Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

The hunt is On.
Sponsored by
Can you track down Scotland's wildest beastie?
 
 
Friday, 5th December 2008

Haggis Hunt is now on!

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Don't let this Lamb go to the slaughter



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 February 2008
I NOTE from your article "Restoration of 300-year-old Lamb's House is on the cards" (News, February 11) that yet again a part of the noble history of Leith and Scotland is to become shuffled along with other relics into flats.
The National Trust seem proud that this much-loved building will come back into everyday use.

There are over 30,000 homes planned by Forth Ports and others to house incomers who decide to live near their work or think that living in Leith is now t
he in thing.

They know or care not a jot about this A-listed building, its heritage or history.

Newcomers and visitors will know of this, if the ancient fabric of the town continues to be commercialised.

I wonder how many of the newly domiciled Leith dwellers, have supported the Leith Museum petition, which returns to Parliament next week for another airing, or even know of its existence.

If the National Trust doesn't want it, or doesn't want to continue to pay for the upkeep of it, hand it over to those who do care who will gladly take that part of the Government cake enjoyed by the National Trust and put it to real use.

I presume that when the Town Chambers, now Leith police station, if you can pronounce that, will go the same way for more flats, not for affordable housing to be used by the hoi-polloi who elected the "decision makers" in the first place.
Steve Mitchell, West Granton Road, Edinburgh

Hard to keep up heavy workload
I REFER to the article in the Evening News of February 12 about my resignation from the Board of the Science Festival.

Despite not receiving notification of the Science Festival meetings, on checking I found that on the five dates it did meet, I had other meetings to attend on three of them, indeed on one of the dates I had four meetings, one of which was with your journalist, Alan Roden. For the record, the SNP business manager has informed me that since May, I have attended 588 meetings as a councillor.

My workload as leader of the SNP group and deputy leader of the council is greater than I anticipated as this is the first time the administration of the council has been run under coalition terms and it was uncharted waters. However, I and my fellow councillors (from whichever party) do indeed put in a great deal of time and effort into our work, sometimes meetings conflict with each other, that is inevitable, but I believe that we all try to do our best to live up to the demands of the office to which we were elected.
Councillor Steve Cardownie, Deputy Leader of the City of Edinburgh Council

Ca(i)re cut will be a false economy
I AM horrified to learn that funding for the Ca(i)re Project, an invaluable service, is to be cut by 66 per cent.

This is a false economy as the resulting distress caused to carers will manifest itself in greater demand for GP services and respite care for clients with complex needs. I have also learned that funding is to be cut for the Edinburgh Development Group, another invaluable resource for carers like myself, caring for an autistic brother.

Everyone wants and needs a bit out of the apple, but the ordinary people of Edinburgh are being scunnered by a money-centred approach by the council for our most under-represented group.
Anne Murray, The Glebe, Kirkliston, West Lothian

Give pupils school that they deserve
IT is great to see articulate and passionate pupils from Portobello High School arguing their case for a new school building via a DVD (News, February 11), but sad that they have to resort to that. Pupils learn better in high-quality buildings.

Last April, in an otherwise excellent report, school inspectors identified "important weaknesses" in the quality of the building and teaching space. Rebuilding Portobello High School is clearly necessary, justified and urgent.

The Lib Dem/SNP council must now allocate funds to start the work. The SNP Government cannot shirk its responsibilities and pretend not to know the scale of the problem – especially when one of its senior ministers is the local MSP. Local residents expect local politicians to stand up for their area. Mr MacAskill should start by lobbying his own SNP colleagues.
Rami Okasha, Dickson Street, Edinburgh

Setting the record straight on coach
HAVING been interviewed by your newspaper on the telephone about my time at Royal High School I have now read the resulting article and find myself utterly embarrassed.

Some inaccuracies are of little importance, but I wish to correct the travesty of what I said about rugby in the school.

In 1957 and for years afterwards we ran between 17 and 20 teams from a school roll of around 700 – a point I made to the interviewer. I was asked within an hour of arriving on my first day if I would help with the rugby and, having been coaching in my previous school, I readily agreed.

With so many teams to look after, we obviously had around a score of coaches and I played my small part.

At no point did I tell the interviewer that I was head coach, which would have been a lie and I paid tribute in my reminiscences to the real head coach, Douglas F Mitchell, who was highly regarded throughout Scotland for the outstanding teams he produced year on year and, even more, for the open, running, handling style of play he advocated.

Finally, I have not recently retired from coaching. I retired from my post of principal teacher of Classics at the Royal High School in the summer of 1987, and as the school was short of coaches I was asked if I would help out and I continued helping out for a number of years, but it is a long time now since I stopped.
Jock Dewar

Zoo has become embarrassment
THANK you to Hazel Mollison for highlighting my fears over Edinburgh Zoo. Since the article we have lost two types of antelope in the African Plain to the Wildlife Park at Aviemore.

Jenny Dawe's remark that it is better to have fewer animals in better enclosures misses the point completely. All these animals were in good enclosures. I suggest she visits as often as I do. The zoo should be honest – if they remove animals, tell us why and give a timetable for the replacement.

Does the gentleman who owns the ground at the park at Aviemore and is also a trustee at Edinburgh Zoo have too much influence?

Having been to Dublin, Vienna, Prague and Munich Zoos, I find Edinburgh Zoo very sad and embarrassing.
C J Kennedy, Broomhall Loan, Edinburgh




The full article contains 1144 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 February 2008 8:30 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Linda,

Edinburgh 15/02/2008 12:36:18
As a Labour candidate Rami Oshaka should know that despite 23 years in power Labour failed to build a new school for Portobello and left a horrendous deficit in the Education budget.

Also Scottish Government received a very poor block grant from Westminster while oil revenues reach record levels.
2

Life of a Liberal?,

Edinburgh 15/02/2008 13:34:26
Dear Linda, I could not agree with you more, but the blame game must stop and action must be taken now. Another 5 years of inactivity and the real crisis will be upon this school.
3

Mikey,

15/02/2008 13:39:16
There is a real crisis now! This is all because of Labour's inaction! I agree, however, that the time for recrimiations is over and a new school is needed.

Pity about Labour demanding the trams go ahead, though! Just think of the money that would have been saved!
4

Farky,

Edinburgh 15/02/2008 13:55:12
where I can view it?

Building need refurbished from time to time. New windows, painted/decorated. Rewired or replumbed, No one would argue with that. I think that might be all that is required in Portobello as well as many other school building which are being earmarked for demolition and rebuild at ENORMOUS expense to the tax payer via PFI / PPP projects. Research by Edinburgh University highlighted this funding model as being exceptionally bad value for money, hence why they didn't have their new QMRI building at Little France funded via PPP.

However, back to the particular subject of Portobello High School which is receiving so many complaints in these columns just now. Are we really saying that this building is so unfit for educational purposes that the only option being considered is demolition? Many old building gain a new lease of life just from being refurbished, I fail to see why this school, along with many others can't be considered for a complete overhaul and benefit from new educational facilities being installed.

We really need to look once again at the school building programme and ask ourselves whether tax payers money is being spent wisely, and also whether or not new schools do in fact improve the attainment of our children? Maybe more to do with other factors than the building alone. Parenting, teaching standards, resources etc... Only demolish buildings which where there is NO other option available.
5

Farky,

Edinburgh 15/02/2008 13:56:04
Missed the first line in previous post.


Rami,

Do you have any evidence that pupils learn better in high-quality buildings? If so, can you tell me where I can view it?

Building need refurbished from time to time. New windows, painted/decorated. Rewired or replumbed, No one would argue with that. I think that might be all that is required in Portobello as well as many other school building which are being earmarked for demolition and rebuild at ENORMOUS expense to the tax payer via PFI / PPP projects. Research by Edinburgh University highlighted this funding model as being exceptionally bad value for money, hence why they didn't have their new QMRI building at Little France funded via PPP.

However, back to the particular subject of Portobello High School which is receiving so many complaints in these columns just now. Are we really saying that this building is so unfit for educational purposes that the only option is demolition? Many old building gain a new lease of life just from being refurbished, I fail to see why this school, along with many others can't be considered for a complete overhaul and benefit from new educational facilities being installed.

We really need to look once again at the school building programme and ask ourselves whether tax payers money is being spent wisely, and also whether or not new schools do in fact improve the attainment of our children? Maybe more to do with other factors than the building alone. Parenting, teaching standards, resources etc... Only demolish buildings which where there is NO other option available.
6

,

15/02/2008 14:30:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

Jingling Geordie,

Sunshine on Leith 15/02/2008 14:34:17
I'm sure that Steve "one grand mobile phone bill" Cardownies workload is reflected in his expenses claims.
8

Unimpressed one,

15/02/2008 15:34:06
Edinburgh zoo is definately going downhill fast. Fewer species, more play parks. They need someone to pull the zoo's future plans into focus. Compared to other leading zoos, it's a has been.
9

fresian,

edinburgh 15/02/2008 16:22:08
you think thats bad, i was at the zoo down on seafield Road, the only animal they had was a small dog,

it was a shihtzu
10

mkmitch,

Edinburgh 16/02/2008 16:39:52
In the Lambs to a Slaughter letter the paragraph:
'Newcomers and visitors will ** know of this, if the ancient fabric of the town continues to be commercialised'. The word **NEVER is misssing, now they think they do know, you know.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.