Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Minister says 'judge for yourselves' in row over £80m hotel revamp



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 February 2008
MINISTERS said yesterday they were ready to publish all correspondence surrounding their involvement in an £80 million expansion plan for a hotel resort run by an SNP donor.
The Aviemore Highland Resort has been at the centre of controversy since it emerged that ministers met Donald Macdonald, the developer, shortly before environmental objections were withdrawn.

Sir Ken Collins, the former chairman of the Scottish E
nvironmental Protection Agency (Sepa), was yesterday reported to have claimed that ministers put pressure on his organisation to withdraw its objections.

But he later appeared to contradict himself when he said he did not know if ministers had been involved in the process.

However, Campbell Gemmell, Sepa's chief executive, said: "Our minister put us under no pressure to withdraw our objection."

As confusion mounted over the extent of ministerial involvement, Mike Russell, the environment minister, said he had asked parliamentarians for permission to publish correspondence on the matter, so "everyone can judge the issue for themselves".

The furore surrounds plans for a major redevelopment in Aviemore by Mr Macdonald's company, which owns the Aviemore Highland Resort.

Sepa raised concerns about possible flooding problems for homes in Aviemore if the 140-house development went ahead, and asked for a flood-risk assessment from the developer.

There was a delay which threatened to derail the development, and it was at this point MSPs got involved. Fergus Ewing, the SNP MSP for the area, along with other Highlands representatives, took up Mr Macdonald's case, worried hundreds of jobs might be at risk if the development was axed.

Mr Macdonald – who gave the SNP £30,000 last year – also met at least two ministers at the SNP conference last year, held at his firm's Aviemore resort. Alex Salmond, the First Minister, has also acknowledged he called Jim MacKinnon, the chief planner, over the issue, while Mr Russell contacted Mr Gemmell to raise concerns about the delay caused by Sepa's demands.

After ministers became involved, Sepa withdrew its objections, apparently before receiving the full flood-risk assessment from the developer.

In a letter to Mary Scanlon, the Tory MSP for Highlands and Islands, Sir Ken said Sepa had "unusually" withdrawn its objections over flooding concerns.

But asked if ministers were involved in the process, Sir Ken said: "I know as much as you do. No minister phoned me, and neither did the developer."

Mr Gemmell went on: "Our decision was made purely on environmental grounds."

TRUMP PLAN SPLIT PLANNING AUTHORITY

THIS is the second major planning issue to have caused problems for the Scottish Government since the SNP won the election last year.

Alex Salmond has been questioned by a powerful Holyrood committee twice over his role in the decision to 'call in' the massive Trump golf development in Aberdeenshire.

Donald Trump's plans were approved, then rejected, then backed by various bodies on Aberdeenshire Council before John Swinney, the Finance Secretary, called in the development, giving ministers the final say.

As the MSP for Gordon, Mr Salmond is the constituency MSP for the area which Mr Trump wants to develop and is on record as supp-orting the development. He has insisted he'd no idea the application would be called in.





The full article contains 541 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 05 February 2008 9:32 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

An Beal Bacht,

06/02/2008 01:29:28
Time for some discipline at Holyrood.
2

subrosa,

06/02/2008 02:07:40
The trump interview with Duncan McNeil will be on Holyrood Live at 10am this morning. I may just watch it for the entertainment value :)
3

donald,

glasgow 06/02/2008 07:36:26
Let's see the lib lab desperadoes make fools of themselves again.
4

Jeeemy,

St Andrews 06/02/2008 08:11:06
“Facts are chiels wha canna ding”
When did Sir Ken Collins leave SEPA?
When did Mike Russell the minister to whom SEPA are responsible to contact SEPA about their procrastination with the plans for Aviemore?
Now instead of clinging on to the New Labour (North Britain Branch) much produced and inaccurate hand outs; why can we not get some of the hacks and scribes who take monies on the false premise that they actually do work for this paper, get digging or is it just as easy meeting at the “Lords” watering hole and collecting the handouts.
5

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 06/02/2008 09:06:14
"
Mr Macdonald – who gave the SNP £30,000 last year – also met at least two ministers at the SNP conference last year, held at his firm's Aviemore resort. Alex Salmond, the First Minister, has also acknowledged he called Jim MacKinnon, the chief planner, over the issue, while Mr Russell contacted Mr Gemmell to raise concerns about the delay caused by Sepa's demands."

Looks like sleaze to me - developer's are not usually charitable idealists. If this man gave £30,000 to the SNP yoiu can be sure he wanted something in return. looks like he got it.

SEPA has never been an independent agency - it has always been filled by placement from wehatever party was in power.
6

Chris.J,

Edinburgh 06/02/2008 09:09:57
"Fergus Ewing, the SNP MSP for the area, along with other Highlands representatives, took up Mr Macdonald's case"

.... come on Scotsman tell the full story. It was a delegation of MSPs from ALL PARTIES including the Labour Party that approached the ministers.

"As confusion mounted over the extent of ministerial involvement"... Really? Where? Seems like journalistic smear by implication to me. The only confusion here appears to be originating from the hack's half truths.
7

Richard Lionheart,

06/02/2008 09:17:09
It seems that if you give £950 to Wendy A and you get to develop 2 shopping centres, Glasgow Fort and Silverburn!
8

Spicey,

Glasgow 06/02/2008 09:40:08
I find all the recent money for favours scandals, north and south of the border, completely unworrying. Procedures for declaration may have been broken, but if £950 could buy you influence with a national party then everybody would be at it! £30,000 is a much more substantial sum, but the point is that it has been declared, everybody can see it and therefore will keep an eye on any contace between this person and the government.

I think this goes to show how clean (in terms of bribes anyway) British governments are if this is the biggest scandal they can find at the moment. Same with cash for honours - were they all not found out by the selection panel before any of them recieved a peerage? ie the system worked?
9

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 06/02/2008 10:17:47
If you want your unionist party political propaganda dressed up as a news column then give it to Hamish.

Hamish find a job ye like.
10

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 06/02/2008 10:22:26
If there was anything at all to this story then it wouldnt just be in a column posted by Hamish the red but be on every national media broadcast in the UK.
Its amazing but our Hamish seems to get every exclusive anti Nat story before anybody else every time.
Where is his Pulizer?
11

Queen D,

Glasgow 06/02/2008 10:23:35
I WANT HONEST REPORTING.
IS THERE A NEWSPAPER IN SCOTLAND THAT I CAN READ THAT DOES NOT HAND OUT PROPAGANDA FOR THE LABOUR PARTY?
ANYONE?
12

Queen D,

Glasgow 06/02/2008 10:27:52
Just read an interesting article in the Press and Journal about Aviemore.
13

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 06/02/2008 10:43:39
An interesting article in the P&J...shurely shum mishtake :-)

So SNP steps in to save development & jobs in Scotland, at the behest of representatives of ALL parties....uhm, where's the sleaze again??!!
14

Rasco,

06/02/2008 10:56:13
Listening to the Trump on line at the moment by what I'm hearing Trump is going to ditch Scotland and head for Ireland.
15

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 06/02/2008 11:16:58
16

And who would blame him?
16

alanh,

ek 06/02/2008 11:25:16
it will be good to see all the correspondance from this.
It may aid the nu labour member that was at the meeting to remember why she was there again?

good to see this paper allowing comment on this story, surprisingly they dont give us the same right for the poor wee picked on wendy story tho as usual. Do you thin kl Wendy will be as open with us as the govt have been and fully publish her full question that she finally rememberred to ask about her many gifts towards her leadership campaign, even if it was over a month after it should have been declared anyway, and the full answer so we see fo9r ourselves
17

alanh,

ek 06/02/2008 11:26:51
not sticking to the innocent until prooven guilty line as you have on wendy over this AM2?
18

Rasco,

06/02/2008 11:30:47
This is a TRIAL not an investigation
19

Rasco,

06/02/2008 11:34:30
Its finished bye bye Scotland will be in Ireland soon I would like to see Wendy put through a meeting like this about her breaking the LAW.
20

Auld Twa,

Edinburgh 06/02/2008 11:45:42
We have just watched the Holyrood committee on the Trump application live and are horrified at the levels of antagonism and ignorance displayed by the members.
The chairman appeared to have lost his temper and was shouting at Mr Sorial after he said that it was his opinion that the committee was introducing more delay into the handling of the application.
If the Trump Organisation does not withdraw the application and take the investment to a friendly and welcoming country it will be nothing short of a miracle.
21

Spicey,

Glasgow 06/02/2008 11:55:26
personally i would like to see the correspondance between the scotsman and political parties - i'm betting quite a lot of stories come straight from Lab press releases with no actual investigation done.

Any chance of an inquiry into this?
22

S'me,

Edinburgh 06/02/2008 12:16:48
Grow up SNP... here we go...! I love it...
23

John south of Soutra,

06/02/2008 12:35:28
The way that we are carrying on with the Trump Organisation shows to the world that we are a lost cause, I'm sure the Irish will him chase away because some trumped up nonentities are on an ego trip.
Scotland the most forward looking country in the world - not if Nicol & his chums can help it
24

The west awake,

Argyll 06/02/2008 12:37:32
AM2

"Sir Ken Collins, the former chairman of the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (Sepa), was yesterday reported to have claimed that ministers put pressure on his organisation to withdraw its objections.

But he later appeared to contradict himself when he said he did not know if ministers had been involved in the process.

However, Campbell Gemmell, Sepa's chief executive, said: "Our minister put us under no pressure to withdraw our objection."

- C'mon AM, you suspect "shenanigans". Given these comments (in the Scotsman no less) you would have to believe the following;
1. That all correspondence relating to the issue can be discounted, even though all parties concerned are free to confirm or deny.
2. That the SEPA people concerned have been coerced into retracting statements, clarifying statements and issuing downright lies.

Possible? - I suppose anything is, probable? - No.

Alternatively, of course, the SNP could be doing what is apparently beyond Labour. That is, acting without pork-barrel, brown envelopes or other "rewards".

I truly believe the latter, you seem unable to even consider it.
25

subrosa,

06/02/2008 13:56:13
#6

So what? I meet a government minister most weeks, does that make any request I make to government sleazy?

It's actually laughable you mention Mr Macdonald meeting ministers at last year's SNP conference. Funnily enough I'd bet quite a few people met ministers then too.

Really you have no argument. Are you a councillor or ex union man?




26

subrosa,

06/02/2008 14:01:11
# 16

That's what I heard last week from a good source. It was part of the reason they decided to go before the kangaroo court. I'm sure you heard it being said "We had a much better reception at Stormont last week than we've had here today".

If anyone is to blame for this it's Duncan McNeil. Just dreadful behaviour from a chairman. In fact just dreadful behaviour from an elected member of our Parliament.
27

subrosa,

06/02/2008 14:07:52
# 23

The Trump organisation are in negotiations with Ireland. I expect you heard Mr Soriel saying "We received a much better welcome at Stormont last week than we have here this morning" or words to that effect. Last week I heard, from a reliable source, that the project is going to Ireland. Perhaps that is attributable to the Trump representatives changing their mind about attending the 'trial'.
28

Andrew D,

06/02/2008 14:45:45
If that development is lost (I'm hopeful it remains an "if") then the SNP should full tilt 100% aim the guns fair square publically at Labour and the Lib Dems and destroy them over it.

Mind you I think the Lib Dems in Aberdeenshire have pretty much achieved that end result there all by themselves.

Just imagine for one moment that Labour had got into power in the last election; this whole thing would have been sewn up by now, contracts signed and ready to go.

It's just become a political football (after political football) from the LibLabs who are just going all out to SPOIL. They don't care about Scotland; hell no! This is all about being anti-whatever-the-SNP-are-pro.
29

Rasco,

06/02/2008 14:55:27
Mr Soriel also said they have never been accused of sleaze in any other place and they have had no contact from one Nicol SLEAZE is he not man enough to say sorry I Wonder what he will say when Trump goes to Ireland.It was obvious to see that McNeil & co today were out to get Salmond and not interested in anything else.
30

,

06/02/2008 15:16:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
31

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 06/02/2008 15:58:16
I am sick to the back teeth of these unionist parties trying to hold Scotland back just to get at the SNP.

WE suffer thanks to their nonsense.
32

Andrew Allan,

06/02/2008 18:31:26
Considering that members of all the major parties in Scotland were pressing for this project to go ahead in the first place, how, even though the owner of the resort is an SNP donor, can anyone say the Scottish Government were acting in the interests of their own party, and not that of the interests of the country?
33

Andrew Allan,

06/02/2008 18:38:04
#39., Richard Taylor.
The only reason Scotland should worry on the number of those addicted to unionism, is the unionists idea of protection for the country on all things from beneath their own beds, with westminster as their blankets.
34

Shellfishfarmer,

Inverness 06/02/2008 20:22:42
Nobody has mentioned the fact that Ken Collins is a Labour Party man. Perhaps that explains his first response which he then couldn't back up.
35

Miss Jean Brodie,

06/02/2008 20:55:37
Open honesty - it’s something all unionist parties canny do !
36

juan kerr and his dead magic hands, now re risen.,

06/02/2008 21:14:00
Labour and their grateful appointed placemen in SEPA have olny highlighted one thing thru this affair. That the loss of power has lead to a house of cards and depserate measures. Scotland is secondary in their priorities. Self interest is the first.

They are acting in a manner which will damage Scotland long term, where ousiders will view us as uninvestable and a parliament that cares more about party point scoring than the future of Scotland.
37

Amaury,,

06/02/2008 21:18:35
apropos the budget

Lyrics:
TOMORROW BELONGS TO ME

The sun on the meadow is summery warm
The stag in the forest runs free
But gathered together to greet the storm
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me

The branch on the linden is leafy and green
The Rhine gives it's gold to the sea
But somewhere a glory awaits unseen
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me

The babe in his cradle is closing his eyes
The blossom embraces the bee
But soon says the whisper, arise, arise
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me

Now Fatherland, Fatherland, show us the sign
Your children have waited to see
The morning will come when the world is mine
Tomorrow belongs to me
Tomorrow belongs to me
38

,

07/02/2008 00:17:13
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
39

Jimmy the Pie,

07/02/2008 00:18:20
Another literary masterpiece by Hamish. You really are intent on making a complete fool of yourself.
40

,

07/02/2008 00:21:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.