Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 7th September 2008

Free Capercaillie CD

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

No love lost over ballet budget cut



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 May 2008
THEIR coalition to run the Capital has seen its share of drama – and now Steve Cardownie and Jenny Dawe are starring as Romeo and Juliet in protest leaflets about the decision to axe the annual £40,000 council grant for Scottish Ballet.
A mock-up of the flyer for the new production of the world's most famous love story – which opens at the Festival Theatre tonight – shows Edinburgh's SNP and Liberal Democrat group leaders under the words: "This pair of star-crossed lovers has cut al
l their funding for Scottish Ballet."

Senior Labour politicians will be stationed outside the theatre tonight, handing out the leaflets and asking people to sign a petition against the cuts.

The party's culture spokesman, Malcolm Chisholm, MSP for Edinburgh North & Leith, is due to join former Lord Provost Lesley Hinds and other councillors at the protest.

Labour says the cut means the end of Scottish Ballet's outreach programme in schools and risks turning ballet performances into the preserve of the "élite".

Mr Chisholm said: "There are two keys aspects to arts policy – supporting excellent performing arts and making it as widely available as possible.

"This cut shows what the SNP's fine words about the arts amount to – not only are they cutting support for excellent performance art, they are ensuring that fewer people can enjoy it."

Labour group leader Councillor Ewan Aitken said that the funding for Scottish Ballet – and a similar amount to Scottish Opera, which has also been cut – had been provided for decades to give ordinary people access to the arts.

He said: "They have chosen to attack one of the bedrocks of this city's soul – its cultural life.

"This is a classic example of putting pounds before people. The benefits pupils in this city get from that relatively small amount of money is enormous.

"In engaging with ballet and opera, they are getting a cultural experience they would not otherwise have."

He said each year Scottish Ballet went into city schools with its outreach programme: "The children are not just watching it, they are performing it – it's a phenomenal piece of work."

Scottish Opera used a similar model for its engagement. But the council cuts mean both organisations will stop their outreach work in Edinburgh.

Cllr Cardownie said the council had shown its support for the arts by increasing funding for the Festival and would continue to fund Scottish Ballet on a project-by-project basis for work carried out in Edinburgh.

But he claimed the financial "mess" left by Labour was to blame for the cuts.

He said: "I wish their sense of humour was matched by their sense of fiscal responsibility."





The full article contains 449 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 May 2008 10:43 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Duncan in Edinburgh,

13/05/2008 11:46:15
Shame on Steve Cardownie for blaming Labour for the complete and utter mess that the SNP and the Lib Dems have made of running the council for the past year. This lie about the council being in financial trouble when they took over is as pernicious as it is false. The council accepted the SNP government's bribe of more spending freedom in return for cutting services to the people who elected them. That is the real story, and the council should not be allowed to continually obscure it by blaming the previous administration for its own troubles.
2

Brian M,

edinburgh 13/05/2008 12:03:17
Funding for arts at any level should not come from the city's taxpayers, especially at a "Scottish" level
3

Dragonlord,

13/05/2008 12:17:49
Ballet is eletist,those that want to see it can afford to pay to keep it running. Council tax payers should not be burdened with this cost.
4

Doh,

13/05/2008 12:25:14
1 Duncan

You lied about Iraq.
You lied about the 10p tax rise.
You lied about the council budget.

The council burn rates were way ovr budget and you know it.

Please stop your pathetic Labour lies.
5

Buggalugs,

13/05/2008 13:01:50
If the 40k was to bring Scottish Ballet into Edinburgh schools and community centres, and expose local citizens who may not have even thought about attending the ballet to what is otherwise considered an elite interest, then I think the Council has got its priorities all wrong. Edinburgh is a world cultural centre and all our citizens should be able to share in that - not just the well off, or the "elite" classes.
Then again, its just another example of how the working class in this city are being marginalised and erased from the consciousness of those in charge - who cares if some kids in Craigmillar or Wester Hailes never get to see or participate in "high" culture - its not for the likes of them, eh Steve? "Festival Czar" my a**e.!
6

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 13:06:38
Surely the answer then would be for Scottish Ballet to provide schools with free tickets to their productions
7

capy,

leith sur le mer 13/05/2008 13:14:36
prancing around pilton in a tutu or my roads fixed. no contest.labour spent the first 5/6 years blaming everything on the tories!!
8

Duncan in Edinburgh,

13/05/2008 13:16:29
#4 I have never lied about any of the three issues you claim I have. You're certainly right that the Labour government lied about WMD in Iraq, but what this has to do with Edinburgh Council I have no idea.

The Labour group in Edinburgh fully expected to be returned to power in a coalition with the Lib Dems. Do you really think that they would have left themselves a budget crisis?

I am sick of explaining this: the budget problems arose because the new councillors had no clue about reining in their departments, every department put in a claim for more money, and the wet-behind-the-ears newbies ran scared of their officials.

Labour wouldn't have done that. The failing is in the Lib Dems and the SNP (though the Lib Dems take the greater share - Dawe is an utter disaster for Edinburgh).
9

Edward,

13/05/2008 14:09:47
So upto now Scotish Ballet have been around all the Edinburgh Schools for the last five - ten years??
They have given preformances and workshops at each and every school in edinburgh??
I would like someone who has children attending an Edinburgh School to confirm that they have at least seen or had a visit from Scottish Ballet in the last year or so.
Somehow I think I should not hold my breath!
In addition Im amused at Duncan's remarks that Edinburgh's finances were rock solid sound, instead of the reality of being a basket case!
10

Edward,

13/05/2008 14:13:30
Malcolm Chisholm, Lesley Hinds and Ewan Aitken
The usual suspects, the latter two being a pair of free loaders out for themselves!
Labour group leader Councillor Ewan Aitken said that the funding for Scottish Ballet had been provided for decades to give ordinary people access to the arts
Thats funny I dont remember being enticed to go along and watch a performance of Ballet, I must have missed the invitations.
11

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 14:31:28
Chisholm said: "There are two keys aspects to arts policy – supporting excellent performing arts and making it as widely available as possible"

I fail to see why the council should be expected to fund the arts.

Let the arts community fund it by providing free admission for accompanied children.
12

Edward,

13/05/2008 15:25:56
Loves Labour Lost
Love it, Labour Lost
13

Edward,

13/05/2008 15:28:49
If the Labour councillors and MSP are being serious about this then it show a singlur lack in understanding basic money managment
If there isnt enough money you spend on the essentials. As labour overspent and made a mess its now upto the current administration to sort it out and manage it better
14

Duncan in Edinburgh,

13/05/2008 15:46:40
#13 No, simply repeating a lie doesn't make it true. Labour did not overspend. The Lib Dems and the SNP agreed to ridiculous overspends when they first came to power, and have been desperately trying to claw them back ever since.
15

Doh,

13/05/2008 16:04:32
#13 Duncan

Repeating Labour lies makes you a Labour liar also.

Labour lied about Iraq.
Labour lied about the 10p tax rise on the poor.
Labour lied about the council budget.

Here is a link to a report discussing the overspend in
Children and Families (under Labour's ruinous administration) -

http://cpol.edinburgh.gov.uk/getdoc_ext.asp?DocId=104240

Labour cant be trusted and are in denial of the facts.
16

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 17:14:56
#14 Duncan

When the SNP and Lib Dems "came to power" the budgets and spend for the financial year had already been agreed by the previous labour administration. It's only now that the SNP and LDs can try and haul back the profligacy of Labour
17

The Tin Man,

Over the Rainbow 13/05/2008 17:21:54
I don't think that Scottish Ballet is going to sink just because Edinburgh Council cancel a 40K p.a. grant, and I feel to see do this grant allows ordinary people access to the arts.

Anyway, I am sure that Cardownie is very happy the Kiev Ballet.
18

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 17:31:32
#18 Tin Man

Too true, the "Scottish" Ballet will not sink, just that they are miffed at not getting £40k for nothing.
19

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 17:41:26
and as for the "Senior Labour politicians" who will be stationed outside the theatre tonight, handing out leaflets, they really are scraping the political barrel in an attempt to create some sort of people's outrage over a mere £40k when labour have probably squandered millions in past years
20

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 17:42:53
I wonder if these "Senior Labour politicians" will be claiming some sort of attendance allowance or expenses for being there
21

Boy Wonder,

13/05/2008 17:57:05
With all the cuts, will Scottish Ballet now be forced to stage "Swan Pond"??
22

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 18:10:16
Why do we need to have "Scottish" Ballet (with a capital B) needing taxpayers funding?

Why restrict it to ballet?

Let's have "Scottish" Jive, "Scottish" Highland Dance, "Scottish" Sequence Dance, "Scottish" Ballroom Dancing, "Scottish" Ceilheidh (however ye spell it)
23

Moscow Central 42,

13/05/2008 18:37:29
4 DOH

What a load of rubbish you talk about the state of Edinburgh's finances. If the situation was half as bad as you suggest it was towards the end of the Labour Administration, don't you think the Accounts Commission would have been called in to investigate?
24

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 18:57:00
#24 And who would "call in" the Accounts Commission (whoever they are). And how do you call them in?
25

Moscow Central 42,

13/05/2008 20:05:02
25 Brian M

The Accounts Commission already has the statutory powers to scrutinise the finances of all local authorities in Scotland. In particularly dire circumstances the Scottish Government might well intervene directly. See the Accounts Commission website for information about how they actually operate. Hope this is useful.
26

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 21:43:25
#26

they have powers, but as you suggested in post #24 somebody has to call them in.

27

Brian M,

Edinburgh 13/05/2008 21:49:34
anyway, this is all about the so-called "arts" people not receiving money which they think they should from the citizens of Edinburgh just because they are "artists
28

iain morrison,

14/05/2008 08:42:33
5# Ballet as a working class issue!!?hahahahahahahahahahahaha. god joke.
If you go to any working class area i'm sure if you asked folk for a list of causes to give £40k, Ballet would not make the top 1000 if it registered at all.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.