Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


T in the Park

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Puffins suffer as warming sea hits food supply for nesting isle



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 June 2008
PUFFIN numbers on one of Scotland's strongholds have dropped by 30 per cent in five years.
It is believed Scotland's most popular seabird could be suffering because of a lack of food supply caused by warming seas as a result of climate change.

The Isle of May in the Firth of Forth is home to the largest colony of puffins in the North Se
a.

After almost 40 years of numbers rapidly increasing on the island, the puffin population has now dramatically fallen.

Five years ago there were 69,000 pairs of puffins on the Isle of May but now numbers have dropped to just 41,000 pairs.

This contrasts to 100,000 pairs that scientists had expected to find if numbers had continued growing at previous rates.

Professor Mike Harris from the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, who led the research, has been studying puffins on the Isle of May for the past three decades. He said: "Something worrying appears to have happened over last winter and probably the one before.

"Puffins appear to be joining the ranks of other seabirds in the North Sea that are suffering reduced breeding success and decline in numbers."

He thinks the most likely cause is sea warming, which has an impact on the amount of plankton in the water.

With fewer plankton the fish that feed on them are affected, and so are the puffins that rely on the fish to feed.

"Puffins can probably cope quite well with a change of sea temperature," he said. "It doesn't affect them directly but just through the food supply."

He said when the birds returned to the Isle of May this year to breed they were very underweight compared to normal, backing up the theory they are struggling to find enough food.

"It's too early to start talking about the demise of the puffins but we need to understand what's going on," he said.

He said another possibility is that large numbers decided to have a year off from breeding. But this is very unlikely.

"We also need to widen the survey to include other colonies in the North Sea to measure to what extent the population is declining in the area," he said.

Caroline Warburton, manager of Wild Scotland, said it was worrying, as puffins were a huge tourist attraction. "They are by far the favourite seabird. If they suffer a similar drop over the next few years, it would become much rarer to see puffins."





The full article contains 423 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 June 2008 10:09 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Guga II,

Rockall 04/06/2008 01:13:16
I gather then that it is nothing to do with the huge quantity of Sand Eels that are hoovered up from the North Sea by European fishing fleets?

It sounds to me like another good reason for us getting out of the CFP, as well as the CAP or, better still, out of the EU altogether.
2

MarkR,

USA 04/06/2008 02:25:06
Global temperatures have not gone up since 1998. Species numbers are always going up and down - it's called cycling. Please note that numbers had been going up for 40 years - while you've been told that the Global Warming Monster was coming to get you. No one said Global Warming was helping puffin numbers for 40 years, did they?
3

Nell,

Far from the Struan 04/06/2008 07:34:48
Maybe its due to the SNP.
4

Beth Boyle,

NY 04/06/2008 07:38:03
That is sad news. I was on the Isle of May in 2005 and the Puffins were amazing. It was one of the most wonderful days of my life. I snapped photos of the Puffins with their bills full of eals.
5

Unimpressed one,

04/06/2008 08:08:19
"It is believed" says it all. No evidence just a belief system. And who says 'climate change' is not the new 21st century religion?
6

Jock E,

Edinburgh 04/06/2008 08:11:53
It may not be the North Sea that's the problem. The Farne Islands 60 miles south of the Isle of May has a flourishing Puffin colony.

A head count is underway for 2008.
7

Marian,

04/06/2008 08:14:02
The EU has allowed the taking of over a million metric tonnes of sandeels from the North Sea, every year for over 25 years. At a conservative estimate that's 20 million tonnes of these tiny fish removed from the food chain. They are supposed to feed wild salmon, cod, haddock, puffins, kittiwakes and other birds and fish. The Danes processed them to make food pellets for farmed-salmon in Scotland, pig food (which is why your bacon tastes of fish) and central heating oil (believe it!).

You will notice that the RSPB, SNH and a host of wildlife NGOs make little reference to the sandeel fishery these days - in fact its a deafening silence. See there's no money or deal-making to be done if you focus on sandeels - because you would be fighting UK Govt, EU Govt and big, big business. Far better to blame it on 'Climate Change' and carry on cosying up to Brown and the EU. Don't make waves and keep getting the grants. In less than 30 years the EU has allowed the destruction and repeated crashing of: the sprat fishery in the Forth, the cod fishery, the herring fishery, the mackerel fishery on the West coast etc.

And they call this 'the common fisheries policy'. Climate change is happening; climate change has always been happening; it is the very nature of climate to change. The simple truth is you can't turn 20 million tonnes of sandeels into pig food and heating oil without wrecking all the ecosystems which depend on them. The silence of the conservation lobby is a complete bloody disgrace.
8

Black Five,

edinburgh 04/06/2008 08:16:42
Just dip your toes in the Forth and tell me the sea has heated up.
9

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 04/06/2008 08:31:08
Amazing isn't it - the EU has caused the crash of every single fish stock in the North Sea over the last 30 years: herring - crashed; mackerel - crashed; cod - crashed; -sprats - crashed; haddock - crashed and h0vering on crashing every year; meagrim - now extinct as a commercial species; sandeels - a million tonnes a year on average over the last 30 years - taken to feed pigs in Denmark (that's why your bacon tastes fishy. Sandeel are also made into pellets for salmon farms - by the hundreds of thousands of tonnes.

I was in Eyemouth harbour last week and spoke to a woman who runs a business there. Her son had just takena trawler to Orkney with a crew of 5. It cost him £4,000 in diesel and they returned with just 300 boxs of fish; not enough to pay for the diesel - let alone 5 mens wages.

Professor Harris should look up 'Ockham's Razor' in the history of Science. It basically says - investigate the most obvious hypothesis first. If the puffins are starving in a fishless sea - maybe it JUST might be something to do with the fact that we have raped the seas to the point where the only profitable stock left to fish for are 'bottom crawlers'L crabs, lobstes and prawns. There's damn little else left.

The RSPB which played a primary role in getting sandeel fishing controlled back in the 90s - is so far down the global warming hysteria helterskelter that it can't see the facts screaming from the obvious data.

'Global warming!' - yeh - that's why at the Farne Islands - 60 miles south - the puffins are thriving. "oh the sea mush be colder down there in the south eh?"

And your taxes pay people like Professor Harris to come up with this garbage. We are truly screwed.
10

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 04/06/2008 08:59:47
Another clue Professor Harris might want to take a look at. There have been numerous sightings of giant whale-sharks around Scotland this May. This is the largest fish in the world - growing well over 15 metres in length. Guess what it feeds on : PLANKTON!

So these giant fish come thousands of miles north to feed on the bloom of plankton we get in UK waters in summer. So its not a shortage of plannkton to feed sandeels - it a shortage of sandeels - period.
11

Marian,

04/06/2008 09:11:08
An SNP amendment to the European Union (Amendment) Bill that would return responsibility for fisheries and marine conservation to national control, was defeated recently after a debate in the House of Commons. The amendment secured the cross-party backing of 175 MPs.

The UK Government agreed to the Lisbon Treaty without seeking any changes to the text which enshrines fisheries in the EU Reform Treaty as an ‘exclusive competence’. National control of fisheries is a ‘red line’ issue for the Scottish Government.

SNP Westminster leader, Angus Robertson MP, who is a member of the European Scrutiny Committee, said:

“Labour MPs have added insult to injury by voting against the restoration of national control, and fishing communities will be outraged.

“This was an opportunity to ditch the disastrous CFP, but, as usual, Labour failed to stand up for the national interest and safeguard the future of one of our oldest and greatest industries.

“First Gordon Brown failed to ensure that fisheries was a red line issue when the Lisbon Treaty was negotiated, and now Labour MPs have shown that the Westminster Government still views fishing as ‘expendable’ just as the Heath Government did in 1970."
12

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 04/06/2008 09:25:06
It is a great pity that articles like this appear in the Scotsman without showing the evidence upon which the story is based. I don't know off-hand where to find the temperature figures for the North Sea for, say, the last 100 years, but I'm sure they exist and Jenny Haworth should have put in the effort to find them. She has obviously spoken to Prof. Mike Harris and I have no doubt he would have the data to hand. A temperature/time graph of the North Sea would have been very useful.

Likewise, there should have been a discussion of the relative impacts of the sand-eel fishery. Again, presumably there is a graph of the total North sea catch of sand eels for the last several decades: why not inform the debate by showing one?

Prof. Mike Harris states, "we need to understand what's going on". That is correct, and it also implies, of course, that we do not know enough yet. But some assessment by him of the relative impacts of the two (or more?) postulated causes of the decline would have been useful.
13

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 04/06/2008 09:49:12
Doing a little Googling, I find that:

"most areas of the eastern North Atlantic have experienced a warming trend of between 0.2°C and 1 °C per decade since the 1980s." (This refers to sea surface temperatures, SSTs)

See Fig.3 in:

http://www.oceannet.org/medag/reports/IACMST_reports/MCP_report/ch_temp/MCPreport_temp.htm

From the accompanying map, the Firth of Forth (that the article is about) looks as though it is warming by 0.4 to 0.5deg. Celsius per decade. It would not be surprising if that had significant consequences for sea life.
14

Flash67,

Edinburgh 04/06/2008 09:59:17
The north sea populations of the lesser sand-eel have been undergoing significant decline, and in all probability, the change in composition (not quantity) of the phyto- and photo-plankton due to increased sea temperatures AND overfishing are responsible. The comment on whale-sharks is not relevant as these large fish will feed indisciminately on any type of plankton as well as small fish.
Either way, the crash in puffin numbers (and many other seabirds in many other colonies) has been both rapid and undeniably human induced. Yes, animal populations show natural, self-regulating oscillations (normally due to reltionships between their predator and food availability) but the rapidity and cross species impact of the changes shows something fundamentaly wrong in the north sea.
15

Flash67,

edinburgh 04/06/2008 10:00:40
sorry - forgot to include reference on other recent sea bird population crashes... http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2004/dec/21/food.fishing
16

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 04/06/2008 10:37:29
"looks as though it is warming by 0.4 to 0.5deg. Celsius per decade. It would not be surprising if that had significant consequences for sea life."

Oh for christs sake Slioch, switch on. A rise of 0.5 deg is nothing. Life isn't so fragile that it depends on temperature stability of fractions of a degree.

This is just another attempt at scaremongering. There are many factors that could result in this decline and none of them are due to "global warming".
17

Flash67,

Edinburgh 04/06/2008 10:44:55
#16 - It's funny how people seem delighted to show off their lack of knowledge in marine biology and ecology. Yes - many species ARE that temperature dependent in a particular locality... in other words, the plankton species don't die out, the whole population (NOT individuals!) migrate over long periods to stay in environments which suit them precisely. The problem is the sheer speed of change - 0.5 deg over a decade doesn't seem much, but equates to 5 deg per century, which is a MASSIVE difference to a marine ecosystem... This kind of speed of change, (looking at marine sediment and ice records for evidence) is unparalleled in geological history. Please don't let your politics and ignorance (and I mean that in the specific meaning of the word - lack of knowledge in this area rather than a judgement on your intelligence!) get in the way of looking at the facts...
18

Flash67,

Edinburgh 04/06/2008 11:02:02
#9 - Tweedmouth - By 'EU caused the crash...' I take it you mean fishermen rather than the EU beauracrats going out in boats themselves....?
19

Flash67,

Edinburgh 04/06/2008 11:04:44
oh - and the RSPB HAVE been asking for a reduction in sand eel fishery -
http://www.birdlife.org/news/features/2005/01/north_sea_seabirds.html

"Sandeels prop up the marine food web, from cod and mackerel to kittiwakes. There is a compelling case for reining in the offshore commercial industrial fishery for sandeels even further," said Euan Dunn, Head of Marine Policy at the RSPB. The preliminary scientific advice for next year is to cut the catch limit by 60% due to the "historic low" sandeel stock level, a move greatly welcomed by BirdLife.
20

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 04/06/2008 12:56:22
#17:

"...but equates to 5 deg per century, which is a MASSIVE difference to a marine ecosystem..."

Yes I can do basic maths too.

I also know that sea temperatures in some areas of the world encounter greater temperature swings than that seasonally. Somehow creatures still seem to survive perfectly well.

The changes we are experiencing are caused by all manner of things. I am fed up with hearing it all being put down to "global warming".

And what would these do-called "experts" say if the sea temperatures started steadily dropping in the next few years? What if the puffin population started picking up in numbers with no perceptable change in the trends they now claim to observe?

I very much doubt if it would be "We're sorry, we got it wrong."
21

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 04/06/2008 14:07:20
Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head gave a remarkably frank account of his attitude to scientific evidence a couple of days ago in another Scotsman thread about climate change. He said:

"To be honest ..., fancy graphs (with hand-picked logarithmic scales) and 20cm thick reports from "experts" mean nothing to me---especially when they are presented as "evidence"."
...
"My synopsis of the whole matter goes from personal memory of what the weather has been like each year I have been alive. The simple fact of the matter is that it has not changed. Not one iota."

A more trenchant illustration of someone who rejects scientific evidence and recording in favour of his own personal experience and memory would be difficult to find.
22

AbandonAllHope,

04/06/2008 14:44:16
Theres been a massive increase in snake pipefish as well, theyre usually associated with poor breeding seasons. Sandeel hoovering is the main reason though for the adult birds.
23

Geomac 1,

Scotland 04/06/2008 14:46:51
Oh Goody, goody! yet another bandwagon to jump on and blame Westminster for!
24

Neil,

Glasgow 04/06/2008 16:25:31
It is disgraceful that this story & headline went out like this. There is no evidence whatsoever that the change in puffin numbers has anythingb to do with warming, particularly since (A) there has been none since 1998 & (B) there are many othe, less PC, possibilities some of them mentioned by commenters.

The Scotsman could just as truthfully have written "ELECTION OF PUTIN'S MAN CAUSED BY HIGH LEVELS OF PHLOGISTON" & who knows - they may yet.
25

MIncePie476538,

Alba 04/06/2008 19:47:03
Sorry Folks,

I ate a lot of those puffins myself as I did not have anything to eat due to rising food (and oil) prices. Please forgive me...

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.