Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


MacAskill faces MSPs' fury on court vote and Canada trip

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 May 2009
OPPOSITION parties are considering an unprecedented vote of no confidence in Scottish justice secretary Kenny MacAskill.
The minister provoked fury among many MSPs after he ignored a vote last week to set up a community court in Glasgow.

He also came under fire after new evidence emerged about a junket he took to Canada in January instead of attending a conference
at Holyrood on knife crime.

The Scotsman has learned that he turned down an interview with Canada's leading travel magazine, Travel Week, even though he was supposed to be promoting Scotland and the Year of Homecoming.

Labour, who discovered the information through Freedom of Information requests, said: "It is clear he only went to enjoy himself, not to promote Scotland."

However, the Scottish Government have said he had a full itinerary and met with a long list of leading Canadian officials and politicians.

In a statement to MSPs yesterday, Mr MacAskill claimed that the community court, which would have been a pilot scheme to deal with low level crime and speed up community sentencing, was too expensive because it would have cost nearer £1 million to set up than the estimated £750,000.

He warned that "in these difficult times" with £500 million coming off the Scottish block grant next year, the only way to pay for the new court was by cutting front-line services.

His statement drew a furious reaction from opposition parties who reminded him that on becoming leader of a minority government, Alex Salmond had pledged that the days of the executive "imposing its will on parliament" were over.

In a previous vote, the SNP had reluctantly agreed to fund £500 million for Edinburgh's trams because it commanded the support of a majority of MSPs.

Labour justice spokesman Richard Baker told The Scotsman afterwards that he and his party would support a motion of no confidence in Mr MacAskill.

"He just came up with the same excuses as last week," said Mr Baker. "This is not additional, as Mr MacAskill claimed, but essential for the progression of the justice system."

Conservative justice spokesman and convener of the Justice Committee Bill Aitken made a veiled threat in his response.

"We have lost confidence in the justice secretary on a range of issues," he told Mr MacAskill in the chamber.

Afterwards he said he was weighing up his options on a motion of no confidence, but he later suggested that the minister had one more chance.

Liberal Democrat justice spokesman Robert Brown branded Mr MacAskill's approach "a shambles" and said he should resign.

He added: "The Minister should be embarrassed to tell Parliament that the SNP holds its view in contempt."

During First Minister's Questions, Alex Salmond defended his colleague when Scottish Labour leader Iain Gray, mocked the minister for "making an official visit to a pub" in Canada instead of going to the knife crime conference.

Mr Salmond claimed that the responsible minister, community safety minister Fergus Ewing, was there.

He added: "The parliament should be ashamed of an opposition leader who treats one of the most serious subjects in society like this."

But a few weeks ago Mr Salmond, seemed to show he was losing confidence in Mr MacAskill when he gave responsibility for a bill on alcohol to health secretary Nicola Sturgeon. MacAskill's plans to set up a sentencing council has outraged judges who claim he is attacking their independence.

While politically embarrassing, a vote of no confidence would carry no weight unless two-thirds of MSPs voted for it, impossible if all SNP MSPs support Mr MacAskill.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 May 2009 9:37 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Politicians' expenses
 
1

The Creature from the Black Lagoon,

14/05/2009 22:35:52
I wonder who will go first?

Kenny Macaskill or Michael Martin.

Either way, both of them are finished.
2

The Online Scot,

Scotland 14/05/2009 22:44:00
"The Scotsman has learned ..."
... nothing at all and continues with an anti SNP agenda.

"Labour leader Iain Gray, mocked the minister ..."
Anything you say Mr Maddox.

These diversions aren't working, people have noticed Labour's intrinsic corruption.

Brown is finished and Labour are now in terminal decline, 22% in the UK polls and falling.

The independence referendum will be held and the Scottish people will have their say.
3

The Creature from the Black Lagoon,

14/05/2009 22:46:10
The Scotsman has learned that he turned down an interview with Canada's leading travel magazine, Travel Week, even though he was supposed to be promoting Scotland and the Year of Homecoming.
=======================================================

DEAR OH DEAR OH DEAR.

If the interview had've been about independence then MacAskill would have had all the time in the world to attend.

An absolute disgrace.
4

Jimmy Le Pie,

15/05/2009 00:19:19
Comrade Gray must be getting tired of clutching at straws.

Pathetic really but there you go.

7% and falling!!!!
5

Iainbroch,

15/05/2009 00:35:38
A wee ditty for you as well David

I am in particularly cruel mood tonight as Gerri has found out already!

Broonies Lament! Or his forthcoming resignation speech or perhaps Michaels Final words

They slowly passed an orphans home one day
And they stopped to watch the children play
Alone I was standing when they asked me why
I turned with eyes that could not see and began to cry

Im nobody’s child Im nobody’s child
Im like a flower just growing wild
No mommy’s kisses and no daddy’s smiles
Nobody wants me Im nobody’s child

Well you know the rest
6

Colin B,

Bearsden 15/05/2009 00:58:35
MacCaskill is hopeless- his only role is to make Hyslop look effective- he lets civil servants dictate policy- he's gone native on the trapppings of office - time for a taxi
7

Brianwci,

15/05/2009 01:09:06
Somehow or other I don't think MacCaskil's trip to Canada will be the main talking point down in the shopping centres or on the radio phone in's.

Gray was on form at FMQs but it was all lost in the Westminster maelstrom. He didn't lay a glove on oor Alex but he did make him work harder to avoid getting a slap.
8

Edward,

15/05/2009 01:52:02
Yet another attempt at smearing by Labour
You can tell its a smear, when its written (or is that copied?)by David Maddox
Labour are in dire straights and willnow do anything to divert attention from the corruption thats surrounding Westminster
9

Edward,

15/05/2009 01:55:25
The Canadian trip was no secret as Kenny McAskill a piece in a proper paper called the Observer
on Sunday 25th January.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/jan/25/canada-scotland-homecoming-scottish-diaspora
Funny how there was no howlsof indigation then, no calls for a vote of no confidence from Labour,but then again we didnt have Labour in the middles of the biggest scandal since its formation!
10

Edward,

15/05/2009 02:04:08
According to another quality paper, the Toronto Globe & Mail 'Kenny MacAskill, the Scottish Justice Secretary, met with LCBO officials in January to compare notes about dealing with alcohol abuse'
(LCBO=Liquor Control Board of Ontario)
Doesnt sound like a junket to me!
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/GIS.Servlets.HTMLTemplate?current_row=2&tf=tgam/search/tgam/SearchFullStory.html&cf=tgam/search/tgam/SearchFullStory.cfg&configFileLoc=tgam/config&encoded_keywords=murray+campbell&option=&start_row=2&start_row_offset1=&num_rows=1&search_results_start=1&query=murray+campbell
11

Edward,

15/05/2009 02:14:52
Kenny McAskill was also promoting the Homecoming and was interviewed on CFRB Newstalk (a News Talk station covering the greater Toronto and Hamilton area and is also linked to other News Tlk stations accross Canada)
As Labour dontreally like the Homecoming idea, they will state that this is a junket
http://www.cfrb.com/player/player?mediapath=&type=mp3&fi=files%2Fsrimedia%2FMacAskill%20-%20Come%20to%20Scotland%20Interview.mp3&nid=863064&
12

yockel,

15/05/2009 07:49:28
Kenny may be a complete waste of space but this is utter garbage. Only Grey could think he was making a point and only the Scotsman would report it as such. What next, Annabel with compulsory jail for playing the pipes?
13

BIG EYE,

Paisley 15/05/2009 08:25:50
Laboiur are unbelievable. They seem to think the guy who has presided over a record increase in the number of police officers in Scotland and a dramatic drop in crime in Scotland is a target!

McAskill's trip to Canada promoted Scotland and was a positive contribution...something Labour seem to find impossible.

Anyway not to worry there won't be many of them left very shortly. What will Mr Maddox do then will they still send him press releases for him to report verbatim when they are out trying to find new jobs?

This could take them some time!
14

SandyBottoms,

Edinburgh 15/05/2009 09:49:52
Keep your morals to yourself! Out with MacAskill!
15

smokey joe 1,

15/05/2009 09:53:51
Gray is pathetic.I cant realy add to that, but Im sure he knows how stupid he comes across st FMQ,s.
7% now that does surprise me,who are they ?family members mibee.
16

alanh,

ek 15/05/2009 10:05:35
I'm really surprised that this was not questioned or reported on at the time with lots of loverlee negative SNP stories/nu liebore sleaze and spin, north brittian dept, party's press releases in this "news" paper about it...............oooooooooooooops I forgot there was , silly me
As usual the greyman got tore a new butt hole as he tried to USE a serious issue to score some cheap political point
17

Clartmonkey,

15/05/2009 10:23:11
Interesting story. Good, blanced reporting DM.

When Spud Murphy was in China recently 'promoting Scotland' his trip did not include a single public or media event.

Rumour had it that he was visiting his 'second home for expenses purposes' in Shanghai, prior to flipping it for a bigger place in Beijing, and that the taxpayer picked up his travel costs as a result.
18

Clartmonkey,

15/05/2009 10:27:35
#13"What will Mr Maddox do then will they still send him press releases for him to report verbatim when they are out trying to find new jobs?"

I think it will be more like:

"Scottish government faces fury of Saughton inmates!"

The government of a newly independent Scotland came under furious criticism from a group of long-term Saughton detainees, led by Nigel 'Beefer' Griffiths...

etc etc, repeat ad nauseam...
19

neoloon,

Moray 15/05/2009 11:38:52
Re.MacAskill: I'm afraid this is just another attempt by the corrupt Labour party to tar everyone with the same stinking brush.
Sad but predictable.
Public confidence lies gasping amongst the dregs of Labour's slush-bucket.
Gardyloo!
20

Tartan Viking,

15/05/2009 12:53:41
Eck should ditch this guy. He is a liability.
21

Brianwci,

15/05/2009 13:20:15
Re.MacAskill: WHO?? Sorry, do you mind. I'm trying to keep up with the real news of SLEAZE, SLEAZE and MORE SLEAZE at Westminster.

MacAskill was on Government duty and let it be known in advance where he was going and why.

He isn't even on the fringes of the public radar much as the unionistas would love him to be centre stage to give their lot a 1 minute breather.
22

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 15/05/2009 13:56:26
It's like being savaged by a dead sheep.

Incidently, the level of journalism in this rag has hit a new low. No wonder Johnston Press are in such trouble.
23

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 15/05/2009 14:09:02
Good. It's about time MacAskill was booted out. Him and his categorically stupid, fantasy land ideas are an embarrassment to the SNP, the Scottish Parliament and Scotland itself.

Let's hope that Robison is hot on his heels too. Without that pair, the SNP will regain a great deal more credibility than they have now.
24

Alec M,

Falkirk 15/05/2009 14:31:49
Watching FMQs every week as I do, I am always surprised that the Presiding Officer constantly allows Gray to deliver a speech before putting each of his questions to AS.

He invariably sounds like a backward Primary 2 pupil trying to show off his reading skills to "teecher".
25

hoblar,

15/05/2009 14:44:37
Gray suffers from an inability to present himself with any oratory flair or even a half decent script with something pertinent and in the Scottish interest.

His weird delivery is irritating, and he is basically a nothing politician living in cloud cuckoo land where his party new labour are in a position to mouth off at others and he believes representing westminster is vital for scotland.

26

FLUB,

a rocky outcrop in eastern central Scotlan 15/05/2009 15:43:53
How does one define a junket? If an elected representative of the voting public attends, at public expense, a conference, or series of conferences, or meetings, whether in the next town or abroad, and while there is sufficiently polite to accept his host's hospitality after dealing with the business in hand, is that a junket?

Do the critics wish to see those same representatives decline hospitable invitations and closet themselves in spartan hotel rooms, eating only gruel and not watching the telly, with lights out at 9.00pm? Get real.

Labour - you're increasingly rapidly losing what little credibility you have left. Stop the baseless sniping, come up with some strategy to fill the void that will be left by your seemingly inevitable demise and get out and talk to voters about what they want, not what you think they need. Don't throw it away to the SNP.
27

Neil Waugh,

Old Strathcona 15/05/2009 15:50:33
Travel Week is clearly NOT "Canada's leading travel magazine."
Canada's doesn't have a "leading" travel magazine. So Kenny's alleged snub is a figment of somebody's fertile imagination.
And if the Get Kenny vote happens then what?
Does the government fail and trigger a general election?
ScotLab may not like what they're asking for considering the ongoing Westminster Sleaze Storm.
Kenny is as safe as houses.
I hope he enjoyed his pub visit.
28

LEAL,

15/05/2009 16:28:18
27,
I reckon people have more confidence in the justice minister than they have in Mr Gray.Especially when Mr Gray takes his orders from the London cesspool that is Westminster.
29

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 15/05/2009 16:29:13
#26:

It's probably just as well he wasn't at the knife conference. We were certainly far better off WITHOUT someone who would have argued than banning stanley knives from DIY stores would go some way to solving the problem of neds stabbing each other with flick knives.

MacAskill is a fool and the sooner he goes the better all round.
30

smokey joe 1,

15/05/2009 16:34:44
Ah Gray the london puppet who wants to deny the people of Scotland a referendum on independence.
I dare you Gray, go on I dare you.
31

Number 6,

Germany 15/05/2009 16:52:11
The wretched unionista detatchments at Holyrood have been in "Tasmanian Devil Mode" since day one of
SNP control. Reduced to hand wringing student politics, they remain a policy free zone.

Hopeless and incompitent, how dare they ask the Scottish people for their support.
32

Queen D,

16/05/2009 11:08:46
Another Labour /Maddox attempt to discredit anything the SNP does / does'nt do.

Failed again Mr Maddox et al.

P.S There's a wee problem down the road at Westminster , maybe you should try sticcking to that.
33

Skasia,

21/07/2009 08:56:33
What's wrong with a community court? Come on get with it.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.