Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Tuesday, 13th May 2008

Evening News / Sony Centre Reverse Auction

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Wendy Alexander's job as Scots Labour leader still 'absolutely safe'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 May 2008
WENDY ALEXANDER'S position as Scottish Labour leader is "absolutely safe", a senior MSP and former minister insisted today.
Malcolm Chisholm claimed Ms Alexander's call for an early referendum on independence had widespread support, including from the business community.

And he tried to play down Gordon Brown's failure to back Ms Alexander when pressed on the issue at
Prime Minister's Question Time in the Commons yesterday.

Labour has been left in turmoil by the sudden U-turn on a referendum which Ms Alexander announced in a weekend TV interview.

She attacked the SNP for waiting until 2010 before producing its referendum Bill and said she did not fear the verdict of the Scottish people. "Bring it on," she added.

But the move took colleagues, including the Prime Minister, by surprise. One Labour MP said the general view at Westminster was Ms Alexander had "probably gone mad". And SNP, Conservative and Lib Dem leaders at Holyrood said her position was untenable.

But Mr Chisholm said she was "absolutely safe". He said: "What Wendy said this week has widespread support not just in the Labour Party, but throughout Scotland. What she said was the SNP should bring their referendum Bill forward in the interests of Scotland."

He said that was a position backed by business organisations such as the CBI and Institute of Directors. Mr Chisholm also denied the Prime Minister's failure to endorse a referendum yesterday amounted to a snub, saying: "I know Gordon Brown holds Wendy Alexander in the highest regard and he trusts her political judgement on this issue."

Mr Chisholm hinted Labour could still bring forward its own Bill for a referendum to force discussion of the issue, even though Holyrood's rules mean it would almost certainly not be allowed to go forward as legislation.

Labour strategists say the rules allow non-government Bills to be blocked on the grounds the government is planning similar legislation – but only once the proposed Bill has gone through a consultation process and been published. Mr Chisholm said:

"A Bill before the parliament, which would be fully consulted on, would raise the whole issue of the referendum Bill."

The Prime Minister caused astonishment in the Commons when he responded to Tory leader David Cameron's question on whether he agreed with Ms Alexander's call for an immediate referendum by claiming: "That is not what she has said". Mr Cameron later wrote to Mr Brown, claiming he was treating people "like fools".





The full article contains 417 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 May 2008 11:30 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Andrew Murphy,

EDINBURGH 08/05/2008 12:29:29
WENDY ALEXANDER'S position as Scottish Labour leader is "absolutely safe", a senior MSP and former minister insisted today.

Malcolm Chisholm said this:

As an MSP he should know, no seat is safe. The electorate will eventually decide if Wendy's seat is safe - and yours too Malcolm.

Our politicians are showing an arrogance not seen for years now. And the people backing these failed politicians might like to think again when making statements like this.

If they carry on the way they are, it may me that even their own seats are no longer safe.

Politics will change, and it's the electorate who will decide who can stay and who can't.

We are not there for you. You are there to represent us as our representatives. And because of that, it is the electorate who will decide.

It's time for our politicians – Council’s and Central Government - too get their feet back on the ground. They need to get back to grass root politics instead of trying to dictate to the electorate by telling them what’s acceptable and what is not.
2

capy,

edinburgh 08/05/2008 12:35:42
oh dear oh dear.just wathed wendy on first ministers questions. she had the look of a startled gerbil that had just swallowed a wasp. at least she was brave to ask a question or two. but she had the cheek to say that her party was giving the scottish people their say. it has been a very quick conversion on the road to damascus then. she never wanted the Independence question put, and excluded any nationalist from her commision. a touch of hypocracy methinks.
3

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

08/05/2008 12:42:44
She's got a nice mouth & smile.
4

Proximaking,

Seychelles 08/05/2008 12:44:05
This is hilarious!! I just love the way interviewers are now just repeating the question over and over and over and over until the politicians HAVE to answer it. Why didn't they do this years ago? Great entertainment watching Wendy squirm every time she is on TV. Salmond seems to be having a right old hoot to himself. Shows you how far into the mire politics in this country has slipped when Jon Snow took Salmond to task for sticking to his manifesto pledge by saying "What does that matter? Nobody reads the manifestos anyway!" It is now expected by commentators that you will just pay lip service to the people and do whatever you please once the mugs have marked their X in your box. And am I the only one who was peed off by the smug arrogance of Dunwoody's daughter who said "We'll see about that when I've won". Why don't we have rule to prevent members of one family setting up dynasties of politicians, this isn't Whitney Houston or Lilly Allan we are talking about this is someone supposed to be representing us and 600 in Westminster are from few enough different backgrounds without the incest of taking them all from the same family. Labour is riddled with such multiple family members, the Benns, and the Millibands for starters and it is about time the people's interest was put above these families interests.
5

THE BPRENTICE,

08/05/2008 13:06:10
Just heard Wendy Alexander on the radio saying 'bring it on' with reference to a referendum on independence - then they play Brown saying that Wendy didn't say she welcomes one. Ooooh she's gettin it.
6

Gastric Antral Vascular Ectasia,

08/05/2008 13:07:11
Let's have a competition here to see who can be the most intractably boring.
7

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 08/05/2008 13:09:32
Damn! No photo!

If Wendy's position as leader is safe, what does that say about the quality of the rest of the labour party?
8

Alberto.,

08/05/2008 13:11:56
"I know Gordon Brown holds Wendy Alexander in the highest regard and he trusts her political judgement on this issue."

So what!

Remember Blair - no matter the trouble any Minister got him / herself into, he always, without fail, had full confidence in them (to say differently would only reflect on his poor judgement on them being selected in the firsty place!

But, whoever the 'Rogue' was they ended up getting booted 'OUT!'

In another recent incident, that of the case of Michael Martin - the Speaker in the House, accused in the press of seemingly fraudulent expenses claims amounting to many thousands of Pounds, yet when Brown was asked to comment, remarked only to say 'He is doing a good job!' - what else? I am assuming that Gordon Brown actually knows who Michael Martin was / is, although he did seem, surprisingly, somewhat not too suer I thought!

I assume Mt Chisholm has been a politician for quite some time now, and would have 'cottoned on' as to how the system works - especially in a system where his own Party has achieved notoriety, or so it seems, mainly on the back of being 'not too strong on truthfulnes and honesty', which by now is a well known and oustanding fact of life to most, if not all of the Population!!
9

Ah Bristo,

08/05/2008 13:26:51
I hope she stays on as leader for as long as possible.

Every day she does is a day closer to Independence.
10

gorgeousgorgieboy,

Edinburgh 08/05/2008 13:30:39
She should learn not to mess with the jowly jambo.
11

me150,

08/05/2008 13:32:01
Her position is safe.

Is this not just political speak for her position being reviewed/under threat?

Just like football signings and managers jobs etc.
12

Talorthane,

08/05/2008 13:55:48
Malcolm Chisholm's earlier remarks show how much disarray the Labour Party are in.

As one of their most experienced and respected MSPs, he was arguing that the referendum question should not be alopng the lines of "Do you want to Scotland to be independent?", but instead to be based on the question "Do you want Scotland to remain in the UK?"

In other words, he is arguing to spent resources on a referendum to do nothing.
13

Tynietiger,

08/05/2008 13:57:06
One Labour MP described Wendy as a political suicide bomber. But she is the best Labour have at Holyrood.
14

a proud doonhamer,

Dumfries 08/05/2008 13:58:07
She's staying... oh happy days.

Best news of the afternoon. I was truly worried after watching FMQ that she had lost not only the will to go on but the will to live.

I have seen more happiness at the funeral than was apparent on the Labour benches.
15

Talorthane,

08/05/2008 14:01:24
Alex Salmond made a number of comments that distinguished between the Labour leadership (or the Labour party itself) and the individual MSPs.

I wonder if he was presenting an olive branch (or an amnesty) to those Labour MSPs who may be on the verge of considering jumping ship.
16

Jwil,

08/05/2008 14:07:18
As we have found out over the last year, Labour don't do resignations. Wendy will stay until she is dragged kicking and screaming from the parliament. in the meantime her Mickey Mouse politics will go on.
17

Dragonlord,

08/05/2008 14:21:18
16# Yes,Yes,Yes. PLEASE Labour keep Bendy Wendy for as long as possible. She is the best advert for the SNP ever. Soon the people of Scotland will be begging for independance.
18

Hugh T,

Perth 08/05/2008 14:37:48
Lay off Wendy, she will be looked back upon as a genuine heroine of an independent Scotland.

HT
19

Niadh,

Edinburgh 08/05/2008 14:43:58
#18 Hugh T.

Either that or the original court jester!
20

Boggle fey the Bog,

08/05/2008 14:55:08
18 Hugh T,Perth 08/05/2008 14:37:48

They will even put up a statue of her in Holyrood, as one of the 'Prime Movers' in the fight for Scottish Independence.

She's an asset to the SNP.
21

Arrow,

edinburgh 08/05/2008 14:58:29
to misquote Lenin
Brown is supporting her like a rope supports a hanging man (or woman).
22

I love to eat Sellotape,

08/05/2008 15:30:11
To misquote Lennon

Imagine there's no water
23

steve 1511,

aberdeen 08/05/2008 15:46:48
wendy the daftie,in charge of the labour dunderheid party of scotland,if she is the best that labour have got how bad are the rest of the eejits in the labour party
24

Jimmy the Pie,

08/05/2008 15:49:16
No comments from his Lardship, Fatty Foolkes, on this latest New Labour Sleaze debacle???

Or is he still recovering from a heavy weekend on the expenses????
25

Voice of reason,

EDINBURGH 08/05/2008 16:40:16
I want revenge for Section 28 , so I want her to stay and be slaughtered at the polls .
26

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 08/05/2008 17:02:27
#22:

"Imagine there's no water"

It's easy if you're dry.
27

pehman,

sussex 08/05/2008 17:28:16


Wendy's job is absolutely safe------- say's malcolm chisholm-------- oh aye, and he would know; would he
28

Bob Christie,

08/05/2008 17:43:33
" Wendy Alexander's job as Scots Labour leader still 'absolutely safe' "

Oh dear Wendy! This is classic Liebourspeak for the knives are being sharpened. I would not turn my back on Chisholm. He is a Broon-noser of the first order.
29

brownlie,

08/05/2008 17:48:00
I hope her job is safe. Where else in Scotland could we find a politician with charm, wit, sincerity, intellect, personality and, as an extra bonus, she is gorgeous!!
30

gus1940,

Edinburgh 08/05/2008 18:04:11
Yet again the use of quote marks which, if not noticed, would give a reader the impression that one person's opinion is a fact.

Reprehensible, misleading journalism sadly typical of today's Scotsman Publications.
31

blackley,

Edinburgh 08/05/2008 18:43:17
Wendy opened her muckle mooth without thinking and is regretting it. In the present circumstances Labour do not want any more talk of elections or referenda.
32

valleyjim,

Scottish Parliament 08/05/2008 23:05:25
#31. Blackley. How can you say that Wendy has a "muckle mooth".? Wendy has a mooth like a highland koo. Big gobblin lips. Bet she could blo' a mean moothie.
33

valleyjim,

08/05/2008 23:25:19
#brownlie 29. Are you by any chance related to "blackley 31"? If so, have you seen whitely lately?
34

donald,

glasgow 09/05/2008 04:56:31
Her Bendyness. Queen of the pigmy caterpillars in La La Land. Head of the Tellytubby Party.
35

me150,

09/05/2008 10:33:30
It is debatable that Wendy is the best Labour have but just have a quick look at SNP.

Their leader resigned a number of years ago with a vow not to return, yet here he is because there was no-one able to do the job, not that he is doing much of a job.

I will give criticism where it is due and on this occasion it is due to you lot pointing fingers, point them at Salmond now because he and his party did exactly the same just a short time ago.
36

Sanny,

10/05/2008 00:57:21
I'm glad to hear the Wendy's position is safe. She's the best recruiting sergeant the SNP has

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.