Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Jack's legacy is the loser in the great game of politics

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 31 December 2008
HARDLY a day goes by without Alex Salmond launching yet another event to celebrate 2009, the Year of Homecoming. Indeed, so completely has the First Minister taken ownership of the issue that it is easy to forget that Homecoming was actually a Labour idea, pioneered by Jack McConnell's administration before the SNP came to power.
It was much the same with the battle to secure the 2014 Commonwealth Games for Glasgow. Mr Salmond flew to Sri Lanka to lobby Glasgow's case and celebrated when the city emerged triumphant last November.

Mr Salmond had indeed worked hard on this
issue in the run-up to the November 2007 decision, but a lot more work had been done in the months and years before that, much of it by Mr McConnell.

It was said at the time – and only half-jokingly – that if Glasgow won the bid Mr Salmond would claim the credit and if Glasgow lost, he would blame Mr McConnell.

Glasgow won, the new First Minister celebrated in Sri Lanka, while Mr McConnell was stuck back home in Scotland.

That, unfortunately, is the nature of politics. Electoral cycles move quickly and politicians make sure they gain what advantage they can, when they can, even if this means expunging the record of their predecessors as soon as possible.

But with the elevation of the SNP to the Scottish Government, this reversal of Labour's agenda has reached extraordinary lengths.

Every new administration has political priorities at odds with the government it replaces; that is accepted and, largely, understandable.

That inevitably leads to a reversal of party political policies in all the main fields, from health to transport.

However, there is usually an understanding across the chamber that the worthy, non-partisan initiatives pursued by one administration are carried on by the next, particularly if they were endorsed with cross-party support when they were introduced. This, though, does not appear to be the case any more, not if Mr Salmond's approach is any guide.

When he was Labour First Minister, Mr McConnell started a number of non- party programmes designed to improve Scotland socially and raise its profile inter- nationally.

All were worthy, non-controversial, well-meaning and widely supported, but all have been ditched by the incoming SNP administration.

They included: ProjectScotland, the youth volunteering initiative, a Scottish component at the international EXPO 2010 event in China, anti-sectarian summits and the Retired and Senior Volunteers Programme.

Each one of these has been halted, curtailed, axed or cut back, either by the withdrawal of funding or of ministerial support – which amounts to the same thing.

Every time a project of this sort has been axed, the reason given is different, from the need to avoid duplication to handing more control to local authorities. However, the effect in each case is the same – the ending of a non-partisan measure set up by the previous Scottish Executive.

There is no doubt that the Scottish Government is under much tighter financial pressure than its predecessor and ministers are looking to cut back on all non-essential funding packages.

But the combined effect of all these cuts is to make the Scottish Government look mean, simply because these are not political projects that are being cut but non-party programmes which MSPs of all parties support.

It also has the knock-on effect of burying Mr McConnell's legacy as completely as possible. That may have short-term benefits for Mr Salmond and the SNP but it is unlikely to do much either for relations between the two parties or the future of bi-partisan politics in Scotland.

China project ditched

EXPO, the worldwide global event that happens every four years, will take place in Shanghai in two years' time.

Expo 2010 is essentially a global forum, giving countries the chance to market themselves to the Chinese public, at all levels from tourism to business.

The Labour-led Scottish Executive decided to commit £500,000 for a specifically Scottish component in the British pavilion, which will be sited in one of the best locations at the event.

The Scottish Executive had made several deliberate attempts to establish strong links with China and had encouraged the teaching of Mandarin in Scottish schools to prepare young Scots to deal with the world's next economic super-power. Establishing a Scottish component in the British pavilion fitted in with that ideal.

When Alex Salmond's government came to power in 2007, however, that commitment was axed.

A spokesman for the First Minister said the new government did not believe in "duplication" and that where Scotland was already represented by the UK and where taxpayers' money from Scotland was already being spent, there was no need to do anything specifically Scottish.

Labour claimed that was an unusual argument, particularly as the Scottish Government has encouraged "duplication" in the United States, where Scotland has its own representation, alongside that of the Foreign Office, and in Brussels, where Scotland House is the Scottish Government's base in Europe.

The decision also drew a robust and dismissive response from Lord Steel, the Liberal Democrat peer and former Presiding Officer, who said he was "appalled" at the wasted opportunity.

Sectarian fight 'dropped'

ALEX Salmond used his maiden speech as First Minister in the Scottish Parliament to praise Jack McConnell for his work in tackling sectarianism – and then promptly dropped key parts of the initiative.

Mr McConnell started convening summits on sectarianism, bringing together church leaders from both sides of the divide in an attempt to eradicate "Scotland's shame".

He made other progress too, getting agreement to tone down and lessen the effect of marches and parades. But when the SNP came to power, much of this was dropped.

Stewart Maxwell, the sports minister, justified the move by saying that while sectarianism was an important problem for Scotland, it was no worse than other problems such as racism or obesity so should not be singled out for special treatment.

He said: "People would be quite cynical if we just carried on having summits. While it looks nice and gets on the news, I don't think it fundamentally tackles the problem."

The Scottish Government has continued to work on sectarianism on a broader basis, linking in with other forms of discrimination. But a number of recent high-profile incidents, including an attack on Celtic coach and former player Neil Lennon in Glasgow and controversy over a Rangers song about the Irish potato famine, have put the issue back near the top of the political agenda.

Mr McConnell spoke out recently to condemn Mr Salmond as "weak and complacent" for dropping his anti-sectarian summits.

The former first minister said: "A sectarianism summit would take half a day from his (Mr Salmond's] diary in the next 12 months and he refused to commit to any action to maintain the progress of recent years and end the appearance of complacency."

Volunteer vision doomed

THE Retired and Senior Volunteers Programme (RSVP) was part of the Community Service Volunteers initiative and was funded for three years by the Labour-led Scottish Executive, before the SNP came to power last year.

The RSVP had enrolled, trained, organised and supported 1,600 volunteers, who provided 64,000 hours of their time.

The scheme supported literacy programmes for children, services to patients, energy savings work, other mentoring, befriending and many other valuable initiatives.

Jim Mather, the enterprise minister, told parliament that local councils should take on the funding of this group from the Scottish Government.

But Labour politicians now claim the whole programme is "severely endangered" and will end in March next year unless transitional funding is found.

Richard Simpson Scottish Labour's public health spokesman, said: "The SNP seem content to put this hugely successful volunteering programme at risk. It was very clear Jim Mather simply did not understand that in ending funding in March 2009 the government has effectively told these volunteers that their time and efforts are not valued.

"These volunteers are simply too good to lose and everything must be done to continue to support these individuals who in turn support our communities."

A spokesman for the Scottish Government said: "Funding for RSVP was only ever due to last until March 2009 and it is right that decisions on future funding are now taken locally – this is in line with our concordat with local authorities which reduces ring-fencing and develops single outcome agreements and offers much more cohesion in the delivery of local solutions."

'Peace corps' shut down

PROJECTSCOTLAND was launched in the spring of 2005, with the personal backing of Jack McConnell, as a new volunteering initiative for the 16-25 age group. When it was created, it had cross-party support in the Scottish Parliament.

Based on successful volunteering projects from other countries, ProjectScotland was designed to provide youngsters with the life-changing experiences more commonly associated with the American Peace Corps or VSO, but at home instead of abroad.

It was meant to act as a bridge, linking hundreds of public and voluntary sector bodies to young people. Those who took part were given a subsistence allowance giving them the chance to move around a wide array of placements.

More than 2,000 young people took part in ProjectScotland before the SNP came to power. Then, ministers decided it should close. They started by cutting ProjectScotland's annual budget from £6.5 million to £1.4 million, or 75 per cent, reducing the places on the scheme from 1,500 to 420 a year and then announced it would come to a "natural end" when funding finished next year.

When he was asked to defend the Scottish Government's emasculation of ProjectScotland in parliament, Jim Mather, the enterprise minister, insisted: "We are not punishing ProjectScotland and we do not have a politically vindictive streak — indeed, very much the opposite."

But he added that ProjectScotland was not the only organisation which worked with volunteers and the Scottish Government had to spread its money around as effectively as possible.

He added: "Others in the field carry out similar activity and get good results."



The full article contains 1692 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 31 December 2008 10:41 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

webwise,

Scotland 30/12/2008 22:12:55
My goodness, bitterness simply oozes from this article.

"HARDLY a day goes by without Alex Salmond launching yet another event to celebrate 2009, the Year of Homecoming."

A capable First Minister who is articulate and clearly wants 2009 to be as big a success as possible, with Scottish culture in general and Burns in particular taking centre stage, a unionists nightmare.

They want brigadoon and nothing more, how dare this First Minister get too big for his boots and really promote Scotland and her people.

This is now two articles from this paper attacking the SNP through the homecoming, the cringe is alive and well - the homecoming should prove a good remedy.
2

,

30/12/2008 23:13:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
3

Jimmy Le Pie,

31/12/2008 00:06:10
What will you write about when your beloved New Labour Sleaze Party get wiped out at the next election, Hamish??

Or will you fade away with the Hootsmon into oblivion??
4

,

31/12/2008 00:21:37
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

yankey,

Edinburgh 31/12/2008 00:22:00

Let us not forget Jokes gift of the Ferry Contract to the Poles
Those ones under investigation for corruption
A friend of mine was in the audience when he spoke in New York wearing his black skirt on Tartan Day
He said it was the most cringe worthy speech he has ever heard
The man is so stupid he does not even know it

He should be in Africa out of harms way but for the fact it would cuase a byelection
And cause the scandel of his wife refusing to go with him wishing to remain in her vastly overpaid job for which she has no real qualifications or talent

6

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 00:24:06
And despite your objections Mr Fruitfly, I am going to comment that yet again we are not allowed to comment on the Gaza story.
7

,

31/12/2008 00:28:59
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

Marga,

Edinburgh 31/12/2008 00:29:23
Mr Macdonnell really can't have it both ways: Salmond is slated for "taking over" some Labour initiatives, then slated again for "axing" others. What's the problem?
9

,

31/12/2008 00:29:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

,

31/12/2008 00:30:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

,

31/12/2008 00:31:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
12

,

31/12/2008 00:38:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
13

,

31/12/2008 00:39:10
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
14

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 00:41:58
12 That's cool Traquir, I have always enjoyed reading your posts so got a bit huffy when you criticised me. Won't happen again.
15

,

31/12/2008 00:46:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 31/12/2008 00:50:58
Roll on the REFERENDUM on INDEPENDENCE in 2010. The result will be that SCOTLAND will be attending the 2012 OLYMPIC GAMES as an INDEPENDENT NATION in her own RIGHT. Now here is my question, what are unionist papers like this one, when the electorate has voted for a different direction, going to do with their reporting?????????
17

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 00:54:04
15 Hamas weren't voted in for no reason. It's all a horrendous tragedy. Can you imagine voting for nutters like them ? It's the Palestine experience that is driving them to this extreme reaction. And what Israel are doing is perpetuating it. I just wish someone would stop the world so they could all get off for a bit. And it's the innocents who die that matter. Perhaps we should just put all the aggressors in a field and let them get on with it.
18

Wardog™,

31/12/2008 01:00:46

This was a party political broadcast from the labour party

19

TheTerminator,

31/12/2008 01:03:53
The Worst legacy of Joke McConnell and Herr Kerr was the smoking ban but it's days are numbered.

THE 1ST WORLD CONFERENCE AGAINST PROHIBITION

"SMOKING BANS AND LIES"

IN THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT BUILDING 27/28 JAN 2009

http://www.antiprohibition.org/ticap_pages.php?q=6


20

Wardog™,

31/12/2008 01:10:01
2 Rufus-T-Firefly, 30/12/2008 23:13:43

Of the 71 school projects in 2008, 42 were financed through PPP with 29 procured through other means. These projects have been supported in large measure by the record funding, both capital and revenue, in the £34.7 billion local government settlement.

An average of six school building projects per month were completed in 2008.

That's over £2 billion worth of construction in Scottish schools under the SNP/.

Brick for Brick.

Including at least £1 billion of work underway on major construction projects where building commenced since Spring 2007 and Local Government identifying well over another £1 billion of investment in schools over the next 3 to 5 years, all of which is financially supported by the SNP Government

21

Dark Lochnagar,

Symington 31/12/2008 01:12:33
#2 HARDLY A DAY GOES BY WITHOUT RUFUS T SHITEFLY MAKING AN @RSE OF HIMSELF ONE MORE TIME. MAYBE IF MORE TIME WAS TAKEN LISTENING TO HIS TEACHERS AT SCHOOL, INSTEAD OF ANNOYING ADULTS WITH SERIOUS POINTS TO MAKE, HE MIGHT LEARN SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE.

By the way, what a non-story this is. This paper is getting really desperate.
22

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 01:21:33
19 No, one of the few success stories that Labour had. I'm a smoker, but I should not be allowed to pollute someone elses workspace (who doesn't have a choice) with carcinogenic smoke. We are not banned from smoking, we are just banned from forcing it on other people. Entirely reasonable, unless you are very selfish.
23

subrosa,

31/12/2008 01:27:48
'Retired and Senior Volunteers Programme.'

I remember when labour brought this in and thought that it would never work. I don't know where all these retired and seniors are getting this training but it's certainly not in the east of Scotland.

As for the suggestion of teaching mandarin in schools - I didn't know whether to laugh or cry at that one. At the time I thought Jock should be more interested in ensuring our children can read and write English and I still think that.

Oh dear, labour has been busy in their press office in the past couple of days, conjuring up all these wee stories.

Perhaps they would have been better off enrolling on a course for mandarin. After all they'll need employment somewhere in the near future.

24

Embra Don,

Temporarily in Dublin 31/12/2008 01:30:19
#21 Dark Lochnagar
Please ignore the Troll - then if he doesn't go away, he'll at least have to appear under another name.
You are right about the piece - presumably the remit is to find something to criticize the Government about. They are really scraping the barrel today.
25

Guga II,

Rockall 31/12/2008 01:35:54
Another black propaganda press release by the Hootsmon and its card carrying party member hacks on behalf of the New Labour Sleaze and Corruption Party (North British Branch).
26

Embra Don,

31/12/2008 01:36:13
Jack's legacy was destroyed when Gordon refused to allow him to disappear to Malawi. He has to sit around Holyrood, like Labour's version of Banquo's ghost, a reminder of their inadequacy.
27

Continental,

31/12/2008 02:12:49
#19 - the banning of smoking in public places in Scotland was instigated by SNP's Stewart Maxwell MSP.
28

TheTerminator,

31/12/2008 02:20:53
#22. A smoker brainwashed by the repeated lies.

#27. Stewart Maxwell's original proposal only covered places where food was served, it was Labour who bent to pressure from ASH Scotland etc. They had been working together since 1999 to get a smoking ban.
29

Conan the Librarian™,

31/12/2008 02:25:07
Rufus-T-Firefly

===========================================

Perhaps if you put some effort into...

...an original way of attacking SNP policies ...

...then we might put some effort into ignoring you.
30

Brian Hill,

Edinburgh 31/12/2008 02:42:56
Mr Macdonell, your article falls short on several points in its attempt to blacken the SNP.

1. It's far too long, even I couldn't be bothered reading it all and I'm interested.

2. You get into gripe mode far too quickly, most readers will be looking for other articles by the end of the fourth paragraph.

3. Your first sentence: "HARDLY a day goes by without Alex Sal-mond launching yet another event to celebrate 2009, the Year of Homecoming." indicates immediately where you are coming from, as if we didn't already know.

The use of the word Hardly has negative connotations in your sentence, also it's in capitals. The breaking of the name Sal-mond (no doubt claimed to be a typo)all subtle put downs.

And of course, all to no avail as a poll of polls for 2008 shows the SNP to be still ahead of Labour in the constituency vote and the regional list.

You and your colleagues are abusing your power on a daily basis, you don't even have an Iain McWhirter or Paul Hutcheon equivalent to write balanced articles.

Shame Executive Editor Bill Jamieson can't be as passionate about Scotland's Independence as he was about the Independence of the Bank of Scotland....
31

Warden An' All, Reborn,

31/12/2008 02:45:12
Sure didn't everyone already know that salmond's motto has always been: NO GAIN, NO CLAIM.
32

Ju@n Kerr - the ex labour sheep,

31/12/2008 02:48:04
Oh dear. I fear Hammish did not get his union jack underpants from his mum in England and is throwing a tizzy.

This article reaches the lower pits of bitterness, it positively oozes it. Wats with the "Alex Sal-mond" jibe?

22 ,fair play and good points.

33

Roy,

31/12/2008 02:53:26
My recollection is that, when the Commonwealth Games were secured, Salmond paid tribute to the work done by his predecessor - and the Unscotsman reported this. Another negative anti-Scottish rant from this rag.
34

Snuffy Ivy,

Aberdeen 31/12/2008 02:55:46
Yet another MacDonell- filler article.

What about a cartoon of similar length...at least that would get read all the way through!
35

JoeMiddleton,

Edinburgh 31/12/2008 04:13:32
Jack's sour attitude since the SNP win has shaped his ultimate 'legacy' but what does he deserve anyway? After all, all he was was a glorified glove puppet of Britain. McLeish was slightly better but even he showed his UJ underpants with his forelock tugging performance on the broadcasting commission.
36

,

31/12/2008 04:26:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
37

The Tin Man,

31/12/2008 06:35:48
Personally I quite liked Jack McConnell as FM, and at least he was able to build consensus and get things done. Creating divisions and getting nothing done is not the way forward.

Anyway, a Happy New Year to all, and all the best for 2009.
38

Navvy,

31/12/2008 06:52:43
Jack himself was quite a good guy but he was lumbered with his labour cronies and its 50 years of misrule
39

Colin Wilson,

31/12/2008 07:03:50
"Mr McConnell spoke out recently to condemn Mr Salmond as "weak and complacent" for dropping his anti-sectarian summits."

Perhaps the First Minister has had the sense to realise that Scotland does not, in fact, have a problem with religious sectarianism.

Scotland has a historic Roman Catholic minority in some areas of the north-west, such as Uist and Barra, Morar, Ardnamurchan, and the Small Isles. In the cities, there are Roman Catholic minorities with more recent roots from other countries, including e.g. Italy and Poland.

There is absolutely no friction whatsoever between any of the above-mentioned groups and the remainder of the population.

On the other hand, there IS a problem with people, who identify with one side or other of the ethnic conflict in Ireland, continuing the conflict by proxy in Scotland. Certainly, this is a very real and serious problem, and it needs to be addressed. However, is is NOT the same as sectarianism, and cannot be addressed properly by treating it as such, e.g. by involving church leaders. The conflict is an ethnic one, not a religious one.

The "Famine Song" is not a sectarian song. There is nothing in it that could apply to e.g. Polish or Italian Catholics. The song is simply anti-Irish.
40

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 31/12/2008 07:04:03
Hamish MacDonell is a purveyor of partisan Labour drivel.

He attacks the present administration about killing a few of Jack the Jokes pet projects, but barely a mention about the cuts in the transfer from Westminster.

Rather than call on the First Minister to spend on fringe programs, would it not be better to call on Westminster to stop punishing Scotland with transfer cuts because they don't like the election result.

500,000 pounds to stick a few Saltires on the UK pavillion at the Shanghai Expo is a complete waste. This money would not have caused any companies that were not planning on attending already to attend. The bulk would have been wasted on Politicians and Enterprise Scotland officials to have a jolly in Shanghai at taxpayer expense.

Sectarianism is not caused by the church leaders, we don't have Catholic/Protestant brawls on the streets of Scotland right after Church. It is the idiot congregations of the Old Firm that causes all the trouble. The Great Army of the Unwashed that follow those 2 teams never go in a Church except for Christenings, Marriages and Funerals. Its not the people in church who are the problem, its the morons in the football jerseys. Having church leaders chatting is not whats needed, but a kick up the backside for the SFA, UEFA and FIFA to get serious about this might help.

While encouraging people to volunteer is a great thing, these services are best organized and delivered at the local level. Why cant the organization of this be done by unpaid volunteers, rather than spending money on salaries for co-ordinators?

Project Scotland while also a worthwhile program was also expensive and duplicated efforts already undertaken in the volunteer sector. Perhaps Jack should be lobbying Westminster to Include Project Scotland in their plans for what they are going to due with all the young people they are trying to shift to Workfare, with no jobs on the horizon maybe they could be useful providing service to their commu
41

W U Merchant,

Aberdeen 31/12/2008 07:04:33
Another SNP shambles.
42

,

31/12/2008 07:11:49
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
43

caithness,

31/12/2008 07:14:36
Ummm.. I thought I was reading the Guardian for a moment. Maybe the Scotsman gets a backhander from Keir Hardie House?
44

The Tin Man,

31/12/2008 07:33:36
#43 Sir Viv

Ahoy. I haven't seen any pictures of McConnell recently, but perhaps a dysentery diet in Lilongwe may get him back in shape.
45

,

31/12/2008 07:48:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
46

Jimmy Le Pie,

31/12/2008 07:56:08
I see the hospital car parking charges are abolished from tomorrow.

Excellent news and another instance of Alex Salmond, the Scottish Prime Minister, and his SNP government putting the people of Scotland FIRST.
47

Faux Cul,

31/12/2008 08:00:17
I see that Brown is against Assisted Suicide.

Pity
48

Jimmy Le Pie,

31/12/2008 08:01:16
I should add that 3 hospitals built under the widely criticised PFI/PPP model will be charging for parking for the next 25 years.

I wonder which half wit signed these deals???

Bet it was the New Labour Sleaze Party involved though???
49

gus1940,

Edinburgh 31/12/2008 08:02:20
Pathetic journalism - an obvious rehash of a paper submitted by Labour.
50

For Scotlands Future,

Vote for the SNP 31/12/2008 08:07:19
Don't worry Hootsman reporter, Hurricane Jecks Legacy is just fine. In fact there are a few:
"Education, Education, Education"
"The Best Wee Country in the World"
Being so bad that The Labour Party thought Bendy Wendy would be better.
Kirsty Wark.
Having Westminster run his 2007 Holyrood Elections.
Having English MP's campaign in a Scottish Government Election.
Being known as the last First Minister of the Scottish Executive.
Having to have Wee Nicol as his Deputy First Minister.

Aye, don't worry, we'll remember you fine Jeck.
51

,

31/12/2008 08:10:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
52

,

31/12/2008 08:12:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
53

Edward,

31/12/2008 08:47:32
This article reads as a bitter tirade against Alex Salmond written in the wee small hours after a few too many G & T's
54

Edward,

31/12/2008 08:51:31
Cant find any article in today's Scotsman about Car Park fee's ending in Scottish Hospitals, but reported elsewhere
55

bully wee alba,

Edinburgh 31/12/2008 09:12:41
I read somewhere recently that the most popular name for male babies in 2008 is “Jack”, and this has been the case for the last 15 years.

To be fair it was not clear from the article if this statistic pertained only to England & Wales or whether the same has been true in this country.

Be that as it may, but perhaps there we have the real legacy of Wee Joke.

Hundreds of wee Jacks mincing about, self consciously modelling their pin stripe skirts in the mistaken belief that they are wearing a kilt.

I wonder how many bemused looking New York taxi drivers we can find to stand in the background when they get their pictures taken?
56

Rony,

Fiife 31/12/2008 09:17:31
Any chance of some serious journalism instead of labour propaganda and vitreol aginst the SNP?
57

Dr. James Wilkie,

Vienna 31/12/2008 09:29:00
It was Jack McConnell's Executive that effectively sabotaged the plans for schools of Scottish Studies in Vienna and Budapest universities by refusing official support, although both institutions were very keen to have them and personnel as well as finance were available. Indeed Scottish Studies had been running for two years in Vienna with high success on a provisional basis, and was intended to be a reciprocal for the departments of Austrian Studies in Edinburgh and Aberdeen universities, which are financed by the Austrian Foreign Ministry. Reading between the lines of the reply that the Executive "has no plans to provide support for Scottish Studies in foreign universities", I am certain that the decision was taken in London, not Holyrood. Now that personnel has been dispersed, and finance is no longer readily available, the damage will not be easily made good.

58

Queen D,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 09:33:37
I am quite fond of wee Jack, I did rather think he would cross the floor at some point particularly as his beloved Arran voted SNP.
But I suppose there are many who can be bought with the promise of a peerage , I just hoped he would'nt be one of them.
I hope he thinks long and hard about the company he'd have to keep in the House of Lords.After all they fiddled the books to get the Child Catcher a peerage.
59

mr angry,

Ayrshire 31/12/2008 09:57:51
#38. Tin Can , you don't half write some rubbish , what exactly did he get done. He sat about waiting from orders from Brown, he was useless, jsut as Labour are for Scotland. Open your eyes.
60

Mikey,

31/12/2008 10:48:25
Hmm, no more article. Was it that bad????
61

MoClana,

31/12/2008 10:54:58
When it all falls quiet over the holidays, the Anti Scottish party (formerly known as Labour)get their scripts ready and their poodle journalists print and ochestrate their lies.

Ian McMillan - in his new years speach blames recession on Scottsih Goverment - desperate lies but printed in the Scotsman.

Brown - likens recession with world war 2 - disgraceful comparison and an insult to all who fought and died - the Scotsman again obliges.

Hamish McDonnell - spews yet more anti Alex Salmond / Scottish Goverment nonsense and wants us to remember static Jack with affection? - Scotsman gives the license to print.

Roll on 2010, its time to see an end to those in Scottish Society that work to counter the aspirations of our country and its people.

Soar Alba



62

Alex,

Ellon 31/12/2008 11:01:34
It would have been beautifully ironic the wee Joke would have come home from Malawi if election jitters had not got in the way..bah !
63

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 11:39:32
Hello fruitfly, got me deleted at 4. Keep on keeping on dear I'm not about to go away, catch you later.
64

,

31/12/2008 11:44:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
65

Goat Laybah,

This week Tashkent 31/12/2008 11:52:07
Jhoke McConnell's greatest achievement?

Surely, being able to get the recession off the front pages in favour of the 'Hokey, Cokey' and 'Bigots under the Bed'. Of course, for this, he required the help of the Hootsmon and BBC Scotland as well as the friends of the West of Scotland Labour Establishment (Celtic Park Branch)The Herald, The Sun and The Daily Record. What is it about denominational schools that makes their 'graduates' so suited for work in journalism?
66

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 31/12/2008 11:52:45
Hamish is treading on very thin ice here. This article is politically driven by his personal beliefs.

To assert the following is plain stupid:

"However, there is usually an understanding across the chamber that the worthy, non-partisan initiatives pursued by one administration are carried on by the next"

This may already have been said (I havent read the comments yet) but for a start the parliament has only been in existence for 10 years which is sufficiently short a time to mean that there are no long-standing "conventions"

Hamish also, stupidly in my opinion, forgets that up until this Goverment took power we only ever had a LabLib one which obviously would carry forward with its own projects.

Duh !
67

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 31/12/2008 11:55:56
#5 Yankey

I'm not surprised that Bridget doesn't want to go with him and its not just because of her job !

I assume you recall his first press conference on becoming FM??
68

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 12:12:43
70 I gave Rufus a mention at 4 - pointed out that he had been slagging off the homecoming big time, as he obviously didn't realise it was originally wee Joke's policy. He doesn't like criticism it seems, I would rather he was out in the open about it 'though.
69

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 12:23:16
73 I don't object to Joke that much, but his wife is a different matter. This will be deleted, but what the hell. She tried to set up the SNP Councillor Billy Mcallister by claiming that he had been aggressive and abusive to her. She gave it the full works,poor little me this big bad man shouted at me, what the silly cow didn't realise was that the whole thing was on CCTV, which proved conclusively that Cllr Mcallister did nothing wrong - she had lied. Now in my book that is gross misconduct and she should have been sacked, but no, the establishment all crowded round and Bridget is safe. And as for Chirnsyde - well google it yourself. She protects gangsters. Just like the Martins do, father and son. I'll probably get banned now - Happy New Year to all.
70

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 12:27:59
73 also, for any gossips who are interested, Bridget got her own back, in a like minded way. She was notorious for it. Sorry, but I just don't like the woman. She's bad.
71

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 31/12/2008 12:33:10
#76 Observer

Now that you are almost certainly banned, please spill the beans on how Bridget got her own back.

Happy New Year to all.
72

­­,

31/12/2008 12:34:42
40 Colin Wilson,

Absolutely correct, the factions that practise and perpetuate this obscenity have long since ceased to be the Churches or bona-fide practising Christians.

Or for that matter, people with a current or historical connection with any part of Ireland, rather initiates of the pre-pubescent rite of passage devised by the founding fathers, who bonded their prejudice and hatred to two Glasgow Football Teams.

Unfortunately the graduates of this cult are in the main fairly contented and secure, behind their emotional barricades and are more numerous than most would care to acknowledge.

Even those who eschewed Religion and faux-Northern Irish/Weegie Tribalism decades ago, for different reasons, are never truly free of it.

The default designation of a "Rangers Supporter", remains in my mind **Brainwashed Numpty, and Anti-Scottish BA$$tard**, until proven otherwise.

WHY?

Because while still aged in single digits, I was approached by a "Press Gang" who demanded to know what "Team" I supported...The truthful answer was not acceptable, I had to choose between Rangers or Celtic - Good and Evil - A pat on the back or a punch in the face.

Having had no indoctrination at home on the subject...How the hell was I supposed to know that kids from Non-denominational Schools were supposed to support Rangers?
73

Nebulous,

Aberdeen 31/12/2008 12:37:16
One of the biggest criticisms of Scotland from external sources has been that we are held back by the size of the public sector. The SNP have shown real intent in tackling this, right from the start and taking a lead themselves when AS reduced the number of ministerial posts. This article is highlighting more of the same- which I am more than happy with.

One of our biggest faults has been that we turn everything into a talking shop; a grant here, a summit there a new quango every third Wednesday in the month. If the SNP are showing leadership and actually taking action on some of these issues instead of just creating more jobs for their supporters as Labour did then so much the better.
74

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 12:38:08
76 Come on connaughtboy do you need me to spell it out ? She was anybody's. Now I am banned.
75

Hugh Roscombe,

31/12/2008 12:41:41
80

Obviously I'm talking about a different person here, but there was a woman who after one drink was anybody's and after a few she was everybody's.
76

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 31/12/2008 12:41:44
#80 Observer

I wanted the gory details !

On the other hand, maybe not all of them......
77

Hugh Roscombe,

31/12/2008 12:42:02
... but I shouldn't talk about my gran like that.
78

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 31/12/2008 12:42:22
#81 :)
79

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 12:45:09
She made a pass at Mr Observer once, I am glad to say he was horrified.
80

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 12:46:51
Anyway happy new year to you Hugh and connaughtboy before I disappear.
81

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 31/12/2008 12:48:02
And all the best to you too Observer.
82

fair scunnered,

edinburgh 31/12/2008 12:50:07
funny the hootsmon used to support the fib dems,so what changed it,did someone slip between the sheets with the pink lord,and were promised a knighthood?
labour has always been like an octopus,tentacles everywhere
run a group in your area,and get good publicity,BANG its filled with labourites,and they put in charge one of their own
when cash iregularities appear,merge with another group and Woof the books disapear faster than a tramp at a free food day
edinburgh sucks dot com is always giving the scotsman pelters along with labour councilors getting caught out
its alway s been jobs for the boys with labour
now jack mcconnels feeliong what sean connery went through when donald dewer and cohorts tried to shaft him out of a knighthood
83

Foresight,

By the Water of Leith 31/12/2008 12:50:14

#74 What do you think !!

R rusty
U unionist
F forging
U unsustainable
S socialism
84

Hugh Roscombe,

31/12/2008 12:50:26
Happy new year Observer. I'm back to escocia in the middle of January for a month so I'll be a non-posting poster. All the best.
85

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 31/12/2008 12:56:00
#90 And a happy homecoming year to you Hugh.
86

Tris,

31/12/2008 12:56:52
Hardly a day goes by without Mr Brown spouting some pious nonsense about his moral compass and being the son of the manse. Hardly a day goes by without him telling us how he saved the world and how the financial crisis started in America and spread to France, etc, etc, etc, and then, "because no country can escape" bla, bla, bla, it has arrived in Britain. Hardly a day goes by without some stupid Labour minister proposing a total waste of time initiative. Hardy a day goes by without the MoD or another government department in England losing a laptop, mobile, memory stick or some other vital piece of information. Hardly a day goes by without the value of the pound dropping farther against the hated Euro.

And NEVER a day goes by without me wishing fervently that we could get Scotland out of this awful union.
87

Queen D,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 13:16:23
Might I make an addition to your " wish list " Tris?
Hardly a day goes by when a Scottish " quality" newspaper attempts to play political opposition to the party voted for by the Scottish people.
Hardly a day goes by when I am not offended by a biased BBC and media in general.
Hardly a day goes by when I do not wonder what happened to the mighty Herald and its great balance.
Hardly a day goes by when I do not question the voting public who can see the demise of the UK ,can see the incompetents in Westminster and yet still stick a cross at the labour candidates name.
88

Darien,

Panama 31/12/2008 13:19:54
Best wee country
Best wee kilt
Best wee puppet
Best wee Malawi governor
Joke McFlannel, like all New Labour wasters, will be remembered for nothing but the above.

All Scots-British Nationalists ("I'm British & Scottish") are a waste of space to Scotland.
89

,

31/12/2008 13:33:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
90

Observer..,

Glasgow 31/12/2008 13:41:59
Union is best - you have forgotten the magnificent economic wizardry of PFI, shortly to be revealed in April next year.

Happy New Year.

91

,

31/12/2008 13:52:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
92

Billiam Wallace,

31/12/2008 14:28:10
Bwahahahahaha!!! Wee Joke McConnel's legacy damaged! Was he in a crash? I didn't know he drove a Honda Legacy. How can you damage a legacy that was even a joke when he was first puppet-minister? The kilt photo pretty much summed up this useless twonk. The only useful thing he ever did was get thrown out. Agree with all the anti Joke comments above and pray that we can move on and really see a brighter, independent future very soon without these utter numpties keeping us back. I can't agree with anyone feeling sympathy for the wee trough snuffler nor hoping that he would cross the floor as no true Scottish administration with our best wishes in mind would have anything to do with such worthless parasites.

A guid New Year tae ain an aw!

Alba Gu Brath
93

Hugh Roscombe,

31/12/2008 14:28:11
Feliz año nuevo a todos.
94

Hugh Roscombe,

31/12/2008 14:28:24
100
95

,

31/12/2008 15:07:02
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
96

bumpkin,

31/12/2008 15:08:54
jack mcconnel is remembered fondly by the hundreds of tenant farmers who have purchased their farms after he brought in the right to buy in 2003.
Others have benefited greatly,as improvements are now harder for the laird to steal, and rent reviews are less one sided.
Unfotuneately, jack started a war between landlord and tenant, which still rages in the land court and court of session, as mass evictions of insecure tenants continue, reminiscent of victorian times.
This war needs to be ended ,with the absolute right to buy( not steal).
Jacks father was summarily evicted from the family farm/home on arran some years ago, hence his personal interest in the subject. Come back jack, and finish the job.
97

Westfield Bairns,

falkirk 31/12/2008 15:16:10
Nulabour Press release from their official partner The Scotsman.
Wee Joke McConnell couldn't wipe his e*rse without first phoning London for permission and we are all going to be paying his PFI for about 30 years,cheers
98

,

31/12/2008 15:24:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
99

,

31/12/2008 15:33:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
100

Faux Cul,

31/12/2008 15:34:48
#90
Hugh Roscombe,
31/12/2008 12:50:26

And I will be back in Fife, Edinburgh and Glasgow the first two weeks of February.

I may seek out the new Herald offices and tan in a few windaes.
101

,

31/12/2008 15:36:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
102

Hugh Roscombe,

31/12/2008 15:44:14
Faux Cu (for it is he)

I'll be around Stirlingshire till mid Feb.
103

,

31/12/2008 15:44:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
104

Faux Cul,

31/12/2008 15:53:20
And on The Adam Smith Website a quotation from Tony Bliar that should rattle the analbicusp of The Mad Hatter Broon

"It is true that we had ten years of record growth when I was prime minister. I have, unfortunately, come to the conclusion that it was luck."

http://tinyurl.com/8xwybc

So Broon has been fibbing all along, as if we didn't know already

Nice year ending for The Snotgobbler.

Cheer up, things can only get better, can only get wetter, can only get deader, can only, can only
105

,

31/12/2008 15:58:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
106

Faux Cul,

31/12/2008 16:05:36
108
Hugh Roscombe,
31/12/2008 15:44:14


Buy you a beer in Edinburgh then?

Train in and train out from Ladybank. No drivee when on swalleee.
107

Faux Cul,

31/12/2008 16:07:37
Havin a wee swallee noo

A 1997 Bourgeois Bordeaux.

Real stuff after the bells.
108

Darien,

Panama 31/12/2008 16:19:47
Best of British to the remaining Scots-British Nationalists in 2009. You'll need that 'Dunkirk' spirit (sic).
109

,

31/12/2008 21:14:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
110

FrancesP,

01/01/2009 02:57:48
So we're going into 2009 and what do we get? A eulogy to the dubious legacy of the man who ceased to be First Minister in May 2007. That's logical.
111

lulach mac gille coemgain,

01/01/2009 20:12:40
What if yer hungry and homeless?
112

Elizabeth I (1558-1603 AD),

edinburgh 01/01/2009 22:40:00
Happy New Year to you all. Scotland, please grow up and remove one's chips from one's shoulders. If there is an AJ Fife in your area don't be a sheep and follow the flock and agree with his/her views for the sake of it, stand up for your own individual opinions.
113

Eve,

Scotland 02/01/2009 16:12:08
ProjectScotland is my bane, I've been looking for a voulentry placement for well over a year now. And project Scotland discrimeinates against thoes of us over the age of 25. Making it more difficult for thoes of us who are over 25 to voulentry.

Is that really Jacks fault? So he's the person who I should complane to about my difficulties.
114

Eve,

Scotland 02/01/2009 16:40:51
Noone said that Jack did do anything that was good or anything helpfull.

For the way I see things it appears it's the thing he wanted to do but held him self back because he had to lisen to the labour party parents in London and do what they say, while tossing what the people of Scotland want out the nearsts widow or bin. That Jack gets critaseed for.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.