Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Scottish hotel downturn worst in Britain as trade plunges by 7%

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 28 July 2008
SCOTLAND'S ailing tourism sector was dealt a further blow yesterday as it emerged hotel occupancy rates had fallen more than anywhere else in Britain.
Rates across Scotland fell 6.8 per cent in May compared with the same month last year. Although the average occupancy rate across the UK was down 0.3 per cent,

Glasgow's hotels were down 12.3 per cent, while Edinburgh's and Aberdeen's were down
5.6 and 5.1 per cent respectively.

The figures follow a similar pattern to those unveiled for April by market analysts PKF. Then, Edinburgh's occupancy rate was worst hit, down 5.2 per cent compared with April 2007.

The firm believes a combination of a cut in corporate spending due to the credit crunch and a slump in short-break business is to blame.

Alastair Rae, a partner in the hospitality and leisure sector at PKF, said: "It's clear that Scotland is now experiencing a downturn in the hospitality sector.

"Given that 2007 was an excellent year for the hotel sector in Scotland, it was almost inevitable the 2008 figures would be down on the previous year.

"But there are signs that there has been a steep fall in certain parts of the country, with Glasgow experiencing the largest drop of any city in the UK in both occupancy and rooms yield, probably due to a reduction in corporate spending.

"Edinburgh has also experienced a slowdown which is, in part, attributable to a reduction in holiday visitors and also continued pressure on the financial services industry as the impact of the credit crunch continues to be felt.

"The picture across the UK is more positive but this could be affected by single events, such as Cardiff hosting rugby's Heineken Cup Final in May. Equally, Liverpool is benefiting from its tenure as the European City of Culture."

VisitScotland has already been forced to reallocate £1.5 million from its US marketing budget to try to woo visitors from the UK, Europe and Canada to come to Scotland over the summer.

The tourism sector is thought to have suffered badly over the last few months because of the rising US dollar, fuel price hikes and the credit crunch.

But hoteliers said that the industry could recover over the next few months if it properly targeted people who had scrapped plans to take a foreign holiday and also pitched their prices at the right market.

Peter Dornan, the chairman of the Edinburgh Principal Hotels Association, which represents three-, four- and five-star hotels in the capital, said: "I don't think we should be too despondent at the moment. People are definitely booking later and later this year and we should be looking at how to attract the last-minute customer by making prices as attractive as possible."

The Scotsman revealed last month that hotels and guest-houses had suffered a major slump in bookings for the normally lucrative summer festivals season.

Hundreds of private flats were still being advertised on the message boards of the Fringe website yesterday, many of them posted in the last few days.

Ron Hewitt, the chief executive of Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce, said: "While we would be foolish to ignore the early warning signs of a dip in the market we should also take this report cautiously.

"We are just entering peak season for Edinburgh and measuring our hospitality sector's performance can only be done effectively over the whole year.

"While any prudent manager will be accounting for an international drop in consumer confidence, early indications are that while we might not reach last year's peak, this will be a very successful festival season."





The full article contains 617 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 28 July 2008 1:43 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

The Answer,

Glasgow 28/07/2008 00:36:53
Lots of rooms available for next weeks fringe, checkout laterooms.com!
2

gerad,

greenock 28/07/2008 00:43:31
Not value for money, and the service is S****
3

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 28/07/2008 01:31:36

D'oh! Is one Stupid or Something!!

Charge £240.00 per night for 'Bed and Breakfast' what do you expect!!

'Muppet's'!

Do you think we are all, 'Rockefeller' or Something,??
4

Fanling,

Switzerland 28/07/2008 01:42:13
If the majority of them slashed their rip-off prices by at least 50% they might gain a touch of sympathy. But, no chance.

Criminally high cost (for bed and no breakfast), surly service, and charging extra for anything they can think of, internet access for one glaring example, are prime characteristics of Scots hotels. This also applies to England and pretty much most of Western Europe.

When in Hong Kong, and more especially in mainland China, the level of service I have known for years is miles better than anywhere. (And I've been in many countries.) Great hotels, great service, genuine friendliness and helpfulness on a level you don't find in Europe, impress, as do their realistically affordable prices.

5

Fanling,

Switzerland 28/07/2008 02:01:05
Hang on .... The headline I posted to above was "Scottish hotel downturn worst in Britain as trade plunges by 7%".

So it's now 12% as we speak. Inflation eh, you just can't control it. If the faceless business moguls that run hotel chains put themselves in the shoes of cash-strapped punters they might just be able to grasp what the problem is. That and the fact that they continue to get away with paying slave wages while shamelessly hoovering up profits.
6

Fanling,

Switzerland 28/07/2008 02:30:54
The genius in charge of headlines has now reverted the percentage. Man, this newspaper is something else these days .
7

S'me,

Edinburgh 28/07/2008 04:42:47
Overpriced and the perceived anti English atmosphere fostered by Nationalists
8

The Daleks,

Longmen 28/07/2008 05:47:10
#4 Fanling

Are you serious about the level of service in Mainland China!!??

I've stayed in dozens of hotels across mainland China. They're incredibly noisy at all hours of the day and night. They're dirty and smoky. Are haunted by extremely dodgy characters, and they all have resident prostitutes who ring your bedroom phone incessantly, until you're forced to disconnect it.

As for Scotland, you could buy a house when I was a boy for the sort of money they currently charge for the use of one room for one night!!
9

SouthernSkye,

28/07/2008 07:27:53
There are many many good and reasonably priced Hotels in Scotland. Just shop around before booking. Herself and I do and we have stayed at some fantastic places (B&B and Hotels). We have also stayed at some very mediocre places.

China....Holiday Inn in GuangZhou it was impossible to sit and read the paper quietly in the bar without some floozy or three pestering you all the time. Quite enjoyed the attention for the first 15 mins then got fed up and went back to my room...alone! Only Hotel in China that I have stayed in has been Floozy-Free was the (Golden?)Flamingo in Harbin.

10

Ninian Reid,

28/07/2008 07:53:24
I feel desperately sorry for decent, hard-working hotel staff throughout Scotland. But until the economics of the madhouse are reversed, it will always be cheaper to EasyJet yourself to the Continent for half-board pampering on an affordable scale.We need bold and brave hotel bosses to DRASTICALLY reduce their rates before the domestic market will flourish - again...No more Malaga, but Mallaig instead.
11

Boy Wonder,

28/07/2008 07:53:30
Hotels are too expensive. Go backpacking. Cheaper and lots more fun.
12

john z,

edinburgh 28/07/2008 08:17:54
A lot of Edinburgh hotels charge outrageous prices, with very poor service, just like many major capital cities around Europe. London and Paris are both the same.

The small bed and breakfasts have a problem though, in that often the standards of the rooms and showers etc.. are not very good. Many owners, especially in the highlands, think it is still the 1960's, with shared showers etc.. People nowadays just don't want that.

It is good to see Gordon Brown, doing his bit for Scottish tourism by taking his holiday, and press entourage to his homw constituency of Fife for his holidays, to help promote the beauty of the East Neuk to the global media.

Oh, hang on, I've just checked, he's actually on holiday in Engerland, to prove his 'britishness' or something, to voters in Southern England.
13

Fanling,

Switzerland 28/07/2008 11:52:43
#9 The Daleks,Longmen
"Are you serious about the level of service in Mainland China!!??"

Of course I'm serious. Why else would I say so? The description of "dozens of hotels across mainland China" which have been your said experience is unrecognisable to me. I'm choosy about where I kip.

14

Guga II,

Rockall 28/07/2008 13:43:36
As Maggie Broon is dragging us into a recession, people can't afford to pay the rip-off prices charged by hotel or B&Bs. They charge international five star hotel prices for standards more akin to backpackers hostels.
15

Joanna,

Cambs, England 28/07/2008 14:35:04
I think S'me @ No 8 has hit the nail on the head.

The biggest market for Scottish tourism has always been England, but with frequent headlines announcing that the English are no longer welcome people are put off visiting. Its a shame because most people in Scotland are friendly but recent 'anti-English' actions like the Edinburgh Dungeon story, which had a full airing in English papers and was jumped on by English Nationalists don't help matters.


16

Kitti Kat,

Newtown Square 28/07/2008 19:34:33
As most visitors will say, the hotels in Edinburgh are very expensive and with the pound being almost twice the value of the dollar, we yanks are thinking twice about visiting the UK. Edinbugh is a beautiful city (or was until you started building those awful buildings) . Some of the hotels are way over-priced for what the rates are which is another reason to t hink twice aboiut staying there. Especially since most of the hotels have no air conditioning, window screens or windows that open enough to let in the bugs and breezes should there be one. Rather than terr down your lovely old buildings, they should modernize the hotels,etc.
17

Navvy,

28/07/2008 19:55:43
far too expensive. Few othe countries charge by the person, most charge, and logically, by the room. A modest charge for the additional breafast and towel is all that is acceptable.

Go to Germany for much better value for money
18

Mincepie76537,

Alba 28/07/2008 21:11:06
I'm not surpriused at this - these hotels and B&Bs are so over-priced it boggles the mind as to why anyone would use them and hence why tourism in Scotland is suffering.
19

MoragtheToerag,

Argyll 28/07/2008 22:27:34
We looked at staying in a hotel father north of here for a wee holiday.

Then discovered it was far, far cheaper to hire a 3-bed caravan. No extra parking fees, either.

We've been going self-catering now for several years and it works out miles cheaper than any hotel - drinks easily and cheapily accessed, too.
20

danbob,

28/07/2008 22:43:58
Nothing to do with scottish nationalism as some have suggested. I think 21# is nearer the mark. The cost of renting a caravan or even a cottage in Scotland is far cheaper than say Cornwall. And the countryside is head and shoulders better too. Hotels are pricing themselves out.
21

Snuffy Ivy,

Somewhere 29/07/2008 02:00:41
Americans are put off by the lousy prices, equally lousy service of Scottish hotels. Dollar has dropped and so visiting the UK is out for this year...probably next too.
22

Statsman,

Edinburgh 29/07/2008 03:05:16
Expensive, rubbish service and the ASH Nazis have made it difficult to get a smoking room anywhere. It's easy to see why anywhere but Scotland is a better destination.
23

Breezy,

Argyll 29/07/2008 05:10:55
Hardly surprising folk no matter where they are from, are shying away from expensive hotels, 21 and 22 are bang on, the caravan trade here is doing very well, depending on standards of course, cottages/cabins too. There's no better holiday for folk, and families of six or even eight can have a weeks break for as little as £400 to £500.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.