Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Attacks on Capital's vulnerable vice girls double in two years

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 17 December 2008
A FORMER prostitute today told how it had become too dangerous to work Edinburgh's streets as new figures showed an increasing number of attacks on the city's sex workers.
The 39-year-old said she had quit after being held at knife point and sexually assaulted, and blamed new kerb-crawling laws for increasing violence.

Ten prostitutes were raped in Edinburgh between January and September this year, more than double the number of rapes reported in 2006 – the year before the new legislation was introduced.

Figures released by support charity Scot-Pep to coincide with the International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers revealed the number of reported attacks on prostitutes almost doubled between 2006 and 2007, from 66 to 126, while there were 92 attacks in the first nine months of this year alone.

Former prostitute Joanne – whose name has been changed to protect her identity – worked on Salamander Street and Salamander Place for the best part of a decade until she was sexually assaulted last year.

It followed an incident earlier that year where a man pulled a knife on her in a car to try to rob her night's earnings.

She was attacked while working on Salamander Place by a man in Edinburgh on a stag night.

She said: "What happened put me off severely. I went on a methadone programme after that and was helped through Streetwork's women's team.

"It took months and months after being told about the chance of rehab before I decided on it. You have to get to the level where you reach rock bottom first."

Although Joanne reported the attempted robbery to police, she did not report the sexual assault as she was already on her second caution and did not want to be arrested.

Scot-Pep said this was one of the main reasons behind the "immense under-reporting" amongst street workers.

Ruth Morgan Thomas, project manager for the charity, said there was "not a night goes by" where support workers in Leith did not hear of an attack taking place.

She said: "There has been a dramatic increase in attacks since the kerb-crawling legislation came into force.

"The legislation has, to a certain extent, been successful in that some men have chosen not to seek to purchase sex in public places.

"However, we have not invested significantly in the alternatives and what we are left with now is women who have to work longer hours and take more risks.

"The reality is that men who are not put off by the thought of having a conviction for seeking to purchase sex are more likely to be those men who are prepared to rape or assault women."

Joanne, who was forced into prostitution after getting addicted to heroin when she was 26, said women were putting themselves into dangerous situations every day due to the new laws.

Prostitutes are having to take risks and meet men in secluded industrial estates and give out phone numbers to make money.

Joanne, who first started drinking and taking drugs at the age of 11 while growing up in care homes in Edinburgh, said: "

At least if you see them first in a car, you can decide whether you want to get in. You get a lot of wrong ones – more often than not they're wrong ones."

Lothian and Borders Police said they encourage all victims of crime to report incidents.

Chief Inspector Denise Mulvaney said: "Lothian and Borders are committed to engaging and working with other agencies to ensure that avenues are open to those workers who wish to route themselves out of prostitution."


The full article contains 613 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 December 2008 11:06 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Prostitution
 
1

,

17/12/2008 12:09:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

hibbywul,

17/12/2008 12:20:43
Shame for all the "real" Joannes out there, everyone now thinks you were a former prostitute.
3

brandy al,

embra 17/12/2008 12:28:58
Terrible these girls are only doing a job,some are very good at their job.
4

Foo,

17/12/2008 12:41:03
#1

Your really are an evil little crackpot aren't you?
5

,

17/12/2008 12:49:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

C.,

17/12/2008 12:52:43
just thinking. if a guy goes to a prostitute, has sex, doesn't think it was that good and refuses to pay, is that rape?

thoughts please
7

Foo,

17/12/2008 12:55:18
#6 - I think caveat emptor would apply in situations such as this.
8

Black Five,

edinburgh 17/12/2008 12:57:30
There`s two slants to this article.One is there should be licensed brothels for the people who want to do this and the other who might say why complain if you are attacked as you are doing something illegal and immoral.Both can be argued, it`s an age old argument but the bottom line is as it stands presently the law says that prostitution is illegal and therefore if women run the risk of making a few quid by selling themselves in this way they are going to get this kind of treatment from time to time by the type of people who would want this service.It`s to me their choice either pack it in or run the risk from the bampots of this world.
9

,

17/12/2008 13:00:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

elayne,

17/12/2008 13:10:45
its a dangerous life,wrong or right, there are always going to be weirdos and guys who hate women, and the girls who work on the streets are always going to be the most vunerable,ok a lot of people dont agree with prostitution but at the end of the day women often have little choice in the matter due to mostly drug issues,what would you do if you saw a prostitute being attacked?i know i would try and help her
11

Bill MacD,

17/12/2008 13:40:48
I read Jenny M's comments earlier (1) and agreed entirely with them. But I see they've now been removed by the administrator. Why? She may be outspoken, and clearly she has no time for Christians and feminists, but said nothing obscene. But she's entitled to this view.

I too think that religious people do far more harm than good, and should stay out of public life. What right does the Evening News have to censor honest viewpoints? They should edit obscenities and libel etc. But expressing strong views about someone else's views you find offensive should not be censored.

The Evening News should allow free exchange of ideas. It shouldn't print what I consider to be extremist ideas from religious figures who seek their dogma-based ideas on everyone else including non-believers by involving themselves in politics, and then censor those who seek to complain about this. That's one-sided bias. Shame on this paper!
12

Logie Almond,

17/12/2008 14:07:02
This whole article is based on "Figures released by support charity Scot-Pep". They are not therefore official crime staistics and I would suggest they are totally unreliable. Scotpep have a vested interest in the continuation of prostitution as their jobs depend on it. They have opposed every measure proposed to reduce or eliminate prostitution for the same reason. So this is a complete non-story.
13

Uncle Piehead,

17/12/2008 14:14:30
The term 'vice girls' is a newspaper relic from the times when it was unacceptable to print the word 'prostitute'.

14

Top_Dawg,

17/12/2008 14:33:09
Easier to phone the ones adertising in the EEN. Bloody expensive though.
15

Uncle Piehead,

17/12/2008 14:44:03

#14

Are you one of the insecure greasy baldies in a cheap suit that you see going into Blair Street Sauna to horse a girl for £30 because you can't get any in real life?

Or was it just a funny joke ha ha hee hee.
16

An Deasach,

17/12/2008 16:12:13
#15
How do you know it costs £30 ?
17

James (1),

17/12/2008 16:13:50
#12 Spot on! That Scotpep have everything to lose by any down trend.
That may be their reason for not trying to persuade women to give up being prostitutes?

18

Uncle Piehead,

17/12/2008 17:29:42
#16

Because I know how to haggle.
19

GmL,

Edinburgh 17/12/2008 19:20:10
Ahhh, James, the "chocolate fireguard" approach ;0)... how you doing?

You ever considered that they may actually be telling the truth?
20

SnowdropExplodes,

UK 23/12/2008 05:43:35
#12 - the reason that sex workers' rights campaigners oppose laws designed to reduce or eliminate prostitution is because a) such laws do not work - people have been trying for 3,000 years! and b) because the laws always hurt the women. Strange as it may sound, but sex workers' rights organisations are actually in a better position to judge than the official organisations such as the police, because sex workers have to fear the police as long as there are any kinds of laws against them. Therefore, crimes against sex workers simply go unreported in official statistics! Strange as it may sound, many of the people involved in the sex workers' rights organisations are in fact sex workers themselves, or former sex workers.

It is reported that "Lothian and Borders Police said they encourage all victims of crime to report incidents." This is completely pointless. It is too late for you to report the crime after it has happened (and sex workers are all too familiar with a brush-off attitude from law enforcement personnel anyway). The only way in which the law can possibly protect prostitutes is if there are no laws against prostitution. That way, they can practice their business in safety, in well-lit areas, with the protection of CCTV or whatever, with the protection of association in decriminalised brothels. In short, prostitution is ONLY so dangerous because there are laws against it.
21

SnowdropExplodes,

UK 23/12/2008 05:47:05
Oh, and James @ #17, speak not of what you know not: sex workers' rights organisations all over the world, including the UK, are adamant that sex workers should have the right and the ability to leave sex work at any time, and it is very often these organisations that provide outreach, drugs rehabilitation access, work training and qualifications, and more, for women seeking to leave prostitution.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Should the police be asking the public to take note of kerbcrawlers’ registrations?
Yes, everyone should do their bit to fight crime.
No, it’s the police’s duty to police, not ours.
No, what if the wrong number is noted by mistake?

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.