Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 7th September 2008

Free Capercaillie CD

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Music review: Hebridean Celtic Festival



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 July 2008
HEBRIDEAN CELTIC FESTIVAL
ISLE OF LEWIS
THERE were many and various forms of crowd-pleasing work during the 14th Hebridean Celtic festival – and crowds don't come much better pleased than the 15,000 or so folk who nowadays flock to Stornoway each July, drawn from near and far by the event'
s deservedly outstanding international reputation.

Some of those charged with entertaining them adopted the old-fashioned tactics of top quality performances delivered with heart, soul and a fitting sense of occasion; others adapted this approach with more new-fangled methods or attitudes. All found their supporters among the crowd.

Lewis itself constitutes a pretty seductive warm-up act and backdrop, offering its wealth of ancient sites and breathtaking beaches by day, while the imposing towers of Lews Castle frame the main festival area by night. Then there's the island's position as a key heartland of Gaelic culture, a proud living heritage artfully reflected in the programme.

The young Leodhsaig Norrie MacIver, for instance, featured both with the Gaelic singing supergroup Na Seoid, who packed out Wednesday's opening show, and the gifted traditional five-piece Bodega, while fellow islanders Alasdair White – usually seen with the Battlefield Band – and Calum Alex MacMillan (Dàimh), meanwhile chose Heb Celt to launch their fiddle/vocal duo.

From neighbouring North Uist on Thursday, Gaeldom's current crown princess, Julie Fowlis, inaugurated proceedings in the huge castle marquee with customarily immaculate polish and poise, having earlier appeared at An Lanntair in a one-on-one with Lewis doyenne Maire Smith. The festival's Gaelic content is very much there as of right, simply taking its place alongside other rich cultural traditions that embrace beneath the contemporary Celtic banner.

Asked for their personal highlight as the weekend drew to a close – in perhaps the least scientific straw poll ever – a decided majority of people unhesitatingly nominated Orkney eight-piece The Chair, who stepped up on Friday ahead of this year's primary headliners The Saw Doctors and played a blinder to easily their biggest audience yet. Palpably well rehearsed and suitably on their mettle, their heavy-hitting line-up – twin fiddles, accordion, banjo, guitar, bass, drums and percussion – socked it to us straight and chaser for a triumphant 90 minutes, further fuelling the wildfire buzz kindled by their Open Stage award at last year's Celtic Connections.

The Saw Doctors seemed less specifically appreciative of the occasion – but their stock-in-trade is uniting massive crowds with simple, heartfelt, irresistibly feel-good anthems, which they did with gusto for well over two hours.

Their endearingly staunch refusal to take themselves at all seriously certainly isn't an accusation that could ever be levelled at Brit-folk poster boy Seth Lakeman, whose megabucks major-label deal resonated loud and clear through Saturday's slick, largely soulless Radio 2-friendly selection from his new album Poor Man's Heaven.

In their very different ways, veteran Irish mavericks Four Men And A Dog and television talent show winners the Red Hot Chilli Pipers were both more of the tongue-in-cheek persuasion, and earned similarly noisy audience respect at a festival that keeps on going from strength to strength.



The full article contains 527 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 20 July 2008 7:18 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

spongebob33,

carrbridge 21/07/2008 19:02:48
sue wilson - just wondering if, unlike many 'music festival critics', you actually attended the Seth Lakeman gig rather than garnered a 'snatch' of opinions from a small minority at the Festival club. I was a first year attendee and not a huge fan of folk - but Seth Lakemans set was a level above many live sets I've seen in the past and if it felt a bit 'shiny and corporate' in comparison to the other bands, this was only due to the sheer professionalism of years of hard work on the road. As a wee postscript I notice no opinion on Scottish darlings 'Shoogelnifty' who I think deserve - dare I say a real slating! I walked out after 3 songs and defy anyone to truly say they played an inspiring and roof lifting set.....dull & mediocre.
2

Eric_the_Red2,

21/07/2008 19:33:33
Seth was ok but I agree that the Chair were great: both at the main stage and the festival club.

Shooglenifty were absolutely and utterly fantastic, I think you may have left prematurely! Was the 5th time I'd seen them, and their performance in the festival club afterwards was brilliant, and I didn't notice any dissatisfaction in the crowd.
3

Scotchmissed,

22/07/2008 10:00:02
Perhaps Sue should pay some attention to spelling, and if she wasn't sure she could ask others.

"young Leodhsaig Norrie MacIver" - I think that the word is Leòdhasach...

Also, it would have been Mary Smith and not Maire (an Irish spelling, not used in the islands)

It was the SawDoctors 3rd if not 4th appearance at the Heb Celt Fest, and it was the best set of theirs that I've seen in many a year. I wasn't particularly taken by the Chair, their music sounded very samey and it didn't do it for me, I'm afraid.
4

Craig157,

Orkney 27/07/2008 15:47:54
I would agree entirely with Sue's views, though why Shooglenifty weren't mentioned is beyond me. Sometime's they can be a hit or a miss, but on Saturday they were most definiteyl on top form.

It might have been a complete coincidence, but every number Seth played seemed to be 'off the new album' - fair enough play new material but enough of the shameless self-promotion, we know he you have new album out!

I've seen the Saw Doctors before and thought they were fantastic, but wasn't that taken with them last week - partly as the crowd dynamic seemed to change entirely. As soon as the first chord of 'I Useta Lover' struck through, all the drunken, beer-spilling, finger-pointing-to-every-word loyals seemed to find themselves at the front.

Also being an Orcadian I could be seen as biased, but you surely couldn't miss the reaction The Chair received. As for samey....eh!?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.