Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


T in the Park

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Dawn raid as 50 police swoop on Highland estate in poison inquiry



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 March 2008
SCORES of police officers investigating the illegal poisoning of birds of prey have swooped on a Highland estate in one of the largest operations of its kind in Scotland.
Investigators found several legally protected and rare birds of prey – red kites and buzzards – poisoned in the area, and poisoned bait allegedly used to kill them.

More than 50 police from the Highlands, Grampian and Tayside forces mounted a daw
n raid on Glenlochy Moor shooting estate, in the northern Cairngorms near Grantown-on-Spey, owned by the Formula 1 motor racing tycoon and multi-millionaire Paddy McNally.

Four gamekeepers were detained for six hours and police seized a large number of items, including clothing, equipment and documents during the raid at about 6:30am on Thursday.

While the four gamekeepers were questioned at police stations across the region, scores of officers, with staff from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds Scotland, the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and the National Wildlife Crime Unit, combed the upland estate that runs to several thousand acres.

Police dogs, including one specially trained to detect pesticides, were used in the hunt

for evidence of banned poisons such as Carbofuran – which was used to treat soil in root crop and cereal farming but is now the most popular pesticide for the illegal poisoning of birds of prey to try to maintain grouse levels for money-spinning shooting parties.

Shooting rights on the estate, which is near a nature reserve run by the RSPB, were bought by Mr McNally in 2004.

The multi-millionaire, who has been romantically linked with the Duchess of York, made his fortune selling advertising for Formula 1 and is estimated to be worth £623m.

The Scotsman was unable to contact him at the offices of his company, Allsport Management in Geneva, Switzerland.

Last night Northern Constabulary's wildlife crime co-ordinator, Chief Inspector Paul Eddington, said prohibited pesticides laid down by gamekeepers posed a risk to birds of prey, land animals, pets and people.

He said: "If these items were left in the high street there would be an outcry. There's just as much a risk in open areas, given the size of the leisure industry. Public safety is the crucial one I'm focusing on."

The searches, which follow an investigation lasting several years, came after a series of high-profile discoveries of poisoned birds of prey across Scotland.

Last year The Scotsman pledged its commitment to helping the SSPCA catch those responsible for killing birds of prey and other wildlife.

Last night Mr Eddington warned: "People who are responsible for land management, people who have responsibilities for the local environment, shouldn't be doing this.

"My own opinion is these activities are carried out by a relatively small number of people but they are making a significant impact on tarnishing the good reputation of the gamekeeping profession."

Northern Constabulary, which led the operation, said: "A substantial number of items were recovered during the searches of several properties and locations in the Badenoch, Strathspey and Nairn area. Inquiries will continue."





The full article contains 524 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 March 2008 9:53 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

W Smith,

Middle East 22/03/2008 01:14:29
1) I thought the SNP and Labour are against dawn raids. oh.. I forgot .. that's only when muslims are involved.

2) Never mind going after the knife gangs in Glasgow - lets go after the eco-terrorist gamekeepers then, eh?

3) If the solution to knife crime is a knife ammnesty shouldn't we have a poison amnesty?

Or do the police not believe their own propaganda?

4) Unlike the muslim fanatics, the gamekeepers are ulikely to play the race card and have millionaire civil rights lawyers accusing the police of 'discrimination' and they won't get any support from Justice Lite Minister Kenny MacAskill.
2

GalacticCannibal,

Murrieta, CA....captured from Mexico 1845 22/03/2008 04:02:08
Hey Dudes ,
If Mr McNally was aware of prisoning wild birds of prey using banned poisons such as Carbofuran – to try to maintain grouse levels, for money-spinning shooting parties .

Then he should be tried and given the maximum sentence that law allows. If found guilty.

In my world this guy should be lock up for 25 years with no parole.

GC
3

Sinead,

Tanunda 22/03/2008 06:01:31
Money is more important than endangered wild life. Definitely not!!!!!
4

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 22/03/2008 06:43:47
Hang them high, the way they hang their 'game'. Those who don't respect nature and life, don't deserve either.
5

yockel,

22/03/2008 07:23:21
Lets just wait and see if there is anything further to this story or if it is just another RSPB publicity stunt that comes to nothing. The story is pretty devoid of fact and the Hootsmon NEVER allows comment on court cases so.
6

Max Born,

22/03/2008 08:03:12
#1
What a load of mince.......typical expat caca de torro
7

donald,

glasgow 22/03/2008 08:27:49
Labour supports dawn raids when miniatures are involved, not Labour perks of right.
8

First Minister,

The Raj Restaurant 22/03/2008 08:30:06
I think #1 is actually in Scotland and trying to be sarcastic, however that doesn't excuse the fact that you are a nutjob!
I bet you are a Rangers fan? Council flat? Low Income?
Struggling to pay your council tax? Drink Irn Bru? pin no 1690?
9

yockel,

22/03/2008 08:31:48
Normada #6 It takes lackies to make a toff.
Without the grovelling sycophants there are no stars.
Forelok tuggers are just as guilty as the paymasters.

Some keepers are no better than rural traffic wardens it's just the RSPB want to take over their jobs and continue the backdoor nationalisation of the open countryside.
10

E300,

tomich 22/03/2008 08:51:08
There is certainly no defense for anyone killing rare birds. But,"50 police swoop", yes, I know gamekeepers often carry guns for their jobs, but, they certainly use them responsibly and don't go around shooting people, least of all police officers. When it takes 3 days to get one constable to investigate a mugging or burglary it might be thought that 50 policeman is a bit OTT for some birds being killed.The only other time we here about mass police invasions is when someone is reported as carrying a table leg or someone wearing a T-shirt is concealing a massive bomb.
11

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 22/03/2008 09:10:25
It is good to see the suspect estate and owner named in the above article. Too often this is not done, which may bring other innocent estates in the vicinity into disrepute, as well as hiding the potentially guilty.

"Who owns Scotland" gives the following information about this estate (though it is a little out of date. Come on Andy - get yer finger out!)

"Estate: Glenlochy Moor

Grid Reference NJ 090230

Acreage 5760

County Inverness

OS 1:50k Sheet 36 Grantown, Aviemore & Cairngorm"

5760 acres is 23.3 square kilometres. The estate is on the southern end of the Cromdale Hills and Mains of Glenlochy is about a mile north of Bridge of Brown.
12

Pilrig.,

Livingston 22/03/2008 09:29:15
1 - the polis are investigating criminal activity, do you have a problem with that ?
13

Gothic Rose,

22/03/2008 10:06:21
They Stink.!!!
14

joppa jock,

Huntingdon 22/03/2008 11:16:27
The fact is that all over the country huge areas of land are in the hands of the mega-rich and being used for little else than the slaughter of specially bred birds and deer by their equally mega-rich chums. The numbers who make up these parties are tiny in comparison to the massive acreages involved and the murder of wild birds that live in their midst is indeed a criminal act. If the mega-rich want to show off to their mates then let buy a corporate suite at one of Scotland's football grounds where they'll be in the company of other well-heeled eejits. Just leave the eagles and hawks to get on with their lives.
15

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

22/03/2008 12:34:07
No one should be exempt from the law, and these erses have been hiding behind their big bad gamies for long enough....time to strike at the real source of the problem...the people who pay the gamekeepers to cruelly poison animals and birds...never mind fining them...jail them...and maybe then they will think twice about their shennanigans. Better still, remove their land from them if they continue to offend...if they can remove property from drug dealers dont see why they cannot treat law breaking land owners the same way...

Aye where is Sam?...tugging on a forelock somewhere and giein it

'Aye yer lairdship consider it done yer royal highness right honourable big cheese ruler of us serfs'..backs oot the room bent ower and chin scraping along the floor....
16

Endemoniada,

22/03/2008 14:17:01
"Investigators found several legally protected and rare birds of prey – red kites and buzzards – poisoned in the area, and poisoned bait allegedly used to kill them."

#5. So exactly how is this an RSPB publicity stunt?

50 cops to search for evidence over 5760 acres of woodland, mountain & moor doesn't sound like much to me. How many cops will be on duty at the ~10 acres around the stadium at the next Old Firm match?
17

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands 22/03/2008 16:05:36
Grantown on Spey is surrounded by shooting estates owned by many people many of which are aristocracy I have never seen them raided ever. The game keepers are kept in houses tied to their job and the landowners are all in cahoots together.

If a game keeper refuses to use the poison he looses his job, his home and any future prospect of making a living anywhere in Scotland as a game keeper.

I am quite sure(I know alot of game keepers) that they are advised what they must do to protect the income of the estate.

The people who will pay for this crime will be the game keepers on £10K per year while the landowners make £10k per week from an average shooting party will claim they knew nothing and employ new game keepers.

As for 50 policemen in Grantown on Spey I wonder how many of them brought their family for the easter weekend raid. Double time, accommodation, fuel expenses, eating allowance.

The Gamekeepers are not likely to keep the pesticide in their garden. The highlands have the same land mass as belgium. You can be sure the pesticide is located on a sypathetic farmers land with a justifiable reason.

Total waste of resources and time. We could have spend the money on rearing and breading the bloody birds.

50 cops 3 days 8 hours per day double time @£15 / hour is about £36K just for the man hours over the weekend. Plus Accommodation £10K, etc etc Police Jaunt.

18

Jonesy,

holland 22/03/2008 17:00:32
Funny how these multi-millionairs seem to be on the wrong side of the law. Is there a connection to money makoing on a gross scale and crookedness?
19

Endemoniada,

22/03/2008 18:11:50
#19. Perhaps if the only way these poorly paid gamekeepers can stay in their job/house is by systematic law-breaking (ie. putting wildlife, domestic animals or children at risk by deliberately laying out illegal toxic chemicals in the countryside) they are in the wrong career.

If their representative organisations (eg Scottish Gamekeepers Association) were to make a stand and say categorically that it's members will not break the law, and report any landowner/laird who forced their employees to do so, then this Victorian attitude and abuse of all our natural heritage would stop and there would be no need for this "waste" of police resources.

It is the criminals who should be condemned, not those who are trying to prosecute law-breakers.
20

the Falconer,

22/03/2008 21:17:58
Please do not tar all Gamekeepers or Landowners with the same brush!

As far as I can make out at present there has been no annoncement of anything illegal having been found!
Untill there has then all you people out there condemming the landowner and their staff should keep your opinions to yourself.

It being Easter weekend is this another RSPB ATTEMPT AT GRABBING HEADLINES IN THE MEDIA, JUST PRIOR TO THEM ANNOUNCING THAT THE OSPREY HAS RETURNED AND IT IS DUE TO THEIR GOOD WORK!! MORE RSPB SPIN.

And yes I would also agree with some comments listed that the police could and should spend the tax payers money on fighting general crime with as much enthusiasm as they show for "wildlife Crime" I daresay they would not get the same media coverage or pats on the back for dealing efficiently with other crimes as after all that is what the police are supposed to be doing all the time.
Come on SCOTSMAN LETS SEE LIST OF DETECTION RATES FOR THE REAL CRIMES LIKE MURDER, RAPE, CHILD MOLESTING, MUGGINGS ETC ETC.
21

sam the god,

23/03/2008 14:59:45
#6 Nomada

Just to keep you happy it is a conspiracy by the anti’s if you check the internet you will see that there are numerous of these organisations that kill and starve to death animals in their care.

#17 Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen sorry to disappoint you but that was not the case the reason I have not posted earlier as I was out giving a deer the good news also gave some foxes the lead ballast as well.

For your information I do not shoot on a big estate but have access to several farms.
22

Chris Roberts,

Aviemore 23/03/2008 16:27:51
Well done the police and sspca for carrying out this dawn raid. As mentioned these people are innocent until proved guilty, but if they are I hope that all involved are sent to prison including the state owner.
Many estates are obviously killing these birds or prey (and animals) or certain species such as Red Kites would be far more widespread.
Its about time that this scum realize that wildlife belongs to all of us, and a few with vested interest shouldn't kill it.

Chris Roberts.
23

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

23/03/2008 21:38:03
23...Aye right son...away ye go and fondle yer weapon..
24

dido-bendigo,

Argyll 25/03/2008 21:04:09
The strange thing about this story is that if the Police, RSPB, SWT, SNH, etc, find a protected bird dead at the foot of a wind turbine tower they are not making a similar fuss, it is the incidental result of a legal operation! Wind turbines are as big a threat as they are a hazzard 24hours a day, every day! Even when the blades are stationary birds are likely to fly into them (bad visibility, night-time, cloud).

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.