Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Fury as another golden eagle is poisoned

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 June 2009
THE killing of a golden eagle in Scotland was condemned yesterday as an unacceptable crime that was "beneath contempt".
The dead bird of prey, which had been poisoned, was discovered by walkers on a remote hillside in Argyll.

The magnificent creature – believed to be one of a breeding pair – had been killed using a banned insecticide.

Yesterday, wildlife crime
officers revealed they were following a positive line of inquiry in their hunt for the eagle's killer.

Roseanna Cunningham, the environment minister, condemned the illegal killing.

She said: "I was disgusted to hear of another poisoning of a golden eagle. This is an unacceptable crime against a magnificent creature.

"There is nothing which can excuse this behaviour and the individual or individuals involved are beneath contempt.

"Our wildlife is world-renowned and a crime against it is a crime against Scotland. The use, in this case, of highly toxic, carbamate poison is particularly worrying as it poses a serious danger to other wild animals, domestic pets and even people."

The eagle's body was discovered by walkers on the slopes of Beinn Udlaidh in the Glen Orchy area on 7 June. They alerted the RSPB and the charity then called in wildlife crime officers from Strathclyde Police.

Biologists and chemists from the Science and Advice for Scottish Agriculture, a division of the Scottish Government in Edinburgh, examined the carcasse and confirmed that the eagle had died from poisoning caused by toxic insecticide.

A police spokesman said a major operation to trace those responsible had taken place on Wednesday. including searches of a number of premises in the Glen Orchy and Bridge of Orchy areas.

He added: "Police are now following a positive line of enquiry."

Bob Elliot, head of investigations with RSPB Scotland, also hit out at the killing, which followed the poisoning of a golden eagle in the Borders in August 2007. He said: "As ever, we're shocked and saddened that there are still people out there placing poisoned baits in the countryside, which often result in the deaths of some of our magnificent birds of prey.

"This area doesn't have a recent track record of wildlife crime, which is even more worrying in a way. It's likely that this bird was part of a breeding pair in Argyll, so the crime may have affected the chances of survival of young birds in the nest too.

"SNH's recently published golden eagle framework report showed that this iconic bird is being held back in parts of the country due to illegal persecution, which simply shouldn't happen in the 21st century."

Constable Stevie McAleer, wildlife crime officer for North Argyll,
said: "I would urge any members of the public who may come across a dead bird or carcasse to alert the police. I would advise people not to touch the bird or the surrounding area. If possible, and if safe to do so, branches or grass should be thrown over the carcass to avoid it being seen and eaten by other animals or birds."

There are an estimated 440 pairs of golden eagles in Scotland. According to the RSPB, 14 have died as a result of poisoning in the past ten years.





The full article contains 536 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 June 2009 9:13 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Jo Flo,

circling 20/06/2009 02:13:18
Do we like the big birds or not?
2

W Smith,

Middle East 20/06/2009 03:15:28
The SNPs Colin Campbell blamed 9/11 on "poverty".

How do we know the person who killed the Golden Eagle isn't poor?

BTW
Hopefully the 'killer' will be sent to Castle Huntly where life is a 'skoosh', eh Roseanna?
3

Phillip,

20/06/2009 05:43:48
Make the killer eat a healthy dose of the same poison and see how he likes it.
4

Mikey,

20/06/2009 07:58:15
Smith, shut up you moron!
5

Am Fidhleir Lomartach,

20/06/2009 08:12:35
Where are the puppets from the SRPBA and SGA? Yet again, no comment. Their silence speaks volumes.
6

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 20/06/2009 08:42:50
I am very sorry but I fail to get excited about birds. They are all flying rats as far as I am concerned. Raptors are maybe a bit different but I also understand farmers and estate managers not wanting them - they cause havoc !

If the obscenely rich RSPB actually 'cared' about birds they would have, long ago, bought up large areas of land which they could turn into their own bird sanctuaries. It seems they just want to take the money and snipe from the fringes without any proactive stance. Another greedy charity !

If Bird charities - which to me are amongst the most pointless - had a modicum of decency and purpose they would be taking positive action - buying land and populating it with the birds that are, allegedly, endangered - then they have a safeguard and much more control!

Like most militants they never put their own money where their mouth is and never take responsibility. Even the Africans are more advanced - they recognised there was a problem with poaching so they made game reserves and policed them vigorously - now endangered species are thriving again .... Elephants are all very good and well but YOU wouldn't want a herd wandering around your farm! This is just like farm owners - raptors are great (to some folk) but they can create big problems to those who are struggling to make a living off the land - so let them pay for 'reserve' where they can all be kept.
7

john z,

edinburgh 20/06/2009 08:55:41
Yes, Voldemort, you willingly publicly display your pig ignorance on this matter.

The fact is, the problem is cause by rich estate managers, who make money from rich guests, don't want the Golden Eagles.

I really think the time has come for the Scottish Parliament to introduce a new law regarding Scottish wildlife, with jail sentences. Perhaps jail rather than fines, will stop the moronic landed gentry (whose REAL knowledge of wildlife could be written on the back of a stamp) from murdering native Scottish wildlife.

New Zealand takes it very seriously, it is time Scotland did the same.
8

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 20/06/2009 09:24:16
Strange how some blinkered people don't consider the big picture! The region in question is dripping with windfarm applications. A Special Protection Area (SPA)for golden eagles is being sought, but the wheels of government seem to turn exceedingly slow! Will the birds be dead and gone before the SPA is declared?
9

Iain Mac,

20/06/2009 09:31:16
We should hammer the rich landowners responsible for this. Especially as these birds are rare. If a schemie killed a cat, he would be up in court.

W. Smith - the voice of senile dementia.
10

Pilrig,

Livingston 20/06/2009 09:50:36
2 - we don't know anything aboot the culprit till he/she's caught. Doh !
But whoever the bassa is they obviously dinnae like golden eagles
11

Pilrig,

Livingston 20/06/2009 09:56:26
6 yes and go back to the guid auld days when the bulk of Scotland's land mass was restricted to the gentry and their hirelings...
12

Pilrig,

Livingston 20/06/2009 09:57:25
8 - so a wind turbine poisoned the eagle ? !
13

dido-bendigo,

20/06/2009 10:05:47
#12 Pilrig.
Your question is not as purile as you might think! Did it?

I suppose we could always blame it on good old 'climate change'!
14

Endemoniada,

20/06/2009 10:16:22
As usual we can expect the ignorant ramblings by the apologists for those who think they can slaughter our protected wildlife, destroy our natural heritage and ignore the law.

Voldemort - if you cared to open your narrow little mind, you would discover that wildlife charities like RSPB (with 1 million members who do care), Scottish Wildlife Trust etc etc do purchase areas of land that are managed very successfully for wildlife. In fact RSPB has over 150 reserves in the UK. But does that mean that the rest of our countryside has to be a sterile desert, populated only by grouse, sheep or pheasants, where any perceived threat is shot, poisoned or has its nest destroyed. Why should the vast majority of our uplands, particularly in the S & E of Scotland be managed so that artificially high numbers of one species can be blasted out the sky every August. What right do these land managers have to destroy our natural heritage so that they can line their pockets with subsidies we pay for?
15

Pilrig,

Livingston 20/06/2009 11:00:24
13 - I knoeth not. Who knows what mischief the turbines get up to when no one's looking....
16

sam the god,

20/06/2009 11:54:44
yet again a raptor killed for political purposes of the screaming lefties.
17

Pilrig,

Livingston 20/06/2009 12:19:14
Well report the screaming leftie responsible to the polis as you seem to know who dunnit
18

Not gay,

Huntly 20/06/2009 13:01:37
Why if our police are finding it hard to meet their commitments to the public are they wasting time and precious resouces on hounding the person who might have commited thios 'crime' rather than on real crime?
19

Endemoniada,

20/06/2009 13:12:29
16 - peddling your usual rubbish I see! Where's your pals Overton & Jacqueline Hyde today? They can usually be relied on to come out with similar tosh.

18 - poisoning a golden eagle is against the law - ie a crime.
20

senza nome,

20/06/2009 13:59:53
I take it few of the people on here have ever seen a golden eagle in flight above the Highland peaks.It's one of the most magnificent sights you could see in Scotland and it's a disgrace that anyone should kill one of them.

# 18, yes it is a real crime, a very serious one.
#14: Well said.
21

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 20/06/2009 14:13:24
#14. Endemoniada. You might like to re-address your comment about "ignorant ramblings"? If you care to investigate some of the protection measures used by the RSPB on some of their reserves you will find that killing corvids, foxes and mink are part of the 'measures'. But it is 'only selective' so that's alright then! Also, are you aware that grouse moors support most of our breeding moorland wader populations? It might be a bitter pill to swallow, but predator and habitat control on these sites proves to be the best conservation policy of all. A welcome 'spin off' for country sports as well as the rural economy! And please don't shoot the messenger, it gets very tiresome!
22

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 20/06/2009 14:18:27
Of course, the efforts to pin this poisoning onto country sports supporters is just another opportunity to spit in the eye of countryside managers. That area of Argyll can hardly be classed as good grouse production country.
23

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 20/06/2009 14:30:56
#22 That said,it is a very good area for corvids, foxes and mink! I really must finish now, I'm expecting visitors up from England who are hoping to see our resident eagles and the ospreys at their nest. Tootle pip!
24

sam the god,

20/06/2009 16:23:47
#21 dido bendigo
do not tell the tree huggers that you might shatter their illusions that the land owners and people interested in the countryside are only out to destroy the countryside.
I have been out doing my bit in corvid and fox control today. I wonder if Endemoniada has done anything I very much doubt it sitting back and spouting tosh does not amount to anything productive in relation to the countryside.
25

Endemoniada,

20/06/2009 17:38:47
Sam & didi

I've been working in countryside management for the last 22 years, have a degree in ecology and thus feel suitably qualified to comment!

Fox, mink & corvid control are legal, although the latter is only so under the terms of general licences. I've done this myself.

I did not say Argyll was grouse country, but the areas where 2 Red Kites were poisoned recently certainly is. I'm not trying to pin this on country sports supporters, but are you trying to suggest that the fact the vast majority of confirmed poisonings of birds of prey in Scotland occurs in areas of driven grouse moors is a coincidence? Or then again, maybe you're suggesting that the corpses are "planted" or "recycled", like the chairman of the SGA has suggested? Something like 75% of convictions for offences of killing birds of prey have been of people from game shooting/rearing interests.

You constantly attack organisations like RSPB. Why? Because they are effective at drawing attention to the national disgrace that is the persecution of our raptors.
26

Fi,

20/06/2009 17:39:06
#21-24; Mink are vermin, introduced artifically into Scoland. We should make mink coats a Scottish fasion item, like New Zealand has done with possum fur.

I supprt New Zealand's efforts to exterminate possums, I wear possum fur.
27

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 20/06/2009 22:28:57
14- why do the stinking rich RSPB buy their 151st reserve and stick their flying rats in there then ?

Perhaps landowner should not poison raptors but they don't do it just for fun there is clearly a big problem with them .. why can't they catch them alive and them deliver them to a reserve ??

28

Pilrig,

Livingston 20/06/2009 23:38:36
24 - oh the guid auld days when the countryside was reserved for the great and the...well the great, and the common herd knew their place - in cities and toons.
29

Pilrig,

Livingston 20/06/2009 23:41:13
27 so it's the landowners who are doin the poisinin then ? Better no tell Sam cos he'll accuse them of being screamin lefties
30

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 21/06/2009 00:25:09
Ok - I will admit that I am being a bit extreme in my comments but just because I love winding up folk who have no love in their life and so love birds (feathered!). Bill Oddie (SP?) just gets on my breasts .. if I had any!

So lets 'try' and get sensible ...

Raptors are obviously not flying rats as I have said before but they are clearly a big problem to some estates. Now like them or loathe them the 'landed gentry' are not all filthy rich some people genuinely rely on income from the land that they own to feed their families.

It is a fact that the RSPB are one of the richest charities in Britain they are worth hundreds of Millions of pounds - wealthier than the vast, vast majority of landowners. Why don't the RSPB, if they were really concerned about bird welfare as opposed to ramming their political views down peoples throats and being satisfied with being 'smug' through telling other people what to do.

Why don't the RSPB (with over 150 reserves, so I am told) give a reward of say £10,000 to any gamekeeper that gives them a live 'problem' raptor .. that would make the far too valuable to be poisoned the 'problem' would disappear overnight. This is a REAL soloution.

The only thing that stands in this soloutions way is the RSPB's (and eco-terrorists) egos ..... frankly I don't think they give a hoot about the birds but are hell bent on 'class war' - they would rather see the estate owner squirm under legislation than bird being saved!

I raise about £1/2million a year for charitable causes you can be assured that the RSPB will not get any --- not that they need it! They are filthy rich !
31

Endemoniada,

21/06/2009 15:22:23
Why should people be rewarded for not breaking the law? I haven't killed any birds of prey today. Should I get £10,000?

Voldemort - I'd stick to Harry Potter books, well in keeping with the fantasy world you inhabit.
32

Lara Crofter,

argyll 24/06/2009 10:04:33
The chances are that this eagle was killed by poison laid out to catch foxes. Eagles have never been seen as a problem in this part of Argyll but foxes taking lambs most certainly are. Some idiots never learn that poison is so indiscriminate that it effectively negates any benefit from its use. This area is not rich in game, but it is an area that holds large sheep numbers, I'd reckon on it being nothing to do with gamekeepers at all, but most likely to be a shepherd unable to get a particular fox that is causing his lambs damage.
Surely if this is the case then all government subsidy provided should be withdrawn from the culprit's place of work, this would certainly show any others who continue to use poison that there are serious consequences to this recklessness.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.