Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 29th August 2008

RBS Ambassador, Luke Donald

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

'Calamity' Kate refuses to quit as pressure grows over £50m crisis



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 July 2008
THE leader of crisis-hit Aberdeen city council yesterday defiantly refused to resign in the face of a mounting storm of protest over the scale of the authority's £50 million budget cut target.
Councillor Kate Dean was accused by opposition councillors of heaping "calamity upon calamity" on the running of the city authority at a meeting of the council's urgent business committee.

But she angrily turned on the opposition and called on
them to stop sniping from the sidelines and join the administration in helping chart of way out of the city's financial crisis.

The bitter exchange came at the first meeting of the authority since the revelations earlier this week in a leaked confidential report that the city council must make cuts totalling £49.7 million this year – almost double the previous estimate of £27 million.

Councillor Dean claimed at the meeting that the £49.7 million total was not new and that all the figures about the council's savings had been contained in the budget papers, published earlier this year, or approved by the council at a meeting last October.

She said: "This is not a case of suddenly doubling the savings. These are savings and figures that we have all been aware of for some time."

But Councillor Willie Young, the secretary of the Labour group, told Councillor Dean she was "deluded" if she believed "everybody" knew about the £49.7 million figure.

He claimed: "The fact remains that everybody thought it was £27 million in budget cuts rather than £49.7 million. Indeed, when speaking to some of the members of your own group they were of that opinion."

Councillor Young said the crisis had become an "embarrassment" for the city and claimed the business community "no longer had trust" in the council leadership.

He called on the leader to "consider" her position.

Councillor Dean's leadership was also criticised by another Labour councillor, Barney Crockett, who has been appointed as chair of the scrutiny panel.

He said: "We have long-term difficulties but short-term catastrophe. Calamity has been laid upon calamity in the last five years."

But Councillor Dean said: "As far as I am concerned I have been elected to do a job by the people of Aberdeen and by my colleagues around this council. I see no reason to stand down from that job."

The committee unanimously endorsed a series of recommendations to begin addressing the council's financial crisis. The 22 recommendations include a freeze on recruitment, a moratorium on new capital projects and a move towards a targeted early retirement programme and voluntary redundancy scheme for council employees.



The full article contains 447 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 18 July 2008 10:07 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Matt there,

somewhere 19/07/2008 00:30:42
But Councillor Willie Young, the secretary of the Labour group said: "Jings! If only you was as wonderful as our beloved leader Wendy Alexander!"
2

Marky Bhoy,

Dunfermline 19/07/2008 00:45:06

Why should she quit the massive debt was built but lat administration
3

Edward,

19/07/2008 00:57:12
The figure of £ 49.7 million debt is actually not new, it was stated at the very beginning last year
This smacks of Labour dirty tricks, by breifing the press into stating this is new when its not
The debt by the way was caused by the previous Labour council over spending, but we dont want that little fact to get in the way of a good story do we!
4

Iainbroch,

Moray 19/07/2008 01:01:38
Why were previous administrations allowed to drift on in illegality and who signed off the books of those previuos council administrations?
I thought that councils had a legal obligation to balance thier books? - It certainly appears that previous council administrations were allowed to get away totally without any scrutiny and I wonder who is to blame for that?
Perhaps the press and media in this instance can perform a job thats is truly in the public interest for once in this instance and actually get answers to questions that need to be asked about those councils and who ruled them!
I guess pigs will fly before that happens? As the truth might be uncomfortable for them?
5

Power in a Union,

Scotland 19/07/2008 01:09:40
How can Edward at number 3 still blame the previous Labour administration. This council has been run by the Liberals since 2003 - with Tory partners first and now Nat partners (not much difference really). Surely the Liberals should have realised any shortfall long before now if the problem was inherited.
6

Iainbroch,

Moray 19/07/2008 01:26:36
re 5

The problems go back further than 2003 - indeed back as far as 1999, or so I have been informed! Labour is just as culpable! The budgets were signed off for 8 years in a row when they were not actually balanced in any of those years?

Indeed Aberdeen council never grew up and dealt with the realiy it found itself with after local govt reorganisation - it went on behaving as if it still ran a region and not just a city?
7

catgut,

pomona 19/07/2008 06:49:03
has the debt reached 40% of GDP
8

livilion,

livingston 19/07/2008 09:19:11
8 catgut
Does repayments on PFIs and PPPs count?
9

lulach mac gille coemgain,

19/07/2008 09:26:10
Local Aberdeen politics has ALWAYS been prone to scandal read the history books right back until the pictish times for rare old tales of corruption and scandal - NOTHIN’ changes !
10

chico y,

19/07/2008 09:34:02
The problems in Aberdeen seem to be the same faced by the Scottish government - having to sort a mess created by Liebour sleaze and incompetence.
11

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 19/07/2008 09:41:52
-- ALL politicians appear bright until they speak!

.. and Dundoniennes are often attractive.
12

Alberto.,

19/07/2008 09:42:36
Surely this situation, as reported, is screaming out for 'Suspensions of senior officials and a 'Dam good and meaningful full audit!'

Otherwise, why all the fuss!!!!!!
13

An Greumach Mor,

Highlands 19/07/2008 09:56:35
Councils need to be run by professionals not party politics.

They should be trying to solve the problems not passing about blame. The current problems sit on all the councillors not just the ones running it council past or present.

Although I note from the article it seems the Scotsman only reports what a couple of Labour bampots claim.

How very suprising from this propoganda outlet for the Sleaze and Corruption party ZaNu Labour.
14

Senga Jean,

19/07/2008 11:00:20
Labour caused it and now wallow in their own sick mess. Labour need to be shocked into taking responsibility for their past mistakes and not be allowed to spin out of taking the blame. AND it is not just Aberdeen. The SNP Government have to work hard to regain fiscal probity,for fairness to all!
15

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 19/07/2008 11:28:40
Painful times ahead, & to think we're trying to diversify from oil - hell, it's needed more than ever!!
16

Nebulous,

Aberdeen 19/07/2008 13:10:47
Yes oil is needed more than ever - but we don't hear anything about them contributing to find a solution, other than Ian Wood's family trust. It would be good given the billions they are making at the moment if they made some sort of a gesture to help out.
17

Jonesy,

faroffski 19/07/2008 13:27:32
Ach, is it no longer possible for the poor woman to keep her snout in the money trough and ignore comments around her. Its not what Kate's Dean but what Kate's done. Politicians refuse to accept any responsibility but grab what they can. Keep up the good work hen and grab what you can while the going's good!
18

Coileach an taobh Tuath,

19/07/2008 14:07:45


Form the Herald


"....Labour lost power in Aberdeen in 2003 and Labour councillor Barney Crockett admitted that the city's difficulties were long-standing.

"We have long term difficulties but short term, catastrophes," he said, adding that over the last five years "calamity has been laid on calamity."

"Aberdonians know about the long term but they also know they would give anything to get back to where they were five years ago."

Oh Dear, the cat seems to be out of the bag.

It's Time LABOUR apologised for the mess that they created.

19

Coileach an taobh Tuath,

19/07/2008 14:09:56
5 Power in a Union, Scotland 19/07/2008 01:09:40

Pathetic Squirming from Labour's Supporters.

Be a big man and put yer hand up.

Labour /Liberal Coalition watched this farce as a government for over 8 years....... the spending plans were generated in 2001, unfortunately the Liberal Coalition didn't have the guts to cause a political storm

20

Coileach an taobh Tuath,

19/07/2008 14:13:54


Councillor Young .....an "embarrassment"

It’s the lack of movement on the part of the Labour party that’s stopping the council from ‘moving on’. The finance secretary John Swinney was in town this week telling the council to shut it, get together, work together and fix the bloody mess

Do we have a plan from Labour on what to do?

Were Labour even there when the accounts commission gave their verdict and suggestions?

The people of aberdeen know fine well who is at the centre of this crisis....

Lewis Macdonald MSP
Anne Begg MP
Frank Doran MP
Richard Baker MSP

Shoogly pegs?

21

,

19/07/2008 14:16:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
22

Scottish 'N British,

19/07/2008 14:22:45
Aberdeen's malaise is the fault of every cooncillor, not just the previous ones, but the present administration.

BTW, Salmond hankers for the chance to do great things for Scotland. Here's his chance.

But, needless to say, he's no where to be seen when the country (or in this case Aberdeen) really needs him.

23

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 19/07/2008 18:11:26
#22 has he - whoever it is - sold that car yet?

#23 1st paragraph I agree with totally.
24

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 19/07/2008 19:01:55
Slab is run on the Mee family ethos. The present generation of the 3 Mee monkeys who dominate Slab thinking are, in this order,

Efter Mee - hands over eyes (cannot see themselves as others see them)
Michty Mee - hands over mouth (I'm saying nothing)
Twazny Mee (Now I deny everything and don't want to hear any more about it)

25

Scottish 'N British,

19/07/2008 19:35:16
I know it's the weekend, but I wonder if there's ony update on the Scottish Executive bailing out, assisting, guiding Aberdeen's hapless coooncillors out of this massive hole.

If it was Glasgow this would never be off the news.

Jings, £27 big wans wiz bad enough - but £50m? That's a lot of sackings, or frontline services to be cut. It'll never be enough.

Only the erstwhile Swinney can sort out this problem. But will he?
26

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 20/07/2008 15:18:03
Disabled transport seems to be next in line for the axe.

Scandalous.

I can help Kate Dean out re transport. I have a one-way ticket outta here...TAKE IT KATE.

Whip crack away, Calamity Kate...;o)
27

Nebulous,

Aberdeen 21/07/2008 08:21:58
#23 - Why? What have the current ones done except try to resolve the situation?

Labour contributed to the problem when they were the administration. They didn't put forward any budget proposals this year. They are now engaging in a twin strategy. Oppose every cut and claim that if it is imposed the sky will fall down - while insisting they would never have done that. At the same time castigate the present administration for the mess they have got the city into.

Meanwhile the Unions have turned down a £10 million plus settlement for single status and have delayed almost every single cut by entering into a dispute procedure - At the same time, yes you've guessed it they are complaining about the state the administration have got the council into too.

So they are all doing their best to make the situation worst, while pretending they are prepared to work together to make it better. They talk almost with glee about the possibility of the council going bankrupt.

What they don't appreciate is that if the council did go bankrupt it would have a devastating effect on the council staff and Union members. Everything, but everything would be privatised. At the moment the council has about 12,000 employees. If they went bust they'd be lucky to have 2000 left. Current Labour policy seems to be self-defeating, the ultimate in cut off your nose to spite your face.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.