Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Homecoming 2009 advert features song of homesickness

View Video
Download Video

Video

A video clip of the new Homecoming TV advert
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 29 November 2008
WHILE sitting on a beach in northern France, the young Dougie MacLean wrote a song about his love for Scotland.
The lyrics to Caledonia proved so powerful that MacLean's friends started longing for their homeland.

Now 30 years on, a tune that he finished in just a few minutes has been given the ultimate accolade as the official rallying cry for Scots to return home in 2009 for the Homecoming celebrations.

Yesterday, in tribute to a song that has lasted a generation, Alex Salmond, the First Minister, launched a TV advert featuring Scottish singers, actors and sporting heroes performing lines from MacLean's work.

The £150,000 advert, made to promote the 250th anniversary of Robert Burns's birth, features ten famous Scots: actors Sir Sean Connery and Brian Cox, cycling star Chris Hoy and golfer Sam Torrance, musicians Lulu, Sandi Thom, Eddi Reader and Amy Macdonald, plus Kelly Brown and Thom Evans from the Scotland rugby team.

At a special screening at Edinburgh's Filmhouse cinema, the First Minister said: "Caledonia is a song that resonates with Scots the world over.

"For those far away it is a reminder of strong bonds, full of the promise of return. That is what makes it the perfect anthem for our year of Homecoming.

"I'm especially proud that we have a stellar line-up of Scottish talent who will deliver this invitation through this new television campaign."

Peter Lederer, the chairman of VisitScotland, said: "Caledonia is the one song that pulls at the heartstrings of Scots around the world.

"Every time a Scot hears it, they think of Scotland and what it means to them."

"We hope the advert and celebrations taking place next year inspire people in Scotland."

Caledonia was first released in 1979 on an album of the same name, and later came to prominence as the soundtrack to a Tennent's lager advert in 1990.

Since that time there have been repeated calls to use the song as Scotland's national anthem.

The advert will be shown on the BBC and STV and in cinemas throughout Scotland. It will then be available online at YouTube and will be sent to one million people around the globe via internet groups linked to the Scottish diaspora.

Mr Salmond said: "This campaign is a victory for optimism. We have got to get away from negative perceptions of Scotland and with Homecoming we are hoping to mobilise five million plus Scots and make them feel proud."

The Homecoming budget is £5 million, although all the celebrities appeared in the advert for free. They were filmed in a studio but appear in front of famous Scottish backdrops ranging from Edinburgh Castle to Far Beach, aimed at enticing Scots back home.

Dougie MacLean said: "It's amazing that my wee homesick song has become such an iconic tune for lovers of Scotland all around the world. And I'm thrilled that Homecoming Scotland is using it as the call to Scots and anyone with a fondness for Scotland to come home in 2009."

There are currently no plans to show the advert on English television.

Helen Campbell, the group marketing manager of VisitScotland, said: "It is important to see how the public respond to the advert.

"Then maybe we will look at broadcasting it in England."

IN QUOTES

ALEX SALMOND: "Caledonia is a song that resonates with Scots the world over."

DOUGIE MACLEAN: "It's amazing that my wee homesick song has become such an iconic tune for lovers of Scotland."

AMY MACDONALD: "I hope the ad inspires people all over the world to come to Scotland."

LULU: "Scotland lives in my heart. No matter where I travel, I always feel at home when I bump into a Scot."




Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 28 November 2008 9:42 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Homecoming , Video Archive
 
1

Rufus T. Firefly,

28/11/2008 22:35:33
Salmond said "I'm especially proud that we have a stellar line-up of Scottish talent who will deliver this invitation through this new television campaign."

So Sam Torrance, Lulu, Sandi Thom, Eddi Reader, Amy Macdonald, Kelly Brown and Thom Evans are a stellar Line-up!!

The only ones missing are Michele McManus, the Macdonald Brothers and Sidney Devine.

What a world famous line-up.

What a waste of tax payers money once again.

Just as well there is not a recession on.

2

,

29/11/2008 00:23:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
3

Sam the man the snp Fear most,

STOP THE SNP 29/11/2008 00:31:16
I am glad i am British i would hang my head in shame if i was Scottish every time i heard this rubbish.

What kind of mascot for scotland is a wife beater who lives abroad and takes his money/taxes with him, connery is a vote loser for the snp-GOOD.

STOP THE SNP
4

Sam the man the snp Fear most,

STOP THE SNP 29/11/2008 00:31:44
I am glad i am British i would hang my head in shame if i was Scottish every time i heard this rubbish.

What kind of mascot for scotland is a wife beater who lives abroad and takes his money/taxes with him, connery is a vote loser for the snp-GOOD.

STOP THE SNP
5

Rufus T. Firefly,

29/11/2008 00:35:55
Helen Campbell, the group marketing manager of VisitScotland, said: "It is important to see how the public respond to the advert.

"Then maybe we will look at broadcasting it in England."

Well thats the final nail in the coffin of the Union if that happens.

If we start bombarding England with that advert and these mega stars, they will be demanding a separation referendum withing months.
6

I-Mac,

29/11/2008 00:37:58
"At a special screening at Edinburgh's Filmhouse cinema, the First Minister said: "Caledonia is a song that resonates with Scots the world over."

Not me, Eck. I enjoy many Scots songs but this one is a dull, plodding effort.
7

,

29/11/2008 00:42:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

Rufus T. Firefly,

29/11/2008 00:49:01
Its a shame Timmy Mallett is not Scottish. He would be the perfect addition to that "stellar" line up.

9

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 01:15:25


I have purchased several hundred, 'sick bags' in-case I am unfortunate, to get a unwanted glimpse of the advert!

Mind you 'money not wasted' if we use it to entertain, as comedy show, the 'Monkeys' at Edinburgh zoo.

10

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 01:26:31


OMG!!

I have just seen a 'leaked' version on You Tube!, take a neb!,.....


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCEDjEp60aE&feature=related




11

SilverShred,

in the jamjar 29/11/2008 01:44:08
This site has become a sanctuary for sad unionists sacks with more than a few screws loose.
12

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 01:57:50

SilverShred ~12,

'The Loony Bin' one presumes?

Or just a thread commenting on the,..'Muppet Show'?

Whatever!, might be better than your,..'jamjar'!



13

Dark Lochnagar,

29/11/2008 02:05:36
Why is Rufus T Sh!tefly always first on these posts. Does he sit up all night like some deranged hack with a fag in the side of his gub, toungue drooling waiting for some new story he can spin against Scotland. Get out you sad Fwck!
14

Edward,

29/11/2008 02:20:09
#14 Dark Lochnagar
Think your right there, Rufus is one sad motha f**ka, who isnt even Scottish, thank god, who is mentally unstable, same goes for that idiot Sam the pratt
15

W Smith,

Middle East 29/11/2008 05:17:19
The idea that some Scots left Scotland only to regret the decision is what I would expect from the politically correct, kilt wearing, sporran-must-be-synthetic-fur, hug-a-muslim, SNP!

I have friends and relatives who emigrated to Oz, USA, Canada and their teenage kids don't want to go back to dad's homeland.

I DON'T BLAME THEM!

Ah yes Mr Salmond this homesick song makes me want to come back to my beloved Scotland and pay back all the income tax I've managed to dodge over the years!

AYE RIGHT!

BTW
I suppose we should be thankful that The Proclaimers are not inculded in this .. er.... "stellar line up".
16

Robert Matheson,

Sierra Madre 29/11/2008 05:55:11
What is it that makes Scots in Scotland so bloody cynical?
Ya canna see the forest for the trees!!?? Get off yer high horse and travel, you'll soon see what you're missing. I'm five generations removed from my ancestors that lived in the Highlands, but my heart is still there.
17

tassiestag,

rosebery 29/11/2008 07:20:36
im speechless.......well almost,90%of the s..t head posters above are the ones who hold scotland back........by the way chris hoy is a world super star.
18

Moffat's Murkin,

29/11/2008 07:51:55
#24 Tassietag, the cringe factor from the 90% is palpable, even the subhead referring to homesickness is laced with bile.

As Rufus/Andy et al are supposedly already here, it's just as well the video isn't aimed at them. This is for the expats that love and visit Scotland, rather than the haters like WU.

19

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 07:53:06
1900: It was reported today that, Queen Victoria, who is now very frail and hard of hearing, whilst celebrating her 80th birthday at Sandringham, surrounded by her family, turned to one of her nurses and asked the name of the tune being played?

The surprised nurse replied: "Why, Ma'am, it's the National Anthem!

The Queen replied, "Oh, please don't remind me? Albert and I could never stand listening to that bloody dirge, day in, day out"!
20

Doc Martin,

Dundee 29/11/2008 07:56:22
Ditto No.24

90% of the posters, but thankfully only 1% of the population. If you don't have anything positive or constructive to say..... then shut up.




21

Moffat's Murkin,

29/11/2008 08:01:17
Have to say I'm amazed someone persuaded Sam Torrance to sing!

This is the definitive version, played by Dougie McLean in Ontario. Only viewed 135,000 times on youtube.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=KMpSg78s684&NR=1
22

,

29/11/2008 08:42:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
23

,

29/11/2008 08:48:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

New kid on the blog,

29/11/2008 08:51:20
What a MISERABLE bunch of t***S! Can the Scotsman NEVER do anything right? Merry Xmas![Not!]
25

,

29/11/2008 08:55:49
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

ricky40,

29/11/2008 08:57:25
Rufus

As your posts are so full of negativity it's a pity your mum was not more negative all these years ago.

Saturday Sannie

If the brightest and the best have left Scotland then, presumably, you are still there.
27

Unimpressed one,

29/11/2008 08:57:52
#1, No mention of Fran and Anna or the Krankies either!!!
28

John Cameron,

St Andrews 29/11/2008 08:59:19
This is the most toe-curling nonsense in Scottish history. One can almost smell the bannocks being burned on the bonny, heather covered, banks surrounding that lovely clachan known as Easterhouse. Reality check, anyone?
29

Douglas,

Bathgate 29/11/2008 08:59:50
The video is not art, it's a tourist advert designed to tug at the heart strings of those born abroad who have listened at the knee of parents, grandparents and so on to stories of the old country.
If a few well known faces bring some notional Scots over to spend money then it's worked.
30

lachlan,

29/11/2008 09:00:29
glad to see the more supportive comments for the principle at least of the song being posted as daylight comes in. says a lot about the hours some of the critics keep.the term 'billy nae mates come to mind'.
31

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 09:07:02
#37 Douglas

You're right there. The state the economy's in, we need every 'My granny was from Forfar you know' muppet to come 'home' and spend as much of their Yankie/NZ/Ozzie/Hong Kong dollars as possible.
32

ricky40,

29/11/2008 09:08:16
36 John Cameron

"This is the most toe-curling nonsense in Scottish history"

Do you mean even worse than the Scots being dragged against their will into an illegal invasion of a country that left death and desolation behind? Even worse than men, women and children who already led wretched lives being blown to bit?

I think it's you that needs the reality check.
33

ricky40,

29/11/2008 09:09:38
39 Draco

Do you think we should discourage tourists and leave Scotland to miserable gets like you?
34

Gdgy,

dndy 29/11/2008 09:10:05
Xcellent idea....come home to scotland and spend some cash, please!!!!!
Another Labour idea being touted by the SNPites as their own......
35

ricky40,

29/11/2008 09:11:34
35 unimpressive

Why is it that every time Rufus posts, some sycopantic posts follow - co-incidence? I don't think so - hope you don't run out of different monikers?
36

Castaway™ ,

ex East Lothian now Manila 29/11/2008 09:15:27
#30-Boy Wonder-well written.
#33-I am always happy when I meet a fellow Scot.
I feel a problem with some of those negative posters is they are either taking the p*** or wu merchants or they are not Scottish and envious of that fact or if they are Scottish they are worried that as far as "Scotland's Year of Homecoming" is concerned most Scots will actually enjoy themselves and those Scots are "thinking positive Scotland" instead of "thinking negative Scotland".
37

Young Asa,

Dunfermline 29/11/2008 09:17:02
This version of the song is pathetic to say the least.

The most stirring and much more appropriate version is the one sung by Frankie Miller..a man who has more talent than that lot put together.
38

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 09:17:08
#41 ricky40

Not at all. We need as many tourists as possible because that's all we're good for now, a tartan Disneyland for ex-pats.
39

Nebulous,

Aberdeen 29/11/2008 09:17:29
What a bunch of cynics - I really like it - you have a cross-section of ages and genders of people who want to promote their country. As opposed to people on this thread who run it down.

I'm constantly amazed at the idea peddled that people who emigrated were the "best." Sure some people emigrated because they had increased opportunities elsewhere. Others emigrated because they had to, through clearances, transportation and more recently to escape justice and even to avoid National Service!

No-one has to celebrate Homecoming. It will be a big successful, cheerful event, with I am sure some failures - and it is exactly what the country needs in the middle of a recession.

Equally people of Scottish descent will come here for all sorts of reasons and some of them will be very clear they don't want to participate for a variety of reasons. Again all that is up to them.

40

ricky40,

29/11/2008 09:22:25
46 Draco

Explain "that's all we're good for now" and the reason for your inferiority complex which, thankfully, is not shared by the vast majority of Scots?
41

Pilrig,

Livingston 29/11/2008 09:33:54
I see the anti-Scots are up early this morning.
42

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 09:35:21
#ricky40

In being a Scot, I'm neither inferior or superior to any other race. I just am. I'm quite proud of it but I just get on with it and try to contribute in a very small way to the wellbeing of my country. I'm not a hypocrite about it like proud Scots like Connery and Lulu. What pees me off with this advert is the use of these people. By all means get real Scots to go on screen in Toronto or Timbuktoo, or wherever, and say COME and visit because it's a great, interesting, beautiful country with (generally) nice people. Not GO and visit because Im really proud to be associated with it but wouldn't in a million years choose to live there.
43

The_Reiver,

29/11/2008 09:36:04
More sentimental trash than send out all the wrong messages about Scotland (sorry BrigadoonSNPland).
44

bonhommedubois,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 09:45:33
Miserable
Sad
Warped
Twisted
Mean spirited
Curmudgeonly
Cynical
Narrow-minded

Most of the negative people on this board - and the image they are projecting to the world. God help us if you lot were promoting Scotland.

I am ashamed that Scots actually think like this. Ashamed that all of your carping from the sidelines brings down Scotland and the reputation of our wonderful country.

TRY and get your heads round this:

1. The Homecoming is apolitical - it was originated by Labour and picked up by SNP. All parties support it.
2. The Homecoming is designed to boost one of our biggest industries - tourism. This supports jobs and secures millions of income for our people. Every time you slag this initiative off - think of people in Scotland who are trying to hang onto thier jobs and make a living in a tough climate.
3. The whole point of the Homecoming is that it is OK for Scots to live abroad (why should that be a problem?) - it's not telling them to come and live here. But some Scots who do live abroad, like SIr Sean - give their time and global clout for free to help their country. By the way- they also visit here regularly, spend money here and support their nation abroad. The Homecoming is for Scots abroad ('come and visit') non-Scots, and for all of us here - there will be 250 events across Scotland.
4. The Homecoming is supporting rural communities and the WHOLE of Scotland, events will be held all over and visitors encouraged to travel.
5. OK - so some of you don't rate the 'stars'? Putting down people who have achieved in their lives - and who are giving back to YOU (numpties) - that's really smart. Putting down the likes of Chris Hoy, Sam Torrance, Lulu - you lot aren't fit to wipe their boots.

GET REAL!

There I feel better now.



45

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 09:49:52
#52 bonhommedubois

Were you lucky enough to meet Lulu once? Was she nice and chat to you and did she seem really 'natural' when she 'gave back' to you? Sad git.
46

bonhommedubois,

29/11/2008 09:50:13
#50
You obviously don't get marketing. The reason celebrities are used in ads is because that's what WORKS. (Think M&S = Twiggy, Tiger Woods = Accenture, Louis Hamilton = TAG Hauer, etc.)

A bunch of 'ordinary Scots' would be....well, dull.

The celebs may not work for you - I accept this - but this would be a non-story if it was about ordinary folk. (And there would certainly not be over 50 posts about it!)
47

bonhommedubois,

29/11/2008 09:51:26
#53
Help your country. Don't slag it off at every opportunity. You're the 'sad git'.
48

bonhommedubois,

29/11/2008 09:53:18
#52 P.S. No, I've never met Lulu. Am I right that she came from a working class family in Glasgow - and through talent and work and energy she made something of herself?
BTW - what have you made of yourself?
49

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 09:54:46
#55 bonhommedubois

I try to. Every day. By Contributing to it in a very small way. By actually choosing to live here.
50

brownlie,

29/11/2008 09:55:41
50 Draco

How can you claim to be proud of a country after denigrating it by saying "that's all we're good for now"?

The "now" in your statement suggests that we were good for something at one time but now no longer are.

I take it you mean "that's all we're good for now" because successive generations of unionist governments have neglected Scotland to their detriment.

You are hardly the one to give us the benefit of your advice on attracting tourists by describing them as "muppets".
51

bonhommedubois,

29/11/2008 09:59:05
#55
OK - so are you saying that Lulu, Sir Sean etc are 'not helping their country' by appearing in this ad for free?
Or perhaps, maybe, that the ad may persuade a few more Americans, Germans, French etc to visit here and spend some money in Edinburgh, Glasgow, Lewis, Kintyre or wherever...in 2009 - a year which will possibly be one of the worst on record for tourism?
An appropriate, more gracious and generous sentiment would be "These people may not be to my taste, my politics, etc BUT at least they have stepped up to the plate and have agreed to help out. Thanks for that."
52

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 10:02:06
#58 brownlie

The other day, on George Street here in Edinburgh they unveiled a statue of a very great Scot. That's what we were. Now, unfortunately we're increasingly welfare junkies, burger flippers, tourist guides and 'celebrities' like Lulu and Connery. That's what depresses me about the way this country continues todecline. And the 'muppets' are the ones that leave a country and still cling to some tartan shortbread tin image of it.The reality is in many ways infuriating, is still great but could be much better.
53

Rufus T. Firefly,

29/11/2008 10:05:18
"31 Press agenda HQ,29/11/2008 08:48:01
Rufus in true issue doging fashion has decided to come bash Scotland on this thread"

Errrmmm where did I bash Scotland?
54

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 10:07:01
#59 bonhommedubois

So Lulu can't pursue a career whilst based in Scotland? Likewise Connery? There sentimental attachment to this country is nauseating. I bet if you asked them to return to the country they profess to love so much, they'd run a mile. We've been expecting The Second Coming of Connery for decades now. Surely there's one house in the whole of Scotland posh enough for his taste and big enough to accomodate his ego?
55

brownlie,

29/11/2008 10:08:01
60 Draco

Do you ever stop to ask yourself why the country "continues to decline" and once you've worked out the answer ask yourself what you, and I, and other Scots can do to address the situation?

Could you possibly reach the conclusion that the status quo is not working and that things should change and that only you, and I, and other Scots can change it?
56

Rufus T. Firefly,

29/11/2008 10:08:22
"34 ricky40,29/11/2008 08:57:25
Rufus

As your posts are so full of negativity it's a pity your mum was not more negative all these years ago."

Full of negativity???

This is me in 'glass half full' mode.

Wait until I turn negative.
57

Bibamus,

29/11/2008 10:12:01
I am very much Scottish, and very much a Scot,although we live in Cyprus, it's just that this song is such a dirge, could we not have had something cheerful, by Eric Bogle perhaps ?
58

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 10:15:35
#63 brownlie

We're a million miles from the article. In my humble opinion, the reason this country (which I do like and still feel proud of) continues to stagnate, if not decline, is my felow citizens' infuriating and sentimental (see, we have, like the Irish, a tendency towards sentimentality)attachment to Socialism, welfarism and the Big State.

Anyway, I'm off to spend some of my cash in the LOCAL economy. Maybe I'll bump into Lulu on Raeburn Place.
59

Rufus T. Firefly,

29/11/2008 10:16:09
"35 Unimpressed one,29/11/2008 08:57:52
#1, No mention of Fran and Anna or the Krankies either!!!"

Good point. Clearly another oversight by Salmond.

It heard that Salmond himself wanted to sing in the advert too.

The only problem was that there are not enough IMAX cinemas available to screen it.
60

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 10:24:04
Chill out unionists - it's a commercial.

Although the way you all line up to rubbish your own country is a bit disturbing.
61

Silence of the Yams,

29/11/2008 10:30:22
I agree with the OP - Lulu, Amy McDonald, Sandi Thom...oh dear! Burns should be left in peace from that lot.
62

brownlie,

29/11/2008 10:30:51
66 Draco

Sadly, whilst you will obviously recognise her she will not recognise you. That's why she's in the advert and you are not.

To borrow a phrase from AM2 and his many aliases, "Now do you get it?.
63

JLF,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 10:31:19
It's scary how the vast majority of you obviously don't like your own country- but ignorance breeds fear right enough
64

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 10:32:26
As I do not know many of those mentioned other than Sean Connery on your list, could someone please tell me who the Gaelic speakers or singers that are featured. Since an extremely high number of those who will be in Scotland have Gaelic speaking ancestors or are Gaelic speakers? Can I take it that there are some on this list.

I know of a number of people like Julie Fowlis, Christine Primrose, Isabhel Macaskill, Cathie-Anne Macphee, etc who are world class Gaelic singers.
65

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 10:36:15
Is this Home-coming event only for Lowlanders?
I understood it was for all those who had Scottish ancestry, but maybe not.
66

brownlie,

29/11/2008 10:48:28
73 The Canadian

If it's any comfort to you Dougie MacLean can speak Gaelic and his tune The Gael featured in "The last of the Mohicans".
67

Greenheatman,

TAIN 29/11/2008 10:54:42
I am approaching retirement now but in my youth I spent most of it away from Scotland leading an adventurous expat life, usually in hot and sticky places.

What is clear from much of the bile above is that there is a lot of disgruntled losers whose idea of adventure is to travel to the Costa del Sol for a fortnight once a year, eat good old British Food (none of that foreign muck, eh?) and return to their sad pathetic jobs-for-life for another 50 weeks.

This song does have a resonance for those of us that have been away in foreign pairts for years on end - it is little wonder that some will think twice about this homecoming if they are going to meet some of the authors of these sad posts above.
68

Darien,

Panama 29/11/2008 10:55:08
#1, #3 etc are simply anti-Scot rants by rabid British Nationalists. Union with Scotland is the last thing on their minds. Subjugation, hatred and ultimate removal of all things Scots is what they seek through your British Nationalist agenda. Anything portrayed as 'Scots' in the upstart colony is anathema to the BritNat. For an institutionalised example of this BritNat stance consider the way Labour MSP's sneer at SNP MSP's at Holyrood; the latter smile back, feeling somewhat sorry for rogues who would give up their nation so readily. Brown's refusal to acknowledge the First Minister and still referring to the ScotGov as the Executive is another illustration of the BritNatz mis-treating the Scots and Scotland as little more than an internal colony. The British Nationalist agenda is not a Scots agenda, anything but. More Scots need to realise that.
69

Dark Lochnagar,

29/11/2008 11:08:34
No Canadian, it's for everyone. Even if your great great granny even got sh@gged by a big hairy scots "sojer", you'll be very welcome. In fact even if your great great grandfather got sh@gged by a big hairy scots "sojer" you'll still be welcome although possibly slightly less so. I look forward to meeting you.
70

brownlie,

29/11/2008 11:13:05
67 Rufus

In order to give you a political advantage, if you stop telling lies about Salmond, we will stop telling the truth about Brown.
71

blancmange,

Madrid 29/11/2008 11:19:49
Yip. Lulu's done a lot for Scotland. she also gave her services for free when she publicly supported and encouraged Scots to vote for Margaret Thatcher. In any case, she's about as genuine as Shrek.
72

,

29/11/2008 11:31:33
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
73

,

29/11/2008 11:33:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
74

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 29/11/2008 11:42:41
I hope it also sells a lot more Dougie Maclean albums. He has been one of Scotland's most charismatic, adventurous, talented and yet unassuming performers/composers and fully deserves all the recognition he can get.

However, I still prefer Runrig's "Alba" for sentimental heartstring tugging.
75

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 11:43:48
77
What reason do you have to be so crude?
73
You say Mr Maclean can speak Gaelic. The references I have read simply do not comment on whether he does or does not.
So are you saying he sings this song in Gaelic? Never heard it other than today in English.
I have looked at his Album and song list but did not find even one song listed in Gaelic.

What events are being planned both for publicity and during the year which are run in Gaelic and where can I get a list of them?
76

bonhommedubois,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 11:45:40
The level of carping and sniping here is unbelievable. All because a few people were asked to help promote Scotland and they said "Yes". And for this they get slagged, denigrated and misrepresented.

Burns said:
"O wad some Power the giftie gie us
To see oursels as ithers see us!
It wad frae monie a blunder free us..."

I wish all the meanies on here had the ability to see themselves as others do - and perhaps reconsider their mean, cheap, sour comments.

This is the country whose people gave the world the decimal point, cordite, the adhesive postage stamp, tarmac, the bicycle, pneumatic tyre, the telegraph,telephone, television, radar, fax machine, first postcard, speedometer, the steam engine, steam boat, golf, Grand Theft Auto, whisky, logarithms, fingerprinting, MRI scanner, kaleidoscope, paraffin, keyhole surgery, first cloned mammal, basketball, hypodermic syringe, penicillin, insulin, beta-blockers, vacuum flask, the macintosh, US Navy, Bank of Scotland, Bank of France, Bank of England, marmalade, refrigerators and Peter Pan, Jekyll & Hyde, Sherlock Holmes and Long John Silver.

We also gave the world the theory of modern economics and a way of philosophical thinking which is now the norm throughout the Western world.

And we are/have been home to some of the greatest actors, singers and entertainers of the last century - a centre of creativity and imagination.

Seeing some of the comments above it's a wonder how we did any of it.
77

bonhommedubois,

Galsgow 29/11/2008 11:48:20
83

http://www.homecomingscotland2009.com/an-tilleadh-albannach/default.html

I don't speak Gaelic - but have a look above....
78

Pinelands,

cape town 29/11/2008 11:49:05
love Scotland

its just the Connery bit.

What an example. never lives there.
its right to slap women
always around for the publicity
If i knew he went on holiday for a few weeks to Spain ok
ut he chose spain he cannot love Scotland it a fraud.
Tke away Bond and what is he a nasty bit of work.

Mind you of all the others on this video who lives in Scotland
79

Scimitar1,

Alba 29/11/2008 11:50:08
As an exile for a long time I much preferred the Runrig "Alba". BBC Alba , made a wonderful rendition sung by ordinary Scots and the singing, lyrics and the images are sublime.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=bs07sYQqc1c


80

brownlie,

29/11/2008 11:52:27
83 The Canadian

I should imagine that by writing and singing in English he appeals to a wider audience than the few people who can speak Gaelic. Such being the case he is more widely recognised than the instances you gave of Chrissie Primrose and the rest of the Gaelic singers you mentioned. I would have added Jenna Cumming to your list.

You may recall that Runrig are better known for their songs sung in English with a mixture of Gaelic songs added to appeal to the majority.

There are Gaelic events, including the National Mod, held all over Scotland and I'm sure that these will be substantially added to in next year's events.
81

brianmca3,

auld reekie 29/11/2008 11:52:32
rufis the dufis,away an bile yer heid ya sanctomonious onionist
yopu would be better making soup and flogging it in freedonia
your so funny you should be on the stage
aye theres one heading south just now get on it and go suck up to broon the doom
82

Rob - Honest Toun,

29/11/2008 11:54:31
Home-coming - frae the English dictionar = the return of a person who has been away for some time.

Homecoming - frae the Scots "hamecomin" = birth.
83

,

29/11/2008 11:57:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
84

bonhommedubois,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 11:58:47
86

"Always around for the publicity."
This is the first time Connery has appeared in advertising for Scotland. He is notoriously difficult to get to do things. This is an exception. Statement simply not true.

"Never lives there".
So, if you are a Scot, but don't live in Scotland - does this mean you have no right to promote Scotland? There are millions of Scots living abroad. Are they somehow disenfranchised? I spent most of my childhood in the Far East - my father was working there - am I a second-class Scot? The ad isn't telling people to LIVE in Scotland. It is asking people to JOIN IN the events in Scotland. Why should SC not be a decent spokesperson for this? Wherever we live - we are all Scots.

"Slap women"
I don't know the facts. If he has done wrong in the past and is now leading a good life does he get no quarter from you? A 'life sentence'?

Truth is - like it of not - Connery is a global star - and if it were not for him the ad would be less powerful and newsworthy. Is that what you want for the country you love?
85

bonhommedubois,

29/11/2008 12:01:56
84

Great list.
Maybe money, availability, timescales, practicalities came into it.
Still would be nice for Version 2.

Anyhow - it's all subjective. Your song and your list may not be to everyone's taste.
86

blancmange,

29/11/2008 12:02:17
91. I'd go along with that list.
87

,

29/11/2008 12:06:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
88

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 29/11/2008 12:08:16
#87
Yes but don't forget that this is a Lowland event promoted by Lowlanders with the odd sop thrown north of the Forth-Clyde axis. Gaelic is so far removed from their oh-so important little lives, most of them still pronounce it "Gay-lick"!
89

Thomas1,

// 29/11/2008 12:20:19
I get the impression that many of the posters here have never experienced the human emotion of homesickness,what are you?robots.
90

,

29/11/2008 12:22:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
91

Son of Gramsci,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 12:26:26
Hey, who needs enemies when we are so acompished at kicking ourselves?
92

sergiesmax,

29/11/2008 12:26:40
What some of you seem to miss is that this video is aimed at scots who live in other lands.It maybe because your job or career takes you there,or it maybe because your wife husband or partner happens to live in another land.This does not make these people any less scottish. Scotland is in your heart, in your blood, in your soul and I for one am proud of my country,but not so proud of some of the mean comments made on this site.I for one like the song and when I hear it,it really pulls the strings in my heart for my country,and when you don't live there anymore then you realise what you are missing. Scotland, what a beautyful country. And, by the way, I live in Germany,near Munich.
93

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 12:27:36
They've missed out Robert Carlyle for some reason.
94

,

29/11/2008 12:29:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
95

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 12:35:05
102 It's a government made commercial. Since when have they ever been good ? Personally I would have handed it over to the Scottish arts community to come up with something, but then you've got to please the Sunday Post readers too. It's a compromise. But I think they should have put Robert Carlyle in it, that's my subjective opinion. And Craig Ferguson - as Bing Hitler.
96

,

29/11/2008 12:40:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
97

,

29/11/2008 12:42:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
98

Nebulous,

Aberdeen 29/11/2008 12:44:18
#99 exactly - we pore over every little thing in case any of our fellow countrymen get the slightest advantage anywhere.

#96 what is your point? So there will be public money spent on events in the Highlands - there will be gaelic events and hoperfully a lasting legacy - and all you can do is spew bile because there will be more in the central belt? Have you any idea how small minded that can look? How about appreciating what this will do for the country as a whole instead of playing one bit of it off against the other?

On the singers nobody has mentioned Eddi Reader- she deserves to be there as much as anyone I can think of.
99

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 12:46:03
105 - Yeah Jerry should be in it !
100

Heather B,

Anstruther 29/11/2008 13:02:38
Great song, delivered with a bit of emotion, something that not all Scots can cope with I see.

Shame there's so many negative comments - maybe not enough got hugs from their mums when they were in their nappies, who knows, who cares? This song has nothing to do with nationalism, its about homesickness.

As for saying it's amateurish - yeah, that's probably true, not all are professional singers ya numpties.
101

Scimitar1,

Alba 29/11/2008 13:08:47
No 96 : Axiomatically true, hence the absence of our greatest female vocalist - Karen Matheson.
102

BorderLineScottish,

29/11/2008 13:13:54
#19
Robert Matheson
"I'm five generations removed from my ancestors that lived in the Highlands, but my heart is still there."

Absolute tosh! You are no more Scottish than I am!! You're only Scottish in the fact that you don't live there, but harp on about how it belongs in your heart.

If you want it that much - then get your backside over there and contribute to the economy.

The Scottish disease - Love It, but Don't Live in It!
103

pwd,

Borders 29/11/2008 13:23:35
I heard Eddi Reader only once and I can't forgive her for mangling "Ae Fond Kiss" - it was TERRIBLE!

And now this homecoming advert - when oh when is this long list of embarrassments going to stop? When can we get back to being real Scots and away from the current, excessive and inaccurate preoccupation with 'highlandism', wee bit hills and glens and all that tourist tat tosh? The genius that made Scotland something for a brief moment in history was overwhelmingly lowland. Oh, Hutton, Hume, Maxwell, and many others - when will we see your likes again?
104

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 13:31:41
#111 pwd

Careful. If you don't sign up to the Brigadoon orthodoxy as promoted by this bunch of 'celebs', you'll be accused to being a Britnat who didn't get enough cuddles from mummy.
105

brownlie,

29/11/2008 13:36:59
111 pwd

Unless they've changed the words since I last heard Dougie Maclean makes no reference to "highlandism", wee bit hills and glens.

Are you mixing your songs up?

What is wrong with the Highlands which are an integral part of Scotland and attracts many tourists from all over the world?

Hardly to follow the logic behind your reference to Hutton, Hume etc etc in this context.

What would your suggestion be to promote Scotland as an attraction for visitors?
106

brownlie,

29/11/2008 13:38:28
112 Draco

Can we act "grown up" and get away from that nonsense? Treat silly remarks with the contempt they deserve.
107

gee whizz,

East Lothian, where 11 teaching posts have already 29/11/2008 13:40:16
If the Nats are that bothered about this homecoming, why is it they are cutting education budgets and teaching posts the length and breadth of Scotland. I assume they are not looking for the return of young families as they will never be able to meet their election pledge on class sizes. To then have Lulu and Connery sing about this homecoming gives me the boak. Scrap this rubbish once and for all and pump the money into the classrooms..... education cuts seen to be the "price worth paying" for our SNP "government".
108

,

29/11/2008 13:44:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
109

,

29/11/2008 13:45:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
110

radge dug,

29/11/2008 13:47:43
#116 - song is great. Dougie Maclean's music and lyrics are generally not of tourist board material.

As to Eddi Reader et al... well if it promotes Scotland and brings more people here, more jobs and more interest in our culture then good.

Im not a banker and have no interest in finance but i can see that having a strong financial centre in Edinburgh is good for Scotland. Just wish the bankers' wealth was spread more evenly.
111

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 13:48:03
#114 brownlie

Suitably chastened. I think what pwd is getting at is the Scott-esque (a bit ironic from pwd's point of view, since it was the good Lowlander Scott who started it all off) schmaltziness of it. We shouldn't be encouraging people to visit because of some imagined past that people's Scots grannies told them about (although before you say it, any visitors, for whatever reason, however misguided, are welcome)We should be promoting the positives of starting businesses and living here permanently, not thinking fondly of it from afar.
112

radge dug,

BBC Alba petition 29/11/2008 13:49:15
By the way, sign the petition to get the BBC to use licence payers' money to put BBC Alba on Freeview so we can all see it. Not just Rupert Murdoch subscribers.

http://epetitions.scottish.parliament.uk/view_petition.asp?PetitionID=289
113

brownlie,

29/11/2008 13:53:20
119 Draco

If enough visitors come along a few might like it enough to stay. Quite frankly, I would prefer Auld Lang Syne which is universally know but have no problem with the sentiments of Caledonia.

117 Ananda

Should that not be broken into two words?
114

simpleman,

edinburgh 29/11/2008 14:16:30
Where is Sandi thom popular outside scotland?
Answer..No where
She had one yes one Novelty single that made it to the top of the charts ansd an album that sold on the back of it.
Nothing she has released since then and that includes numerous singles and another album has even scrapped near the top 20 and some didnt even get into the top 100 and yet because she supports Alex Salmond (and yes i voted for him so im not just knocking the nationalists) and is a pesonal friend he continues to have her on the pay roll for SNP entertainment at the conventions and continually hypes her up as a Scots superstar success but just looking at her career anyone with any sense realises that outside of Scotland no one wants to know her or buy her stuff, If sandi thom was business there would be closing down signs in her window.
Im not against homecoming Scotland , i want it to work but this sentimental tripe and choice of "personal friends" of Mr Salmond regardless of other much more deserving scots artists annoys me.
He is playing right into the detractors hands by yet again appealing to the haggis and shortbread audience. Scotland is MUCH more than that its a country with endless oppertunities and a vibrant lifestyle if you look in the right places. A line up of ageing artists and personal friends who need a relaunch of their failing careers instead of amazing young trend setting scots (and ther are many!) was the wrong way to go as far as im concerned, but yet again "theme park scotland" is the way we have been portrayed
115

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 29/11/2008 14:26:14
Homecoming 2009 is a bold gesture and like most home-grown initiatives, scottish money seldom puts in much of an appearance to back it. Nations and the modern nation-state seem sensible and hopeful human notions and ambitions at the start of the 21st century. There is the Wealth of Nations (in the plural) and even the Health of Nations. Whereas the wealth of the total human population is so neglible as measured per capita, it's a wonder anyone survives at all.

There is a limit to the size of atoms as there is to stars. Perhaps with nations too if they are to demonstrate any virtue and purpose. True republics require the wealthy and priveliged to commit their resources and even lives to the defence of the State when required. Democracies require well educated citizens. Stands Scotland where it should?
116

Pandapuss,

Delaware, USA 29/11/2008 14:49:00
Scots who don't live in Scotland live elsewhere for a plethora of reasons and, for many, it's not always so easy to "gang hame". That doesn't mean Scotland doesn't remain "home" or where one's heart lies. That said, I do have to say that no matter what you may think of Sean Connery living elsewhere, I have never heard him...or of him...downgrading Scotland or the Scots. Lulu is a while 'nuther story. On one of her first visits to this country, on a very popular talk show, I could not believe my ears listening to her soundly mocking the Scots and, in particular, Scotsmen. I've never had any time for her, since...and disappointed to see her in this video. (BTW I'm a Scotswoman).
I love this song..first heard it sung by Bill Torrance and not ashamed to say it DOES move me even years on, every time I hear it.
And I'd like to add that reading the majority of the negative posts here...I've come in contact with hundreds who, with no ties to Scotland other than the love of the country, her history and her beauty, do nothing but compliment her having visited. My one question to each them has always been "And were you treated kindly?" The answer...every time...is "The Scots...the BEST! Great people and could not be more hospitable or welcoming.." Myself, as a Scot living here for over forty years...have found myself to be warmly welcomed anywhere I've gone here, Italy, Spain with the ice-breaker always being my Scots tongue. Like a poster already said Scots who have never left their ain fireside seem to be the ones who have no idea what they're talking about. You're a bitter lot!
I am a Scot and will be proud of that until my last breath...my country, my people, my history. As to the yoick who implied that any Scot who was every any good, left: aye, maybe so but they all took their inventions, their Scottish education, their hearts, and improved the lot of millions around the globe.
117

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 14:51:47
119
Where do you live?
Why would anyone want to go to Scotland to see anything related to work or industry, do you not think we dwell on such matters long enough during the rest of the year.

Most of the people I know want to find out about where in the Highlands and Islands their people came from and their culture and language.

Industrial Parks or what is on offer is nowhere on the agenda; for that I go to California if the fancy ever takes me. Where on the face of this earth do your thoughts reside when it comes to having a good tme with friends and family.
113
As for Hume; was he not the one who thought the American and Canadian Natives were Savages and should be destroyed, be it by fair or foul means as they were in the way of progress. Somehow I recall he thought the same about the Gaelic speakers in Scotland, which ended up in the justification of the Clearances, less than a century later.
118

Ernie,

Olivos, Buenos Aires, Argentina 29/11/2008 14:59:58
Dear All,

I know not how many of you are involved in the advertising or marketing sectors, but I think some of you may be failing to view this ad from the point of view of the target audience. It's cleary not targeted at Scots currently living in Scotland. It's main audience is abroad. America, Canada, Japan, South America (certainly including Argentina, where I live). The ad is aimed at attracting visitors, not locals. You are already there!
With the right digital marketing people behind it, it could spread through the internet like wildfire. Not to mention international Television, who would use it as an example of how a clever governement can touch the hearts of their own living abroad, as well as their descendants (like myself). Trust me, I know. This is what I do for a living. The ad is PERFECT.
My grandfather emigrated to Argentina from Glasgow in 1905, and my father was Argentinian (God rest his soul), so I have no automatic right to dual citizenship. I have been to Scotland as a tourist 12 times, and this ad made weep, because due to the crisis, I cannot afford to go.
Just my opinion!
Sincerely
Ernie:.Reid:.
119

Dylan fan,

Planet earth 29/11/2008 15:00:22

Yes! Yes! The best possible song for it! Talented people from several fields, beautiful scenery some familiar from news, some not so familiar, leaving an interest to find out more!
My interest in Scotland, rests on the fact that my folks came from there long, long ago, and they were in many ways like folks still there. I wish to trace little things, feelings, moods,language, customs, landscapes, sky, that were familiar to them, that shaped them long ago into the people they became. I feel a bond to every Scot on the Planet..sounds foolish to all skeptics, but there it is. I hope everyone goes home in 2009!
120

Ernie,

Olivos, Argentina 29/11/2008 15:08:32
Dear All,

I forgot to mention that, if properly marketed, the cost of this add would pale into insignificance qhen compared with the tourism business it would bring to you. Don't view it as a cost, but a very bold, clever and timely business investment. It's the return on the investment that's important, not the cost of the ad.

Once again, just MHO
Sincerely
Ernesto J. Reid
121

Brian Hill,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 15:13:24
So much anti Scottish venom in these posts;)

I love reading about each new Salmond/SNP initiative aimed at promoting Scotland because I know that the steam will be whistling from the ears of the 'antiscots' as they rush to pour their latest poison onto the Scotsman or Herald posts.

Unfortunately for them, their insidious campaign is completely missed by the majority of Scots as future polls and election results will show.
122

Chico Mendez,

29/11/2008 15:30:33
I agree with Brian Hill at 130, there is far too much anti Scottish venom in these posts. There is only one thing wrong with Scotland and that's the Scot's. We just hate success and always have to put it down. Lighten up and be positive for a change it would certainly be better than all this negative crit. But then again why change the habits of a lifetime - morons. I applaud anything that puts Scotland on the map and helps us to take our place in the world as a free thinking independant nation with a real pride in our country. You can criticise the yanks but at least they love their country and when the French sing the Marseille they really mean it. We sing about a German Queen and moan about everything positive that is tried in Scotland. At the end of the day it just makes us the poorer in spirit.
123

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 29/11/2008 15:39:25
What we our "does" (to quote the young John Clerk Maxwell) of the 20th century. Where were our outstanding contributions? 2 things. Building fishing boats and writing poetry. The first because intelligent working men were able to raise capital to develop the modern diesel vessel from traditional sturdy wooden sailing stock. And they were built to last for a generation (upgraded with modern materials and electronics). Though local skippers put their own money into conservation-minded gear, the industry was sold out by the UK government. Compare Burntisland twinned with Flekkfjord. The independent Norwegians started with a basket-case economy and now have 50 modern shipyards. Scots abandonned a thriving marine sector for the very dubious benefits of the Union.

In most fields: architecture, town planning, engineering, economics, politics, local government, the native Scots results have been very dismal.

In the age of the internal combustion engine, the USA could pioneer motor transport for the people and aviation. It imported alot of talented people whereas Scotland exported them.

Native Scots also wrote great poetry as it needed only pen, paper and intellect. Will it be consequential?
124

,

29/11/2008 15:42:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
125

Scotsbybirth,

USA 29/11/2008 15:45:51
Well said Chico Mendez. I couldn't agree more.
Most of the posts here make me very sad to call myself Scottish. Why do you not have any pride in your country? and if you hate it so much, do what the rest of us did who are proud of Scotland & it's people, JUST LEAVE! I feel so sorry for a lot of you that have never stepped outside the country and do nothing but bitch, moan and put Scotland down. Grow up & do something with your lives.
126

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 15:56:05
#133 Ananda

Exactly. It appears it's a cardinal sin to criticise any aspect of Scottish society or dare to question the true patriotism of some of those who are shouting the loudest about it, e.g Connery. God knows there's enough about our society that needs critised and challenged. It doesn't mean people who do love the country any less.

#125 The Canadian

Guess from the name where I live and try to contribute. I'm actually one of those Scots that lived outside Scotland for a few years when I was younger. It made me realise how much I liked my country and its people as much as I missed my family and friends. But I put my money where my mouth was. I came home, even though it might not have been the best move professionally or financially. I suspect some of the super-patriots on here who decry any critism of Scotland still prefer a tax-reduced lifestyle to actually moving back. I also suspect their desire to live 'back home' will kick in the more they need the NHS.
127

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 15:58:01
#134 Scotsbybirth

Says the person who left.
128

Van (not white) Diesel,

Amsterdam & Augsburg 29/11/2008 15:59:06
Nothing like confusing stellar with Stella!
129

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 16:02:03
125 - so you haven't heard of the ''Scottish enlightenment'' then ? There is more to Scotland than mourning the clearances. And we don't all speak Gaelic. This is a modern multi cultural Scotland, we should be celebrating all aspects of our culture and heritage.
130

Heather B,

Anstruther 29/11/2008 16:02:36

#122 "A line up of ageing artists and personal friends who need a relaunch of their failing careers instead of amazing young trend setting scots (and ther are many!) was the wrong way to go as far as im concerned, but yet again "theme park scotland" is the way we have been portrayed


What guff! Chris Hoy came out and said after the Olympics he wasn't impressed with politicians jumping on the bandwagon, so how does that make him a friend of Alec Salmonds?

And what is ageing about Amy MacDonald or Sandi Thom? Or the rugby players? Lulu might be getting on a bit but she looks better than half the 25 year olds you see wandering about!

Sean Connery is a A-list Hollywood star recognised all over the world. You'd have to be crazy not to get him involved. What's the point in filling an ad with amazing trend setters that no-one knows who they are?

What is theme park about Brodgar or Glencoe? Theme parks are artificial worlds created in a sanitized environment. There's nothing sanitized about Rannoch Moor!

Let's face it a lot of Scots might not like the shortbread / tartan / Loch Ness image but countries would fall over themselves to have anything like it to sell to tourists.
131

Scotsbybirth,

USA 29/11/2008 16:05:21
#136, My point exactly. If you ever left, you may understand. I am very proud of the accomplishments of Scots throughout the world. Very proud of Scotland, and the very positive feelings of people I meet every day when they hear my accent. I just hope they never read the negative posts of people and think this is what MOST Scots think of their own Country. Maybe you need to leave to realize all the positive stuff Scotland has to offer. Particularly it's people, especially the ones who left and left their mark throughout the world for greater good.
132

Isabella,

Chicago 29/11/2008 16:06:30
Why do the Scots seem to have so much self loathing! Rather than be proud of who they are (and they have A LOT to be proud of) all I read here is loathing for themselves! I am a Scot who has lived outside of the country for many years and I have found that the bitter Scots who have never done anything better with their lives are simply jealous and resentful of anyone else who has! This fact alone prevents me from returning to Scotland - you are a bitter, resentful, jealous lot - I feel sorry for you!
133

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:08:28
#140 Scotsbybirth

I refer you to my post at #135. Unlike some, I loved Scotland so much I moved back rather than just talk about it or follow her progress on t'Internet.
134

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:09:54
#141 Isabella

I'm sure there will be thousands can't sleep tonight for the loss of you.
135

Isabella,

Chicago 29/11/2008 16:12:50
#140 Scotsbybirth. Quite right! I think that you do have to leave the country before you can fully appreciate the huge contribution that the Scots have made throughout the world. I am always PROUD to say that I am Scots but when I read some of the posts written by my fellow countrymen and woman, well frankly I am ashamed.
136

Isabella,

Chicago 29/11/2008 16:14:48
# Draco was a Wimp!! (WELL NAMED!!!)
YOU, yes YOU are the very person that I am talking about - you make me sick and you are a WIMP - you are everything that is bad about Scotland - get a life you moron!!!
137

Scotsbybirth,

29/11/2008 16:16:51
Draco Was a Wimp - Read your #135, Sounds to me like you regret the move back! Sorry it was the wrong move for you. Instead of being bitter - try again.
138

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:18:30
#144 Isabella

Get your heid out yer e**e. Like most emigrants (me included), you did it for one thing, MONEY. Don't give me your sanctimonious guff about going abroad to make a contribution. Unless, of course, you went to the States to help the under-privileged. Aye, right.
139

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:20:14
#146 Scotsbybirth

I've (almost) never regretted the move back. You should try it, you might encounter the reality of Scoland today.
140

Isabella,

Chicago 29/11/2008 16:22:58
You're damned right I did you idiot! I AM one of the people that Scotland is trying to get back WHY?? because the country is going down the tubes because of bitter people like you dragging it down! You are what Scotland has left - does it make you proud to see the damage you do? - God help Scotland!!
141

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:23:12
#144 Isabella

You do need to come home. You've obviously been in the States far too long. You've picked up the charming American habit of over-use of the exclamation mark. I can almost hear the 'Oh, my God!' from here.
142

Pandapuss,

Delaware,USA 29/11/2008 16:29:33
#147 Draco

For MONEY?? LOLOL..if that were the case I'd be back home, now! As it is, it's been going on fifteen years since I've managed even a visit. Nor am I anxious to just come home to see the hills, moors and heather of legend...it's to be among my ain folk and mither tongue.
143

tartan army 2222,

29/11/2008 16:30:03
So many haters of all things Scottish on this site - for example, Rufus, Sam the Man, Charles Linskaill. Such a shame.

To the article. Great song. Great sentiment. Of course it's not to everyone's taste but nothing would have satisfied the above circus troupe (apart from perhaps GSTQ). The version isn't as good as the original but if it does what it aims to do (bring the diaspora back) then it's money well spent. Put it this way - if we attract 150 Americans who spend £1,000 each then the investment is paid back.
144

Scotsbybirth,

29/11/2008 16:31:06
Draco was a wimp - No thank you. If you are a representation along with many of the others here, I have no interest in living is such misery. I am happy where I am, happy to visit Scotland and tell everyone else what a wonderful country it is. How great the people are in general (with some exceptions). Scotland wants to encourage it's people back? I don't think they meant your type! Oops I used an exclamation mark! Oops again!!!
145

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 16:31:23
Well said Draco. I'm the same as you, left and then came back. Could have earned more elsewhere but I wanted my family to be Scottish. There is something just a tad annoying about being lectured by people who don't even live here. How does Isabella know Scotland is ''going down the tubes''. Has she read about it ?
146

Scotsbybirth,

USA 29/11/2008 16:32:33
Tartan Army 2222 - Well said.
147

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:34:09
#151 Pandapuss

I know what you mean. On a fine day like today, walking down Dundas Street with the view over the Forth to Fife, is when I realise how glad I am I came home and that there's nowhere else I'd rather live. It stll doesn't make it Nirvanah. Almost though.
148

Pandapuss,

Delaware, USA 29/11/2008 16:35:42
When I first came to this country I was barely 21yrs. old and that first week I was privileged (and happy) to meet a 90yrs. old Aberdonian who had been brought here as a bairn, married a farmer and had never been able to return to Scotland. At that age and blind, it was still her wish. You can take the emmigrants out of Scotland but you will never take Scotland out of them.
149

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:42:41
#153 Scotsbirth

Sounds like it was you the privilege of a Scots birth was wasted on. The US is welcome to you. As you Americans say, 'Enjoy!'
150

Pandapuss,

Delaware,USA 29/11/2008 16:47:22
#156

Aah..sounds braw, Draco. For me it would be sitting having a cuppa with my sister, overlooking the Tay to Fife having spent the afternoon ga'ein doon the toon, nipping in for a coffee, smelling the aroma of freshly ground coffee from Braithwaite's, walking by the Auld Steeple, over to buy the fresh (not 'previously frozen'!) fish for tea then walk (or drive) up the top o' the Law to soak in the view.

(I was privileged enough to have my daughter a Scottish education from 7-8yrs. old and again from age 13-18)
151

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 16:50:55
#159 Pandapuss

You sound like one of the diaspora who would be more than welcome back.
152

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 16:56:48
It seems that there are many people in Scotland who have a loathing for things that are Scottish but adore everything that is English, even English accents.
A number of months ago I had the pleasure of meeting one of the Clan Chiefs from Edinburgh in Scotland and he was as English in accent, manners, ways and thoughts as a person from Oxford or Cambridge in England. Is this what Scots now aspire to become?

He had no idea about the Gaelic Culture that many communities in Canada have kept for over 200 years and thought that a puirt-a-beul was something connected to the Kilt. Do parents in Scotland accept responsibility for passing on any tradition or information about their culture and who they are or has Scotland become part of the zombie and robotic state of living.

I read some of the remarks on these newspaper articles and wonder what has gone wrong in, what was our ancestral homeland 200 years ago and often thank God there is a place in Canada called New Scotland.
153

Scotsbybirth,

USA 29/11/2008 16:56:59
Draco was a Wimp - You see, there you go again with that VENOM thing!!!
I do consider my Scots Birth a privilege. My American home & family a joy. My father's advice to "see the world" and "don't stay stuck in Glasgow forever" makes it easy for me to see the bitterness of the people who never did leave! Scotland is my country, my Scots birth was not wasted on me. My belief in the Scots as a Nation is passed to my children.
Have a nice day!! As they say in the good old USA
154

Isabella,

Chicago 29/11/2008 16:58:43
Draco the Wimp:
There are 2 reasons why I left Scotland: (1) MONEY, (2) to get away from moaning gits like you who do nothing but bring the country down. There is a LOT wrong with the States but they don't denegrate their country, they love their country (for better or worse) and they proudly say it. I am proud to be Scots and you should be too - stop tearing your country down. Now, I am out of here.......ENJOY!!!!!!!!
155

,

29/11/2008 17:00:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
156

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 17:04:37
#162 Scotsbybirth

Like Isabella, dinnae flatter yourself. You make yourself sound like some sort of 18th century adventurer. See the world my e**e. There are airports here in Scotland from where you can (and I do, regularly, including your country) 'see the world'. You stayed in the USA because you were better off, despite your much vaunted love of Scotland. Don't give me yir nonsense.
157

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 17:04:38
164 - no it's not the same as everywhere else in the Western world, and it's certainly not homogenous.

If we want an accurate video depicting Scotland then someone should start an argument.
158

lawrencezhang,

29/11/2008 17:05:49
Many people are discussing it at wealthy dating club ... WealthyBeautydotcom ... where the successful and affluent singles and hot girls and models to hook up for Hot Love, Flirt and Sexy Dating!
159

Pandapuss,

Delaware,USA 29/11/2008 17:05:54
#159

Thank you, sir...for today I've settled for making a big pot of 'kail' (my Mum's Scotch Broth recipe) with a lamb shank which will eaten wi' mashed neeps and tatties. :)
160

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 17:11:43
#166 Observer.1

Yes, you can tell the ones who've been away too long. They've forgotten we're not happy unless we are.
161

Scotsbybirth,

USA 29/11/2008 17:12:55
Observer 1 - LOVE IT! Now there's the Scots humour I love & miss.
Draco Wimp - Well what can I say!!! I guess my Dad was an 18th Century adventurer born at the wrong time. He was disabled and was not able to travel ANYWHERE because of it, so he wanted to be sure his children did! So 2 left, 1 stayed in Glasgow, and is very happy to be there.
162

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 17:22:40
#170 Scotsbybirth

Apologies if you think me insulting' I don't mean to be. It's all a matter of personal choice. You had the absolute right to leave Scotland and make a better life elsewhere for yourself. Good luck to you. Just don't denigrate those of us who stayed or who, like me,left and returned and dare to have a more realistic view of the country you left and chose to stay away from.
163

Pandapuss,

Delaware,USA 29/11/2008 17:24:51
#170 Scotsbybirth

I can understand your Dad's philosophy. Growing up in Scotland I had no desire to leave permanently but so many places in this world tempted to see (and why not?). I've been lucky having seen and lived in quite a few of them (with others to remain just a dream, now) but always thought I'd come home where I belonged. There is a great deal of truth, though, to "There is no Scot like an exiled Scot". Maybe it's in the leaving which brings us to appreciate our birthright much more than we did. Like "How can I miss you if you/I don't go away?"
164

brownlie,

29/11/2008 17:29:03
Scotsbybirth, Isabella, pandapuss - love the name - you are all welcome to Scotland and hope you enjoy your visit. Don't be put off by moaning minnies.

The Canadian - you are very welcome. Go to Harris in the Western Isles and find a chap called Bill Lawson who traces Scottish emigrants and their off-springs. He runs a place called Seallam.

Thig a nall, a charaid!_
165

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 29/11/2008 17:32:49
#172 Pandapuss

You can still do it. I've seen the view from the top of the Empire State and the bayous of Louisiana and the proverbial Blue Ridge Mountains. And Tahoe was beautiful and the Grand Canyon truly jaw-dropping. And the Americans are one of the most welcoming people on the planet. But you can't beat the view over Loch Torridon or the craic you can have with the wee wifie that works in the drycleaners on Elm Row. That's worth more than money and swimming pools.
166

Scotsbybirth,

USA 29/11/2008 17:35:42
Draco Wimp # 170 - No apology necessary. I would never denigrate those who stay in Scotland or leave & return, (as my brother did). I think it's great Scotland wants it's people back. I also think the people of Scotland need to stop putting themselves & their country down. If you don't like the way the country is now, then there are 2 choices. Change it! Or move on. I don't choose to stay away. I prefer to live where I do and visit Scotland & family at every opportunity. I have a very realistic view of Scotland, and still love what the Scots have done throughout the world, and very PROUD to be Scottish.
167

Scotsbybirth,

USA 29/11/2008 17:44:04
Pandapuss, "There is no Scot like an exiled Scot" So true!
Brownlie, Thanks for the welcome. I always feel welcome when I'm back. That's what I love about the Scots! They welcome everyone (even expats).
168

Thistledhu,

29/11/2008 17:47:19
Ithink this is a good advert with some surpriseingly good singing from the likes of chris hoy and sam torrence.

£150.000 not excesive lets face it hardlwey covers a labour mp,s travel expenses and wage paid to family members does it?
169

Moffat's Murkin,

29/11/2008 17:53:37
#161 The Canadian, you'll enjoy this. Over 1000 places/towns in Canada with Scottish names. Event he Lil'Wat tribe of Saskatchewan who are all named Wallace!

http://www.culturalconnectscotland.com/
170

Thistledhu,

29/11/2008 17:59:26
and of course best wishes to all in scotland and those of scotish roots all over the world on st Andrews day
171

Scythia,

29/11/2008 18:14:03
No 161 - The sad fact is the cultural heritage your ancestors left behind has long gone. The residents are more interested in the next episode of "River city"
and their next plasma tv than "puirt-a-beul".Many of them couldn't even spell culture (for them Alba is a US fashion model)and others want to supress it (see post 138) especially the gaidhlig variety. I lived in LA for 5 years coming back 2007,and before that many other countries in Europe including Ireland and was deeply shocked at the relative decline in the land of my birth - the old Scots values seem to have gone ,something the disporan will soon find out.
172

Sandi,

San Diego 29/11/2008 18:18:21
Well, it had me in tears. I hope it's used all over the USA. It's a pity this is going on at the same time the economy is taking a dive.
173

Pandapuss,

Delaware, USA 29/11/2008 18:41:01
#182

Speaking of St. Andrew's Day....

http://maat45.blogdumps.net/2008/11/27/why-no-st-andrews-day/
174

cambeuluk,

England 29/11/2008 18:52:22
"musicians Lulu, Sandi Thom, Eddi Reader and Amy Macdonald, "

What?! Who was responsible for this choice?

Speaking as a Scot who has spent too many years working outside Scotland, one of the links that has meant so much to me is the music of Scotland, especially that of Dick Gaughan, Brian McNeil and Phamie Gow - I am afraid that this lineup of 'talent' would not have worked the same magic.

Unlike many of my compatriots (including some in this advertisement), I plan to return to Scotland, but would not have been drawn by a this publicity. In so many fields, Scotland has given and continues to give so much that is the 'best' to the world, but unfortunately, other than for a few exceptions, this is a pale reflection of the best.
175

Moffat's Murkin,

29/11/2008 19:30:34
I've got three mates from around the globe who have decided to come back to Scotland. These poor sods took Tebbit's advice and got on their bikes, with a single digit geddit-rite-up-ya at Thatcher. A couple of decades of differing fortunes and they've decided that they want to be more Scottish than a couple of weeks holiday and the odd skype call to family and friends.

They're not wrapped up in Brigadoon, but have come to realise that the Kailyard is our national identity through no fault of our own. They're guys just as comfortable with Kenneth McKellar, The Bathers or Glasvegas.
176

Darien,

Panama 29/11/2008 19:40:06
#91 Ananda - you would be most unlikely to get Sir Alex Ferguson to promote Scotland alongside more patriotic folks already in the advert. Like all ardent unionists he is first and foremost a British Nationalist. Billy Connolly is of a similar bent, in my view, though some may disagree. To my knowledge both maintain that Scotland is dependent on the union for its very survival, as do all unionists/BritNats.
177

Scimitar1,

29/11/2008 19:42:15
Oops, another knuckle dragger(190) enters the board..
178

Conan the Librarian™,

29/11/2008 20:04:55
193

Sand yachter.

Sounds like an insult, eh?
179

SIACK AND TIRED OF HIGH TAXES - TO FUND AFRICA ???,

New Zealand 29/11/2008 20:05:47

This is very SAD. Having been involved in the music industry (not in Scotland) the whole thing reeks of politician & councillors. It is a bit like accountants being asked to write a song and put a concept together for the homecoming theme.

I would lay some money on that the whole campaign was created by an advertising agency that no doubt have some “connections”.

I have dealt with advertising agencies too and if you are not a male in pink with a pony-tail your are just not cool. What needed to happen (in my opinion) was to roll-out a competition to CREATE the theme and music – by SCOTTISH people to represent SCOTLAND. Hello, since when are Red Hot Chilli Peppers Scots.

My online friends – this stinks of being created in an air conditioned office that most probably the “creative team” have never been to Scotland and have viewed Scotland via their flat screen.

You could have had a Street Busker create a more passionate and well produced production – but of course such routes of creativity offers – risk, risk that those with corporate jobs cannot take risks. In fact it all stinks of the same stench of the banks that the public have just bailed out with billions and the bank are now refusing to lend money back to those that bailed them out.

The first time I saw the Homecoming theme advert picture down the sidebar – I knew it was destined for failure, which too seems like it was selected on some sort of PC basis so as not to offend ethnic groups. I men com on, some office chick in pants – no tartan, I see more Scottish representation of Scotland here in New Zealand – WHY IS THAT?
180

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 20:10:37
190
Isn't accent the only difference between the Scots and the English now.
The Scots in Canada do not live in the past what they have done in many places is continue to develop their culture. What seems to have happened in Scotland is the Scots seem to have taken English culture onboard lock, stock and barrel and without even knowing it while they often justify their actions by saying they are not living in the past.
181

tartan army 2222,

29/11/2008 20:15:27
199 taxes
*****
I see more Scottish representation of Scotland here in New Zealand – WHY IS THAT?
*****

Because the Brit Nats are so scared of losing their precious union that they'll play down any attempt to promote Scottishness. The only reason we're seeing any Scottishness at all is because a pro-Scottish party is now in power at Holyrood.
182

tartan army 2222,

29/11/2008 20:17:18
197 daniel rober

*****
Billy Connolly a British Nationalist. Now your taking the p+++.
*****

No he isn't joking. Connolly is indeed a forelock-tugging monarchist Brit Nat.
183

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 20:18:01
200 Whit ? Has the Scottish Parliament escaped your attention ? Did you miss Alex Salmond being elected First Minister ? I can assure you there is very much a sense of Scottishness, but it is based in the 21stC, it acknowledges the past, but doesn't live in it.
184

TREV,

Poland 29/11/2008 20:20:40
Isn't it a bit strange that an advert for an event based around the 250th anniversary of Robert Burns doesn't use one of his tunes?
185

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 20:21:03
It is very clear there exists a very wide divide between the present Scots culture which seems to be extremely English in outlook and is cool for the Scots and the rest of us.

If this is the case and the Scots in Scotland potray an image that is more English than Scottish the question arises why bother going to Scotland at all? When you can go for the real thing and simply go to England instead or stay at home.

It obviosly doesn't bother those on this site as they have no stake in tourism or getting any dollars into Scotland their cool English image is all that counts.
186

tartan army 2222,

29/11/2008 20:21:27
200 Canadian

Perhaps the most ridiculous post I've ever seen - and that's saying a lot.
187

Observer. 1,

Glasgow 29/11/2008 20:23:29
205 Your a troll on the wind up. Try and make it funny.
188

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 20:31:59
201
How come your parliament makes no attempt to promote Scottishness and from what I read here, most people have more interested in factories and new technology which seems to always fall away, once any money is made and goes elsewhere.

Did I read correctly that the Bank of Scotland has disappeared into the mists from whence it came; sadly.
189

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 20:36:47
207
I don't need to wind you or anyone else up after experiencing what Scotland offers culturally to the tourist, that is mainly English heritage and culture.

What a let down.
190

john z,

edinburgh 29/11/2008 20:39:27
Rufus,

Day after day, you come on the Scotsman forums to splurge your bile about how poor Scotland is, how terrible the Scots are etc... etc...

The Homecoming WILL bring extra tourists to Scotland - and tourism is our biggest industry -so what is your problem?? This will bring money AND jobs to Scotland during a recession.

You know, people travel to other countries all over the world to see what can be termed 'cultural cliches', so its hardly surprising that Scotland markets itself offering what tourists want. Many tourists DO come to Scotland to see castles kilts and Bagpipes. But homecoming is about so much more that Scotland offers, the home of golf, Whisky, great people (except saddoes like Rufus), great food, amazing history, wonderful country hotels, truly stunning scenery...and so on.

Home coming will be great, Scotland is great, but you Rufus are just a sad wee Scotland hating self loathing jobbie.

Happy St. Andrews Day - oh, you probably hate that too.
191

TREV,

Poland 29/11/2008 20:40:31
209 Canadian, care to illustrate what you mean about 'mainly English heritage and culture'?
192

john z,

edinburgh 29/11/2008 20:44:40
The Canadian.

Do not feed the TROLL!!!!
193

tartan army 2222,

29/11/2008 20:49:33
210 john z

Spot on. And 'jobbie' - great word, not heard that in such a long time.
194

TREV,

Poland 29/11/2008 20:53:37
It's interesting to note that immigrants and diaspora often have different notions of what constitutes the 'home culture' and often exaggerate it as if to reinforce their own image to themselves (not knocking it, just saying). I mean, how many Irish people really walk around with shamrocks et al tied to their shillelaghs?

Being the son of a Scot I moved to Scotland to find out more about it and lived about 10 years there. I felt the need to buy a kilt, although many of my friends, and indeed my own dad, had NEVER worn one in their life. BUt does that mean I can accuse them of neglecting their Scottishness?

NO!

To someone who lives in their country there is not a need to express that which you know you are everyday.
195

simpleman,

29/11/2008 21:02:18
As ever any chance of serious debate or comment decends into rabid overstatement and quite scary open contempt of nationalities on both sides, My heritage is Scots and im very proud of it,but will this contempt of the english and their culture stop if we gain independance? I dont think so, i mean we tear each other apart on a weekely basis in some parts of scotland over our religious beliefs, who are we going to turn on if there isnt an "Auld Enemy" and just supposing that their is a referendum and its decided democraticaly that we will indeed be staying together? what then? will the hatred of the union by those already opposed become even stronger? This whole camapign isnt about independance yet it is being hijacked already by people on both sides of the political spectrum and in doing so it will be torn apart and any chance of showing the rest of the world just how great this place is will be lost.
Homecoming has been planned for a long time now, it wasnt the SNPs idea its not a platform for independance and it never was, Im a snp supporter but not every single issue has to end up being about independance, which is all the zealots seem to think the snp is about. I like england, its a great little country with some really nice folk living in it, But 2009 is about Scotland the country and its people not the referendum on the end of the union, thats for the future
196

MacGhillieBhain,

Aberdeen 29/11/2008 21:05:32
I see that many of the posters here equate criticism of this song to being unpatriotic. To my mind,having been in the army abroad and working abroad(and glad to come home),nothing is further from the truth.I saw a bit of this song on tv. and I was dismayed to see the so called stars performing it.Imagine,one hundred and fifty grand to promote this pile of absolute manure?-------------YE GODS!
197

brownlie,

29/11/2008 21:09:27
209 The Canadian

I worked and lived in England for years and the only difference I've noticed is that my Morris Dancing has shown a tremendous improvement.
198

brownlie,

29/11/2008 21:13:12
190 sm753

"Why does a person's accent matter to you

What about the colour of their skin?"

Or whether they are thin or fat????

Curious?

199

WHY NOT,

New Zealand 29/11/2008 21:39:21

Reading the comments on here actually explains a lot about Scotland.

I can assure you that there are a LOT MORE Scots that still crave living in their home country than where they are currently. I am one of those and we are returning to live in Scotland early 2009.

It is sad that most of our family and friends believe we are mad to move from New Zealand back to Scotland. Most of the comments start with the appalling weather.

Well, I have lived in three continents and I can honestly say that every time I have been back to Scotland it moves me, it is without a doubt THE most beautiful country and ANYTHING that is done to capitalise on that should.

If the` Scots took a page out the Kiwi’s book of “how to advertise “(nearly every Kiwi is an ambassador for NZ) their country then Scotland would double, triple their tourist trade. Perhaps there is a brutal honesty in the Scots make-up that does not allow them to focus on the positives and a fear ingrained that worries that others may see the negatives and that you will be pointed out for being wrong for saying that Scotland is an AWESOME country.

FACT: You are never going to please everybody, some folk prefer warm beer. Get over it.

I know MANY Brits here in New Zealand that would go back to the UK in a flash but are trapped here. We have the third most expensive housing in the world and some of the worst wages in the world and still the skilled workers and tourists are beating at the doors to get here, that is, the back end of the world - WHY? Or should I say – WHY NOT SCOTLAND. I tell you why – do a Google on New Zealand expo and look at the venues and dates – the Kiwis are OUT THERE – selling their country because their economy relies on it.

New Zealand is damp & cold ( that is – inside the houses ) , the service levels here are pathetic, non-Kiwis will always be aliens here and those are a couple of at the top of list of reasons we are returning to Scotland to live – yes, I have considered my r
200

Jock H. the Republic of Scotland,

Arvada, Colorado, USA, ReNiddrie Mains Terrace, 29/11/2008 21:52:21
Rufus T is NOT a unionist, he is from Texas,used to work with him in " MB of Littleton," Colorado, nice guy sorry he went back to Texas, where men wear 10 gallon Stetsons to fit their 10 gallon heads,,,,
201

PointOf View,

Scotland, 29/11/2008 22:30:06
14 and 15,
Spot on, sadly i think Rufus T Flybrain and Charles NUMBskull are one and the same person. That aside does anyone know Rufus's home address? I'd like to send the insane B****rd a get well card!
202

Rufus T. Firefly,

29/11/2008 22:53:47
Pointofview, stop using my name as a football.
203

The Canadian,

29/11/2008 22:58:56
220
It is the Scots who say they are different in many cases very different. After being in Edinburgh the only thing I found as a tourist to be different from England was the brogue/accent. The same music in the pubs as in England though slightly quieter, same food in hotels, same cars, same dancing, same fashion and clothes, same kinds of hotels and so on and so on.
Is there anything different other than the accent/brogue.
Go to Quebec or New Brunswick and you will see the differences immediately.
204

TREV,

Poland 29/11/2008 23:13:15
Canadian, travel Europe and you could say the same about a lot of countries... same food, same music , same clothes etc. As for 'same food', well at least the English don't have anything as disgusting as East Coast salt'n'sauce.

I think they key thing is that you say "As a tourist". Some things are not immediately obvious. But hotels have to deal with a common denominator and provide what most tourists expect of a hotel the world over.

If you were to live in 2 different Scottish cities for a length of time you'd find a difference between the people (as well as a lot of similarities).
205

Norlaggan,

Aberlour 30/11/2008 01:11:31
If this ad is the best that Homecoming Scotland can do with a £5 Million budget then perhaps we should just forget the whole thing and jump from 31st Dec 2008 straight to 1st Jan 2010
206

PointOf View,

Scotland 30/11/2008 02:30:21
228 The Canadian,
Funny you say that. I was in the USA and Canada a few months ago and i thought exactly the same as you, Canada / USA, same same, but for the tasteful French.

Of course the real indigenous (robbed) owners of their homelands, the native Americans will do better under the Union. And once the USA, Mexico, Canadian Union is complete you'll be able to enjoy your Union Dividend and spend your New Euro currency over here withought worrying about the weak Dollar. Have a nice day..
207

PointOf View,

Scotland 30/11/2008 02:36:53
227 Rufus T FLYbrain,
Believe me, Its not your name i'd like to use as a football!
208

Pandapuss,

Delaware, USA 30/11/2008 02:53:58
#228 The Canadian

Just curious...all of my life it was an Irish brogue but a Scottish burr.
209

EnglishHighlander,

30/11/2008 09:35:03
#226 Col. Blimp­IV

Well said.

As an Englishmen living in Scotland, I often wonder how the shoe would fit on the other foot. I'm pretty sure that if the majority of programs shown in England had the Scottish accent as the "norm", it wouldn't be well received. It's just a pity that Scottish programming is not very good, save for the odd few items.

I can't see it ever changing, as I'm sure there are plenty of Scots (my wife and daughters being amongst them) who would not relish the thought of losing the programs produced over the border.

My daughters find it highly amusing when Emerdale comes on and everyone talks like their dad!!

Tartan terrors, the pair of 'em! ;-)
210

lorraine in canada,

30/11/2008 17:42:12
I'VE LIVED IN CANADA SINCE 1968 AT THAT TIME MY HUSBAND COULDN'T GET A JOB I HAD A NEW BABY AND NOBODY TO LOOK AFTER HIM SO I COULD GET A JOB. WE HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO GO TO CANADA DUE TO THE KINDNESS OF MEMBERS OF MY HUSBANDS FAMILY WHO PAID OUR FARE TO CANADA WHICH I WILL BE FOREVER GRATEFUL. WE WERE IN CANADA FOR 11 YEARS WHEN WE DECIDED TO COME BACK TO SCOTLAND EDINBURGH IN PARTICULAR AND TRY AGAIN. I KNEW 3 WEEKS AFTER ARRIVING THAT I COULD NOT LIVE IN SCOTLAND AGAIN BUT WE GAVE IT TWO YEARS AND THEN WE CAME BACK TO CANADA, A DECISION I HAVE NEVER REGRETTED. I GO BACK TO VISIT MY FAMILY ON AVERAGE EVERY 2 YEARS AND ALWAYS HAVE A GREAT TIME. IT'S A TRUE SAYING THAT SCOTLAND NEVER LEAVES YOU AND THAT I THINK YOU ARE MORE PATRIOTIC WHEN YOU DON'T LIVE IN SCOTLAND THAN WHEN YOU DO. I WILL ALWAYS MAKE THE EFFORT TO RETURN TO SCOTLAND FOR A VISIT. I THINK THE CANADIAN IS RIGHT, EVERY TIME I READ THESE POSTS WHATEVER THE SUBJECT THERE IS A LOT OF NEGATIVITY FROM THE USUAL SUSPECTS. I THINK YOU HAVE TO LEAVE SCOTLAND TO REALLY APPRECIATE HER. I REALIZE THAT SOUNDS STRANGE BUT IT IS CERTAINLY TRUE.
211

faddy,

germany 30/11/2008 20:01:29
Well put Lorraine.Been in Germany for 28 years. My three children born here but Scottish through and through. The two youngest are set on going home.Me too if I could get a job.
212

Number 6,

Germany 01/12/2008 09:57:01
AHHH The Scottish unionista, is there a more depressing, self-loathing, petty and immature species on the planet?. I think not.

Maybe they will cheer up on "Britishness day" when they can all wave their goverment issued unionjacks
in the mini bus down to london. I say london because there will be nothing "celebrated" anywhere else.
213

luv2bscots,

Niagara Falls, Canada 31/12/2008 18:39:42
Being first generation Canadian, I would have been very proud to have been born in Scotland. I have visited several times and will again as long as I draw breath, maybe even retire there. This song gives me goose bumps when I listen to it and so do the bagpipes behind the advert. I think all Scots should stand tall and welcome all who wish to celebrate with them for "Rabbie's 250th".
214

luv2bscots,

N.F., Canada 31/12/2008 18:47:11
...and a "Happy Hogmanay" to Scots everywhere they roam.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.