Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


MSP hints Lockerbie bomber may drop appeal

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 May 2009
A NATIONALIST MSP has given the clearest hint yet that the Lockerbie bomber is preparing to drop his appeal in the hope of being reunited with his family in Libya.
The Libyan authorities have requested that Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi be transferred to North Africa from Scotland to serve out the remainder of his sentence there.

But the Scottish Government can agree to the transfer request only if all le
gal proceedings are completed and, as Megrahi is currently appealing against his conviction, he would have to drop the appeal to be eligible for transfer.

Christine Grahame, an SNP list MSP for the South of Scotland, met Megrahi – who is suffering from terminal cancer – in Greenock Prison yesterday. She said afterwards that Megrahi was in deteriorating health and was "absolutely desperate" to see his family.

This appeared to be a clear sign that Megrahi is willing to do anything – including drop his appeal – to make himself eligible for transfer to Libya.

But, even if he does that, there is no guarantee ministers will accede to the request.

Justice secretary Kenny MacAskill, First Minister Alex Salmond and the Scottish Cabinet will make the decision within the next 90 days.

Mr Salmond made clear earlier this week that the decision would be made on judicial grounds only, and not for humanitarian reasons.

After her hour-long visit, Ms Grahame refused to say whether Megrahi – who is serving a life sentence for the 1988 bombing which killed 270 people – was intending to abandon his what is second appeal.

Emerging from the prison, she said: "I found it quite upsetting. The man is obviously very ill and he is desperate to see his family – absolutely desperate to see his family – so, whatever it takes, that's the priority."

She added: "He did tell me things I can't discuss with you.

"But I am absolutely more convinced than ever that there has been a miscarriage of justice."

Asked if Megrahi planned to press on with his appeal, Ms Grahame said: "I can't say that – that is for him to say through his lawyers."

But the MSP again stressed Megrahi's anxiety to see his wife and children.

"I can just tell you what he told me – that his priority is to see his family," she said.

Megrahi was diagnosed with prostate cancer last year and later failed to be freed on bail pending his appeal, which finally got under way last Tuesday in Edinburgh.

Ms Grahame said: "His health is deteriorating, he was pretty upset and he is a man who wants to see his family."

With his health worsening, Megrahi believed he had only "a short time to go", Ms Grahame said.

"It was all about his family – we did talk about other matters, but it kept coming back to the importance of family," she said.

Megrahi did not tell her how long he expected to live, nor did he offer an opinion on the transfer request by Libyan authorities, said Ms Grahame.

But she also said he wanted to clear his name.

"That is essential to him as well," she said.

"Other matters I can't discuss with you because it would prejudice anything else."

Ms Grahame has previously said that if Megrahi's appeal was abandoned, there should be a public inquiry, and she repeated that view yesterday.

She said Megrahi knew a lot about the Lockerbie case.

"This man has lived this case for the last decade; he knows more about it probably than any other person on the planet. He is well-informed, but his priority is his family.

"The man is an able man, but he is a man who is terminally ill and missing his family, as we all would. He wants to die at home with his family."

Scottish Government and Scottish Prisons Service staff have started compiling information that will be used by ministers to decide on Megrahi's possible transfer to Libya.

However, that decision cannot be taken until and unless Megrahi abandons his appeal, something he has not yet done.





The full article contains 678 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 May 2009 9:35 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Lockerbie
 
1

W Smith,

Middle East 09/05/2009 04:04:38
As knife crime continues to rise under the SNP our Christine is more interested in the welfare of a muslim terrorist.

So if its not Mike Weir (SNP) defending the Dundee Taliban (James McLintock) - he's 'innocent' as well according to our Mike - its the bleeding heart Christine bleating on and on about this.

This is getting a wee bit predictable is not Alex?

Especially considering the SNP will not support the Scottish lads fighting in Afghanistan but they're always falling over themselves to support this lot.

In my opinion, the 79 Group is still alive and kicking.

SAOR ALBA!
2

Kipling,

09/05/2009 04:52:36
If the Libyan government had not been aiding the IRA in the years prior to the PanAm disaster would this man be in prison? I think not. The prosecution was simply a means to bring the Libyan government to heel. Saorry Alba, u got it rong.
3

Mercutio,

FALKIRK 09/05/2009 05:15:42
Mr Salmond stated categorically in 2007 that this man should serve his sentence in Scotland. Now he says that PTA should receive due process.Is Mr Salmond worried that if the appeal is heard the Scottish Legal System would be discredited just like the Banks?
4

Jock's Away,

Africa 09/05/2009 06:30:55
Mr Megrahi is but one man with a cancer that claim humans every day. The worse cancer is that which is eating the Scottish justice system and British political sysyem from within. That which Government can deny the citizens there right to see justice done.Denies an accused the human right of a fair trial.It is quite apparent the mans trial was tained & the verdict is in doubt. This makes it even more urgent for the politician and Judges that the problem goes away.
That a crime was committed is Never in question what is is who did it. Were all of the above sacrificed at the alter of Anglo American expediency?? the special relationship? The victims families got hand outs but did they get the justice they crave?? Libya paid not so much from a position of guilt but from the need to get the special reltionship off it's case. Dr Swire has it right the case can not yet be closed, Mr Megrahi May yet become the latest falal victim of that horrific example of mans in humanity to man.
5

puskas,

East kilbride 09/05/2009 07:55:19
The headline is bull..

Hamish, your a twister..

The whole interview by Christine Grahame was heard on BBC Radio Scotland 810.... You may have heard it but you obviously didn't listen..

6

Mallory,

Edinburgh 09/05/2009 08:21:13
Dropping the appeal might be very helpful for preserving the dignity and reputation of Scottish Justice...
7

Don Roberto,

09/05/2009 10:17:48
Better he dies besides his family and friends in Libya than in Greenock with severe doubt hanging over his head.
8

overshot,

perth 09/05/2009 10:43:41
Megrai is carrying the can for a lot of other people. Repatriate himand try to improve the world.
9

greenhill,

09/05/2009 10:46:36
Swire has stated that he would forgive Megrahi even if he thought he was guilty. He is a looney Longford Christian.Turning the other cheeck is not a moral position it is weak and pathetic.

Soon Megrahi will be wormfood:good riddance.
10

Don Roberto,

09/05/2009 11:00:03
#10. And if he is innocent?
11

Prudence,

09/05/2009 11:49:27
If the tumours are in the bone , Mr Magrahi has little time left. Prostrate cancer is on the increase in the UK. Would Mr Magrahi have been free of it , had he led a normal life in Lyba ? What is the rate of incidence of prostrate cancer in Arab countries? I think a golden opportunity is being lost here due to lack of humanitarian efforts.
12

Luigiana,

Aberdeen 09/05/2009 12:28:08
It will be very conveneient for the Scottish judicary if Magrahi's appeal is dropped. There are so many unanswered questions concerning this whole affair. The Scottish judges were under extreme pressure to convict "someone" during the Lockerbie show-trial, and there is a lingering suspicion that not all available evidence was fully considered.

I fully sympathise with the friedns and families of those who lost their lives over Lockerbie, but it is important to establish, beyond reasonable doubt, if Margrahi was indeed responsible. Without a proper appeal, some doubt remains.
13

Donald F,

Court of Appeal 09/05/2009 13:32:12
There is a powerful mass of evidence showing Megrahi (and Libya) of being responsible for the worst mass murder in UK criminal history.
Hours after the bombing, a German airport worker identified an unaccompanied suitcase, originating Malta, being transferred onto the PanAm feeder flight. Also, clothes identified as being in the bomb suitcase, came from a batch sold in a Maltese clothes shop. Megrahi travelled to Malta on a FALSE PASSPORT the day before the bombing. He worked for Libyan Intelligence. He was intimately associated with MEBO who make – wait for it – BOMB TIMERS. He resembled the Libyan who bought the clothes from the Maltese clothes shop. But perhaps most significantly of all, his sidekick, Al Fhima, wrote December 1988 diary notes speaking about obtaining "Air Malta tags for Megrahi" (tags that would be used to start the bomb on its journey from Malta). All of this evidence is accepted as being FACT. Even Megrahi has now been forced to admit that he worked for Libya and travelled on a false passport. Not much is said about Al Fhima's acquittal, who some feel got away with cold-blooded murder.
People should read the undeniable circumstantial evidence that resulted in Megrahi's conviction, before being misled by a biased media establishment where not one single journalist has felt compelled to investigate the lesser-known evidence highlighting the security of this conviction. Even SACL aren't jumping on the "Megrahi Is Innocent" bandwagon. www.SACL.info/Lockerbie.htm - and they know more than most in here about judicial corruption and legal conspiracy.

Megrahi should not be sent back to the country responsible for employing him to down a passenger aircraft in mid-flight.
14

Observer,,

Glasgow 09/05/2009 13:45:40
14 the dogs in the street know that Megrahi is innocent. A patsy, a victim of a stitch up. Most people think Iran brought down the plane, in realiation for a passenger plane of theirs brought down by the US. Allegedly.

What an impossible position for the Scottish government or any person with any form of ethical or moral sense. This is emotional blackmail of the most vicious kind.
15

Observer,,

Glasgow 09/05/2009 13:49:57
The Scottish government need to try and find some way of releasing Megrahi, even if it is in Scotland, that does not compromise legal proceedings. Megrahi's legal team have every intention of continuing the appeal posthumously. They can do that. This is now about trying to accord the man as good a death as we can in the circumstances. Considering the hideous injustice that the Scottish juduciary system stands accused of, let's hope they find a way to square the circle.
16

JC1,

Glasgow 09/05/2009 17:38:22
Christine Grahame, as in 'Oh no, it's Christine Grahame!'
looks like the nats tied up on knots
17

ultravires,

Edinburgh 09/05/2009 20:59:52
Christine Grahame's attempt to get some better headlines after her £25,000 stationery expenses claim was revealed.

How long has she been on the Lockerbie bandwagon ?
18

Boston sports fan,

09/05/2009 21:39:49
If things are so dire for this terrorist, why doesn't Christine bring the family he misses to stay at her house? She could then bring them with her when she gives comfort and aid to the enemy. It's too bad the families of the victims can only visit the cemetery.
19

Prudence,

09/05/2009 22:28:36
There's a quality some human beings have called compassion. Shakespeare knew about it. Its mentioned in the Koran. In the Bible its the concept of forgiveness, and before that Buddha talked about it. Unlike "feeling sorry " an individual is carried into a positive state of consciousness, beneficial to all. Things might be dire for those that have little time left to come to terms with their wrath before Mr Magrahi dies.
20

steve52,

Kinfauns 09/05/2009 23:07:43
Justice? Not in this country and anyone who thinks there is, well your living on cloud nine. Why was this deal between the UK governemnt and Lybia signed? Just how many prisoners of UK nationality are being held in Lybia? I would guess at none. So who has most to gain here? The UK and US governemnts thats who.

Compassion? He should be treated the same as any other prisoner and only released when he has weeks left to live. Oh and I think the guy is innocent.

The appeal should go ahead but it wont as the governemnts dont want the truth to come out. Its OK for we here in the UK to know how corrupt our court system is but not for the rest of the World to know.

As in all criminal cases the Crown Office goes out to win at all costs and justice has nothing to do with it. The appeal system is just the same, our judges do not want a black mark on the judicial system so they help with the cover up.

Our Lord Advocate and those before here quite happily conceal evidence from the defence where this would harm their case. This Lord advocate even hides behind public interest to conceal the truth and save her subordonates in the PF's office and police. She quite openly refuses to prosecute corrupt police officers yet leave men rotting in prison for crimes they did not commit.

Last thing...there are some right sick person with out parents on here.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.