Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 7th September 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Northern Ireland prospers 10 years on from Good Friday agreement



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 March 2008
NORTHERN Ireland has enjoyed a massive fall in unemployment and an influx of new workers in the decade since the historic Good Friday agreement, new figures show.
It now outperforms every region of the UK except for the south-west, with only 4.2 per cent of its population out of work.

At the same time, the "peace dividend" has seen a long-standing pattern of emigration swapped for immigration, as it attr
acts migrants from new European Union member states such as Poland.

Figures from Westminster dramatically illustrate the effects on both sides of the religious divide since paramilitary action ended.

Some 18,558 people claimed unemployment benefit in the four Belfast parliamentary constituencies in January 1997.

But by January, this had fallen to 6,698 – an astonishing 64 per cent drop.

Across the province, around 100,000 more people are in work and the 4.2 per cent unemployment rate outperforms Scotland (4.9 per cent), the UK (5.2 per cent) and London (6.6 per cent).

Northern Ireland economics consultant John Simpson said the economic recovery had been "dramatic". But he warned that the economic turn-around "cannot be date-stamped at Easter 1998" and there was still widespread deprivation. Average weekly earnings in Northern Ireland stood at £330 last year – compared with £375 for the UK as a whole.

The figures emerged as politicians yesterday debated the legacy of the Good Friday agreement that restored – after several faltering starts – a devolved government and assembly to Northern Ireland.

The deal was struck in 1998 after many days and nights of painstaking negotiations and with the encouragement of the then prime minister Tony Blair and the former US president Bill Clinton.

The 108-member assembly took power in December 1999, though direct rule from London resumed temporarily in 2002 when devolution collapsed due to bitter arguments about the refusal of the IRA to decommission its weapons and the suspicion of a republican spy ring existing at Stormont.

Power returned in 2007 after an election left Ian Paisley's Democratic Unionists and Martin McGuinness's Sinn Fein in command. This saw men who were once the bitterest of enemies work alongside each other as First Minister and Deputy First Minister.

Concerns remain about the presence of sectarian hatred and violence. However, the Royal Ulster Constabulary, reformed as the Police Service of Northern Ireland, is well on its way to the target of having 30 per cent Catholic officers by 2011.

Of the 450 loyalist and republican prisoners released early under the Good Friday deal, only 20 have had their licences revoked.

In 2005 the IRA ended its armed campaign and British troops now number 5,000.

Billy Hutchinson, a former Progressive Unionist Party (PUP) assembly member from north Belfast, said: "Sectarianism is still alive and well. People are still living in disadvantage and the only thing changed is the more peaceful atmosphere."

But former Northern Ireland minister Paul Murphy said: "The Good Friday agreement has most certainly stood the test of time. We must remember that without the agreement, none of this would have been possible."

Memories of a new dawn

DAVID ANDREWS (Irish Government – Fianna Fail): "I remember politicians desperately trying to grab some sleep in the negotiation rooms as the deadline for agreement loomed.

"I also recall the conclusion was very sudden. I remember George Mitchell set the final deadline and then a phone call from (US President) Bill Clinton to (Ulster Unionist leader) David Trimble sealed the deal.

EILEEN BELL (Alliance Party): "I suppose one of the most striking memories I have is of some pretty senior republicans and loyalists queuing up for food that week and watching them engage each other in conversation. It may have only been only about the food, but it was remarkable to see former enemies engaging."

MARTIN McGUINNESS (Sinn Fein): "After the agreement was forged… I ran into a republican ex-woman prisoner in my home city who had spent a long time in Armagh Jail and I asked her 'What do you think?'

"Her response was 'Martin, what do you think?' and when I said I thought we had done the right thing, she said: 'That's all right for me'.

"I have to say it was bit scary and humbling that people were putting so much faith in our leadership."

LIZ O'DONNELL (Irish Government – Progressive Democrats): "The people who made the greatest political sacrifices suffered most. I think history will be fairer to David Trimble."





The full article contains 756 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 March 2008 11:18 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Northern Ireland
 
1

Jeeemy,

St Andrews 22/03/2008 01:45:35
“Northern Ireland prospers 10 years on from Good Friday agreement”
By ROSS LYDALL
POLITICAL EDITOR
My compliments on a nice article, BUT and it’s a big but, you have not mentioned the amount of monies pumped into Northern Ireland over the past 10 years.
Might I suggest that you go back and take a closer look, take a look at the grass roots of sport as an example?
The amount of monies ploughed into sport in Northern Ireland over the past ten years could have paid for a Commonwealth Games.
These monies that were allocated to Northern Ireland has nothing to do with the Barnett Formula but were supplementary to that allocation.

2

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 02:43:47
Aye that usually follows on from a long period at war!!! Mind you they have long way to go to catch up with their independent neighbours in the South.
3

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 07:41:38
In 1921, after the partition of the Island of Ireland,
the British Empire did not hesitate to introduce devolved government to the truncated 6 Counties of the Province of Ulster for military and geographic reasons.

Many forget that in in 1932 when the new Northern Ireland Government moved into Stormont House it consisted of a Lower House (of Commons) and an Upper House (Senate)? A bloated, bicameral parliament for a population of less than the then Home Counties? We all know the reasons why this gerry-mander parliament fell into disrepute.

Yet, Scotland, an ancient nation, only has a unicameral, devolved parliament to govern a country with the same demographic characteristics as 49 other small and medium sized independent nations in the world? (U.N. statistics)
4

Border Scot,

22/03/2008 07:45:14
#2 - One day the people of the Republic of Ireland may get the cradle to grave welfare system they enjoy in the North. It won't happen for a while though.

#3 - When the Scots want more, we will get it. Isn't it great living in a democracy?

5

donald,

glasgow 22/03/2008 08:04:15
Good job the "thick" Irish never had any oil reserves or they would be even poorer.

Only the "mean" Scots do not benefit from English "generosity" and superiority.
6

Border Scot,

22/03/2008 08:15:09
#5 - Yes, we are such victims aren't we? No control over our own lives, too weak to do anything about it. What a fine picture of the Scots you paint - totally in thrall to the English and powerless to do anything about it. Do you really hate Scots that much?
7

danielrober,

22/03/2008 09:21:39
Can't say i know much about the deep politics, but this is good news. However, I would ask for more investment in Northern Ireland, in spite of recent increases, the area has suffered 50 years of under investment. Northern Irland has truley become an inspiration to every diplomatic team on the planet. Good luck all.

P.S how about a few tidal turbines, off Port Stewart.
8

Liberal for life,

Dunblane 22/03/2008 10:46:02
Credit where credits due - well done Tony Blair.
9

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 11:22:26
4

A welfare system with no NHS dentists??? and a two tier health que?? where you have to go to India for your life saving operation and use their private health service???
An NHS service now run exclusivly by PFI projects based on profit management as opposed to patient care management.
Or maybe your referring to the Unemployment benefit system where you can no longer sign on when you leave School because you havent been able to pay your NI contributions.

Maybe the people of the North will wake up one day and see a prosperity down south they could only dream about in their part of the UK.

More what?? More of what already belongs to us you mean??? How generous.

6.

Yes as a matter of fact we are victims of our own gulliblity and stupidity but for how long???
Until people start listening to people like me and not to people like you.
10

Eve,

Scotland 22/03/2008 19:51:13
#4 Border Scot: Which Scots are you talking about?

I'm a Scot and I want more for my country. I like many (and there are plenty of us about) Scots want independence for Scotland.

Democracy is great BUT we aren't receiving the full benefit of full democracy, cause the unionist parties won't let us have a referendum on anything thing of importance.

I personally have never voted in a referendum and feel like my voices doesn't matter to the folk in Westminster. As I vote against rubbish Labour MP BUT they still get in and don't feel represent and I need to fell represented, in place that make decisions that effect me.
11

HEN BROON 5,

22/03/2008 21:48:26
1 Jeeemy,St Andrews 22/03/2008 01:45:35


Westminster could not give enough money to Ireland or Scotland and Wales for that matter to compensate for the damage their imperialist fascist madness has cause down the centuries.

Evidence of the fanatical Brit Nat spite and malevolence can be read on these forums mostly emanating from the troll AM2 who is a self confessed Irishman, who has taken it upon himself to lecture to Scots on the great and bountiful dividends and fruits of his fascist union. He utterly despises the SNP and Eire and all it we stand for.

This paper is but one of the many weapons deployed in this nation to thwart independence, but they may as well try and turn back the tide.

ALBA GU BRATH
12

Lovepan,

England 23/03/2008 16:42:17
#11
I come from the North of England, which has suffered many invasions from Scotland - the worst being from the slaughterer Robert the Bruce.

Countless times the French prompted the Scottish to invade my part of the country, and it was the local men and women of Northumbria and Yorkshire (not the whole nation of England which it is always presumed to be) which saw off the Scottish armies.

(see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Neville%
27s_Cross )

Maybe - under your justifications - some reparations from the Scottish government for the North of England wouldn't go amiss?

And have you ever heard of the Irish army which invaded Lancashire in 1487? The German mercenaries who were with them were so disgusted by their torturing of the local polulace that they refused to be associated with them - just look up the memiors of Martin Schwarze.

No one is innocent.

Maybe you have to come from a border area to understand that there are no differences between you and your neighbour, and that nationalism is exclusive, not inclusive.
13

Lovepan,

England 23/03/2008 16:50:27
#11
don't forget that 6 per cent of Rep. of Ireland's GDP comes from European money.
The UK gives more than it receives.

When I worked in Ireland on the N6 project, the public money (from Europe, and therefore the UK) available for road projects and infrastructure was immense, and therefore there was a lot of wastage.

Ireland's done well and it's a place I love (like Scotland), but its econmic miracle is largely down to European monies and the fact that it started from a low base in the early 1990s.
(Wasn't it still classed as a third world country in 1994?)
14

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 23/03/2008 22:08:12
13

It nearly died altogther during the potato famine while part of the UK.
15

Zilperhonka,

24/03/2008 09:13:31
Re 13

The 1487 invasion was an English affair, launched from English controlled Ireland and led by an English pretender to the English Throne. Besides there are about 100 such incidents of English atrocities in Ireland for every one you can drag up. Read about Walter Raleigh and Francis Drake in Ireland, or the atrocities committed during the nine years war, i don't even have to discuss the terrible 17thC or later atrocities.

BTW I do not blame any English living today for the crimes of their forefathers.

As for the Irish economy, if as you claim...

'(Wasn't it still classed as a third world country in 1994?)'

Then doesn't this contradict your theory that Ireland's economic performance is down to handouts since we had been receiving those since the seventies?

Ireland is also now a net donor in the EU. The upgrading of Ireland's performance is down to low corporate taxation, excellent education standards, an aggressive policy of chasing foreign investment, though we do have to thank the EU for the assistance they gave in upgrading our infrastructure.

16

Alba Abú,

Edinburgh 15/04/2008 22:08:52
#4 Border Scot...... " one day the people in the Republic of Ireland may get the cradle to the grave welfare system they enjoy in the north" As far as I am aware they have at this time that system in place,and unlike the six counties they did not spounge the money from England.
17

Alba Abú,

15/04/2008 22:14:48
#16... Oops there is no "U" in sponge! Only in the U in Ulster sponge.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.