Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Gerri Peev's Glenrothes by-election blog



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 05 November 2008
ONLY Alex Salmond would be audacious enough to hint that perhaps the Obama team pinched his slogan.
For the last couple of days, the SNP has been trotting out the "Yes We Can" phrase.

The First Minister insists that the party used it in 1997. "We should have patented it."

Meanwhile, the Tories seem to have stolen the SNP's Time for Change slo
gan. Maurice Golden (Boy) is a fresh faced candidate who is endearingly trying to pitch the Tories as the mavericks, unsullied by power in either Westminster or Holyrood.

He can be compared to the kind of X Factor contestant who doesn't necessarily have the most talent, but who is kept in week after week by the "mum" votes because of his smile.

An SNP activist admits that he had the best one liner of any candidate at a hustings. When he was asked what he would nationalise, he said: "Lindsay Roy's diary".

DELIGHTFUL as Fife is, anyone camped here for the by election knows that this is not the top contest to be covering this week.

But somehow, the cocky SNP has tried to draw far-fetched parallels with Barack Obama's triumph of hope over fear to its party's likely victory over Labour.

This afternoon, the party created traffic chaos with a photo call in the centre of a roundabout.
A giant saltire was held up by activists, as Peter Grant and the FM posed in front of it.

It would have been more dramatic if Mr Salmond had come over the top of the hill, and landed a giant belly flop in the centre, but alas he was not game for that.

Instead, I ask him whether he has put his money where his mouth is. He tells me he has had a flutter on the by election – and put money on the SNP to win. He does not tell me how much. Wonder if it is a spread bet?

One activist tells me they put a £250 bet on in the last 48 hours.

THERE was almost a "Sharon Storer" moment (not Sharon Stone – no kilts here) when the photo call was ambushed by parents demonstrating against the closure of a school in Paisley.

OK it is not in Glenrothes but it was the SNP what dunnit, say the parents.

They demand a meeting with the First Minister. He eventually comes over, mindful of the fact the press are there and promises to listen to their concerns.

THE atmosphere in the Liberal Democrat camp this morning was surprisingly relaxed.

Candidate Harry Wills had time to linger over a cup of coffee with The Scotsman, along with Willie by election supremo Rennie and Tavish Scott.

Mr Wills is wonderfully un-PC for a Lib Dem. The Lib Dems slogan is "Harry Wills, Fighting for Fife" but every time a press release pops up on my email, I become alarmed, thinking it reads "Harry Wills Fighting for Life".

But despite reports that the Lib Dems could lose their deposit, Harry is in good spirits. What makes him better than his rivals. "Oh that's not for me to say," he says blushing. But then he adds that he has had years of experience in business in the area.

A "mature" woman sits down beside us to ask him whether he can get the recycling bins near her home emptied (it has not been cleared since it was installed there). He promises to get on the case. She also asks for him to ensure that the vast Kingdom Shopping Centre gets all its empty shops filled. He is too smart to promise that he can fix the decline in retail to sort this one out...

She is later spotted shaking hands with John Prescott.

One Lib Dem activist insists that voters are telling the SNP they are voting for Peter Grant because "they will say anything to get them off their doorstep quickly. They are so pushy." So while America feared the Bradley effect, Glenrothes could have the Jehovah Witness factor.

LABOUR have just been on the phone. Things are very positive, they report. If that is the case, Lindsay Roy has an impeccable poker face. It is difficult to tell when the 59 year old is happy/sad/angry. He seemed to get a bit agitated last night at the hustings, which seemed suspiciously packed with SNP activists.
A week ago, one senior Labour MP told me that Lindsay's advantage was that he was not a politician, he did acquiesce to spin doctor's instructions. At times, he seems to have been defiantly unbriefed though. He seems to detest the streetfight so much that he doesn't engage with it. One wonders why he would give up being headmaster, running the show, for an uncertain life as a backbencher. Is he too decent to be a politician?




The full article contains 812 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

PaulW,

Borders 05/11/2008 17:50:43
Dear Gerri,

Your red-rose patterned slip is showing. Another example of unbiased reporting. Not. First Minister doing a belly flop, huh? Mature journalism? I don't think so. As for "far-fetched parallels" -perhaps you would like to reflect on the unremitting negativity of the Labour /establishment campaign (Scotland "can't do" anything) versus the aspirational message of the SNP (Scotland, or more appropriately the Scots can do what they set out to do) - if you can't detect a parallel, then you are not up to the job.

Thanks for reminding me why I didn't buy the paper (again) today. Johnston Press must be flush if they are able to ignore more than 650,000 SNP voters out there who are pig-sick of reading Labour propoganda every day.

Hoping that one day I can read an unbiased piece and feel comfortable buying what used to be a great paper, which I used to have much affection for.

I regret today is not that day.
2

brusque,

05/11/2008 17:57:44
#1 I so agree with you.

I talk constantly about how much respect I had for the impartial and factual reporting in the Scotsman.

How I miss that now, and in its' place we have gutter journalists who don't seem capable of independent thought, and show not one single ounce of respect for Scotland.

It is nothing new to have Political Parties who have apposite views, but quite another when - what used to be - a newspaper cannot find it withing itself to report facts, instead of the fictional meanderings, not to say wishful thinking, of 3rd rate hacks with an agenda.

3

DouglasT,

05/11/2008 18:46:25
Surprising that Labour have chosen a candidaete whose sole experience is being a teacher.

Teaching is an admirable profession but politics is a very different world. Government already have an ex-teacher in office, Home Secretary Smith. To date her contributions are

rebuffal of tribunal decision on police pay.
proposal to gag coroners who deal in truth relating to the deaths of our servicemen
proposal to create a database of all emails and texts issued by UK citizens.

Seems that teachers may have a tendency to treat the public like school children.
4

bully wee alba,

Edinburgh 05/11/2008 19:06:29
“Education in the spotlight”.

It seems that the Labour candidate, who is also the rector of Kirkcaldy High School, does not know what the budget for his school is in the current or previous financial years.

This fact does not exactly suggest that this guy is up to the job of representing the electorate of Glenrothes, if he cannot accurately represent his fiscal responsibilities in his day job.

Is he too decent to be a Headmaster?

5

brusque,

05/11/2008 19:44:24
I wouldn't dream of questioning Mr Roy's qualifications as a Head Teacher, but I have to say, his demeanour does not bear out his ability!

If you didn't know better, you would think he was an uneducated man, drowning in a pond of rhetoric which is far too deep for him.

6

,

05/11/2008 19:59:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

Andy Stewart,

05/11/2008 21:45:39
Brogan says Labour concedes they will lose Gelnrothes by 1500 +/- 500.
http://broganblog.dailymail.co.uk/2008/11/labour-give-up.html

8

Andy Stewart,

05/11/2008 21:49:11
05 November 2008 8:46 PM
Labour give up on Glenrothes
By the way, Labour word is that Glenrothes is a lost cause. The SNP will take it by 1500, give or take 500. I don't detect a Brown Central attempt to prepare a "shock" win. Instead they say that had they had a few days more it might have made a difference, and that without Gordon and Sarah Brown's personal intervention the result would be far worse. So the good news is that defeat will be masked by the Obama euphoria. The bad news, as Team Dave will doubtless put it, is that the Novice won, and Gordon lost.
9

,

05/11/2008 21:49:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

,

05/11/2008 21:53:40
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

A Better Way,

Edinburgh 05/11/2008 23:19:42
Roy has been telling the people of Fife he will do things for Education,Transport and Widening the roads system, which will be a miracle because he is running for Westminster. He didnt know that there was a big difference. He has no say on Devolved Matters, that is an MSP's Job.

He sems a nice enough man, who like Brown is out of touch with the realities of life. Better he stay School rather than the hard world of just surviving in the present Economic Collapse created by Browns arrogance and Darlings weak ability to stand up to Brown and the deviant Mandelson.
12

,

05/11/2008 23:25:34
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
13

Sheilz,

05/11/2008 23:28:45
The lack of unbiased reporting in this By-election is a national disgrace. The hootsman has always been prejudiced against Scotland but now the Herald is getting just as bad. So much for calling themselves journalists, more like labour lackeys.
Shame on them and their cowardice.
14

somerferg,

perth 05/11/2008 23:39:06


Memo to Gerri:

Good on you, keep up the good work. Your patronising style is bound to keep the monkeys with red rosettes happy and after all that what we at the Hootsman are all about.
15

,

06/11/2008 00:01:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

Silent Hunter,

Scotland 06/11/2008 00:09:43
I, like others, simply wonder just how much money Labour are paying the Herald and the Scotsman to publish their propaganda for them?

I detect the grubby hands of Labours arch spin meister Alastair Campbell behind this blizzard of pro-Labour tosh that we are currently having to suffer from so-called 'independent' Scottish Journalists.........a misnomer if ever I heard one.

I hope and pray that the people of Glenrothes remember just how corrupt Labour have been in 11 years when they stand in the polling booth with their hand poised over their ballot paper.

For God's sake vote SNP and rid us of the sleazy and utterly corrupt Labour Party for good.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.