Register
Sign In
Help
Sitemap
Home
Skip Navigation
Contact Us
Disability Statement
Site
Web
Search
Home
News
Sport
Business
Your Say
Newspaper
Health Info
Money
enhanced by
Scotland
UK
Politics
International
Science&Tech
Health
Education
Entertainment
Gaelic
Opinion
Obituaries
Transport
Odd
Festivals
Lifestyle
Reviews
Columnists
Blogs
Business Club
Video Archive
Archive
Email Newsletters
Whisky
Advertise
You need to have javascript enabled to view this page correctly
Monday, 9th November 2009
Sections
Latest News
Scotland
- North East
- Edinburgh, East and Fife
- Glasgow and West
- Tayside and Central
- Inverness and Highlands
- South
UK
International
Politics
Sci-Tech
Health
Education
Transport
Environment
Arts
Entertainment
Opinion
Obituaries
Odd
Gaelic
Article Index
Other Sections
Supplements
Topics
Topics A-Z
Other Sites
The Scotsman
Scotland on Sunday
Evening News
Heritage & Culture
Living
Dating
Announcements
Money
Scotsman Shop
Scotsman Hotels
Fantasy Golf
Photos Today
Local Pages
Edinburgh Festivals
Homecoming
Whisky
What's this?
The article has been unable to display.
Bookmark:
Del.icio.us
Digg
Facebook
reddit
StumbleUpon
1
2dogs in D.C.,
03/07/2009 01:55:48
Well,if that's the case,Barcelona,don't expect Green Day soon.Jeeze,people,what do you expect? It's a freekin' rock band-quiet is not an option.People pay good money to have their ears bleed after a good show.
Report Unsuitable
2
Finlang,
Hong Kong 03/07/2009 03:36:44
There was me thinking it was an American spy plane spinning over Spain. Francis Gary Powers, where are you?
Report Unsuitable
3
Blogman,
Atlantis 03/07/2009 05:14:10
Come on, it's only rock and roll.
Report Unsuitable
4
Victor Glasno,
03/07/2009 06:09:54
I'm fairly certain that ACDC would be a lot louder.
Report Unsuitable
5
Victor Glasno,
03/07/2009 06:10:38
ACDC would be like TNT or dynamite.
Report Unsuitable
6
Selgovae,
03/07/2009 08:29:03
#3
"it's only rock and roll"
Far from it. It's U2. They've been rehearsing about 30 years and still sound like "ding ding ding ding ding ding ding".
Report Unsuitable
7
Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,
Edinburgh 03/07/2009 09:47:06
#6:
Concurred. U2 to me is just a load of fast strumming backed by the same old stupid 80s drum-beat. I certainly wouldn't dignify them by calling it rock 'n' roll!
Report Unsuitable
8
Aslan,
Edinburgh 03/07/2009 11:25:01
#7 - pretending to be a music critic now?
Go on then, tell us some bands that you DO consider to be 'rock 'n' roll'. Should be a laugh.
Report Unsuitable
9
Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,
Edinburgh 03/07/2009 12:55:48
Rock 'n' Roll:
Bill Haley & the Comets
Chuck Berry
Little Richard
Eddie Cochrane
Early Elvis Presley
Heavy Rock:
Led Zeppelin
Black Sabbath
Free
Cream
Prog Rock:
King Crimson
Yes
Egg
ELP
Heavy Metal:
Judas Priest
Iron Maiden
Motorhead
Rock:
The Doors
Jefferson Airplane
Santana
Jimi Hendrix
The Who
Rhythm & Blues:
Canned Heat
John Lee Hooker
Booker T and the MGs
The Rolling Stones
Punk Rock:
Sex Pistols
The Clash
Siouxie and the Banshees
Glam Rock:
The Sweet
Slade
Gary Glitter
T-Rex
Funny enough for you?
And yes, I would consider myself to be a self-styled music critic.
Report Unsuitable
10
Aslan,
Edinburgh 03/07/2009 13:15:35
#9 - so rock and roll pretty much finished in the 70s for you, then? I thought as much.
Report Unsuitable
11
Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,
Edinburgh 03/07/2009 14:10:23
Asian,
Those were the first groups that came into my head under each genre. I also like some of the more recently popular artists such as Seasick Steve, Oasis, Kula Shaker and Razor Light. As well as some of the others who are still popular and have been for some time, such as Elton John, Queen, Phil Collins and Pink Floyd.
Strictly speaking Rock 'n' Roll finished in the early 1960s. A lot of modern rock oriented music is generically known as "rock 'n' roll" even though it is not strictly of that genre.
Regarding the music of the 1980s, including so-called "rock" bands like U2 and INXS, the vast majority all shared exactly the same brain-dead "boom-chick" drum beat with an over-loud snare on the 2nd and 4th beats of the bar. Try listening to some at some point and you will see what I mean.
Being used to drummers who actually played their kits properly, I found this daft beat more and more unbearable as time went on. Don't get me wrong, there were some brilliant songs in the 80s but unfortunately, most of them were ruined by bad, unimaginative production resulting in a too thin a sound coupled with the aforementioned nursery school "drumming"---sometimes on electronic "drum kits".
About the only ones to break the mould were Michael Jackson and Queen. Don't even get me started on the manufactured Stock, Aitken & Waterman rubbish!
Report Unsuitable
12
Hitchhiker,
Nebraska 03/07/2009 15:14:17
Give me the good ole rock & roll like Led Zeppelin.
Report Unsuitable
13
Finlang,
Hong Kong 03/07/2009 19:19:10
#9/11 (unintended number combination) Fuelheid
You defeated the uninformed schoolboy #8/10 comprehensively (not difficult, mind). Your list is pretty well exact.
Report Unsuitable
14
Aslan,
Edinburgh 03/07/2009 22:47:17
#13 - thanks for that, pal!
Dunno how you worked out that I was 'defeated' - was just busy at work, and couldn't be ar.sed telling Fuelheid why I thought his list of bands sucked.
And I'm no schoolboy, either - have been going to gigs for 25 years, thanks very much. Only three of them involving bands listed at #9, thankfully.
Report Unsuitable
15
Cabe,
04/07/2009 04:53:46
#9
That's a pretty impressive list however I would have left Gary Glitter off.
Report Unsuitable
16
First Lady,
05/07/2009 04:55:48
#9 Alternative
Is there something wrong with the Rolling Stones?
Report Unsuitable
17
Finlang,
Hong Kong 06/07/2009 01:07:33
#16 First Lady
I won't answer that question, but somebody else might!
But ... I'm sure #9 would agree with such omissions from his early list as Jerry Lee Lewis, Fats Domino, Buddy Holly and the Crickets, Carl Perkins, Bo Diddley, Gene Vincent, The Platters ... the list just goes on and on.
Give #9 Fuelheid a chance - he gave you a fine selection box up there.
Report Unsuitable
18
Tussler,
07/07/2009 03:57:08
Come on, everyone needs some satisfaction.
Report Unsuitable
Comment on this Story
In order to post comments you must
Register
or
Sign In
RSS Feed of this article's comments
Delivery formats:
RSS, Atom, Javascript & Email
Email a friend
Print article
Increase text size
Decrease text size
18 comments on this article
More Music
Album review: Robbie Williams, Reality Killed the Video Star
Album reviews: Jamie Cullum | Dimitrie Cantemir | Jim Hart's Gemini | Fred Morrison | Cesaria Evora | Buika Y Chucho
Classical review: RSNO
Album review: Biffy Clyro
Gig review: Jimmy Webb and The Webb Brothers
Gig review: McIntosh Ross
Up and coming: Cuddly Shark
Gig review: Sweet Billy Pilgrim and Portico Quartet
Classical review: Scottish Chamber Orchestra
Interview: The Proclaimers - They're Proclaimed a Scottish institution
Live review: The Nolans: I'm In The Mood Again, The Usher Hall
Mica Paris
The Saxon age still lives on in music land
Gig review: Calvin Harris
Gig review: Daniel Johnston
More Music >>
Featured Advertising