29
Why all the fuss about EFB? Most colonies recover from it without treatment, I have heard. Burning hives is DEFRA's standard response - as in foot & mouth disease - and should be challenged.
11

Phil Chandler,

Devon 27/07/2009 09:45:51
From the Queensland (Aus) government website:

When EFB infection is light, treatment is usually not required as the disease often disappears during a good nectar flow. Re-queening the hive is also advocated as a treatment. Stress is also an important factor in the control of EFB. Stress can result from:

* poor nutrition
* working winter honey flows
* excess movements of hives
* insecticide poisoning
* sudden expansion of the brood, resulting in insufficient nurse bees.

12

Uphallster,

West Lothian 27/07/2009 13:21:43
Perhaps so Phil, but if an individual thinks he can deal with this disease on his own or not is not the point, it's still a notifiable disease under the law, like it or not. And due to it's infectious nature other beekeepers have a right to know of it's presence for obvious reasons.

But lets not loose sight of the real issue here. We have all the necessary organisations and positions needed to maintain healthy populations of honeybees and a modern skilled beekeeping industry, but it's probably no great surprise to many beekeepers in Scotland that this has gone undiagnosed or publicised for so long. No regulation, no workable support mechanisms, no great surprise!
13

Uphallster,

West Lothian 27/07/2009 13:38:58
asl, don't get the idea that the SGRPID have no interest in the wider beekeeping communities, and that it's a closed door, that is definitely not the case. I contacted them direct with concerns and and received a very positive response. There was an opportunity for others to contribute but it was not well advertised. If you want more info contact me through EMBA website.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.