Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


A free market dilemma for council: now what would Smith have done?

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 April 2008
HE IS widely credited with creating the concept of free market capitalism.
But modern-day economists and academics are urging council chiefs to ignore the very principles Adam Smith espoused in his theories about economic growth through market competition.

Smith enthusiasts around the world have been lobbying the city co
uncil to scrap plans to sell off his former Old Town home and instead intervene to "save it for the nation".

The move would need the City of Edinburgh Council to postpone the sale of Panmure House – where Smith spent his final years before he died in 1790 – and to put aside any thoughts of what the economist himself would have done.

Now the heritage and conservation lobbies have waded in, urging the local authority to do all it can to keep Panmure House in public hands, rather than allow it to be turned into offices, luxury flats or a bar-restaurant.

The council has been urged to instigate plans to convert the property, built for the Earl of Panmure in 1691, into an Adam Smith Museum or study centre.

But the local authority also stands to generate £1 million by selling the building, which has attracted more than 20 bids, on the open market.

In a letter to the city council the heritage group the Cockburn Association, has stated: "We're concerned that an opportunity to develop Panmure House in a way that will promote and enhance Edinburgh, through its connection with one of its most famous citizens, could be lost.

"Developing Panmure House, perhaps in association with the universities, as a centre of excellence for the study of economics would celebrate Edinburgh's pre-eminence on the world stage and would be a fitting tribute to Adam Smith and his connections to the capital."

Terry Levinthal, director of the Scottish Civic Trust, the leading conservation body, added: "I do think the council has to seriously consider the cultural value of this building, and I would be very surprised if they have done that so far."

Dr Eamonn Butler, the director of the Adam Smith Institute, said: "Adam Smith would be the first to say there is more to this world than money, although any proposal to save Panmure House for the nation would obviously have to make economic sense."

A spokeswoman for the council said a report on the sale of Panmure House would be compiled in the next few weeks.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 23 April 2008 9:32 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 24/04/2008 03:21:43
We have got to save as much of our SCOTTISH heritage as possible now, for too much has been lost in the union with england. SAVE IT FOR HEAVENS SAKE!!!!
2

Navvy,

24/04/2008 04:11:53
Scotindy, can we assume that your cheque is in the post?

3

Lady of Shallot,

24/04/2008 09:50:01
I live close to Panmure House and can I point out that it's quite a small building, so you couldn't create very many luxury flats or offices out of it!

I think it should be turned into an Adam Smith museum; he's buried in the graveyard a few yards away and I see plenty of tourists look at his grave. There is even an "Adam Smith trail" around the old town, so the interest is there.

A bar/restaurant would be totally inappropriate as it is in a quiet residential close.

Lets keep this building in public ownership so that it can be visited by everyone.
4

Number 6,

Germany 24/04/2008 10:09:25
Come on, of course this house should be preserved.
Get your finger out Edinburgh.
5

John Blackley,

Florida 24/04/2008 20:03:37
True to Adam Smith's principles then. I think the disciples of Adam Smith should buy it. The Secret Shadow World Council of Economic Masterminds should secretly purchase it and turn it into a Supersecret Headquarters for Cabal Meetings and Global Conspiracy Hatchings.

Or, it could be a museum.
6

Buttress,

25/04/2008 08:48:42
Of course, it won't actually be lost - it will still exist in some form, even if not council owned.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.