Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


'Ban under-16s from the catwalk'

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 12 July 2007
KATE Moss and Lily Cole may have made their first appearance on the catwalk at the age of 14, but future supermodels may have to wait until they turn 16 to hit the fashion circuit.
A new report commissioned by the fashion industry has recommended banning under-age models from London Fashion Week.

It also expressed concern at the way girls below the age of consent are "sexualised" and about the prevalence of eating disorders and drug abuse among models. The report calls for more protection for models, including health checks.

Outlining the panel's interim findings, Baroness Kingsmill, who chairs the Model Health Inquiry, described the "dark side" of the modelling industry. "It seems that there has been a blind eye turned in the past. They look glamorous, they look gorgeous, they are OK. But they are not OK. They are ill, many of them," she said.

Baroness Kingsmill said the inquiry had highlighted the need for greater protection for models. "The working conditions of models are pretty appalling. They are young and vulnerable and they have very short careers.

"There was strongly expressed concern that it is profoundly inappropriate that girls under 16 - under the age of consent - should be portrayed as adult women. The risk of sexualising these children was high and designers could risk charges of sexual exploitation."

Rosalynd Ramage, at The Look Agency in Glasgow, said she agreed with the ban: "I think it's right, especially if they are wearing clothes designed to be worn by a woman in her thirties.

"We don't book girls under that age. All the models we have under 16 are booked as children. They do things like children's magazines and things which are appropriate for their age."

However, Kay Gannon, the co-director of Glasgow-based All Talent UK, said she felt it was fine for younger girls to take part in adult fashion shows, as long as they were well looked after and mature for their age.

"You love getting girls at 13 or 14 years old and keeping an eye on them. If you get it right, the chances are they are going to have a long-term career."

Cathy Owen, operations manager for The Model Team, also in Glasgow, said banning under-16s from catwalk shows could create problems for the next generation of British supermodels.

"If you are limited to starting at 16 years old it could take years for them to build up enough experience and to get enough pictures in their 'book'."

A MODEL AT 14 - AND BOTH SHE AND HER MOTHER ARE DELIGHTED

AS THE latest 14-year-old recruit to the Glasgow model agency All Talent UK, Jenna Stewart is not happy about a possible ban on girls her age taking to the catwalk. "I think people should be able to model from any age really," she said.

Jenna, from Falkirk, thinks it would be a shame if she was not allowed to take part in catwalk shows before her 16th birthday - and her mother, Betty, agrees.

"I think if they are healthy enough and they are safe enough, then why not model at that age? They have got lovely figures at that age," Mrs Stewart said.

She acts as chaperone for her daughter, and does not agree that modelling "sexualises" young girls.

"They are only showing the clothes off," Mrs Stewart said. "If you look at what 14-year-old girls wear, it is very similar to what you see on the catwalk - just a cheaper, high-street version."

Karen Reoch, of Glasgow, whose daughter Jennifer has been modelling clothes since the age of 12, agrees.

"It has given her a lot of confidence," she said. "She got to travel and it was a lot of fun for her."

Jennifer, who has just turned 18, said: "I think it depends on the maturity of the person. I felt I was ready to do that and it was a brilliant experience. My mum always chaperoned me on jobs. I never went alone."

The model, who is with Glasgow agency the Model Team, said that, while she was always body conscious, she never allowed herself to become unhealthy.

"There is an awareness that you need to keep your body in shape. But I have never felt pressure to be skinny or to be a size zero," she said. "I think the experience has made me more confident. I have never been in a situation where my confidence was dented and I have met a lot of nice people through it.

"To some extent, you look at people like Kate Moss and Lily Cole and you look up to them, but you have to be realistic. And when you think about some of the other things Kate Moss has been through, it is not so appealing. At the end of the day, school was the main priority for me when I was younger."

The full article contains 825 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 11 July 2007 9:28 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: London Fashion Week
 
1

Navvy,

12/07/2007 01:46:06

It also expressed concern at the way girls below the age of consent are "sexualised"

Society is sexualised, children are exploited from birth, advertising is rammed down their throats. Toys and gimmicks are displayed at child's eye level in children's clothing departments and supermarkets and parents love and support it all

So why single out this one aspect?

2

I'm going for a beer,

On my high horse 12/07/2007 03:00:35

You cant ban 14 y.o. girls! Many of them look like coked up, worn out slags by the time they are 24, you'll be cutting 20% from their working lives.

They are only showing the clothes off," (a very stupid) Mrs Stewart said. - Then why can't my mates fat girlfriend get a gig as a model then?

3

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 12/07/2007 06:37:03

Modelling should be banned full stop. It stereotypes women. The stereotype being long legged and only concerned about labels and fashion.

As we all know, theres a good bit more to women that the above and the knock on effect? Poor lassies, as young as 6, "dieting" to be like the models they see on TV or in the massive array of womens mags.

4

Boy Wonder,

12/07/2007 06:54:11

I wanna see REAL WOMEN modelling. Not the stick insects and certainly not kids.

I'd like to see women with curves ... like the Brigitte Bardots and Raquel Welch's who adorned my walls on posters when I was a kid growing up. The balloon bods that made bikinis look like strings with gland conditions!

Women ... not thin children!!!

And let kids be kids. JKeep "fashion" out of their lives until they're 18!

5

Petroleum Head,

Edinburgh 12/07/2007 08:30:18

What's the problem with 14 year olds being models? They can be pop-stars and actors so where is the issue?...

...or is it just political correctness once again?

6

Firozali A.Mulla MBA PhD,

Dar-Es-Salaam Tanzania 12/07/2007 09:28:04

KATE Moss and Lily Cole may have made their first appearance on the catwalk at the age of 14, but future supermodels may have to wait until they turn 16 to hit the fashion circuit.
"I think if they are healthy enough and they are safe enough, then why not model at that age? They have got lovely figures at that age," Mrs Stewart said.

She acts as chaperone for her daughter, and does not agree that modelling "sexualises" young girls.

"They are only showing the clothes off," Mrs Stewart said. "If you look at what 14-year-old girls wear, it is very similar to what you see on the catwalk - just a cheaper, high-street version."

Know something. You can never teach old monkeys new tricks. Sex or no sex, do you really think that will stop the pornop. Carzy this reading Imean the sanctions.
honest. Those who want to will try in privte. Toughen the spring tight realeased faster it flies. let them be. This is not a driving test.

7

Maurice,

Fife 12/07/2007 12:36:51

A Farm I worked on in South Africa in the early 80's used to export fruit to the UK. During the school holidays the labourers kids used to earn a few pennies by helping out during picking season. UK inspectors came round one day and saw this. The farm was then deamed to be using child labour and was blacklisted. 36 familes (including kids) were then left jobless and ultimately homeless. Not long after, Kate Moss at 14 was cavorting on the catwalk. This too is child labour just in a different industry. Another example of british double standard?

8

Petroleum Head,

Edinburgh 12/07/2007 12:41:02

Maurice,

The example you give there is typical of the actions of blinkered, politically correct jobsworths. These are the kinds of people who would rather see kids starve than see them work for what they consider to be inadequate pay in sub-standard conditions.

I sincerely hope that all these jobsworths get their come-uppance some day---and that whatever it is, it is excrutiatingly painful.

9

J.O.,

12/07/2007 13:16:37

"They look glamorous, they look gorgeous, they are OK. But they are not OK."

They most certainly do not look glamorous or gorgeous. Just look at that picture of Kate Moss on this very page, she looks terrible!

10

de Hairun,

12/07/2007 13:25:18

Thank God they're finally started to do something about this ridiculous situation. Most of these "mothers" would be better placed working to support their children rather than hope their daughters get rich to keep them from an honest days work and to hell with the consequences. How can these girls be expected to have any self respect or self worth if they have to depend on their appearance?
This is just as bad as the child beauty queen thing in the US.
Kate Moss should serve as an example as why this should be banned. A coke head, shacked up with a junkie and having suffered from eating disorders. If a single mother in a lowly paid job in Easterhouse or somewhere did this her child would be taken away.

11

TimW1234,

0ttawa, Canada 12/07/2007 13:38:36

What about the male models? They are just as sexualised and hit upon and into drugs and illicit sex as the women. Why are they being ignored?

They cannot all be rampant seducers of young female models and some of them look VERY young to me and the way they are dressed by designers they may as well be wearing a tight body suit.

Scandalous!

12

Pickleskin 25,

12/07/2007 14:50:18

If a 14 year old girl wants to be a model and is told that she can't until she is 16, it certainly isn't going to combat eating disorders. She will do everything she can to combat puberty and keep her body looking the way it did when of a young age.

13

gfaBlack,

At work till 10 12/07/2007 17:18:16

The whole of the model industry needs a major shake up.
To prevent a 14 yearold girl from walking down a cat walk because she is 14 is stupid.
Any model below a size 10 should be banned from the cat walk on health and safety grounds.
As the recent tv programmes highlited size zero has profound effects on your health.
It is assumed that a woman watching a slim model walk down the cat walk will think 'I could look that good in that dress!'.
Unfortunatly for these deluded ladies the reality is (unless they too have a body like a stick insect) that they dont quite carry it off.
The fashon industry should cater for the masses and model differing size clothes with obviously differing sized models.
Very few of my friends concider the 'Thinner' lady to be attractive. Most (including myself) prefer a more rounded figure.
Women will probably automaticaly think we are talking about brest size. No not nessaserily. This area again needs to be addressed as large brests are not what the majority of chaps look for. They look for well proportioned features.
An hour glass figure is the dogs Bol*^$%ks.
In my opinion. ;-}
Black.

14

Selgovae,

Scottish Borders 12/07/2007 17:53:11

#7 Maurice

"Another example of british double standard?"

Um, well, not exactly, ehhh, you see, mmmm, not so simple, ahh, yes.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.