Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Poor nations 'must stop blaming rich for emissions'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 07 November 2009
THE poor countries of the world cannot delay acting on global warming by blaming climate change on the rich, Chancellor Alistair Darling has warned ahead of a key meeting of G20 finance ministers in St Andrews today.
As the group meets to discuss plans for a $100 billion scheme to help developing countries cut emissions, Mr Darling said it was fruitless for those nations to continue to argue that, as the developed world had caused the most pollution, it should ta
ke sole responsibility for cleaning the mess up.

He claimed that, with 90 per cent of future emissions likely to come from developing or emerging countries, it was no longer sustainable for major economies, such as China or India, to continue to grow using fossil-fuelled power.

The Chancellor was speaking to The Scotsman before a key meeting of his fellow finance ministers in St Andrews this afternoon, where the issue of climate finance is high on the agenda.

The talks are the last in a series in which leaders agreed a $1trillion "fiscal stimulus" in the wake of global recession.

Mr Darling is hoping to broker a multi-billion package to help developing countries to wean themselves off high-carbon power. However, the talks are stalling with rich and poor countries miles apart on how much each should pay.

Developing economies have said that, with the industrialised West having caused so much of the world's carbon emissions so far, and having built their countries on it, it is wrong to expect them to meet the cost of a finance package.

The deal will be thrashed out at the Copenhagen climate change summit next month, but Mr Darling and Environment Secretary Ed Miliband have accepted that a binding treaty may now be out of reach.

The Chancellor insisted he would be telling finance ministers today that they needed to put in the "necessary action" to back up their words. The UK government has pledged £1bn towards a global climate finance pot.

But while rich countries needed to pay up, he said that emerging countries, such as China and India, needed to draw a line under the past. He added:

"Seventy-five per cent of the emissions we have at the moment were caused by the developed world. That's true. But 90 per cent of the future emissions are going to come from the developing and emerging economies, so we all need to be sitting around the table."

He went on: "We know what has happened historically, but that doesn't help you in a situation where India and China are building a coal-fired power station every week without carbon capture and storage, for example.

"What happened in the past you can't change. What you can change is what happens in the future. We have got to try and break down those barriers".

Mr Darling said he would step up his efforts to persuade rich countries in the G20 to stump up their fair share of money. But he warned that many are reluctant to do so, because they have little confidence in the way the money will be handled.

There is growing pessimism that those barriers will not be brought down in time for the Copenhagen summit, and that hopes of a deal to reduce carbon emissions will remain distant.

Climate change and measures to ensure long-term growth in the global economy will be at the top of today's agenda.

Mr Darling said the G20 countries were united in their belief that existing fiscal stimulus packages needed to stay in place for now. "I think we can reach agreement on firstly making sure we don't remove support too early, because the recovery is by no means established everywhere," he said.

The G20 will also consider how to ensure more balanced growth over the coming decade, to avoid a repeat of last year's financial meltdown.

Outside the G20 meeting, protesters are preparing to meet on St Andrews beach to demand that the G20 do more to alleviate poverty and cut emissions.

About a dozen students began to gather in the town centre yesterday, carrying banners with slogans including "Nature doesn't do bail-outs" and "IMF is the problem not the solution".

Amir Gholami, 33, from Luxembourg, said: "I think the people at the G20 are representative of a system that is part of the problem, not the solution."

Dr Richard Dixon, director of WWF Scotland, said: "We need firm action, not just proposals."

Mr Darling said he had received a mixed response from his fellow finance ministers over the choice of St Andrews for the summit.

"When I told them that we would be going to St Andrews, the golfers among them thought it would be great. The others looked at me and said: 'Won't it be cold?'"

He added: "I've always been keen to encourage international meetings in Scotland, and it is a chance to showcase the country. It's good that we don't have all these meetings in London."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 November 2009 12:38 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: G20 Summit
 
1

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 06/11/2009 22:42:50
This is linked to the cuts story.

Subliminal subversion sucks. Seen as superficial circumstantial scribblings.
2

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth, Poor Nation. 07/11/2009 00:22:27
We don't blame China or India for their emission levels but wish we could divert some of the vast funds promised to them if they mend their ways back to UK where we may find the funds of great benefit in dealing with the self-induced financial death-throes. As a poor nation we probably now qualify for big greenie handouts. There are probably a number of former third world countries who could now contribute quite comfortably.
3

Davy,

Subliminal subversion 07/11/2009 02:11:23
Climate change bah hum bug, it is doing our heads in. The brain washing tactics from our politicians & the greeny want to-bees is not working. This has got to be the worlds, biggest con. Aye a bigger con than WMD, a few fell that one.
4

Handsome Scotsman,

07/11/2009 02:25:43
Common sense has long since departed.
A disputed scientific theory has been pounced upon by our politicians as an opportunity to appear tough and save the world.

They ramblie on without having a clue about how planet Earths climate system works.

Forget the "war on terror", we need a "war on misinformation"
5

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 07/11/2009 07:45:39
There is no point in reducing CO2 emissions in the developed world if they are just going to be replaced and exceeded by new sources of emissions in the developing world.

The developed countries should just take the lead on this by setting carbon reduction goals for those willing to sign up and for those unwilling just place a carbon tax on their exports and offer them carbon credits for activities that reduce CO2.
6

El Franko,

07/11/2009 10:05:25
It is encouraging that Darling's officials have realised one of the sorry implications of the AGW scam (for which, I note, there is neither convincing evidence nor convincing theory), and he at least has seen no reason not to go along with them. No doubt a huddle of spinners will be reviewing public reaction to his words to decide if he can stick with them or not. The idiot-fest coming up in Copenhagen has been struck another blow. Hurray!
7

Andrah,

Embrugh 07/11/2009 10:14:24
Just watch the emissions from Mercedes factories soar as developing countries spend their climate dividends on cars for their Presidents and huge entourage of goons.
8

Ben Thehoose,

07/11/2009 10:19:58
The poor remain poor due to their own inaction (medical conditions excepted).

Poor nations should sort themselves out. What wealth they have is squirrelled away in Swiss Banks by corruption. Whose fault is that? Theirs. Think Zimbabwe before and after majority rule.
9

Unimpressed one,

07/11/2009 11:27:15
The greenie love-in next month is already considered an abject failure - here's hoping. Truth is no country wants to be the first to commit economic suicide, although, Scotland, like some drunken, brain-damaged cretin, is jumping up and down claiming to be one of the first to do so. Here's hoping common sense prevails and the greens are shat on.
10

Richard Lionheart,

07/11/2009 15:49:53
any excuse to party!
11

truthsleuth,

08/11/2009 00:28:54
£100 billion of aid for emmissons.

The so called developing countries are already given eneormous aid from the 'West'.

We give aid to India for example yet they can spend money on building A bombs missiles and space exploration.

No these countries get to much and such aid simply helps these countries burgening population rather than bing spent on birth control.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.