Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 30th August 2008

RBS Ambassador, Luke Donald

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Holyrood to fund trams rebate



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 May 2008
FINANCE Secretary John Swinney has promised to fund most of the cost of a rates relief scheme for shops hit by the tram works.
Council chiefs are understood to be on the verge of offering to waive all business rates for traders who prove they are suffering hardship because of the disruption.

And Mr Swinney confirmed the Scottish Government would meet 75 per cent of the co
st of such a scheme.

Shopkeepers along the tram route have complained their takings are being badly hit by roadworks. Traders in Leith Walk and Constitution Street have claimed they are losing up to 90 per cent of their incomes.

And two shops at the West End said they were forced to sell up after Shandwick Place was shut for the tram works.

Currently, lump sum compensation packages of up to £4000 are available to some traders and a 20 per cent reduction in rateable values has been agreed for businesses with an RV below £28,000.

But earlier this month council officials were ordered to investigate the possibility of 100 per cent rates rebates.

The issue was raised in the Scottish Parliament by Edinburgh North & Leith Labour MSP Malcolm Chisholm, who highlighted the "severe hardship" being suffered by traders.

Mr Chisholm wanted to know whether the Government's 75 per cent contribution was automatic or subject to ministers' discretion.

He said: "If relief is not granted it may well be some traders will go out of business altogether."

But Mr Swinney told MSPs: "If the city council comes to the Government with such a proposition, the Government is duty bound to provide 75 per cent assistance.

"The test for hardship relief is a very clear test which the assessor and the council must consider and the Government will act accordingly."

Mr Chisholm called on the council now to go ahead and implement the relief scheme.

He said: "That's the biggest help business could get," he said. "Reducing the rateable value is making a small difference and the lump sum grants are only going to certain businesses, but this is the action which can help everyone."

Mr Chisholm said in the long term, businesses as well as residents would benefit from the £512 million tram scheme.

But he said: "That doesn't take away from the fact there are short-term difficulties which have to be addressed."

SNP Lothians MSP Shirley-Anne Somerville called on TIE to use a £96m contingency fund currently earmarked for infrastructure overruns to help businesses affected by the trams works.

"That would go some way towards making amends for the inadequate compensation package put in place by TIE and the previous Labour administration."

Council leader Jenny Dawe said a report on the matter was due at the next council meeting on May 29.

She said: "We have been listening to the concerns of traders affected by tram works and are keen to do all we can to help them through this difficult period. The 100 per cent rebates scheme is perhaps one way to ease the situation."





The full article contains 511 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

JulesF,

16/05/2008 12:07:35
I'm pro SNP and Anti-Tram and I'm extremely annoyed at this.

Whilst I feel for the shopkeepers I am reminded that John went on record as saying no more money for trams from this government.

I believe the Council and TIE should be funding this.
2

Mr H 2u,

Embra 16/05/2008 12:28:38
"FINANCE Secretary John Swinney has promised to fund most of the cost of a rates relief scheme for shops hit by the tram works."

Very nice of him, but he must be getting paid too much if he can pay for this. Eh? What? Oh!

I'm paying for it! That was nice of me. Barstards.
3

Auld Twa,

Edinburgh 16/05/2008 12:40:03
This scheme was supposed to be planned and costed when it received approval to go ahead.
There seems to be a number of areas that were not all that solid at that time.
Will TIE keep a note of the true cost of the service even when it is subsidised from the Scottish Government ?
4

Arrow,

edinburgh 16/05/2008 13:36:08
as this is going to the shopkeepers perhaps Mr Finney is keeping his powder dry for when the Council/TIE ask for some more money and deduct the cost of this exercise from the wish list.
beware of what you wish for you might just get it!
5

The Judge,

16/05/2008 13:37:34
Second reason in the week not to vote SNP in the next series of elections, well done John. Like all career polticos they promise the earth whilst in opposition but break their promises the moment they are elected. I had high hopes for the new SNP government, turns out they are exactly the same as the rest of them.
6

,

16/05/2008 13:44:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

NorT,

Edinburgh 16/05/2008 14:01:28
#1 - I agree. The SNP government said there would not be any more money for the trams then they agree with this. Tie and CEC should be paying for the damage they are causing not the whole country. John Swinney would be better spending the money on improvements for the A9.
8

antifa,

16/05/2008 15:04:03
"Do we ever get businesses splitting their profits with us when they enjoy the good times ? No."

Yes, we do - it's called taxation.
9

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 16/05/2008 16:11:49
'NOT A PENNY MORE' (David 'Taxi for' McLetchie)(and all the rest of the Pretendy Parliament)
How do you tell when a politician is lying?
Easy - his lips move.
10

Jwil,

16/05/2008 16:15:49
Mr Chisholm doesn't sound very grateful for the government's offer, but I am sure he will be taking the credit for it.
11

Miss H,

16/05/2008 16:37:53
He is not putting any money into the trams project. And given that the Government has already slashed business rates for small businesses I doubt this will cost very much money.
12

Gorgie_Tony,

Edinburgh 16/05/2008 16:41:05
No surprises from the SNP - promise one thing in the run up to the election - then do the exact opposite. Salmond and co are nothing but liars - roll on the next election.
13

Megan H,

16/05/2008 17:11:27
"But Mr Swinney told MSPs: "If the city council comes to the Government with such a proposition, the Government is duty bound to provide 75 per cent assistance.

"The test for hardship relief is a very clear test which the assessor and the council must consider and the Government will act accordingly."

Seems to me that the SNP government is operating under the rules and will out pay out if the normal criteria is met.

Contrary to Gorgie Tory's statement the SNP government keeps it's promises. Remember it was Labour, Tories and LibDems who voted through the trams
14

JulesF,

16/05/2008 17:45:27
#13 Having just re-read that you have a fair point.
15

Sanny,

16/05/2008 17:57:23
13Megan H
Your point is well made megan. What a pity that the article could not have drawn attention to it. Once again the SNP prooves to be a government of its word and law.
16

Euan,

Edinburgh 17/05/2008 00:03:11
If this whole disgraceful tram project was to be scrapped NOW there would be more than enough money to compensate all the businesses that have suffered financial hardship, enough money to put this fine City back to normal and more than enough money to spend on far, FAR more worthwhile and beneficial transport projects across the whole of Scotland.

It's just too bloody obvious though, isn't it??
17

Gorgie_Tony,

Edinburgh 17/05/2008 01:10:55
#16 - the SNP allowed this fiasco - those that said in their election manifesto they were to scrap the tram project. Were you old enough to vote at the last election? If so - did you vote SNP? If you did vote for them you should hang your head in shame - you made your bed - now lie in it.
18

Leila,

Edinburgh 17/05/2008 01:53:33
#17: I really wish I understood where you're coming from on this. The SNP were the ONLY party to oppose the trams in their manifesto. Quite a lot of people voted for the SNP - many of them presumably because of the SNP's opposition to trams. The SNP were subsequently put in a position by Labour and others where it was either go along with trams or submit to a vote of (no) confidence. So they decided they had to go along with trams. How can any blame for that unanticipated outcome rest with those who voted for the SNP? How can you possibly claim that "if you did vote for them you should hang your head in shame" when those who voted for the SNP on the trams issue did so in good faith?
19

rs,

they've made of the Finances !!!! 18/05/2008 09:16:13
talk about back pedalling

Tony....theres was a democratic vote to scrap the trams, love them or hate the project as I do, thats democracy.

But this MASSIVE U turn, if confirmed , John Swinney should either fund this personally or resign.

Why should the Scottish Taxpayers, the Majority who will never be in/on a tram be paying for a MISMANAGED project in Edinburgh....
...The is Already OVER BUDGET and months behind.

Years if you take the original road closures PROMISE.

That Tramworks would be more more than 200m in length.

Remember Princes Street is to close for 6months, opposed to 200m tramworks taking 18 months as planned.

The Project is turning into another Holyrood.!!!!!!
20

rs,

in ma house 18/05/2008 09:18:01
SNP Lothians MSP Shirley-Anne Somerville called on TIE to use a £96m contingency fund currently earmarked for infrastructure overruns to help businesses affected by the trams works

could someone tell us were this £96m has suddenly come from.

Have they employed Paul Daniels!!!
21

jtdx,

22/05/2008 07:39:43
If the businesses get a rebate during the works they should agree to pay it back if their business increases when the Trams start running.
22

Geekazoid,

Willowbrae 25/05/2008 17:36:48
Surely the rebate should be coming from the people causing the disruption. Do I get a rebate? After all, Time is money and the city centre works are adding half an hour a day to my east-west commute.
Which I wouldn't be having to do if the politicians had kept their promise to fund my sixth year courses, and build me a new school.
23

celtic4,

USA 02/06/2008 00:50:33
Another instance of a whole lot of cash. Who is going to pay for it? Scotland? England? Where does all this dough come from? Taxation? Woe is me.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.